נביא
A Deeper Explanation of the Story of נבות היזרעאלי & his כרם
Catalog entry: MISCELLANEOUS (English) no. 3 Pocket Guide p. 69 תשנ"ט (1998–99) English 1 hr 2 min
Listen
About this shiur
The Mashgiach explains that everything a person receives, from food to talents to a vineyard, carries sparks of his own soul and comes to him for his mission, and from this he explains why Navos lost his life and his vineyard and why Achav and Izevel wanted it.
The Mashgiach opens with the Chasam Sofer on the weeping 'for their families' in Beha'aloscha: the people wanted meat to elevate relatives reincarnated in animals. From the Borei Nefashos blessing and the Ba'al Shem Tov he develops that every food and possession holds sparks of a person's own soul, which only he can elevate. He then tells the story of Navos and brings the Midrash that Navos, a gifted singer, stopped going up to Yerushalayim to sing, and so lost his life. The Mashgiach explains: singing was Navos's mission, and the vineyard, source of wine and song, was his tool; a worker who does not work is dismissed, and the idle vineyard itself accused him. He ties song to Shabbos, David HaMelech and the matching of a chasunah, explains why Achav and Izevel were drawn to the vineyard and how it brought Achav to teshuvah, and closes with Yehoyachin's food and the call to eat and use everything for Hashem.
Topics: The Neviim and Their Times · A Person's Mission in the World · Serving Hashem in Physical Life · Niggun and Shirah
Order of the shiur
-
0:00 Weeping for their families; sparks in food
The Mashgiach brings the Chasam Sofer that the people who wept 'for their families' wanted meat to elevate relatives who died in Mitzrayim and were reincarnated in animals. He explains the Borei Nefashos blessing: Hashem creates people with needs and fills them with what is exclusively theirs, because fragments of holiness that fell through the sin of Adam are held in the food.
-
5:38 Everything a person uses is his own
The Mashgiach brings the Ba'al Shem Tov's answer to why Hashem made people hungry: the food holds sparks of the eater's soul that must return to him and are elevated when he eats properly and serves Hashem with the strength. He adds the Arizal on 'not by bread alone', and explains with an apple cut in half that each person's food, possessions and even his wife are part of his soul, given to him as a shaliach.
-
11:43 The story of Navos and the Midrash listed in the guide
The Mashgiach tells how Achav coveted Navos's vineyard, Navos refused, and Izevel had false witnesses testify so that Navos was killed, after which Eliyahu confronted Achav. He then brings the Midrash on 'honor Hashem from your wealth', read as 'from your throat': Navos had a wonderful voice, stopped going up to Yerushalayim to sing, and for this he was killed.
-
16:10 The vineyard as the tool of song listed in the guide
The Mashgiach asks why the attribute of judgment was so demanding, and answers that each person is sent on a mission and given the tools for it. A vineyard produces wine and wine produces song, and the word kerem itself alludes to this; so Navos, whose mission was to sing and gladden Jews, was given a vineyard as part of his soul, and when he did not sing he had no reason to live.
-
21:03 The idle worker and the accusing vineyard listed in the guide
With a parable of a factory owner who dismisses not only a thief but also a worker who sits idle, the Mashgiach explains that Navos's soul came down from the Kisei HaKavod to sing, and his death was not a punishment but the end of a life that served no purpose. The vineyard too has a mission and accused him for not using it, so it was taken from him.
-
24:41 Seven notes, Shabbos and the song of matching listed in the guide
The Mashgiach explains the seven 'kolos' of Mizmor l'David in Kabbalas Shabbos as the seven notes of music, like the seven-stringed harp of the Beis HaMikdash, and the seven days of creation as seven notes completed by Shabbos and by David HaMelech. A chasunah reunites two matched halves of one soul, and music and poetry are also matching; so the kerem, the source of song and of matches, belonged to Navos, whose soul came from the root of David's song.
-
32:33 Why Achav wanted that vineyard listed in the guide
The Mashgiach explains that a person is drawn to what is his, citing the Satmar Rav's advice to follow one's inclination in a shidduch. Achav wanted Navos's vineyard because it held a part of his soul too, as shown by the fact that he inherited it, as in the Gemara's dispute on the property of those executed by the king. But he got it dishonestly, and the Zohar explains that his sin was not taking the vineyard, which a king may do, but the killing.
-
38:26 The vineyard that brought Achav to teshuvah listed in the guide
The Mashgiach asks how the vineyard helped Achav and answers that it brought him to teshuvah, since the gate of song is next to the gate of teshuvah, as a tzaddik explained the saying that a chazzan is a fool. He brings Rabbi Elazar on Achav's great teshuvah, notes that the miracle on Har HaKarmel did not move Achav while Eliyahu's rebuke over the vineyard did, and adds the Chovos HaLevavos that a sin which breaks a person's heart can be his good fortune.
