פרקי אבות
פרק ששי: The קדושה of צדיקים and the חשיבות of Learning תורה
Catalog entry: MISCELLANEOUS (English) no. 1 Pocket Guide p. 69 תשל"ח (1977–78) English 1 hr 29 min
Listen
About this shiur
Learning the sixth perek of Pirkei Avos, the Mashgiach explains the kedushah of tzaddikim, whose very names carry holiness, and the greatness of one who learns Torah lishmah, for whom the whole world exists and whom the Torah guards from sin.
The Mashgiach opens the added sixth perek of Avos and asks why the Mishnah names its Tannaim: a tzaddik who learns Torah lishmah becomes so holy that his name is Torah. A person's name is his neshamah, as Adam named each creature by its letters; sinners lose their names, as with Zimri and Cozbi, and Moshe called Dasan and Aviram by their righteous father's name. He then asks what the 'many things' are that one who learns lishmah merits. Holy things spoil easily, like wine, which stands for Olam Haba, and that reward is beyond what any navi saw. The whole world exists for such a tzaddik, and everything that happens in it is for the tzaddikim. Following Derech Hashem, he shows that mitzvos bring down blessing, Torah lishmah most of all. Such a person loves Hashem and people and is loved by both. Stories of tzaddikim who sensed forbidden food show how the Torah keeps him from sin.
Topics: Pirkei Avos · Torah Lishmah and Hasmadah · Naming a Child · Stories of Tzaddikim
Order of the shiur
-
0:00 Why the Mishnah names the Tanna listed in the guide
The Mashgiach introduces the sixth perek of Avos, added for the weeks from Pesach to Shavuos and written in the language of the Mishnah. He asks why the Tanna's name is mentioned at all, and answers that a tzaddik who learns lishmah becomes so holy that his name itself is Torah.
-
4:44 The power of a tzaddik's name listed in the guide
The Mashgiach brings the tradition that saying the word Berditchev helps a person in trouble, and the Gemara that mentions Chevron to recall the Avos, to show that even a tzaddik's place carries his holiness. He tells of a simple shoemaker who said the names of tzaddikim with every blow of his hammer.
-
9:01 A name is the neshamah listed in the guide
The Mashgiach explains that a person's name in loshon hakodesh is the root of his neshamah. Adam HaRishon did not invent names: he saw from each creature's nature which letters it was made of, unlike English names that mean nothing. A person who sins loses his name.
-
13:22 Losing a name: Zimri and Dasan listed in the guide
The Mashgiach asks why the passuk at the end of Balak does not name the man and the Midianite woman during the sin but names them after Pinchas killed them: through the sin they lost their names and got them back afterwards. He brings a vort that Moshe called Dasan and Aviram 'sons of Eliav' to raise them through their father's name.
-
17:54 What are the 'many things'? listed in the guide
The Mashgiach reads that one who learns Torah lishmah merits 'many things' and asks what they are, since the list that follows is said to be in addition. The Tanna does not say because he does not know: no eye has seen the reward of a talmid chacham. He begins to explain with the custom of covering wine from a gentile's look, since the holier a thing is, the easier it is spoiled.
-
21:54 Wine, Olam Haba and the power of a look listed in the guide
The Mashgiach explains that wine stands for the wine kept for Olam Haba, which is why Kiddush is made on it and why it is so easily spoiled. A tzaddik's look brings kedushah, as the Ramban explains about Moshe counting the Jews, and looking at the letters of the Sefer Torah at hagbah does too. Olam Haba is so holy that a gentile may not even look at it, and no navi saw the reward of one who learns lishmah.
-
28:17 The whole world is worthwhile for him listed in the guide
The Mashgiach explains that the whole world was created for one who learns lishmah, bringing Ben Zoma's brachah over the crowds who serve him. To answer why Hashem keeps a world so full of reshaim, he gives the mashal of a merchant whose one returning ship pays for nineteen lost ones, and adds that roads are built so that a tzaddik can pass on them.
-
33:09 Everything happens for the tzaddikim listed in the guide
The Mashgiach tells of a tzaddik who smiled because he saw a king's castle, built by twenty thousand workers over twenty years, collapse after it sheltered a tzaddik from the rain for a few minutes. He applies this to the news: Vashti's death in Persia and Nixon's resignation happened for reasons known only in Heaven, and in the future the nations will claim reward for having built roads and houses for the Jews.
