Our Generation's Unique Need to Stress the Truthfulness of the Torah

Catalog entry: EMUNAH #1 (English) no. ⁨1⁩ Pocket Guide p. 72 English 43 min

Listen

  1. Download · Length 43 min

Open in the listening app

Notes Notes prepared by AI from the recording; not reviewed, and not the Mashgiach's words. The recording is the source.

About this shiur

The Mashgiach explains why the truth of the Torah rests on the revelation at Har Sinai before millions, unlike religions built on the word of one man, and why the Torah can never be changed.

The Mashgiach opens by saying that a person must accept, and even thank Hashem for, whatever He sends, and that today's bochurim, exposed to the world and its media, need hashkafah. His subject is the truth of the Torah. Both Christianity and Islam must accept Toras Moshe and only claim it was changed, because of what happened at Har Sinai. He describes how each of these religions began with one man, and how their founders removed the difficult mitzvos, since only Hashem could make a promise like that of shemitah. At Sinai, by contrast, Hashem spoke to millions, and the Torah written for that generation could not have contained a lie; it has come down letter for letter. History seen by multitudes cannot be faked, as with George Washington. He ends that the Torah is forever and Hashem, who knows the future, does not change His mind.

Topics: Torah Min HaShamayim and the Mesorah · Matan Torah at Har Sinai · Foundations of Emunah · Yisroel and the Nations

Order of the shiur

  1. 0:00 Accepting Hashem's plan; why hashkafah today listed in the guide

    The Mashgiach says his plans were changed but that a person must accept, and even thank, Hashem for what He sends. He explains that today's bochurim, exposed to the world and its media, need the hashkafah of the sefarim, and announces his subject: the truth of the Torah.

  2. 6:03 Other faiths must accept Toras Moshe listed in the guide

    The Mashgiach lists the three main faiths and says Christianity and Islam both must accept Toras Moshe, claiming only that it was changed, as with the Akeidah being ascribed to Yishmael. He asks why they must accept it and answers that at Sinai something happened that never happened before or since.

  3. 9:38 How Christianity and Islam began

    The Mashgiach describes how Christianity began with one man and was reshaped by Paul, who claimed a vision, and why idol-worshipping nations accepted a message of one G-d. He then says Mohammed likewise set himself up as a new navi.

  4. 15:24 Shemitah: a promise only Hashem can make

    The Mashgiach explains that a new religion cannot be sold if it is hard. Shemitah would starve farmers, and only Hashem could promise a crop for three years; a man could not, so the founders of those religions removed the difficult mitzvos.

  5. 21:25 Har Sinai: Hashem spoke to millions listed in the guide

    The Mashgiach contrasts the Jewish emunah, which does not rest on one man, with the revelation at Sinai, where Hashem spoke to millions and appointed Moshe as His navi before them all. He brings the passuk telling Klal Yisroel to search all of history for anything like it.

  6. 27:09 A Sefer Torah written before witnesses listed in the guide

    The Mashgiach says that after forty years of mann, Moshe Rabbeinu gave every Jew a Sefer Torah, so the whole generation could check it against what they had witnessed. The Sefer Torah's own laws protect it from change, and every Sefer Torah, even of long-separated communities, is identical.

  7. 30:33 Washington, Caesar and Alexander listed in the guide

    The Mashgiach compares George Washington, whom no one doubts, with Rip Van Winkle, a story told by one writer, and adds Julius Caesar and Alexander the Great: what multitudes experienced cannot be faked, even if small details can be. So too Toras Moshe, given to a multitude and learned day after day.

  8. 34:56 Why the nations resent the Jews

    The Mashgiach says the Torah is hard for the nations, who lack the love of the children of Avraham, Yitzchak and Yaakov, so the Torah was made easy for them and they claimed Hashem replaced the Jewish people. He explains that the nations persecute the Jews out of jealousy, since deep down they know the Jews' greatness, as seen in Jewish advisors like Mordechai and Daniel.

  9. 39:10 The Torah is forever listed in the guide

    The Mashgiach says the Torah promises it will never be replaced and that a navi who comes to change it is a false navi. Claiming Hashem changed His mind makes Him a liar, and with a mashal of a gift of a hundred dollars he shows that One who knows the future cannot change His mind. He closes that he will elaborate further.

The shiur, written up

Accepting Hashem's plan; why hashkafah today

0:38

The Mashgiach begins by saying that his plans for these sessions were changed, but everything has a reason, and a person must not only accept that he is in Hashem's hands but even thank Him for it. In the remaining sessions he will cover only the essential points every Jew must know.

