The Lesson of the בני מכיר and the בנות צלפחד: Our Eternal Connection to Eretz Yisroel

Catalog entry: PARSHA (English) מסעי no. ⁨3⁩ Pocket Guide p. 61 תשנ"ז (1996–97) English 1 hr 19 min

Listen

  1. Download · Length 1 hr 19 min

Open in the listening app

Notes Notes prepared by AI from the recording; not reviewed, and not the Mashgiach's words. The recording is the source.

About this shiur

The Mashgiach explains that every Jew, like every shidduch, is drawn back to his origin in Eretz Yisrael, and that the Bnei Machir and the daughters of Tzelafchad, the family that held Gilad, carry the law of return that Eliyahu will announce at the final redemption.

The Mashgiach asks why Moshe, in Sefer Devarim, retells that he gave Gilad to Machir, something the people saw only months before. He links three episodes about the family of Machir: their conquest of Gilad, the daughters of Tzelafchad's request for a nachalah, and the complaint of the Bnei Machir that ends Bamidbar. The daughters waited forty years for a fitting match and are praised, while Nadav and Avihu are criticized for the same; the Mashgiach explains through the principle that everything is drawn to its origin: the isha to the ish, Adam to the earth of the mizbeach and Eretz Yisrael. Once the daughters received a nachalah they were joined to their root and found their shidduch at once. Gilad, the land of Eliyahu HaGiladi, is the place of Yovel, the law of return, which only Rachel's children could conquer. He ends that Shabbos Chazon is a Shabbos of hope and a great eis ratzon.

Topics: Traveling to and Living in Eretz Yisroel · Shidduchim and Chasunah · Shemitah and Yovel

Order of the shiur

  1. 0:00 Why Moshe retells recent events listed in the guide

    The Mashgiach opens with Moshe's recounting to the new generation at the start of Sefer Devarim, and asks what purpose there is in telling them about the war with Sichon and Og and the giving of Gilad, events that happened only five or six months earlier.

  2. 3:31 The complaint of the Bnei Machir listed in the guide

    The Mashgiach describes the complaint at the end of Bamidbar: the family of Machir feared that the daughters of Tzelafchad would marry into another shevet and their nachalah would pass out of Menashe, and Moshe tells them they are right. He notes this is the third episode involving this family, after Gilad and the daughters' own request for a nachalah.

  3. 7:21 Waiting forty years: praised or criticized? listed in the guide

    The Mashgiach ties the three episodes together and brings the Midrash that the daughters of Tzelafchad waited forty years for a fitting match and are praised for it. He contrasts this with Chazal's criticism of Nadav and Avihu for not marrying because no one was good enough, and asks how the two fit together.

  4. 12:16 The match under their nose; the heart decides listed in the guide

    The Mashgiach points out that the daughters finally married their own cousins, who lived nearby all along, and insists nothing happens by chance. He brings a letter answering someone torn between two shidduchim: no one today can decide for him, but Hashem guides through the inclination of the heart.

  5. 16:33 Everything is drawn to its origin listed in the guide

    The Mashgiach asks why the heart should decide a shidduch and answers with the law that everything is drawn to its origin, contrasting the Torah's view with Newton's gravity. The isha comes from the ish, and Adam from the earth of the mizbeach, so a match is a reunion; this explains the Gemara that the mizbeach weeps over one who divorces his first wife, and why one should follow a pure heart.

  6. 26:25 Eretz Yisrael, the root of the root listed in the guide

    The Mashgiach explains that every Jew belongs to Eretz Yisrael and must return there, and that one cut off from his wife is cut off from Eretz Yisrael too, as hinted in the first Mishnah of Gittin. The daughters of Tzelafchad, as tzidkaniyos, relied on their heart, which drew them to no one until their nachalah tied them to Eretz Yisrael; then their shidduch appeared. The parsha read before Chodesh Av repairs the sin of the meraglim, who did not long for the eretz chemdah.