-
42:29 Izevel's dancing and the root of song listed in the guide
The Mashgiach explains why Izevel was so eager for the vineyard and kept repeating 'Navos HaYizre'eli': she too came from the root of song, as in the Midrash the Tur brings that she would dance before every chassan and kallah, so her skull, hands and feet were not eaten by the dogs. Navos had failed his power of song, so she felt the vineyard was hers. The Mashgiach concludes that whoever has bitachon will receive what is his without dishonesty.
-
47:26 Yehoyachin's food from the true King
The Mashgiach compares the verse in Yirmiyahu, that Yehoyachin's daily meals came 'from the king of Bavel', with the parallel verse in Melachim, which says only 'from the king'. Yirmiyahu is a sefer of hester panim, while Melachim reveals that the tzaddik Yehoyachin knew his food came from Hashem. He applies this to those who worry what any king can do, citing the Midrash that the same Achashverosh later brought joy to the Jews.
-
54:07 Elevating the sparks: the chair, the meal, the mission
The Mashgiach teaches that the whole redemption depends on elevating the sparks: a chair used for learning is elevated, one used for television sinks them deeper, and the roads to Tziyon mourn for lack of their tikkun. A meal is a guest that traveled from the field to a person's table, so he must wash, eat and bless with kavanah and recognize Hashem's kindness in the taste of food. He closes that from Beha'aloscha begins the period of travel and mission, and that Jews are Hashem's vineyard.
The shiur, written up
Weeping for their families; sparks in food
The Mashgiach opens with the verse in Beha'aloscha that Moshe heard the people weeping 'for their families', and brings the Chasam Sofer's explanation. Only one in five Jews left Mitzrayim, and a soul that must return in a gilgul sometimes comes down even into an animal. The people knew their relatives were reincarnated in animals, and wanted meat to give them a tikkun. a,b
Everything a person uses is his own
The Mashgiach brings the Ba'al Shem Tov's question: why did Hashem make people hungry at all? Because the food holds sparks of the eater's soul that must return to him. When a Jew makes a brachah and uses the strength to learn and do mitzvos, the sparks are freed from the Sitra Achra and rise, from plant or animal to a speaking being. The Arizal reads 'not by bread alone does man live' this way. d
Whatever a person eats or uses, his pen, his glasses, his Gemara, even his wife, is his alone. When he cuts an apple and shares half, Providence arranges that each half holds the sparks of the one who eats it. Each person is Hashem's shaliach to elevate what comes his way.
The story of Navos and the Midrash
The Mashgiach tells the story of Navos HaYizre'eli: Achav coveted his vineyard, Navos refused to sell or exchange it, and Izevel hired false witnesses so that he was killed. When Achav entered the vineyard, Eliyahu HaNavi told him his blood would flow where Navos was killed. e
He then brings the Midrash on 'honor Hashem from your wealth', read as 'from your throat': one with a good voice should sing before the amud. Navos had a wonderful voice and sang in Yerushalayim, but stopped going, and for this he was killed. The Mashgiach says this Midrash needs explanation. f,g
The vineyard as the tool of song
Why is the attribute of judgment so demanding? The Mashgiach explains that Hashem sends each person on a mission and supplies its tools: money, objects, talents, food. A vineyard produces wine, and song is said only over wine; the word kerem itself alludes to this. h
Navos's voice was his mission, and the vineyard, a part of his soul, was its tool: owning it and drinking its wine would help him sing and gladden Jews on Yom Tov. He did not sing, and so had no reason to live.
The idle worker and the accusing vineyard
The Mashgiach compares an employer who dismisses not only a worker who steals but also one who sits idle. Navos's soul left the Kisei HaKavod to sing; his death was no punishment, but he no longer deserved life. The vineyard, whose grapes are meant for Kiddush and zemiros, also accused him and was taken away.
