אמונה

Having אמונה throughout עקבתא דמשחא When 'ה Seems Distant

Catalog entry: MISCELLANEOUS (English) no. ⁨5⁩ Pocket Guide p. 69 תשמ"ח (1987–88) English 49 min

Listen

  1. Download · Length 49 min

Open in the listening app

Notes Notes prepared by AI from the recording; not reviewed, and not the Mashgiach's words. The recording is the source.

About this shiur

The Mashgiach explains that the generation of ikvesa d'Meshicha faces the test of the Akeidah, holding on to emunah when Hashem seems distant and the questions seem unanswerable.

The Mashgiach opens with the Mishnah's description of ikvesa d'Meshicha, the 'heel' of history, and shows its signs in his own day: brazenness, places of gathering turned into centers of immorality, and the theater and television that now enter the home. The heel is insensitive and in the dark, yet it carries the whole body, so everything depends on this generation. He then turns to the Akeidah: a nisayon is a test meant to raise a person, and the tenth test should be the hardest, yet being thrown into the fire at Ur Kasdim seems harder. He answers from 'vayar es hamakom merachok': at the Akeidah Hashem seemed distant, and the command seemed to contradict His promise about Yitzchak, but Avraham did not argue and held on to his emunah. Following the Ramban that the deeds of the Avos foreshadow their children, the Mashgiach concludes that the last generation faces this same test, and that those who hold on to emunah will merit the blessing given to Avraham.

Topics: Avodah of the Last Generation · Akeidas Yitzchak · Hester Panim and Suffering · Simple Emunah, Above Reason

Order of the shiur

  1. 0:00 Our generation as the heel of Moshiach listed in the guide

    The Mashgiach opens with the Mishnah that in ikvesa d'Meshicha brazenness will increase, explains that Jewish history is built like a body from head to heel, and says that tzaddikim have identified this generation as the heel.

  2. 4:04 The signs of the time: gatherings, theater, television listed in the guide

    The Mashgiach reads further in the Mishnah that the places of gathering will become places of immorality, and shows how the theater and television, which once had to be visited, now enter the home. He brings Ruth's words to Naomi and the breakdown of respect for elders, and asks how a Jew can survive this period.

  3. 9:12 The heel: insensitive, dark, and carrying everything listed in the guide

    The Mashgiach explains that the heel feels almost no pain and is always in the dark, like a generation insensitive to its heritage; yet the whole body stands on the heel, so the few who are not swept away support the entire structure of the generations before them.

  4. 13:09 The Akeidah: a nisayon is a raising

    The Mashgiach turns to the parshah of the Akeidah said every day and asks what its message is. He explains that the root of nisa means both to test and to raise, like a banner, because the purpose of a test is to promote the student who passes it.

  5. 18:04 The tenth test seems easier than Ur Kasdim

    The Mashgiach argues that the tenth test should be the hardest, since everything depended on it, yet the first test seems harder: Avraham let himself be thrown into the fire by Nimrod for a G-d he had never seen. Only after he came out of the fire did Hashem first speak to him, as in the Midrash's parable of the owner of the building.

  6. 24:11 He saw the place from afar: Hashem seemed distant listed in the guide

    The Mashgiach asks why the Akeidah was the hardest test and answers from 'vayar es hamakom merachok': Hashem, who had been intimate with Avraham, now seemed far. He compares this to the times every servant of Hashem loses his desire to learn and daven, often out of disappointment, and shows how the command about Yitzchak seemed to contradict Hashem's promise.

  7. 30:39 Avraham does not argue; the simple answer he could not see listed in the guide

    The Mashgiach describes how Avraham, with a question in his heart, did not argue with Hashem or listen to the Satan, but went to the Akeidah with a heavy heart and perfect emunah. He then notes that the question has a simple answer, given by Rashi and the angel, that Hashem only said to bring Yitzchak up, and explains that in the time of a test one cannot see the answer.

