“לא איש אל כל ויכזב” - Hashem Knows Past Present and Future

Catalog entry: EMUNAH #1 (English) no. ⁨12⁩ Pocket Guide p. 71 English 25 min

Listen

  1. Download · Length 25 min

Open in the listening app

Notes Notes prepared by AI from the recording; not reviewed, and not the Mashgiach's words. The recording is the source.

About this shiur

The Mashgiach contrasts Jewish emunah, which believes even what it cannot see, with Amalek's denial of what he saw, and shows from the Rambam and the pesukim that the Torah can never be changed, since Hashem is not a man who changes His mind.

The Mashgiach opens by recalling that the Jewish belief in Moshe Rabbeinu and the Torah rests on what millions of Jews saw and heard at Har Sinai, passed down from generation to generation. Emunah in the full sense is believing what lies above human understanding, and since Hashem made the world with opposing forces, there is also a kefirah above understanding: denying what one sees. Amalek, who trembled at the splitting of the sea, still came to fight, the opposite of the Jews who believe even what they do not see. The Mashgiach then explains that the nations, Christians and Muslims, accept the Torah but cannot keep it, and so claim Hashem changed His mind. From the Rambam in Hilchos Yesodei HaTorah chapter nine and the pesukim, culminating in 'lo ish Kel vikazev', he shows the Torah can never change. He closes on why the nations hate the Jews, on censorship of sefarim, and on the security of Jewish emunah.

Topics: Torah Min HaShamayim and the Mesorah · Doubts in Emunah and Amalek · Simple Emunah, Above Reason · Yisroel and the Nations

Order of the shiur

  1. 0:00 Emunah from Sinai and above the intellect

    The Mashgiach recalls that belief in Moshe Rabbeinu and the Torah rests on what millions saw and heard at Sinai and passed down. He mentions the coming season of Purim and the war against Amalek, then explains that emunah means believing what is above the intellect, and that Hashem made every force of holiness with an opposing force.

  2. 4:37 Amalek denies what he sees

    Opposite emunah above the intellect stands a kefirah above the intellect: refusing to believe what one sees. The Mashgiach explains that seeing is not believing, that the Jews at the sea believed even beyond what they saw, while Amalek, one of the terrified chiefs of Edom, came to fight anyway; Moshe Rabbeinu against Amalek is emunah against kefirah.

  3. 9:01 Why the nations accept the Torah

    The Mashgiach explains that a fact witnessed by a multitude and passed down cannot be doubted, like the conquests of Alexander the Great, and the whole Jewish people everywhere has the same Torah and mitzvos. Therefore Christians and Muslims accept the Torah; he asks why they then have other religions and answers that they cannot keep it and rationalize that Hashem changed His mind.

  4. 12:34 The Torah can never change listed in the guide

    The Mashgiach reads from the Rambam, Hilchos Yesodei HaTorah chapter nine, that the Torah stands forever and nothing may be added or taken away, bringing the pesukim of 'lo sosef', 'lanu ul'vaneinu ad olam' and 'lo bashamayim hi'. A prophet who claims the mitzvos were temporary is a false prophet, and he ends with the pasuk that Hashem is not a man who lies or changes His mind, since He knows the future.

  5. 17:48 Why the nations hate the Jews

    The Mashgiach says the learned among the nations know the truth but their pride and desires keep them from admitting it, and asks why they hate the Jews; he answers that it is envy. He describes how censors removed passages from the siddur, the Rambam and the Gemara, tells of converts who gave their lives for the truth, and closes with the security and joy of Jewish emunah in the Written and Oral Torah.

The shiur, written up

Emunah from Sinai and above the intellect

0:00

The Mashgiach recalls the principle of the Ani Maamin on the prophecy of Moshe Rabbeinu: the Jews' faith in the Torah rests on what millions saw at Har Sinai, where Hashem spoke to them 'face to face', and on a Torah handed down through the generations, which cannot be questioned. a,b

3:10

Beyond what the senses grasp, he says, emunah believes what is above the intellect. And since 'zeh l'umas zeh', everything in holiness has an opposing force. c

Amalek denies what he sees

4:46

Opposite emunah stands a kefirah above the intellect: refusing to believe what one sees. Seeing, the Mashgiach explains, is knowing, like seeing daylight through an open window; the Jews, believers the sons of believers, believed even what Moshe Rabbeinu told them beyond what they saw. d

7:28

At the splitting of the sea the chiefs of Edom trembled, and Amalek is counted among them in Vayishlach. Yet weeks later he came to fight. Moshe Rabbeinu against Amalek is emunah against kefirah. e,f

Why the nations accept the Torah

9:16

What millions witnessed cannot be denied, as all accept Alexander the Great; so Christians and Muslims accept the Torah. Why, then, other religions? The Mashgiach answers, citing Chazal on Esav and Yishmael, that they cannot keep it, so they claim Hashem changed His mind.

