Hashem Maintains a Balanced World with Breathtaking Precision
Catalog entry: EMUNAH #1 (English) no. 6 Pocket Guide p. 71 English 25 min
Listen
About this shiur
The Mashgiach shows that people who reject emunah are hiding from what they know, and that the precise balance of the world, from the oxygen in the air to ice floating on water, shows that Hashem maintains His world.
The Mashgiach opens with a letter printed in a newspaper after the Six-Day War, in which a woman asked the editor to stop writing about the miracles because they gave her a guilty conscience about driving to the beach on Shabbos. People, he says, bury their heads in the sand so that emunah will not hinder their desires. He illustrates this with a story the Telzer Rosh Yeshiva, Rav Bloch, wrote in his sefer: a ceiling that kept falling until boards soaked with a suicide's blood were buried, after which one boy stopped coming to the club so as not to see evidence of G-d. The Mashgiach then dismisses fears that the world will be ruined, comparing them to Rashi's account of the Dor Haflagah, and shows Hashem's balance in nature: 21% oxygen, the exchange of oxygen and carbon dioxide, worms and birds, blood clotting, and water, which expands near freezing so that ice floats and fish survive. He ends noting that Jews too have their own pattern of behavior.
Topics: Creation and Its Wonders · Hashgacha Pratis · Doubts in Emunah and Amalek
Order of the shiur
-
0:00 The letter asking to stop writing about miracles Story
The Mashgiach describes the miracles of the Six-Day War and a letter to the editor from a woman in Tel Aviv who asked the paper to stop reporting them because they made her feel guilty about going to the beach on Shabbos. He says this shows how people bury their heads in the sand so emunah will not hinder their desires.
-
3:18 The ceiling that kept falling in the club Story
The Mashgiach tells a story the Telzer Rosh Yeshiva, Rav Bloch, wrote in his sefer: in a club of boys who had left Yiddishkeit, the ceiling kept falling until boards soaked with the blood of a boy who took his life were buried as the Shulchan Aruch requires. One boy then stopped coming so he would not see evidence of G-d, which shows that people hide their belief rather than lack it.
-
9:18 The balance of the air and of nature listed in the guide
The Mashgiach calls fears that pollution and deforestation will ruin the world nonsense, compares them to the Dor Haflagah's fear that the sky would collapse, as Rashi brings, and says Hashem maintains His world. He shows the balance of 21% oxygen, the exchange of oxygen and carbon dioxide between people and plants, and the chain of worms, birds and birds of prey.
-
16:00 Blood clotting and expansion by heat listed in the guide
The Mashgiach explains that blood clots only on contact with air, sealing wounds without causing strokes or heart attacks, and notes hemophiliacs who lack this. He then introduces the law that every element expands when heated, using the gaps between railroad tracks.
-
20:20 Why ice floats listed in the guide
After the thermometer, the Mashgiach shows that water alone expands again as it nears freezing, so ice is lighter than water and floats, keeping fish and plants alive beneath it. He closes saying that Jews also have their own pattern of behavior, to be discussed the next week.
The shiur, written up
The letter asking to stop writing about miracles
The Mashgiach recalls that during the Six-Day War the newspapers were full of miracles, and a woman in Tel Aviv wrote asking the editor to stop: on Shabbos, her day off, she drives to the beach, and the reports gave her a guilty conscience. This, he says, is what people do: like the ostrich they bury their heads in the sand, because emunah would hinder their desires.
The ceiling that kept falling
He brings a story the Telzer Rosh Yeshiva, Rav Bloch, wrote in his sefer. Before the war, Jewish boys who had left home over communism and Zionism kept a club, and after one of them bled to death upstairs, the ceiling below kept falling despite replastering. Rav Bloch said he was a man of halachah, not Kabbalah: the Shulchan Aruch requires burying boards that absorbed such blood, as part of the mitzvah of burial the Gemara learns from the passuk in Devarim. a,b
Once the boards were buried the ceiling held, and one boy stopped coming, saying he saw there is a Maker and could not live as he pleased with that before him. People, the Mashgiach concludes, do believe; they bury their belief because they lack the strength to fight.
The balance of the air and of nature
The Mashgiach calls the fear that pollution and deforestation will ruin the world nonsense: where there is a master of the house, the house is in order, and Hashem maintains His world. It resembles the Dor Haflagah, who, as Rashi brings, calculated that the sky would collapse and built a tower to hold it up. c
He shows the balance himself. The air holds exactly 21% oxygen: more and one cigarette could set the world on fire, less and people would suffocate. People and animals exhale the carbon dioxide plants need, and worms that soften the earth are kept in check by birds, and birds by birds of prey.