  7. 36:01 Why Moshe did not take Gilad listed in the guide

    The Mashgiach returns to the Bnei Machir, who went to Gilad and drove out the Emori there. He explains that Amon and Moav were off-limits, and Moshe could take their former land only because Sichon had conquered it, and asks why Moshe stopped short of Gilad and left it for the Bnei Machir.

  8. 40:00 Kiryas Sefer and the forgotten halachos listed in the guide

    The Mashgiach brings Kalev's promise to whoever would conquer Kiryas Sefer, and the Gemara in Temurah that Osniel ben Kenaz restored the three thousand halachos forgotten in the days of mourning for Moshe. He cites an explanation that the Torah is written into the land of Eretz Yisrael, so that conquering a piece of land gave Osniel a connection to the halachos hidden in it.

  9. 44:10 Gilad and Yovel, the law of return listed in the guide

    The Mashgiach proposes that Gilad is connected to the parsha of Yovel, the law of return. Land in Eretz Yisrael that is bought returns to its owner, because it belongs to his neshamah; the eved who took a shifchah that is not his goes free at Yovel. Every Jew, wherever he is, will return to Yerushalayim and the place of the mizbeach, and he cites the Arizal that even very sinful souls will eventually return.

  10. 49:15 Eliyahu HaGiladi, herald of the return listed in the guide

    The Mashgiach explains that Eliyahu HaNavi is the herald of Yovel who will return children to parents and Klal Yisrael to Hashem and to Eretz Yisrael, and that Yovel and teshuvah are one. Eliyahu chose to live in Gilad, the land of Yovel, and brought the people back to Hashem at Har HaCarmel. He then asks why Moshe did not fight Amalek himself.

  11. 53:14 Rachel's children, Amalek and Gilad listed in the guide

    The Mashgiach brings the Arizal that only Rachel's children can overcome Amalek, so Moshe, from Levi, sent Yehoshua. Purim will not be nullified because Amalek was never fully erased; that will come with Moshiach. Rachel is the neshamah of return, as the navi promises her that her children will return, and therefore only her children, Menashe's family of Machir, could conquer Gilad, the land of return that Moshe left over.

  12. 59:19 Shabbos Chazon: a Shabbos of hope

    The Mashgiach teaches that Shabbos Chazon is not what it seems on the surface: beyond the sorrow, it is the Shabbos before what Tisha B'Av is meant to become, the greatest moed. He brings that on Shabbos Chazon Hashem shows each Jew the third Beis HaMikdash, each according to how much he felt the mourning for Yerushalayim, and that the heart can see.

  13. 1:04:01 Sefer Devarim: Torah for the seventy exiles

    The Mashgiach explains that Sefer Devarim, begun on this Shabbos, is a book of return rather than separation. He asks why Moshe explained the Torah in seventy languages a month before his passing, and, through the wagons Yosef sent, connects the number seventy to galus. Moshe prepared the people for the seventieth, lowest level of galus by bringing the Torah down into every language, so that it would go down with them as a comfort.

  14. 1:10:24 Machir and Gilad: the answer listed in the guide

    The Mashgiach answers his opening question: Moshe retold that he gave Gilad to Machir as a comfort, because Machir and Gilad stand for return and redemption at the end of galus, where Eliyahu HaGiladi will emerge. This is why only the Bnei Machir complained that a nachalah must not leave its shevet, and why the daughters of Tzelafchad married into Machir and received Gilad.

  15. 1:15:02 The great eis ratzon of Shabbos Chazon

    The Mashgiach explains why Shabbos afternoon is a great eis ratzon even though the afternoon is otherwise a time of din, and says that Shabbos Chazon, amid the days of din, is entirely one great eis ratzon. He urges using every moment of it and closes with a brachah that Tisha B'Av turn to joy.

The shiur, written up

Why Moshe retells recent events

0:38

The Mashgiach opens with Moshe recounting past events to the new generation, whose fathers had died in the midbar. He asks what purpose there is in telling them about the war with Sichon and Og, which happened only five or six months earlier. They knew it themselves; it was nothing they had not seen.