-
39:21 Mitzvos bring down blessing listed in the guide
The Mashgiach explains why one who learns lishmah is called a friend, using the Derech Hashem: mitzvos rise to Heaven and return as blessing, aveiros as suffering, and Torah lishmah brings the greatest blessing. He brings Rashi that in the time of the Mabul even the animals were corrupted because of people, while Noach's portion of the world stayed good. He stops for time and promises to explain Torah lishmah further.
-
47:01 Loving Hashem and loved by people listed in the guide
The Mashgiach explains that the love goes both ways: what a person is in Heaven he is below, as in the earlier Mishnah about one whom people are pleased with, and as the Maggid read 'know what is above is from you'. He brings the Midrash of a tzaddik whose coffin floated, with the passuk that one who offers all his wealth for such love is scorned, and explains it with the mashal of offering eighty-five cents for a Buick.
-
53:28 No self-interest, no machlokes listed in the guide
The Mashgiach explains that people quarrel because each has his own interest, while in the days of Moshiach all will want one thing and form one band to do Hashem's will. One who learns lishmah never means himself, so he loves everyone. He resolves how one can love both Hashem and a fellow Jew without dividing the love: every Jew's neshamah is a part of Hashem, as is the Torah.
-
57:53 Kept from sin: the Beis Halevi and Yeshuos Yaakov Story listed in the guide
The Mashgiach explains that one who learns lishmah is never a ba'al ga'avah and has special help from Heaven to stay far from sin. He tells how the Beis Halevi did not eat a chicken later found to be treif, and how the Yeshuos Yaakov sensed that a pancake made in a fleishig pan was treif when it spurted in his face, since for a great tzaddik everything is a sign from Heaven.
-
1:04:38 The Vitebsker's fish in Eretz Yisrael Story listed in the guide
The Mashgiach tells of Rav Menachem Mendel of Vitebsk, the Maggid's leading talmid, whose going to Eretz Yisrael left the other talmidim to become Rebbes. In chutz la'aretz a fish swam into his gabbai's net for Shabbos; in Tzfas the heavenly calls to teshuvah kept him awake, and in Teveria the fish splashed the gabbai, which he explained by the strength of Eretz Yisrael's creatures.
-
1:11:12 Food that once had a shaylah Story listed in the guide
The Mashgiach tells that the Chiddushei HaRim never ate anything on which there had been a shaylah, even when a Rav ruled it kosher, because even a havamina of treif leaves a trace of impurity, and he sensed it once when it was given to him. He adds a story of the Belzer Rav who refused fruit even though every halachic consideration permitted it.
-
1:17:13 The Slonimer Rebbe and the beard Story listed in the guide
The Mashgiach tells a story he heard from a Slonimer chassid in his shtibel in Williamsburg who witnessed it: the Slonimer Rebbe ate supper at the home of a poor beardless Jew in Yerushalayim, refused the fish because the borrowed plates had not been toveled, and told the host and the bearded neighbor the difference between them. He concludes that Hashem helps tzaddikim know what is forbidden.
-
1:24:36 Mr. Singer and the Radziner gabbai Story
The Mashgiach begins a story told to him as a boy by Mr. Singer, an honest man in his Williamsburg shtibel, whose father hosted the Radziner Rebbe's gabbai when he came to collect ma'amados. He starts the story over in brief.
