The Multitudes at הר סיני - An Iron Proof of the Truth of the תורה
Catalog entry: EMUNAH #1 (English) no. 10 Pocket Guide p. 71 English 40 min
Listen
About this shiur
The Mashgiach explains that the emunah of Klal Yisrael rests not on the word of one man but on what millions of people saw together at Har Sinai and in the Midbar, a testimony that could never have been fabricated.
The Mashgiach opens with emunas tzaddikim, belief in tzaddikim alongside belief in Hashem, and says tzaddikim know everything because everything is in the Torah. He illustrates this with the story of the Ramban and his student Avner, who found his name hinted in a passuk of Haazinu, and with the Chazon Ish, who guided surgeons from his knowledge of Hilchos Treifos. The Torah is the blueprint of the world, and it also foretells the future: the division of Eretz Yisrael, the promise that nobody will covet a man's land when he goes up to Yerushalayim, galus, and the survival of the Jewish people and of the Torah while the empires that oppressed them vanished. After a question on Rashi's first comment, he turns to his main theme. Christianity and Islam each began with one man whom people believed. Jewish emunah rests on millions who stood at Har Sinai and lived through forty years of open miracles, recorded in a Torah that every Jew received and that was copied identically across the world.
Topics: Torah Min HaShamayim and the Mesorah · Matan Torah at Har Sinai
Order of the shiur
-
0:00 Emunas tzaddikim
The Mashgiach opens with emunas tzaddikim: at Kriyas Yam Suf the Jews believed in Hashem and in Moshe His servant. He says he has himself seen the ruach hakodesh of tzaddikim, and that tzaddikim know everything because everything is in the Torah.
-
3:13 The Ramban and Avner in Haazinu Story
The Mashgiach tells the story of the Ramban's student Avner, who went off the derech, challenged the Ramban's teaching that Haazinu contains every Jew's history, and was shown his name in the third letters of a passuk. Shaken, Avner did teshuvah and set off in a boat without oars.
-
7:08 Everything is in the Torah
The Mashgiach tells how the Chazon Ish showed surgeons how to perform brain surgery, saying he knew it from Hilchos Treifos. He brings the Ramban that Shlomo HaMelech knew everything from the Torah, explains that the Torah is the blueprint of creation, and notes that the Zohar says the world is round. He adds that, unlike other religions' books, the Torah foretells the future, and it was given identically to all of Klal Yisrael.
-
11:18 The Torah's promises come true
The Mashgiach shows the Torah foretelling the future: the nachalos of the shevatim and Yehoshua's conquest; the promise that nobody will covet a man's land when he goes up to Yerushalayim three times a year; galus and the survival of the Jews while Bavel, Paras, Yavan and Rome disappeared; and that the Torah will not be forgotten, as seen in the growth of Torah learning after the war.
-
18:07 A question on the first Rashi
The Mashgiach brings Rashi's first comment on Bereishis, that the Torah should have begun with the mitzvah of Rosh Chodesh, the first mitzvah given to Yisrael, and asks how it can be called the first when milah, and according to one opinion gid hanasheh, were commanded earlier.
-
21:18 What a multitude witnessed cannot be denied listed in the guide
The Mashgiach sets out why we believe: of the three main religions, Christianity and Islam accept the Torah but claim Hashem changed His mind. He then builds the principle that an event witnessed by hundreds of thousands cannot be fabricated, using President Ford, George Washington, Julius Caesar and Alexander the Great, whom the Gemara mentions meeting Shimon HaTzaddik.
-
29:26 Religions built on one man listed in the guide
The Mashgiach describes how Christianity began with one charismatic man whose teaching, built on Judaism, people believed, and how Islam began with Mohammed, whom the Rambam calls a madman, whose book contradicts recorded history. In both cases people believed one person.
-
33:16 Millions at Har Sinai listed in the guide
The Mashgiach concludes that Jews do not believe because Moshe said so, but because a few million people stood at Har Sinai and heard Hashem. The Torah, written at the end of forty years, recorded the miracles they all lived through, every Jew was commanded to have a Sefer Torah, and the Torah was copied letter for letter so that Jews cut off from each other for centuries hold the identical text.
