Seeking Hashem from a Distance
Catalog entry: EMUNAH #1 (English) no. 17 Pocket Guide p. 72 English 32 min
Listen
About this shiur
The Mashgiach explains that the Akeidah was Avraham Avinu's hardest test because he saw Hashem only 'from a distance', confused by questions he could not answer, and that Klal Yisrael at the end of the golus is living through that same tenth test.
The Mashgiach opens with Parshas HaAkeidah, said every morning, and asks why the last of Avraham's ten tests was the hardest. He contrasts it with the first test, Ur Kasdim, where Avraham, searching for the truth, gave his life for a Creator he had never seen. A test, he explains from the double meaning of nisayon, is meant to raise a person, so each one is harder than the last. The Zohar points to 'he saw the place from a distance': at the Akeidah Avraham felt far from Hashem, because the command contradicted the promise that his seed would come from Yitzchak, and kashyos about Hashem's truth entered his mind. He pushed them away and went blindly. Why he did not notice that he was only told to bring Yitzchak up, as Rashi explains, is answered: when Hashem does not want a person to know, he does not know, as with Haman and the seventh of Adar. Following the Ramban that the fathers' events foreshadow the children's, the Mashgiach says Klal Yisrael now faces the tenth test of hester panim and must hold on to emunah.
Topics: Akeidas Yitzchak · Avraham Avinu · Hester Panim and Suffering · Simple Emunah, Above Reason · Avodah of the Last Generation
Order of the shiur
-
0:00 The Akeidah: the hardest of the ten tests
The Mashgiach opens with Parshas HaAkeidah, said every morning, and asks why it is the climax of tefillah. He asks who in the room would not obey if Hashem appeared and commanded him, and notes that Avraham passed all ten tests, the Akeidah being the last and hardest.
-
3:15 The first test: Ur Kasdim
The Mashgiach tells how young Avraham searched for the truth, rejected the sun and the moon, concluded there is one Creator, defied Nimrod and was thrown into the fire unharmed. Hashem then revealed Himself to him, but in Ur Kasdim Avraham gave his life for a G-d he had never seen.
-
8:00 Nisayon means raising; seeing Hashem from afar listed in the guide
From lashon hakodesh, where nisayon also means raising, the Mashgiach explains that every test is meant to promote, so each is harder than the last. He then asks why the Akeidah was harder than Ur Kasdim and brings the Zohar's hint: 'he saw the Place from a distance', echoed in the haftarah of the second day of Rosh Hashanah.
-
11:43 Avraham's confusion and his blind faith listed in the guide
The Mashgiach describes Avraham's inner turmoil: Hashem is Emes and keeps His word, yet the command to slaughter Yitzchak contradicted the promise of seed through him. Avraham pushed the kashyos away, covered his eyes and said Shema, and went blindly; afterwards he asked the malach why Hashem had changed His mind, and was told, as Rashi brings, that he was only told to bring Yitzchak up.
-
18:38 When Hashem hides, one does not know
The Mashgiach asks how Avraham, who understood Hashem more than the malachim, missed what a child learning Rashi sees, and answers that when Hashem tests a person and does not want him to know, he does not know. He applies the same answer to Haman, who calculated that Moshe died on the seventh of Adar but did not realize he was also born then.
-
21:59 Maaseh avos siman labanim: the tenth test today
The Mashgiach calls the Akeidah a test of hester panim and brings the Ramban in Lech Lecha that the fathers' events foreshadow the children's: the famine, Pharaoh taking Sarah, the plagues and the gifts. By that pattern Klal Yisrael goes through Avraham's ten tests, and at the end of the golus faces the tenth: a whole world full of kashyos, from the Holocaust to the darkness of most of Klal Yisrael.
-
26:23 Holding on to emunah until Moshiach
The Mashgiach recalls books written after the war questioning Hashem, and says that today a handful of Yidden who believe are living through Avraham's last test, with the promise that emunah will prevail. Like Avraham, one must cover one's eyes and say Shema and 'Hashem Elokeichem Emes'; the added word Emes corresponds to the 'eikev', the heels of Moshiach, which is why Avraham was told 'eikev asher shamata bekoli'.