The shiur, written up
Why the Mishnah names the Tanna
The Mashgiach opens the sixth perek of Avos, beraisos added because Avos is learned from Pesach to Shavuos, and notes that unlike other beraisos they are written in the language of the Mishnah. He asks why the Mishnah must name the Tanna at all when no one disputes him. His answer: a tzaddik who learns Torah lishmah raises himself until his name is Torah, so saying 'Rabbi Akiva' is like saying a word of Torah. a
The power of a tzaddik's name
From here the Mashgiach shows how much a tzaddik's name carries. He cites a tradition that saying 'Berditchev' helps a person in trouble, and the Gemara that mentions Chevron to recall the Avos buried there: even a tzaddik's place draws down a yeshuah. He tells of a simple shoemaker who said the names of tzaddikim with every blow of his hammer, knowing this would purify his neshamah. c
A name is the neshamah
A person's name in loshon hakodesh, the Mashgiach explains, is his neshamah. When Adam HaRishon named the animals he did not invent names: the world was made with the letters of the Torah, and he saw from each creature's nature which letters formed it, the ox, the eagle, the lion. An English name means nothing. One who does not keep the Torah can lose his name, and the Mashgiach brings the Shelah's advice to say a passuk for one's name. d,e
Losing a name: Zimri and Dasan
He proves this from the end of Parshas Balak: during the sin the passuk speaks only of 'a man of Bnei Yisrael' and 'the Midianite woman', and names Zimri and Cozbi only after Pinchas killed them. Through the sin they lost their names and regained them afterwards. Likewise Moshe called Dasan and Aviram 'sons of Eliav', using their righteous father's name to raise them, since a rasha's own name brings no good. f,g
What are the 'many things'?
The Mashgiach turns to the Mishnah that whoever learns Torah lishmah merits 'many things', and asks what they are, since the list that follows comes in addition. The Tanna does not say because he does not know: Chazal teach that no eye, not even a navi's, has seen the reward of a talmid chacham. To show how great that is, he recalls the custom of covering wine when a gentile enters, for the holier a thing is, the more easily it spoils. b,h
Wine, Olam Haba and the power of a look
Wine, the Mashgiach explains, stands for the wine kept for Olam Haba, which is why Kiddush is made over it and why even a gentile's look spoils it. A look has power: a tzaddik's look brings kedushah, as the Ramban explains Moshe counting each Jew himself, and at hagbah everyone should look at the letters of the Sefer Torah, since each Jew is one of its letters. i,j
A Jew's look does not spoil wine; a gentile's does. Olam Haba is so holy that a gentile may not even look at it, and no navi saw the Olam Haba of one who learns lishmah. That is why the Tanna could not list it.
The whole world is worthwhile for him
The Mishnah adds that the whole world is worthwhile for him. The Mashgiach brings Ben Zoma, who saw the crowds and blessed Hashem who created them all to serve him. Why keep up a world so full of reshaim? Like a merchant whose single returning ship pays for nineteen that sank, the few tzaddikim give Hashem more pleasure than all the reshaim. Even highways are built so that a tzaddik can travel on them. b,k
Everything happens for the tzaddikim
He tells of a tzaddik who smiled because he had seen, in a far country, a king's castle built by twenty thousand workers over twenty years: a tzaddik sheltered under it from the rain, and then an earthquake brought it down. Its true purpose was those few minutes. So too with the news: Vashti's death and Nixon's resignation have worldly explanations, but everything happens because of the tzaddikim and Klal Yisrael. In the future the nations will claim reward for building roads and houses, and will be told they did it for themselves. m
Mitzvos bring down blessing
The one who learns lishmah is called a friend, and to explain why, the Mashgiach brings the Ramchal's Derech Hashem. Every mitzvah rises to Heaven and returns as shefa: health, wealth and happiness; every aveirah comes down as destruction, sickness and sorrow. Hashem gave Klal Yisrael the power to control the world through their deeds, and the greatest shefa of all comes from Torah lishmah. n
He brings Rashi that in the generation of the Mabul even the animals were corrupted because of people. Each person spoils his own portion of the world through his aveiros, but Noach did not sin, so the animals of his portion were saved. The Mashgiach then stops for time and promises to explain another week what Torah lishmah means. o
Loving Hashem and loved by people
Resuming, the Mashgiach explains that the love goes both ways, as the earlier Mishnah says that one whom people are pleased with, Hashem is pleased with: what a person is in Heaven, he is below. He cites the Maggid's reading of 'know what is above is from you': a Jew who sings zemiros with simcha on Shabbos causes simcha above. p,q
People love him because Hashem loves him. The Mashgiach brings a Midrash of a tzaddik whose coffin floated, carried by malachim, and the passuk that one who offers all his wealth for such love is scorned. It is like offering eighty-five cents for a six-thousand-dollar Buick: the dealer would throw him out. r,s
No self-interest, no machlokes
Why do people quarrel? Because each wants something else: honor, money, desire. When Moshiach comes all will want one thing and form one band to do Hashem's will. One who learns lishmah already never means himself, so he loves everyone. The Mashgiach asks how one can love both Hashem and a fellow Jew without dividing the love, and answers from 'love your fellow as yourself, I am Hashem': every Jew's neshamah is a part of Hashem, as is the Torah. t
Kept from sin: the Beis Halevi and Yeshuos Yaakov
One who learns lishmah, the Mashgiach continues, is never a ba'al ga'avah, since he does not care about his own honor, and the Torah keeps him far from sin with special help from Heaven. When the Beis Halevi left Rav Yehoshua Leib Diskin, the Rebbetzin gave him chicken for the way and then found it treif; Rav Yehoshua Leib said he would not eat it, and indeed he had not.