The shiur, written up
Emunas tzaddikim
The Mashgiach opens with emunas tzaddikim. When the Torah describes the height of emunah reached at Kriyas Yam Suf, it says the Jews believed in Hashem and in Moshe His servant. Believing in Hashem alone is not enough, he says; one must believe in tzaddikim, and in oneself. He has himself seen their ruach hakodesh, and they know everything because everything is in the Torah. a
The Ramban and Avner
The Mashgiach tells of the Ramban's student Avner, who went off the derech and became a general. One Yom Kippur he summoned the Ramban, ate a pig before him, and said he had left because of the Ramban's teaching, hinted in his commentary, that Haazinu contains every Jew's history. Where was he in it? The Ramban showed him the passuk 'amarti af'eihem ashbisa me'enosh zichram', whose third letters spell Avner. Shaken, Avner did teshuvah and drifted off in a boat without oars. b,c
Everything is in the Torah
In the Mashgiach's own days, the Chazon Ish showed surgeons how to perform a brain operation, explaining that he knew anatomy from Hilchos Treifos. The Ramban writes that Shlomo HaMelech knew everything from the Torah. As the Zohar puts it, Hashem looked into the Torah and created the world, so the Torah is its blueprint; the Zohar even says the world is round. Unlike other religions' books, the Torah also foretells the future. d,e,f,g
The Torah's promises come true
The Torah foretells where each shevet's nachalah will lie, given by lottery, and that Yehoshua will cross over and divide the land. It commands every Jew to go up to Yerushalayim three times a year, and for Hakhel with his whole family, leaving his land unguarded, and promises that nobody will covet it. The Mashgiach asks how any author could dare such a promise. h,i,j
It also foretells sin, galus and survival. Bavel, Paras, Yavan and Rome are gone, while the Jews and the Torah live on, as the Torah promises it will not be forgotten. The Germans set out first to wipe out those who learned Gemara, yet today one large yeshiva holds as many students as all the yeshivos before the war. k
A question on the first Rashi
What a multitude saw cannot be denied
Turning to why Jews believe, the Mashgiach notes that Christianity and Islam both accept the Chumash and Nevi'im but claim Hashem changed His mind, which he calls absurd. Why must they accept the Torah?
Someone who denied there was ever a President Ford would have no case: hundreds of thousands saw him, and such a thing cannot be fabricated. So too George Washington, Julius Caesar, and Alexander the Great, whom the Gemara records meeting Shimon HaTzaddik. A historian's detail about Alexander's horse may be doubted, but not that he lived. What a multitude experienced cannot be denied. n
Religions built on one man
Christianity, the Mashgiach explains, began with one brilliant, charismatic Jew whose teaching made sense because it was built on Judaism, and people believed him. Islam began with Mohammed, whom the Rambam calls a madman, and whose book contradicts recorded history. In both, people believed one person.
Millions at Har Sinai
Jews do not believe because Moshe said so. A few million people stood at Har Sinai, Hashem spoke to each of them, and they passed it to their children. At the end of the forty years the Torah was written down, recording what all had lived through: the sea, Matan Torah, the mann, the pillars of cloud and fire. Nobody could deny it.
Every Jew was commanded to own a Sefer Torah, as the Rambam writes; the Rosh says that today the mitzvah is fulfilled by buying seforim. Jews cut off from each other for centuries hold identical scrolls, letter for letter. No other religion, the Mashgiach concludes, has an emunah not based on individuals. o
Sources
Torah
Talmud Bavli
Zohar and Kabbalah
Rishonim
- b apparently Ramban on Devarim, Parshas Haazinu index In the write-up: 3:28
- e apparently Ramban, introduction to the commentary on the Torah index In the write-up: 7:47
- l Rashi on Bereishis 1:1 text index In the write-up: 19:04
- o apparently Rambam, Hilchos Sefer Torah 7:1 index In the write-up: 35:01
Acharonim and Chassidus
Key points
- 0:55 Emunah includes emunas tzaddikim: believing in Moshe Rabbeinu and the tzaddikim, not only in Hashem.