The shiur, written up
The Akeidah: the hardest of the ten tests
The Mashgiach sets out to explain why Parshas HaAkeidah, said every morning, is the climax of our tefillah. He asks who in the room would refuse if Hashem appeared and commanded him. Avraham passed all ten tests, as the Mishnah says, and the Midrash has Hashem ask him to pass this last one, for otherwise all the earlier ones would be lost. a,b
The first test: Ur Kasdim
The first test was Ur Kasdim. Avraham searched for the truth as a boy and saw that so wondrous a world could not have made itself, any more than the building across the street. As the Midrash tells, he worshipped the sun, then the moon, until he concluded that one Master runs this harmonious universe. Nimrod threw him into the fire and he came out unharmed. Only afterwards did Hashem reveal Himself; Avraham had given his life for a G-d he had never seen. c
Nisayon means raising; seeing Hashem from afar
In lashon hakodesh, the Mashgiach explains, nisayon also means raising, as a flag is a nes because it is held high. A test is meant to promote, so each is harder than the last, and the tenth was the hardest. Why harder than Ur Kasdim? The Zohar points to the passuk 'he saw the Place from a distance': Avraham saw Hashem from afar, as the haftarah of the second day of Rosh Hashanah opens 'from afar Hashem appeared to me'. d,e,g
Avraham's confusion and his blind faith
Over many years Avraham had come to know Hashem's attribute of Emes: He keeps His promises, as Bilaam said in the passuk in Balak. Hashem had promised that his seed would come through Yitzchak, and now commanded him to slaughter Yitzchak. Avraham was perplexed: where is the Emes? He felt estranged, as if this were not the Hashem he had known. i,j
He pushed the kashyos away, covered his eyes, said Shema Yisrael and went to the Akeidah blindly, giving the questions no place in his mind. Yet, the Mashgiach notes, it was no kashya at all: afterwards Avraham asked the malach why Hashem had changed His mind, and was told, as Rashi brings from the Midrash, that he had only been told to bring Yitzchak up. k
When Hashem hides, one does not know
Why did Avraham, who understood Hashem beyond the malachim, miss what a child learning Rashi sees? The passuk says Hashem tested him, and when Hashem does not want a person to know, he does not know. So too Haman, brilliant enough to calculate that Moshe died on the seventh of Adar, missed that Moshe was born then, for Hashem wanted there to be Purim. l,m
The tenth test today
The Akeidah, the Mashgiach says, was hester panim: Avraham was confused and had kashyos. The Ramban in Lech Lecha teaches that what happened to the fathers foreshadows the children: the famine sent Avraham to Mitzrayim, Pharaoh took Sarah, was struck and released her with gifts, as Yidden would later leave Egypt with great wealth. p,q
By this pattern Klal Yisrael goes through Avraham's ten tests, and in the last stretch of the golus faces the tenth. The whole world is full of kashyos: the Holocaust, war in Eretz Yisrael, most Yidden in darkness.
Holding on to emunah until Moshiach
The Mashgiach recalls books after the war asking whether G-d is dead. Today a handful of Yidden keep the Torah and believe, with the promise that, as Avraham passed the Akeidah, emunah will prevail until Moshiach. Facing kashyos, he says, one must cover one's eyes and say Shema and 'Hashem Elokeichem Emes'. h
The word Emes, which the Torah does not write and we add ourselves, corresponds to the eikev, the heels of Moshiach, when the truth is not seen. Hence Avraham was told 'eikev asher shamata bekoli'. On us, the Mashgiach says, is the duty to pass this test, holding on to emunah despite hostile media and publications. r
Sources
Torah
- e Bereishis 22:4 text index In the write-up: 9:20
- i Bamidbar 23:19 text index In the write-up: 12:25
- j Bereishis 21:12 text index In the write-up: 12:25
- l Bereishis 22:1 text index In the write-up: 18:47
- q Bereishis 13:2 text index In the write-up: 22:09
- r Bereishis 22:16-18 text index In the write-up: 29:00
Nevi'im
Mishnah
Talmud Bavli
Midrash
Zohar and Kabbalah
Rishonim
Tefillah and Piyut
Key points
- 3:04 The Akeidah, the tenth and last of Avraham's tests, was the hardest; had he failed it, the Mashgiach says, all the earlier tests would have been lost.
- 9:14 A nisayon is also a raising, like a flag (nes) held high: every test is meant to promote a person, so each test is harder than the one before.
