“ולגדלתו אין חקר”- The Human Mind is not Capable of Understanding G-dliness
Catalog entry: EMUNAH #1 (English) no. 8 Pocket Guide p. 71 English 26 min
Listen
About this shiur
The Mashgiach explains why chakirah, philosophy, is a dangerous and unreliable path to emunah: the human mind is not the organ that grasps Hashem, while the neshamah, a part of G-d above, can feel Him unless aveiros insulate it.
After reviewing two approaches to emunah, inherited faith and seeing Hashem's wonders, the Mashgiach turns to a third, chakirah or philosophy. He notes that yeshivos learn the Rambam's halachos but not his Moreh Nevuchim, and explains why: philosophy is mental acrobatics, and a sharper mind can always refute a proof. Jewish philosophy arose in Arab lands to keep Jews from Greek thought, but the Gedolei Yisrael rejected it, and the Mashgiach tells how Rabbeinu Yonah, after Gemaras were burned in Paris, did teshuvah for his part in burning the Rambam's sefer. The mind, made of flesh, cannot grasp the Creator, as a watch cannot understand the watchmaker; the organ for that is the neshamah and nevuah, which aveiros insulate. Philosophy exposes a person to the kasha without the teretz. He closes with the Spanish expulsion, where simple Jews gave their lives while the philosophers converted.
Topics: Simple Emunah, Above Reason · Doubts in Emunah and Amalek
Order of the shiur
-
0:00 A third approach: philosophy listed in the guide
The Mashgiach reviews the two earlier approaches to emunah and introduces a third, chakirah. He notes that yeshivos learn the Rambam's halachos but not his Moreh Nevuchim, and explains that philosophy is mental acrobatics that a sharper mind can always refute, so it proves nothing.
-
6:41 Gedolei Yisrael and Rabbeinu Yonah listed in the guide
The Mashgiach explains that Jewish philosophy was written in Arab lands to shield Jews from Greek philosophy, while the Gedolei Yisrael rejected it as a human product. He tells how Rabbeinu Yonah, after Gemaras were burned in Paris, did teshuvah for his role in burning the Rambam's sefer and wrote Shaarei Teshuvah.
-
10:15 The mind is not the organ for G-dliness listed in the guide
The Mashgiach explains that Hashem cannot be proven by logic because He is above the mind, which is made of flesh and understands only the earthly. A watch cannot understand its watchmaker, and claiming to understand Hashem with the mind is like listening to a painting or watching a symphony.
-
13:51 The neshamah's sixth sense and aveiros listed in the guide
The Mashgiach explains that the sixth sense for knowing Hashem is ruach hakodesh and nevuah, which every Jew has through his neshamah. Aveiros wrap the neshamah like insulation on a wire or Novocaine in the gums, and teshuvah brings the feeling back.
-
17:01 A guide for the perplexed, and the kasha without the teretz listed in the guide
The Mashgiach contrasts the Ramchal's Mesillas Yesharim with the Rambam's Moreh Nevuchim, written for those who are lost and cannot yet be lit by Torah. He explains that the Gedolim discouraged philosophy because one may hear the kasha without the teretz, and shows from Ein K'Elokeinu that we say the answer before the question.
-
22:10 The expulsion from Spain Story
The Mashgiach tells from the Or HaChaim of Rabbi Yosef Yaavetz that at the expulsion from Spain, on Tisha B'Av, simple Jews and women gave their lives for emunah, while those steeped in philosophy converted. He concludes that philosophy is a dangerous path to emunah and should be rejected, and promises a fourth approach next time.
The shiur, written up
A third approach: philosophy
The Mashgiach recalls two approaches to emunah already discussed: the faith inherited from earlier generations, and seeing Hashem's wonders in nature, in the body, in the survival of Klal Yisrael and of the living Torah. A third approach is chakirah, philosophy: deep logic used to prove that there is a Creator and that the Torah is from Heaven.
The greatest Jewish philosopher was the Rambam. Yeshivos spend years resolving contradictions in his halachos in the Yad HaChazakah, yet few even know of his Moreh Nevuchim, and there must be a reason. Philosophy, the Mashgiach explains, is mental acrobatics, like chess: a sharper mind can always refute a proof, so it proves nothing. a,b
Gedolei Yisrael and Rabbeinu Yonah
The Ashkenazi Gedolei Yisrael never cared for philosophy. It flourished in Arab lands, where Jews were drawn to Greek thought, so Sefardi Gedolim wrote a Jewish philosophy to protect them. Others opposed it: they wanted only the Torah received at Sinai, not a product of the human mind.
The mind is not the organ for G-dliness
Hashem cannot be proven with logic, the Mashgiach explains, not because we are not smart enough, but because He is above the mind. A mind of flesh grasps only earthly things, and a watch cannot understand its watchmaker. Claiming to understand Hashem with the mind is like listening to a painting or watching a symphony with one's eyes.