2:12

The yeshivos still follow the European pattern, but each generation has its own needs. Today's bochurim mix with the world, and its media give wrong impressions and plant doubts, so the yeshivos should teach hashkafah from the sefarim, above all to those who will enter the business world. His subject now is the truth of the Torah, that it was given to Israel by Hashem.

Other faiths must accept Toras Moshe

6:45

Of the three main faiths, the Mashgiach says, Christianity and Islam must both accept Toras Moshe. They claim only that it was changed; the Muslims say the Jews edited it, so that the Akeidah was of Yishmael rather than Yitzchak. Why must they accept it? Because at Sinai something happened that never happened before and never will again.

How Christianity and Islam began

10:02

The Mashgiach describes the founder of Christianity, of whom the Gemara speaks, as a Jew who opposed the Chachamim and never claimed to be Moshiach. About a hundred years later Paul claimed that this man had appeared to him and told him to change the Torah. e

12:33

The nations accepted Paul because they worshipped many gods of gold, silver, sun, moon, war and love, which made no sense, while his message of one G-d did. He was a charismatic speaker, and they knew the Jewish G-d had punished Mitzrayim. Mohammed likewise set himself up as a new navi of Toras Moshe.

Shemitah: a promise only Hashem can make

15:24

Both founders, the Mashgiach says, knew that a hard religion cannot be sold. Shabbos ties a man's hands, and shemitah would have starved a world of farmers. The Torah itself asks what the Jews will eat in the seventh year and promises a sixth-year crop for three years, a promise only Hashem can make; Jews have always relied on it. In the last shemitah about four thousand farmers in Eretz Yisroel kept it, and the papers reported that their farms flourished. b

18:41

Paul knew he could make no such promise, so he removed the difficult mitzvos, shemitah, Shabbos and most of the arayos, and replaced Shabbos with a Sunday on which one may do as he pleases. Mohammed did the same.

Har Sinai: Hashem spoke to millions

21:25

Each of those religions rests on one man, but the Jewish emunah does not. At Sinai a few million people stood, and Hashem spoke to every one of them; they all became nevi'im. Suddenly the mountain trembled and they heard the Aseres HaDibros, until they told Moshe they could bear no more.

24:12

Hashem then said, before them all, that He would give the Torah through Moshe, His navi, and in Parshas Yisro He tells Moshe that they will believe him because they heard it. The Mashgiach brings the passuk telling Klal Yisroel to search all of history whether a nation ever heard Hashem speak from the fire; no religion but the Torah claims this. c,a

A Sefer Torah written before witnesses

27:23

After forty years of mann, Moshe Rabbeinu wrote out the Torah and every Jew had to have a Sefer Torah, the last mitzvah of the Torah; the Mashgiach notes the Rosh's view that today there is no special mitzvah, since we have chumashim and gemaros. The whole generation could compare the Sefer with what they lived through, and no one can tell lies to millions. Since one extra or missing letter makes a Sefer Torah invalid, even long-separated communities have identical Sifrei Torah. d

Washington, Caesar and Alexander

31:01

No one doubts George Washington, the Mashgiach says, yet no one believes Rip Van Winkle. That story was made up by one writer, while Washington led hundreds of thousands, and history witnessed by multitudes cannot be faked. The same holds for Julius Caesar and Alexander the Great, of whom the Gemara also speaks. f

33:34

He once read that Alexander's horse was missing a front tooth; such a detail may be invented, but not that Alexander existed. So too Toras Moshe was given to a multitude and learned by Jews day after day.

Why the nations resent the Jews

35:11

The Torah is hard for the nations, who are not children of Avraham, Yitzchak and Yaakov and lack the love that makes bochurim keep it though it is hard; so it was made easy, and they claimed the Jews were replaced. Why do the nations persecute the Jews? A tzaddik says it is jealousy: deep down they know the Jews' greatness, as kings always needed Jewish advisors like Mordechai with Achashverosh and Daniel with Nevuchadnetzar. g,h

The Torah is forever

40:00

The Torah says countless times that it is a statute forever, and in Parshas Re'eh that even a navi who comes to change it is a false navi. To say Hashem changed His mind is a rationalization that makes Him a liar. i,j

41:56

The Mashgiach gives a mashal: giving a hundred dollars while knowing one will take it back is not giving at all. Hashem knows the future, so He cannot change His mind. He will elaborate further.