The Yeshuos Yaakov held off eating a hot pancake until his hostess rushed in: it was made with butter in a fleishig pan. He explained that it had spurted in his face when cut, and a kosher pancake would not do that. For a great tzaddik, the Mashgiach says, everything is a sign from Heaven.
The Vitebsker's fish in Eretz Yisrael
Rav Menachem Mendel of Vitebsk, the Maggid's leading talmid, went to Eretz Yisrael, and so the other talmidim became Rebbes in many places. In chutz la'aretz, when his gabbai announced at the river that he needed fish for Shabbos, a big fish swam into the net.
In Tzfas, a city full of great tzaddikim, the air was so clear that he heard the heavenly calls to teshuvah and could not sleep. The Mashgiach notes that, as the Mishnah later says, these calls go out every day, and a Jewish heart is the radio that picks them up. In Teveria, after three announcements, small fish splashed the gabbai from head to foot, since the creatures of Eretz Yisrael, a land of iron stones, have their own strength. v,w
Food that once had a shaylah
The Torah, the Mashgiach repeats, gives the tzaddik a special guarding from aveiros. The Chiddushei HaRim never ate anything on which there had been a shaylah, even when ruled kosher: just as a havamina in the Gemara is part of Torah, a havamina of treif leaves a trace of impurity. Once the Rav of the city said there was no shaylah at all, yet he put it down. The Mashgiach stresses this is not for plain people. Similarly the Belzer Rav refused fruit although every halachic consideration permitted it.
The Slonimer Rebbe and the beard
A Slonimer chassid in the Mashgiach's Williamsburg shtibel, exact in every detail, witnessed this. The Slonimer Rebbe, Rav Avraham, visiting Yerushalayim, wished to draw close a poor G-d-fearing Jew who wore no beard, and announced he would eat supper at his home. When the fish was served the Rebbe pushed the plate away, and nobody ate.
The host admitted that a bearded neighbor had lent him the plates, and the neighbor said they had been in a hurry and had not toveled them. The Rebbe told the host that in the next world they would ask him, 'Jew, where is your beard?', but the neighbor, 'Beard, where is your Jew?' Hashem, the Mashgiach concludes, helps tzaddikim know what is forbidden.
Mr. Singer and the Radziner gabbai
The Mashgiach begins one more story, heard as a boy in the Polish shtibel in Williamsburg from Mr. Singer, a straightforward, truthful man. His father, a Radziner chassid and the most respected man in his town, hosted the Radziner Rebbe's gabbai, himself considered a tzaddik, when he came to collect ma'amados.
Sources
Torah
Kesuvim
Mishnah
Talmud Bavli
- c apparently Yoma ch. 3 index In the write-up: 4:44
- h apparently Berachos 34b index In the write-up: 18:19
- i apparently Berachos 34b index In the write-up: 22:03
- k Berachos 58a text index In the write-up: 28:41
- m apparently Avodah Zarah 2b index In the write-up: 33:25
- u apparently Chullin 7a 1:00:53 index
Midrash
- r Midrash (place not identified) In the write-up: 49:17
Rishonim
Acharonim and Chassidus
Key points
- 3:29 A tzaddik who learns Torah lishmah raises himself until his name is Torah, so the Mishnah names him and mentioning his name is like saying words of Torah.
- 4:39 A tzaddik's name, and even the name of the place where he lived, carries his kedushah and can draw down a yeshuah for the one who mentions it.
- 19:35 The reward of one who learns Torah lishmah is so great that not even a navi saw it, and the whole world is worthwhile for him alone.