- 11:02 At the Akeidah Avraham saw Hashem 'from a distance': the command to slaughter Yitzchak seemed to contradict the promise that his seed would come through Yitzchak, and kashyos made him feel estranged.
- 14:44 Avraham dismissed the kashyos, covered his eyes, said Shema Yisrael and went to the Akeidah blindly, without giving the questions any place in his mind.
- 18:51 When Hashem does not want a person to know something, even the wisest cannot figure it out; so it was with Avraham at the Akeidah and with Haman and the seventh of Adar.
- 22:40 Following the Ramban that the fathers' events foreshadow the children's, Klal Yisrael at the end of the golus is going through Avraham's tenth test of hester panim, and those who hold on to emunah will pass it.
Questions and answers
-
Question: 10:25 Why was the Akeidah a harder test than Ur Kasdim, where Avraham gave his life?
Answer: 11:02 Because at the Akeidah he saw Hashem only from a distance: the command contradicted Hashem's promise, kashyos about Hashem's truth entered his mind, and he felt estranged from Him.
-
Question: 9:40 What is the purpose of a test, and why is each test harder than the one before?
Answer: 9:20 Nisayon also means raising, as a flag is called nes because it is held high; a test is meant to promote a person, so each one is harder than the last.
-
Question: 18:18 Why did Avraham, the great wise man, not notice what a child learning Rashi sees, that Hashem only told him to bring Yitzchak up?
Answer: 18:47 Because Hashem was testing him; when Hashem does not want a person to know, he simply does not know.
-
Question: 21:16 How could Haman, who calculated that Moshe died on the seventh of Adar, not realize that Moshe was also born on that day?
Answer: 21:43 Hashem did not want him to know, so he did not know; had he figured it out, there would be no Purim.
Stories
-
3:38 Avraham in Ur Kasdim
Avraham as a boy searched for the truth and could not accept that the world made itself. He first thought the sun made it and worshipped the sun, but at night the sun set and the moon came out; then the moon disappeared in the morning. He concluded that one Master runs this harmonious world and began to serve Him without knowing who He was. Nimrod told him to stop; Avraham refused and was thrown into the fire, from which he came out with not even his clothes harmed, while those who threw him in were burned.
In the story: Avraham Avinu, Nimrod, Terach
Insights
- 7:35 Ur Kasdim was self-sacrifice for a G-d Avraham had never seen; the Akeidah was harder because he had come to know Hashem as Emes over many years, and now saw Him only 'from a distance', as if the One he knew was not keeping His word.
- 18:18 Avraham could not see the simple answer a child learning Rashi sees, not for lack of wisdom, but because the test required that he not know: when Hashem does not want a person to know, he does not know.
- 21:16 The same answer resolves how Haman, brilliant enough to calculate that Moshe died on the seventh of Adar, missed that Moshe was also born then: Hashem wanted there to be Purim.
- 24:42 Applying the Ramban's principle to the ten tests, the Mashgiach says each era of Jewish history could be matched to one of Avraham's tests, and the last stretch of the golus corresponds to the Akeidah, a test of hester panim and kashyos.
- 28:23 The word Emes, which the Torah does not write after the parshiyos of Shema but which we add ourselves, corresponds to the 'eikev', the heels of Moshiach, when the truth cannot be seen; hence Avraham was told 'eikev asher shamata bekoli'.
What the Mashgiach says to take from it
- 27:48 The Mashgiach says that in the face of kashyos one must close one's eyes, hold one's hands over them and say Shema Yisrael and 'Hashem Elokeichem Emes', as Avraham did.
- 30:31 The Mashgiach says it is our duty to pass this tenth test by holding on to emunah tooth and nail, despite the kashyos, the hostile society, the media and the publications thrust in our faces.
- 31:18 Because the Akeidah is such an important parshah, the Mashgiach says it is to be said every day.
Mentioned in this shiur
People Avraham Avinu, Bilaam, Haman, Moshe Rabbeinu, Nimrod, Pharaoh, Rashi, Sarah Imeinu, the Ramban, Yaakov Avinu, Yitzchak Avinu, Yosef HaTzaddik
Terms אור כשדים, אמת, הסתר פנים, לשון הקודש, מעשה אבות סימן לבנים, נסיון, עקבתא דמשיחא, קושיא, רבונו של עולם