- 2:59 Everything in the world is in the Torah, because Hashem looked into the Torah and created the world; this is how tzaddikim know everything.
- 11:11 The Torah foretells the future, from the division of Eretz Yisrael to galus and the eternal survival of the Jewish people and the Torah.
- 24:13 An event witnessed by a multitude, such as the existence of a president or of Alexander the Great, cannot be fabricated or denied.
- 30:58 Christianity and Islam rest on the word of one person; Jewish emunah rests on the experience of millions at Har Sinai.
- 34:20 The Torah, written at the end of forty years in the Midbar, recorded what the whole people had experienced and was copied letter for letter by every Jew down the generations.
Questions and answers
-
Question: 22:46 How can the Christians and Muslims, who accept the Chumash and Nevi'im, be forced to agree to the Torah's truth?
Answer: 24:13 Because an event experienced by a multitude, like the existence of a known historical figure, cannot be fabricated; Matan Torah was such an event.
-
Question: 33:22 Why do Jews believe, if not because Moshe told them?
Answer: 33:42 Because a few million people stood at Har Sinai and heard Hashem speak to each of them, and passed it on to their children.
-
Question: 19:29 Why did the Torah not begin with the first mitzvah?
Answer: 19:32 Rashi gives a reason, which the Mashgiach mentions without spelling out here; he goes on to ask how Rosh Chodesh can be the first mitzvah when milah came before it.
Stories
-
3:28 The Ramban and his student Avner
The Ramban had a student named Avner who went off the derech and became a general in the king's army. One Yom Kippur he summoned the Ramban, ate a pig in front of him, and argued with him. Avner said he had left because of the Ramban's teaching that Haazinu contains every Jew's history, and asked where he was in it. After praying by the wall, the Ramban showed him the passuk 'amarti af'eihem ashbisa me'enosh zichram', whose third letters spell Avner. Shaken, Avner decided to do teshuvah, set off in a rowboat without oars, and was never heard of again.
In the story: the Ramban, Avner
-
7:20 The Chazon Ish and the brain surgeons
In the Mashgiach's own adult years the Chazon Ish was known in America to know everything. When doctors were unsure how to perform a brain operation, they sent the patient to the Chazon Ish, who drew a diagram showing how to do it. The professors followed it and succeeded. Asked how he knew medicine, he answered that it is in the Torah: from Hilchos Treifos and the Gemara one knows the anatomy of the human body.
In the story: the Chazon Ish
Insights
- 1:08 Emunas tzaddikim is part of emunah itself: the Torah describes the height of emunah at the sea as belief in Hashem and in Moshe His servant, and the Mashgiach adds that one must also believe in oneself, since all Jews are tzaddikim.
- 8:13 Because Hashem looked into the Torah to create the world, anything that exists in the world must be found in the Torah; a tzaddik's knowledge of medicine or of the future is drawn from the Torah, not from outside study.
- 12:59 The Torah's daring promise that no one will covet a Jew's land while he goes up to Yerushalayim with his whole family is something no human author could have written; it shows the Torah's divine source.
- 27:57 Details reported by a single historian may be doubted, but the bare existence of a figure witnessed by multitudes cannot; this is the type of certainty on which Matan Torah rests.
- 37:04 The worldwide identity of the Sefer Torah is itself a proof: Jews separated for centuries by geography, with no means of contact, are found to hold the same text letter for letter, preserved by the halachah that one missing letter disqualifies a Sefer Torah.
What the Mashgiach says to take from it
- 1:01 The Mashgiach says it is not enough to believe in Hashem; one must believe in tzaddikim, and also believe in oneself.
Mentioned in this shiur
People Alexander the Great, Avner, Moshe Rabbeinu, Rabbi Shimon bar Yochai, Rabbi Yaakov Emden (the Yaavetz), Rashi, Shimon HaTzaddik, Shlomo HaMelech, the Chazon Ish, the Rambam, the Ramban, the Rosh, Yehoshua bin Nun
Terms אמונת חכמים, גיד הנשה, דור המדבר, החודש הזה לכם, הסתר, הקהל, מן, נחלה, קריעת ים סוף, רבונו של עולם, רוח הקודש, תורה שבעל פה