The Torah can never change

12:43

The Mashgiach reads the Rambam in Hilchos Yesodei HaTorah 9:1: the Torah stands forever, and nothing may be added or removed. He brings 'lo sosef', 'lanu ul'vaneinu ad olam' from Nitzavim, and 'lo bashamayim hi': no one may fetch another Torah from heaven. g,h,i,j

15:46

A prophet, Jew or gentile, who says the mitzvos were temporary is a false prophet, punishable as Parshas Re'eh says. Hashem, who knows the future, is not a man who lies or changes His mind. k,l,m

Why the nations hate the Jews

17:58

The Mashgiach says the learned among the nations know the truth, but pride and desire keep them from admitting it. Asked why they hate the Jews, he answers: envy, since they see the Jews are superior.

19:51

He describes how apostates had passages removed from the siddur, including parts of Aleinu, and from the Rambam's laws of Moshiach, and changed 'goy' in the Gemara. Converts who gave their lives for the truth were burned at the stake. n

23:35

These ideas are elaborated in sefarim like the Kuzari. Jews believe in the Written Torah because they saw it, and in the Oral Torah through Moshe Rabbeinu, secure enough to thank Hashem each morning with simchah. o

Sources

Torah

  1. b Devarim 5:4 text index In the write-up: 0:00
  2. e Shemos 15:15 text index In the write-up: 7:28
  3. f apparently Bereishis 36:15-16 index In the write-up: 7:28
  4. h apparently Devarim 13:1 index In the write-up: 12:43
  5. i Devarim 29:28 text index In the write-up: 12:43
  6. j Devarim 30:12 text index In the write-up: 12:43
  7. l apparently Devarim 13:2-6 index In the write-up: 15:46
  8. m Bamidbar 23:19 text index In the write-up: 15:46

Kesuvim

  1. c Koheles 7:14 text index In the write-up: 3:10

Talmud Bavli

  1. d apparently Shabbos 97a index In the write-up: 4:46

Rishonim

  1. g Hilchos Yesodei HaTorah 9:1 text index In the write-up: 12:43
  2. k Hilchos Yesodei HaTorah 9:1 text index In the write-up: 15:46
  3. n Rambam, Mishneh Torah (place not identified) index In the write-up: 19:51
  4. o Kuzari (place not identified) index In the write-up: 23:35

Tefillah and Piyut

  1. a apparently Ani Maamin, seventh principle index In the write-up: 0:00

Key points

  1. 0:31 The Mashgiach says the Jewish belief in the Torah rests on what a whole nation saw and heard at Har Sinai and passed down, which cannot be questioned.
  2. 4:37 Emunah means believing what is above the intellect; opposite it stands a kefirah above the intellect, refusing to believe even what one sees.
  3. 7:20 Amalek, who trembled at the splitting of the sea along with the other chiefs of Edom, still came to fight, denying what he saw.
  4. 11:05 The nations accept the Torah but cannot keep it, so they rationalize that Hashem changed His mind and gave them another Torah.
  5. 12:46 The Rambam, from explicit pesukim, establishes that the Torah stands forever, may not be added to or reduced, and that any prophet who says otherwise is a false prophet.
  6. 13:22 Hashem does not change His mind, because He knows what will be later; the pasuk says He is not a man who lies or changes his mind.
  7. 17:58 The Mashgiach says the nations' hatred of the Jews comes from envy: deep down their thinking people know the truth but their pride and desires keep them from admitting it.

Questions and answers

  1. Question: 12:04 If the nations believe in the Torah, why do they have different religions?

    Answer: 12:12 They cannot keep the Torah, as Chazal say of Esav and Yishmael, so they rationalize that Hashem changed His mind.

  2. Question: 13:10 How can anyone claim the Torah was replaced?

    Answer: 13:18 The Torah itself says it will never change, and Hashem does not change His mind, since He knows what will be later.

  3. Question: 18:50 Why do the nations hate the Jews?

    Answer: 19:28 Out of envy: they see that the Jews are superior, and deep down they know the truth but cannot bring themselves to admit it.

Insights

  1. 4:15 Just as every force of holiness has its opposite, emunah above the intellect is matched by a kefirah above the intellect: refusing to believe what the intellect itself sees.
  2. 6:09 What the Jews saw at the sea was knowledge, not belief, like seeing daylight through an open window; their emunah was in what lay beyond that, what Moshe Rabbeinu told them of heaven.
  3. 7:32 Amalek is listed among the chiefs of Edom who trembled at the splitting of the sea, so his attack weeks later was a denial of what he himself had seen, the exact reverse of Jewish emunah.
  4. 12:04 The other religions are not a denial of the Torah but a rationalization: unable to keep it, they claim that Hashem changed His mind.
  5. 13:04 Hashem cannot be said to change His mind, since He already knows what will be later; this is why the Torah's own promise that it will never change is decisive.

What the Mashgiach says to take from it

  1. 24:17 The Mashgiach says a Jew can be secure in his emunah and get up each morning to thank Hashem with simchah and contentment.

Mentioned in this shiur

People Alexander the Great, Amalek, Cardinal O'Connor, Esav, Mohammed, Moshe Rabbeinu, the Avos, the Rambam, Yishmael

Terms אמונה, גרים, זה לעומת זה, טומאה, כפירה, מאמינים בני מאמינים, מחיית עמלק, מסירות נפש, נביא שקר, קנאה, קריעת ים סוף, רבונו של עולם, תורה שבכתב, תורה שבעל פה

Report an error on this page