Blood clotting and expansion by heat
One need only open one's eyes, the Mashgiach says. An ingredient in the blood dries it on contact with air and seals a scratch; those lacking it are hemophiliacs. It works only with air, because blood clotting in the veins would cause a stroke or heart attack. He then notes that every element expands with heat, which is why railroad tracks are laid with gaps.
Why ice floats
Water alone breaks the rule: as it nears freezing it expands again, so a jar of water bursts in the freezer. Hashem needs this for His world: ice is lighter than water and floats, so a river freezes on top while fish and plants live beneath. The Mashgiach ends that Jews, too, have their own pattern of behavior, to be discussed next week.
Sources
Torah
Rishonim
Acharonim and Chassidus
Key points
- 2:55 People do not truly disbelieve; they hide their belief because emunah would hinder their pursuit of desires.
- 10:05 The world cannot be ruined by human progress, because Hashem who made the world controls and maintains it, as a household with a master is in order.
- 12:08 The air always holds 21% oxygen, the exact amount that lets people breathe without the world catching fire, and the carbon dioxide people and animals breathe out feeds the plants.
- 15:03 Nature is balanced throughout: worms soften the earth for plants, birds keep the worms in check, and birds of prey keep the birds in check.
- 16:47 Blood clots only on contact with air, sealing a wound without blocking the veins, a built-in repair system that shows Hashem's wisdom.
- 21:17 Water, unlike other elements, expands as it nears freezing, so ice floats and fish and plants survive beneath it.
Questions and answers
-
Question: 5:43 Why did the ceiling of the club keep falling down?
Answer: 6:21 Because the boards above had absorbed the blood of the boy who bled to death, and they had to be buried; once they were, the ceiling held.
-
Question: 17:43 Why did Hashem put a clotting ingredient in the blood that works only on contact with air?
Answer: 17:48 So that a person has a built-in repair system for wounds, while the blood never clots inside the veins and causes a stroke or heart attack.
-
Question: 22:33 Why does water not behave like every other element, which shrinks in the cold?
Answer: 22:46 Because Hashem needs it for His world: ice that expands is lighter and floats, so rivers freeze on top and fish and plants live underneath.
Stories
-
1:14 The letter to the editor after the Six-Day War
During the Six-Day War the newspapers were full of miracles, such as a firebomb that set a house ablaze and a second bomb that hit a water tank on the roof, whose water put out the fire. A woman in Tel Aviv wrote to a newspaper asking the editor to stop writing about the miracles. She explained that on Shabbos, her one day off, she drives to the beach, and the reports gave her a guilty conscience about not keeping Shabbos. The letter was printed.
-
4:27 The falling ceiling and the boards with blood
Before the war, Jewish boys in Europe who had left home over Haskalah, communism and Zionism made clubs and dormitories. One boy, disappointed, cut his wrists and bled to death, and afterwards the plaster in the clubhouse below kept falling despite repeated replastering. A boy with a spark of emunah asked the Telzer Rosh Yeshiva, Rav Bloch, who said he was a man of halachah, not Kabbalah: the boards that absorbed the blood must be buried. After the boards were buried the ceiling held, and one boy stopped coming to the club, saying that seeing it showed him there is a Maker, and he could not live as he pleased with that before his eyes.
In the story: Rabbi Yosef Leib Bloch (Telzer Rosh Yeshiva)
Insights
- 8:08 Denial of G-d is not a failure of belief but a deliberate covering up of belief, because a person who sees G-d cannot freely follow his desires; the boy compared it to driving with the brakes on.
- 10:28 Modern fears that progress and pollution will destroy the world are the same mistake as the Dor Haflagah, who built a tower to hold up the sky; Hashem who made the world maintains it.
- 17:50 Clotting that happens only on contact with air is itself the wonder: if blood clotted inside the veins it would cause thrombosis, strokes and heart attacks.
- 22:33 Water's exception to the rule of contraction in cold is a purposeful deviation: Hashem needs it for His world so that rivers freeze from the top and life survives below.
- 24:20 Just as ice has a pattern of behavior unique to it among the elements, Jews have a pattern of behavior different from the nations.
What the Mashgiach says to take from it
- 16:10 The Mashgiach says one need only open one's eyes to see Hashem in the workings of the world.