Seven notes, Shabbos and the song of matching
The Mashgiach explains that in Kabbalas Shabbos, at the sixth psalm, Mizmor l'David, where the Arizal says one begins to receive Shabbos, the word 'kol' appears seven times: the seven notes of music. The Gemara in Arachin says the harp of the Beis HaMikdash had seven strings. Each day of creation was one note, so the harp is complete on Shabbos, the day of 'Mizmor shir l'yom haShabbos', and David HaMelech, 'the sweet singer of Israel', is the seventh string. i,j,k,l
A chasunah reunites two halves of one soul, joined in Adam HaRishon before Chavah was separated. Music is notes that match, unlike a cat walking on a piano, and poetry is lines that rhyme; all are shira. So the kerem, source of song over wine, is the place of matches, which is why the Mishnah in Taanis says the daughters of Israel danced in the vineyards. Navos came from the root of David's song. m
Why Achav wanted that vineyard
Each person is drawn to what is his. The Satmar Rav told someone choosing between two shidduchim that without ruach hakodesh one follows his inclination. Achav wanted Navos's vineyard because it also held a part of his soul, and the proof is that he got it; the Mashgiach ties this to the Gemara's dispute whether the property of those executed by the king goes to the heirs or the king. n
The vineyard that brought Achav to teshuvah
How did the vineyard help Achav? It brought him to teshuvah. A tzaddik explained the saying that a chazzan is a fool: the gate of song is next to the gate of teshuvah, and one who stands in the first should enter the second. Rabbi Elazar describes Achav's great teshuvah, and Hashem accepted it. s,t
Izevel's dancing and the root of song
Izevel too came from the root of song. The Mashgiach asks why she keeps repeating 'Navos HaYizre'eli', and brings the Midrash cited by the Tur: when the dogs ate her, only her skull, hands and feet remained, because with them she rejoiced every chassan and kallah. Since Navos had neglected his power of song, she felt the vineyard was hers. v,w
The Mashgiach concludes that Hashem sends each person what belongs to his soul; one with bitachon need not act dishonestly but can wait for it.
Yehoyachin's food from the true King
Yehoyachin was freed from prison by Evil Merodach and given daily meals. Yirmiyahu says they came 'from the king of Bavel'; the parallel verse in Melachim says only 'from the king'. The Gemara in Sanhedrin says David's curse of lacking bread on Yoav came back on his descendant Yehoyachin, a tzaddik who knew his food came from Hashem. x,y,z
Yirmiyahu, the sefer of the churban, speaks in hester panim, while Melachim reveals that the true King of Bavel is Hashem. Those who worry what a king can do to Torah and Yiddishkeit should know, the Mashgiach says, that if Jews do teshuvah it makes no difference; the Midrash on 'hu Achashverosh' shows the same Achashverosh later brought joy to the Jews. aa
Elevating the sparks: the chair, the meal, the mission
The whole redemption, the Mashgiach says, depends on the sparks. A chair used for learning Gemara is elevated and its sparks rejoice in heaven; used for watching television, they sink deeper. The roads to Tziyon mourn, as in Eichah, for lack of their tikkun. ab
A meal is a guest that traveled from the field to the mill, bakery, store and table, so one must wash and bless with kavanah and eat to serve Hashem. Unlike a fine car fed foul-smelling gasoline, Hashem feeds people tasty, colorful food with grace, and in its pleasantness one should see His kindness.
Sources
Torah
Nevi'im
- e Melachim I 21 text index In the write-up: 11:49
- l Shmuel II 23:1 text index In the write-up: 24:57
- o Melachim I 21:19 13:35 text index
- q apparently Shmuel I 8 37:21 index
- t apparently Melachim I 21:29 index In the write-up: 38:32
- w apparently Melachim II 9:35 index In the write-up: 42:47
- x Yirmiyahu 52:34 text index In the write-up: 47:36
- y Melachim II 25:30 text index In the write-up: 47:36
Kesuvim
Mishnah
Talmud Bavli
Midrash
Zohar and Kabbalah
Rishonim
Acharonim and Chassidus
Tefillah and Piyut
Key points
- 5:13 Every food and object a person uses holds sparks of holiness that belong to his own soul, and by eating with a brachah and using the strength for Torah and mitzvos he elevates them.
- 16:24 Hashem sends each person down on a specific mission and supplies him with the tools for it: money, objects, talents and food.
- 20:10 Navos was given a voice and a vineyard for his mission of singing; when he stopped singing he lost both, not as a punishment but because he was no longer fulfilling his purpose.
- 33:47 Achav could only obtain the vineyard because it also held a part of his soul; one who takes what is his dishonestly would have received it honestly had he waited.
- 38:40 The vineyard of song brought Achav to teshuvah, since the gate of song is next to the gate of teshuvah.
- 49:27 Yehoyachin knew that his food came from Hashem, the true King, and not from the king of Bavel; the whole redemption depends on bringing every spark to its tikkun.
Questions and answers
-
Question: 0:31 Why did the people weep 'for their families' when they asked for meat?
Answer: 0:57 Their relatives who died in Mitzrayim were reincarnated in animals and needed a tikkun through being eaten.
-
Question: 5:46 Why did Hashem make people need to eat at all?
Answer: 6:04 The food holds sparks of the eater's soul that must return to him and be elevated.
-
Question: 15:38 Why should Navos deserve death merely for not singing?
Answer: 20:10 Singing was his mission in this world; a life that does not fulfill its mission has no reason to continue, like an idle worker who is dismissed.
-
Question: 33:36 Why did Achav, a king, want specifically Navos's vineyard?
Answer: 33:47 The vineyard held a part of Achav's soul as well, as shown by the fact that it came to him.