Sources

Torah

  1. a Devarim 4:32 text index In the write-up: 24:12
  2. b Vayikra 25:20-21 text index In the write-up: 15:24
  3. c apparently Shemos 19:9 index In the write-up: 24:12
  4. d apparently Devarim 31:19 index In the write-up: 27:23
  5. i Torah (place not identified) index In the write-up: 40:00
  6. j apparently Devarim 13 (Parshas Re'eh) index In the write-up: 40:00

Kesuvim

  1. g apparently Esther 2:19 index In the write-up: 35:11
  2. h Daniel (place not identified) index In the write-up: 35:11

Talmud Bavli

  1. e Gemara (place not identified) index In the write-up: 10:02
  2. f Gemara (place not identified) index In the write-up: 31:01

Key points

  1. 6:45 The Mashgiach says that both Christianity and Islam must accept Toras Moshe, and only claim that it was changed or edited.
  2. 21:09 Those religions rest on the word of one man, while the Jewish emunah rests on Hashem speaking to millions at Har Sinai.
  3. 17:54 To win followers, the founders of those religions removed the difficult mitzvos, since a man cannot make a promise like the Torah's promise for shemitah.
  4. 28:30 The Sefer Torah was given to the very generation that witnessed its events, who could have exposed any falsehood, and it has come down identical letter for letter.
  5. 31:06 History witnessed by multitudes cannot be faked, which is why no one doubts George Washington while no one believes Rip Van Winkle.
  6. 40:00 The Torah is forever, and Hashem, who knows the future, cannot be said to have changed His mind.

Questions and answers

  1. Question: 9:10 Why must Christianity and Islam accept Toras Moshe?

    Answer: 9:20 Because at Sinai something happened that never happened before in history and, the Torah promises, never will again.

  2. Question: 13:42 Why did the nations accept Christianity?

    Answer: 13:24 They worshipped many gods that made no sense, so a message of one G-d, delivered by a charismatic speaker, made sense to them.

  3. Question: 31:06 Why do we believe in George Washington but not in Rip Van Winkle?

    Answer: 31:10 Rip Van Winkle was told by one writer who made it up, while history experienced by multitudes and passed down cannot be faked.

  4. Question: 36:08 Why have the nations persecuted the Jews throughout the ages?

    Answer: 36:32 Out of jealousy: they see that the Jews are a superior people and know their greatness deep down.

  5. Question: 41:02 Why do they claim that Hashem changed His mind about the Torah?

    Answer: 41:11 They are rationalizing because they cannot accept the Torah; but the Torah itself says it will not change, and One who knows the future cannot change His mind.

Stories

  1. 18:09 Farmers who kept shemitah

    The Mashgiach relates that in the past shemitah year about four thousand farmers in Eretz Yisroel kept shemitah. The papers reported that their farms flourished and they lost no money, while other farms did not grow as well.

Insights

  1. 6:54 The Mashgiach argues that the very fact that the other major religions must accept Toras Moshe, and can only claim it was altered, testifies to its truth, because of the unique event at Sinai.
  2. 17:45 Shemitah's promise of a crop for three years is a promise only Hashem can make; a human founder could not make it, and that is why such founders removed the difficult mitzvos.
  3. 33:34 A small detail, like a story about Alexander's horse missing a tooth, can be invented by one writer, but the core of an event that multitudes lived through cannot.
  4. 29:26 The halachah that one extra or missing letter makes a Sefer Torah invalid is a built-in protection against change, which is why Sifrei Torah of long-separated communities match letter for letter.
  5. 36:31 The nations' hatred of the Jews comes from jealousy: deep down they know the greatness of the Jewish people.
  6. 41:32 Giving something while knowing one will take it back is not called changing one's mind but not giving at all; since Hashem knows the future, the claim that He changed His mind about the Torah makes Him a liar.

What the Mashgiach says to take from it

  1. 1:05 The Mashgiach says one must not only accept being in Hashem's hands but even thank Him for it.
  2. 5:06 The Mashgiach says bochurim who will go out into the world, especially into business, must know these ideas of hashkafah.

Mentioned in this shiur

People Achashverosh, Alexander the Great, Daniel, George Washington, Julius Caesar, Mohammed, Mordechai HaTzaddik, Moshe Rabbeinu, Nevuchadnetzar, Paul (founder of Christianity), the Rosh, Yehoshua bin Nun, Yeshu (Oso HaIsh), Yishmael, Yitzchak Avinu

Terms יציאת מצרים, מעמד הר סיני, נביא שקר, ספר תורה, עקידה, קנאה, קריעת ים סוף, רבונו של עולם, שמיטה

Report an error on this page