- 34:30 Everything that happens in the world, great or small, happens for the sake of the tzaddikim and Klal Yisrael, even when nobody knows why.
- 41:34 Mitzvos rise to Heaven and come down as blessing, aveiros come down as suffering, and the greatest blessing comes from Torah lishmah.
- 49:17 The one who learns lishmah has no interest of his own, so he loves Hashem and people alike and is loved by both.
- 58:52 The Torah he learns keeps him far from sin: Hashem gives such tzaddikim a special sense that warns them away from forbidden food.
Questions and answers
-
Question: 3:00 Why does the Mishnah mention the Tanna's name when no one disputes him?
Answer: 3:29 Because a tzaddik who learns lishmah raises himself until his name is Torah, so mentioning it is like saying words of Torah.
-
Question: 13:49 Why does the passuk not name the man and the Midianite woman during the sin, but names them after they were killed?
Answer: 14:37 Through the sin they lost their names; once Pinchas killed them, they got their names back.
-
Question: 18:30 What are the 'many things' that one who learns Torah lishmah merits, if not the list the Tanna gives?
Answer: 19:04 The Tanna does not say because he himself does not know: no eye, not even a navi's, has seen the reward of such a talmid chacham.
-
Question: 20:01 Why is wine spoiled so easily, even by a gentile's look?
Answer: 21:47 The holier a thing, the easier it spoils, and wine stands for the wine kept for Olam Haba.
-
Question: 28:52 Why does Hashem keep up a world so full of reshaim with so few tzaddikim?
Answer: 29:21 Like a merchant whose one returning ship pays for nineteen that sank, the few tzaddikim give Hashem more pleasure than all the reshaim cause pain.
-
Question: 55:55 How can a person love both Hashem and a fellow Jew without dividing his love?
Answer: 56:31 Every Jew's neshamah is a part of Hashem, so loving a Jew is loving Hashem, and the love stays whole.
Stories
-
7:35 The shoemaker who said tzaddikim's names
In Europe there was a simple Jew, a shoemaker, who knew very little and could not even say over Mishnayos while he worked. All day in his shop, with every blow of his hammer on the shoes, he said the name of a tzaddik: Avraham, Yitzchak, Yaakov, and on. The Mashgiach explains that such simple Jews knew their neshamah would be purified by connecting to a tzaddik.
-
33:15 The castle that sheltered a tzaddik
A tzaddik was seen smiling, and when asked why, he said he had just seen something in a far-off country. A king had built a beautiful castle with twenty thousand workers over twenty years. A tzaddik passing by took shelter under it from the rain, and after he left an earthquake brought the castle down. The Mashgiach explains that the true reason for the whole building was those few minutes of shelter for the tzaddik.
In the story: the Baal Shem Tov
-
59:29 The Beis Halevi's chicken
The Beis Halevi stayed with Rav Yehoshua Leib Diskin, and when he had to travel on, the Rebbetzin prepared a piece of chicken for him to eat on the way. About two hours later she found something wrong with the chicken and that it was not kosher. Rav Yehoshua Leib said the Brisker would not eat it, and indeed it was found that he had not eaten it, saying it did not smell good.
In the story: Rabbi Yehoshua Leib Diskin, the Beis HaLevi (Rabbi Yosef Dov Soloveitchik of Brisk), Rabbi Binyamin Diskin
-
1:01:08 The Yeshuos Yaakov and the pancake
The Yeshuos Yaakov visited a certain Rav, whose wife brought in a piping hot egg pancake, and he was honored to make the brachah. He stuck in the knife but delayed for a long while, until the Rebbetzin rushed in to say she had made it with butter in a fleishig pan. The Mashgiach said he had not known his guest had ruach hakodesh, and the Yeshuos Yaakov answered that the pancake had spurted in his face when he cut it, and a kosher pancake would not do that.
In the story: the Yeshuos Yaakov
-
1:05:41 The Vitebsker's fish and the voices of Tzfas
Rav Menachem Mendel of Vitebsk lived near a river, and every Friday his gabbai would announce there that the Vitebsker needed fish for Shabbos, and a big fish would swim into the net. In Eretz Yisrael he first lived in Tzfas, but the air was so clear that he heard the heavenly calls to teshuvah and could not sleep, so he moved to Teveria. There the gabbai announced at the Kinneres three times; the third time small fish came and splashed him from head to foot, and the Vitebsker explained that the creatures of Eretz Yisrael have a strength of their own.