The complaint of the Bnei Machir

3:31

At the end of Sefer Bamidbar the family of Machir complained that if the daughters of Tzelafchad married into another shevet, part of Menashe's nachalah would be lost. Moshe answered that they were right: a nachalah must not pass from one shevet to another (Bamidbar 36:7). The Mashgiach notes that this family appears three times: Moshe gave them Gilad, and the daughters of Tzelafchad, descendants of Machir, had asked for their father's nachalah, which Hashem granted (Bamidbar 27:7). b,c

Waiting forty years: praised or criticized?

8:55

The daughters were therefore told to marry within their shevet, and they married their cousins (Bamidbar 36:11). The Midrash says they waited forty years for someone fitting and praises them for not settling for less. d,e

10:51

Yet Chazal criticize Nadav and Avihu, who died unmarried because no one in Klal Yisrael seemed good enough for them. The Mashgiach asks how the same conduct is praised in one case and criticized in the other, and how among six hundred thousand Jews the daughters found no one.

The match under their nose

12:31

The midbar was arranged by shevet and family, so their cousins lived close by; their uncles had helped raise the orphaned girls. For forty years they found no one, and suddenly five chassanim appeared under their noses. Nothing happens by chance, the Mashgiach says, so why did Hashem arrange it this way?

15:23

He brings a letter to someone choosing between two shidduchim: in this generation no one can decide for him, but Hashem guides through the inclination of the heart, and the match one is more drawn to is a message from Hashem.

Everything is drawn to its origin

17:05

Why should the heart decide? The Mashgiach answers with a law of nature explained in the Torah: everything is drawn to its origin. A thrown object falls because it came from the ground; Newton calls it gravity but cannot say why it falls down rather than up. Fire rises to its source, and the neshamah returns to where it came from (Koheles 12:7). h

19:34

The isha is called so because she came from the ish (Bereishis 2:23), and Adam is named for the adamah he was formed from (Bereishis 2:7). So there are two origins: the origin and the origin of the origin. Every kallah was once part of Adam with her chassan, and a shidduch reunites what was decreed from the six days of creation. Adam's earth, Rashi says, was taken from the place of the mizbeach, as written 'mizbach adamah' (Shemos 20:21). f,g,i,j

24:08

The place of the mizbeach extends over all of Eretz Yisrael; the Midrash says one buried there is as if buried under the mizbeach. This explains the Gemara at the end of Gittin that the mizbeach weeps over one who divorces his first wife: it feels the loss of what was once united beneath it. Therefore, the Mashgiach says, one choosing between shidduchim should not toss a coin but follow a pure heart, which is drawn to its true match. k,l

Eretz Yisrael, the root of the root

26:32

Every Jew belongs to Eretz Yisrael and will return there at techiyas hameisim, by the law of return. One cut off from his wife is cut off from the root of the root as well, which is why the first Mishnah of Gittin speaks of one who brings a get from abroad: if the ish is separated from the isha, Adam is separated from the adamah. m

29:38

The daughters of Tzelafchad had a special bond with Eretz Yisrael. The Gemara calls them tzidkaniyos, so they could rely on their heart, and it drew them to no one. Their nachalah was written in Heaven but not yet given through Moshe; once it was, they were joined to their root and at once married their cousins, without looking further. n

33:43

This parsha closes Bamidbar (Bamidbar 36:13) and is read before Chodesh Av, when Jews were cut off from their origin. It repairs the sin of the meraglim, who despised the eretz chemdah; their hearts were not drawn to it, so they were sentenced to exile. o

Why Moshe did not take Gilad

36:35

The Bnei Machir went to Gilad and drove out the Emori there (Bamidbar 32:39). Israel was forbidden to fight Amon and Moav (Devarim 2:9, 2:19); Moshe could take their former land only because Sichon had conquered it. The Mashgiach asks: if Gilad was Og's land, why did Moshe not take it in his war? And if not, how could the Bnei Machir fight for it? q,p