-
Question: 37:05 The Zohar asks: a king may take whatever he wants, so what was wrong with Achav taking the vineyard?
Answer: 37:39 Acquiring the vineyard was not the sin; he could have taken it by force. The sin was the killing.
-
Question: 42:43 Why was Izevel so eager for the vineyard, and why does she keep repeating 'Navos HaYizre'eli'?
Answer: 42:47 She too came from the root of song, having rejoiced every chassan and kallah, and since Navos neglected his power of song she felt the vineyard was hers.
Stories
-
12:01 Navos, Achav and Izevel
Navos had a vineyard next to Achav's property, and Achav coveted it and offered to buy it or exchange it for another vineyard. Navos refused, and Achav was dismayed. Izevel noticed, told him she would give him the vineyard, and hired false witnesses who testified that Navos had cursed G-d and the king, and he was killed. When Achav came into the vineyard, Eliyahu HaNavi confronted him and said that where Navos was killed his own blood would flow, and that dogs would eat Izevel.
In the story: Navos HaYizre'eli, Achav, Izevel, Eliyahu HaNavi
-
14:53 Navos the singer who stopped singing
According to the Midrash the Mashgiach brings, Navos had a wonderful voice. He used to come up to Yerushalayim, everyone gathered around while he sang, and the people enjoyed it greatly. Then he decided not to go up to Yerushalayim and stopped singing, and because he did not honor Hashem with his voice he was killed and his vineyard passed to Achav.
In the story: Navos HaYizre'eli, Achav
-
43:40 Izevel danced before chassan and kallah
When Yehu had Izevel killed, the dogs ate her, and all that remained was her skull, her hands and her feet. The Midrash the Tur brings explains that whenever she saw a chassan and kallah coming down the street she went out in front of them and rejoiced them with movements of her head, hands and feet, so those parts remained.
-
47:29 Yehoyachin's daily meals
Yehoyachin, king of Yehudah, was held captive by the king of Bavel, and when Evil Merodach took over the kingdom he freed him from prison and provided him with daily meals. The Mashgiach cites the Gemara in Sanhedrin that because David cursed Yoav with lack of bread, the curse came back on his descendant Yehoyachin, who had no food. Yehoyachin, a tzaddik, knew that his food came from Hashem and not from the king of Bavel.
In the story: Yehoyachin, Evil Merodach, Dovid HaMelech, Yoav
Insights
- 21:59 Navos's death was not a punishment for a sin but the removal of a life that no longer served its mission, like a worker dismissed for sitting idle even though he stole nothing.
- 23:34 Objects have a mission too: the grape is meant to become wine for Kiddush and zemiros, so Navos's unused vineyard itself accused him and was taken from him.
- 29:42 Music, poetry and marriage share one root: each is a matching of parts that belong together, which is why a chasunah has song and why the vineyard, source of song, is also the place of matches.
- 33:59 That Achav obtained the vineyard proves it held a part of his soul; one who takes his own portion dishonestly would have received it honestly had he waited, and now he loses it.
- 38:40 The same vineyard of song that Achav seized became his path to teshuvah, because song stands next to teshuvah; the rebuke over the vineyard moved him where the fire on Har HaKarmel did not.
- 50:51 The difference between Yirmiyahu's 'from the king of Bavel' and Melachim's 'from the king' reflects hester panim versus revealed Providence: the true King of Bavel is Hashem.
- 56:59 A meal is a guest that traveled from the field through the mill, bakery and store to a person's table, and should be received with kavanah.
What the Mashgiach says to take from it
- 47:11 The Mashgiach says that one with bitachon need not resort to dishonesty; he should be patient and wait, and he will receive what is his.
- 14:34 Following the Midrash, the Mashgiach says that one with a good voice should go to the amud and sing nicely so that people enjoy it.
- 54:31 The Mashgiach says a person should use his chair to learn Gemara or say Tehillim, which elevates its sparks, rather than to watch television, which sinks them deeper.
- 57:38 The Mashgiach says one should wash and eat with kavanah, at least eat in order to serve Hashem, and in the pleasant taste of food recognize Hashem's kindness, so that eating is a continuous brachah.
Mentioned in this shiur
People Achashverosh, Achav, Adam HaRishon, Chava, Dovid HaMelech, Eliyahu HaNavi, Evil Merodach, Izevel, Moshe Rabbeinu, Navos HaYizre'eli, Rabbi Elazar (ben Pedas), Rabbi Yehuda (bar Ilai), the Arizal, the Baal Shem Tov, the Chasam Sofer, the Satmar Rav (Rabbi Yoel Teitelbaum), Yehoshafat, Yehoyachin, Yehu, Yoav
Terms בטחון, גלגול, הסתר פנים, זיווג, כינור, ניצוצות, סטרא אחרא, שליחות, תיקון, תשובה