  8. 35:17 The Ramban: the Avos foreshadow their children listed in the guide

    The Mashgiach brings the Ramban at the beginning of Lech Lecha that the lives of the Avos were a sign of what would happen to their children, with the examples of the famine, Egypt and Pharaoh. From this he concludes that the Akeidah, Avraham's last and hardest test, foreshadows the last test of Klal Yisrael, which is happening now.

  9. 39:40 The test of our generation: emunah without seeing listed in the guide

    The Mashgiach speaks of the questions raised after the destruction of European Jewry, in books asking where G-d was, and says this generation lives in a time when Hashem seems distant. Its mitzvah is emunah, believing without seeing, and the theater, television, newspapers and books are agents of the Satan like the one who tried to stop Avraham.

  10. 43:20 The blessing of 'eikev asher shamata' listed in the guide

    The Mashgiach concludes that Avraham received the angel's blessing 'eikev asher shamata' because he listened in a time of distance, and that the Geulah depends on this generation passing the test of the Akeidah. He says fortunate is the one who holds on to emunah, and that when the Geulah comes all the questions will be answered so simply that people will wonder how they did not see it.

The shiur, written up

Our generation as the heel of Moshiach

0:13

The Mashgiach opens with the Mishnah in Sotah that in ikvesa d'Meshicha, the 'heel' of Moshiach, brazenness will be rampant. He explains the term: the order of the generations is built like a human body, with the generation of Moshe Rabbeinu as the head, descending until the heel, the last generation before Moshiach. Tzaddikim qualified to say so have said that this is our generation, and he adds that the signs the Mishnah lists are plainly visible today. a

The signs of the time

4:04

Reading on in the Mishnah, the Mashgiach notes that the place of gathering will become a place of immorality. The Satan has capable agents, chief among them the culture of the times in the name of education: the theater and television. When Ruth wished to convert, Naomi told her she would have to give up the theaters, and Ruth answered, 'Where you go I will go.' Today, he says, one need not go to the theater; it comes into the dining room and the living room. a,b

7:47

He adds the breakdown of the family, where the young no longer offer their seat to an elder, and asks what a Jew can lean on to survive this period without being swept away.

The heel: insensitive and carrying everything

10:12

The Mashgiach asks what distinguishes the heel. A needle pushed into the sole is barely felt, and even at noon in August the sole stands in the dark. So too this is a period of darkness and insensitivity to the heritage passed down through the generations. Yet the whole body stands on the heel: the few who are not drowned with the majority support the entire structure of the generations before them, and everything depends on them.

A nisayon is a raising

13:09

The Mashgiach turns to the parshah of the Akeidah, said every day in davening yet rarely studied, and asks for its message. The passuk says that G-d tested Avraham, and the root of nisa means both to test and to raise, as a banner, a nes, is raised high for all to see. c

17:09

The two meanings are linked, he explains, because a test exists to promote: a student is tested at the end of each year so that he can pass and move up to a higher class.

The tenth test seems easier than Ur Kasdim

18:13

Avraham passed ten tests and after the tenth he 'graduated' as the first Jew. The last test should then be the hardest, and the Midrash has Hashem ask him to please pass it, since the world was created for his sake. Yet the first test seems harder. e

20:21

Avraham grew up in the house of an idol maker, sought the truth, and concluded there is one Creator. Nimrod had him thrown into the furnace, and he went for a G-d he had never seen, known only from observing creation. The fire did not burn him, and only then did Hashem first speak to him, like the Midrash's parable of the owner revealing himself to the man who wondered who kept the building. From then on Avraham went from test to test until the Akeidah. f

He saw the place from afar

24:24

Compared with the fire, the Mashgiach asks, what is so great about obeying a G-d who has spoken to him hundreds of times? He brings a Midrash on 'vayar es hamakom merachok': hamakom refers to Hashem, and Avraham saw Him from afar. The One who had been intimate with him and given him a child at a hundred was now distant. g,h

26:41

Every servant of Hashem knows this, he says. At times he has a desire to learn and daven; at other times his heart is clogged and his mind clouded, which he calls mochin d'katnus as opposed to mochin d'gadlus. Very often this comes from disappointment, when things do not go as a person wants, and he begins to have questions on Hashem.