The neshamah's sixth sense
A guide for the perplexed
The Ramchal named his sefer of mussar, built on pesukim and Chazal, Mesillas Yesharim. The Rambam named his philosophy Moreh Nevuchim, a guide for the lost, written for those too far astray for Torah to light them, like a wet match that must first be dried through teshuvah. g,b
So the Acharonim, the Vilna Gaon and the Chassidishe sefarim discouraged philosophy. The Rambam himself warns that a reader may grasp the kasha and not the teretz, and even while weighing both sides, for that moment he does not believe. Hence in Ein K'Elokeinu we first say that none is like our G-d, then ask who is like Him. h,i
The expulsion from Spain
Rabbi Yosef Yaavetz writes in his Or HaChaim that when Ferdinand and Isabella expelled the Jews, those who gave their lives were simple people and women. It was Tisha B'Av, set for calamity since the meraglim, and they marched out with music; many were killed, enslaved or drowned. k,j
Those who converted were the ones steeped in philosophy. The Mashgiach concludes that philosophy is a dangerous path to emunah, to be rejected, and promises a fourth, most important approach next time.
Sources
Nevi'im
Talmud Bavli
Rishonim
Acharonim and Chassidus
Tefillah and Piyut
Key points
- 5:11 Philosophy proves nothing, because any logical proof can be refuted by a sharper mind.
- 6:47 The Gedolei Yisrael of Ashkenaz never took to philosophy; it was a foreign import, while the Torah was received at Sinai.
- 11:16 The human mind, made of flesh, grasps only what is earthly and cannot understand Hashem, just as a watch cannot understand the watchmaker.
- 14:12 Hashem is perceived through a sixth sense, nevuah and ruach hakodesh, which every Jew has through his neshamah according to his level.
- 16:01 Aveiros insulate the neshamah and deaden its feeling, and teshuvah restores it.
- 19:55 Philosophy is dangerous because a person may grasp the kasha without the teretz, and even while weighing both sides he is for that moment not believing.
Questions and answers
-
Question: 4:43 Why do yeshivos not learn the Rambam's Moreh Nevuchim?
Answer: 6:19 Because philosophy proves nothing and is dangerous to emunah; the Gedolei Yisrael rejected it and taught to learn Torah and halachah instead.
-
Question: 17:27 Why did the Rambam write a philosophical sefer at all?
Answer: 17:44 He wrote it for the perplexed, people too far astray for Torah to reach them, so they could at least understand through philosophy.
-
Question: 21:35 Why does Ein K'Elokeinu begin with the answer rather than the question?
Answer: 21:48 Because we do not trust ourselves with a kasha before its teretz.
Stories
-
8:44 Rabbeinu Yonah and the burning of the Gemaras
Because of the dispute over philosophy, Rabbeinu Yonah was instrumental in burning the Rambam's sefer in the streets of Paris. Some time later the authorities in Paris confiscated the Gemaras of France and burned thirty wagonloads of them, at a time when every Gemara was handwritten and precious. Rabbeinu Yonah concluded that this was the punishment for burning the Rambam's sefer, did teshuvah, and wrote Shaarei Teshuvah.
In the story: Rabbeinu Yonah, the Rambam
-
22:16 Simple Jews and philosophers at the expulsion from Spain
When King Ferdinand and Queen Isabella expelled the Jews from Spain, only those who converted could stay. Rabbi Yosef Yaavetz describes in his Or HaChaim that the ones who gave their lives were simple, unlearned Jews and women. The expulsion fell on Tisha B'Av, and the Rabbanim instituted that they march out with music to strengthen themselves; many were killed, sold as slaves or drowned at sea. Those who converted, even while secretly keeping Judaism, were the ones steeped in philosophy.
In the story: King Ferdinand of Spain, Queen Isabella of Spain, Rabbi Yosef Yaavetz
Insights
- 3:27 Yeshivos build their learning on resolving contradictions in the Rambam's halachos, yet leave his philosophy unlearned, and the Mashgiach says there must be a reason for it.
- 5:31 Philosophy is like chess: a proof by a mind of IQ 200 falls before one of 300, so it can never establish a truth.
- 10:49 Understanding Hashem with the mind is not a matter of being smart enough; it is the wrong organ, like seeing a symphony with the eyes.
- 15:06 Weakness in emunah comes from aveiros, which insulate the neshamah from Hashem like the sheath on an electric wire.
- 17:36 The title Moreh Nevuchim shows the sefer was written for the lost, who are like a wet match that Torah cannot ignite until they first do teshuvah.
- 21:38 In Ein K'Elokeinu we say the answer, 'there is none like our G-d', before the question, 'who is like our G-d', because we do not trust ourselves with a kasha before the teretz.
What the Mashgiach says to take from it
Mentioned in this shiur
People King Ferdinand of Spain, Queen Isabella of Spain, Rabbeinu Yonah, Rabbi Yosef Yaavetz, the Rambam, the Ramchal (Rabbi Moshe Chaim Luzzatto), the Vilna Gaon, Yeshayahu HaNavi
Terms חלק אלוק ממעל, חקירה, מסירות נפש, נבואה, קושיא, קריעת ים סוף, רבונו של עולם, רוח הקודש