In the story: Rabbi Menachem Mendel of Vitebsk
-
1:13:50 The Chiddushei HaRim and the shaylah
The Chiddushei HaRim had a practice never to eat anything on which there had been a shaylah. Once there was a shaylah in the kitchen, and the Rav of the city ruled that there was no shaylah at all, and that it could even be given to the Chiddushei HaRim. When it was served to him, he put it down and would not eat it: he sensed that it had been brought for a ruling.
In the story: the Chiddushei HaRim
-
1:18:07 The Slonimer Rebbe's supper
The Slonimer Rebbe, Rav Avraham, visited Yerushalayim and wished to draw close a poor, G-d-fearing Jew who did not wear a beard, so he announced he would eat supper at his home. Neighbors helped, and the Rebbe came with dozens of people, but when the fish was served he pushed the plate away and no one ate. The host admitted that a bearded neighbor had lent him the plates, and the neighbor, asked whether they were toveled, said they had been in a hurry. The Rebbe told the host that in the next world they would ask him 'Jew, where is your beard?', and the neighbor 'Beard, where is your Jew?'
In the story: the Beis Avraham of Slonim, Zvulun (a Yerushalmi chassid), Reb Leib Osofsky
Insights
- 3:09 The Mishnah names its Tannaim not only to know who said what: a tzaddik who learns lishmah becomes so holy that his very name is Torah, so saying 'Rabbi Akiva' is like saying a word of Torah.
- 10:25 A name in loshon hakodesh is the creature's essence: Adam saw from each animal's nature which letters it was made of, and a sinner loses his name, which is why Zimri and Cozbi are named only after Pinchas killed them.
- 20:37 The holier a thing is, the more easily it is spoiled; wine, which stands for the reward of Olam Haba, is spoiled even by a gentile's look, showing how holy that reward is.
- 35:09 World events like Vashti's death or Nixon's resignation are reported with worldly reasons, but their true cause is the tzaddikim and Klal Yisrael, which will become clear only when Moshiach comes.
- 1:07:48 The heavenly calls to teshuvah go out every day, and the receiver that picks them up is a Jewish heart; a sudden urge to do teshuvah is the heart catching one of them.
- 53:41 Machlokes comes from each person's private interests; one who learns lishmah has none, which is why he can love everyone, as all will in the days of Moshiach.
- 55:55 Loving a fellow Jew does not divide one's love of Hashem, since every Jew's neshamah is a part of Hashem; this is why 'love your fellow as yourself' ends with 'I am Hashem'.
What the Mashgiach says to take from it
- 6:46 The Mashgiach says that when a person needs a yeshuah he should mention the names of tzaddikim, which brings kedushah upon him.
- 15:26 The Mashgiach says a person should guard and strengthen his name and sanctify it, so that mentioning it will bring down blessing.
- 23:53 The Mashgiach says that at hagbah everyone should look at the letters of the Sefer Torah and become holier from it.
Mentioned in this shiur
People Achashverosh, Adam HaRishon, Aviram, Ben Zoma, Dasan, Eliav ben Chelon, Kozbi bas Tzur, Moshe Rabbeinu, Noach, Pinchas, Rabbi Akiva, Rabbi Levi Yitzchak of Berditchev, Rabbi Meir, Rabbi Menachem Mendel of Vitebsk, Rabbi Menachem Nachum of Chernobyl (the Me'or Einayim), Rabbi Yehoshua Leib Diskin, the Baal HaTanya (Rabbi Shneur Zalman of Liadi), the Beis Avraham of Slonim, the Beis HaLevi (Rabbi Yosef Dov Soloveitchik of Brisk), the Belzer Rav (unspecified), the Chiddushei HaRim, the Maggid of Mezritch, the Radziner Rebbe, the Ramchal (Rabbi Moshe Chaim Luzzatto), the Yeshuos Yaakov, Vashti, Zimri ben Salu
Terms הוה אמינא, השפעה, חלק אלוק ממעל, יין המשומר, ישועה, מחלוקת, ספר תורה, עולם הבא, קדושה, קנין תורה, רבונו של עולם, רוח הטומאה, תורה לשמה