29:40

Avraham had such a question: Hashem had promised 'ki b'Yitzchak yikarei lecha zara', and now He commanded to bring Yitzchak up on the altar. i

Avraham does not argue

30:50

Because of the question, Hashem seemed remote. Avraham could have argued that he had been promised, but he held fast to his emunah and refused to listen to the Satan who told him he might argue. At Ur Kasdim he jumped into the fire with fervor; now he went with a heavy heart, resolved to obey without understanding.

33:40

Yet the question was simple: as Rashi explains and the angel told him, Hashem never said to slaughter Yitzchak, only to bring him up. Why did Avraham not see it? Because in the time of a nisayon one does not know the answer. j

The Ramban: the Avos foreshadow their children

35:17

The Mashgiach brings the Ramban at the beginning of Lech Lecha that whatever happened to the Avos is a sign for their children. Avraham went down to Egypt in a famine, Sarah was taken by Pharaoh, Pharaoh was struck with plagues and released her: all of this foreshadowed Yaakov's descent and the exodus. k

38:02

By this rule, if Avraham's last and hardest test was the Akeidah, then the last period of the exile brings the same test, with many arguments to dissuade a Jew from the way of the Torah. This, he says, is happening now.

The test of our generation

39:44

The Mashgiach recalls living through the destruction of the six million, after which books appeared asking why G-d was silent. Today, he says, Hashem seems distant, and the mitzvah of this generation is emunah, to believe without seeing. All the agents of the Satan, theater, television, newspapers and books, play the role of the Satan who told Avraham not to go to the Akeidah, and a Jew must not subject himself to them but hold fast to emunah as Avraham did.

The blessing of 'eikev asher shamata'

43:20

When Avraham passed the last test, the angel gave him a blessing 'eikev asher shamata', because he listened even in a time of distance. The Mashgiach says this is our history: Hashem asks only small things of this generation, but one must hold on to them and not be poisoned by the philosophies and the screens that say otherwise. l

46:24

The Geulah depends on passing the test of the Akeidah, and he is sure there will always be those who hold on. Fortunate is the one who holds on to Gemara and emunah; such people will receive Hashem's blessing like Avraham. When the Geulah comes, the questions will be answered so simply that people will wonder how they missed it, just as Avraham did not see the answer during his test.

Sources

Torah

  1. c Bereishis 22:1 text index In the write-up: 13:09
  2. d Bereishis 22:2 14:37 text index
  3. g Bereishis 22:4 text index In the write-up: 24:24
  4. i Bereishis 21:12 text index In the write-up: 29:40
  5. l Bereishis 22:18 text index In the write-up: 43:20

Kesuvim

  1. b Ruth 1:16 text index In the write-up: 4:04

Mishnah

  1. a Mishnah Sotah 9:15 text index In the write-up: 0:13, 4:04

Midrash

  1. e Midrash (place not identified) In the write-up: 18:13
  2. f apparently Bereishis Rabbah 39:1 index In the write-up: 20:21
  3. h Midrash (place not identified) In the write-up: 24:24

Rishonim

  1. j apparently Rashi on Bereishis 22:12 index In the write-up: 33:40
  2. k apparently Ramban on Bereishis 12:6 index In the write-up: 35:17

Key points

  1. 0:27 History is built like a human body from head to heel, and the Mashgiach says tzaddikim have stated that this generation is the heel, ikvesa d'Meshicha.
  2. 10:12 The heel is the most insensitive and darkest part of the body, yet the whole body stands on it, so the whole history of Klal Yisrael depends on how the last generation behaves.
  3. 16:05 A nisayon means both a test and a raising, because the purpose of a test is to promote the one who passes it.
  4. 25:52 The Akeidah was the hardest of Avraham's tests because Hashem, who had been close to him, now seemed distant, and the command seemed to contradict His promise about Yitzchak.
  5. 31:32 Avraham did not argue with Hashem; he held on to his emunah without understanding, and went to the Akeidah with a heavy heart.
  6. 35:36 Following the Ramban that what happened to the Avos is a sign for their children, the Akeidah foreshadows the last test of Klal Yisrael before the Geulah.
  7. 40:54 The Mashgiach says the mitzvah of this generation is emunah: to believe without seeing, though Hashem seems distant.

Questions and answers

  1. Question: 16:05 Why does nisa mean both to test and to raise?

    Answer: 17:23 Because the purpose of a test is to promote the one who passes it to a higher level.

  2. Question: 24:56 Why was the Akeidah the hardest test, when being thrown into the fire for a G-d Avraham had never seen seems harder?

    Answer: 25:52 Because at the Akeidah Hashem, who had been intimate with Avraham, seemed distant, and the command seemed to contradict His promise, so Avraham had to hold on to emunah with a heavy heart.

  3. Question: 34:02 Why could Avraham not see the simple answer, that Hashem only said to bring Yitzchak up, which a child learning Rashi knows?

    Answer: 35:02 Because in the time of a nisayon one does not see the answer; that is what makes it a test.

Stories

  1. 20:10 Avraham in the fire of Ur Kasdim

    Avraham grew up in the house of his father, a maker of idols. Searching for the truth, he concluded that there is one Creator, not a god for each thing, and went around teaching it. Nimrod, who declared himself a god, warned him, and when Avraham did not stop he had him thrown into the furnace. The fire did not burn him, and only then did Hashem speak to him for the first time and reveal Himself to him.

    In the story: Avraham Avinu, Nimrod, Terach

    told in 6 other shiurim →

Insights

  1. 10:54 The Mashgiach reads the heel as both the generation's weakness and its greatness: it feels nothing and stands in the dark, but the whole body rests on it, so the last generation carries all the generations before it.
  2. 18:36 Since a test is a promotion, the tenth test should be the hardest; the Mashgiach sharpens this into a question, because the fire of Ur Kasdim, faced for a G-d Avraham had never seen, seems far harder than obeying a G-d who spoke to him.
  3. 30:50 The difficulty of the Akeidah was not the act but the distance: at Ur Kasdim Avraham jumped into the fire with fervor, while at the Akeidah he went with a heavy heart, holding to emunah when Hashem seemed far.
  4. 33:40 Avraham could not see an answer that a child learning Rashi knows, because in the time of a nisayon the answer is hidden; the Mashgiach applies this to the questions of his own generation.
  5. 37:43 Through the Ramban's rule, the Mashgiach makes the Akeidah the pattern of the last exile: just as it was Avraham's last and hardest test, the final generation's test is to hold on to emunah when Hashem seems distant.
  6. 41:55 The Mashgiach says each generation has its own mitzvah, and the mitzvah of this generation is emunah.

What the Mashgiach says to take from it

  1. 42:47 The Mashgiach says a Jew must be careful not to subject himself to the foreign influences that want to drag him away from Hashem.
  2. 43:08 The Mashgiach says one must hold fast to emunah as to dear life, as Avraham did.
  3. 45:16 The Mashgiach says Hashem asks only small things of this generation, but one must hold on to them and not be enticed by what is shown on television.

Mentioned in this shiur

People Avraham Avinu, Moshe Rabbeinu, Nimrod, Pharaoh, Rashi, Rus, Sarah Imeinu, Terach, the Ramban, Yaakov Avinu, Yitzchak Avinu

Terms אור כשדים, אמונה, גאולה, חוצפה יסגא, מוחין, מעשה אבות סימן לבנים, נסיון, עובד השם, עקבתא דמשיחא, עקידה, קושיא, רבונו של עולם, תשוקה

Report an error on this page