Kiryas Sefer and the forgotten halachos

40:00

Kalev promised his daughter to whoever conquered Kiryas Sefer (Yehoshua 15), and Osniel ben Kenaz took it. The Gemara in Temurah says it alludes to the three thousand halachos forgotten in the mourning for Moshe, which Osniel restored through pilpul. r,s

42:29

The Mashgiach cites an explanation joining pshat and drush: the Torah is written over all of Eretz Yisrael, each piece holding its portion. By conquest, a kinyan, Osniel gained a bond with that land and could draw out its halachos.

Gilad and Yovel, the law of return

44:31

The Mashgiach suggests that Gilad holds the halachos of Yovel, the law of return. In any country what one buys is his; in Eretz Yisrael a field belongs to its owner's neshamah and Torah, so it must return. An eved who took a shifchah not his own goes out at Yovel.

48:30

So every Jew will return to Yerushalayim, the place of the mizbeach, and the Arizal said even souls needing fifty thousand Yovels will return.

Eliyahu HaGiladi, herald of the return

49:26

Eliyahu HaNavi will announce the Yovel, returning children to parents (Malachi 3:24) and Klal Yisrael to Hashem; Yovel and teshuvah are one. Everyone returns to his achuzah (Vayikra 25:10). Eliyahu lived in Gilad (Melachim I 17:1), the land of Yovel, and at Carmel brought the people back to 'Hashem hu haElokim' (Melachim I 18:39). The Mashgiach then asks why Moshe did not fight Amalek himself. t,u,v,w

Rachel's children, Amalek and Gilad

53:14

The Arizal answers that only Rachel's children can overcome Amalek; Moshe was from Levi, so he sent Yehoshua. The Rambam brings that all moadim will lose their importance but not Purim, because Amalek was never fully erased; that will come with Moshiach. x

56:04

Rachel is the neshamah of return: when she weeps, she is promised that her children will return (Yirmiyahu 31). Gilad, the place of Yovel, was above Moshe's level, so he left it to the Bnei Machir of Menashe, Rachel's descendants. y

Shabbos Chazon: a Shabbos of hope

59:32

Shabbos Chazon, the Mashgiach says, is not what it seems on the surface. 'Chazon' (Yeshayahu 1:1) is a vision of the heart. Rather than the Shabbos before a sorrowful Tisha B'Av, it is the Shabbos before what Tisha B'Av is to become, the greatest moed; a sefer calls the Shabbosim of the three weeks the greatest of the year. z

1:02:35

He brings that on Shabbos Chazon Hashem shows each Jew the third Beis HaMikdash, to the degree he felt the mourning for Yerushalayim; the heart can see, 'libi ra'ah' (Koheles 1:16). aa

Sefer Devarim: Torah for the seventy exiles

1:04:01

On this Shabbos Sefer Devarim begins, a book of return, unlike a get with its twelve lines of separation. Rashi explains that Moshe explained the Torah in seventy languages (Devarim 1:5). Why then, a month before his passing? ab

1:05:53

A sefer on Vayigash links the wagons Yosef sent to the galus. Seventy marks galus: seventy souls went to Mitzrayim, seventy years in Bavel, now seventy nations, seventy levels down. Moshe prepared them for the lowest level, which the Mashgiach says is today, telling them that with the Torah they would survive.

1:09:08

Unlike his earlier teaching, he brought the Torah down into every language, so it would go with them into the deepest galus as a comfort.

Machir and Gilad: the answer

1:10:32

Now the opening question is answered. Moshe retold events as a comfort, and so recounted 'to Machir I gave Gilad' (Devarim 3:15): Machir and Gilad mean return. Moshe did not take Gilad, but Machir, of Rachel's children, did. Moshe brought them across to the bank of redemption, where Eliyahu HaGiladi will emerge from the depths of galus. a

1:12:11

That is why only the Bnei Machir complained: as neshamos of return they could not bear a nachalah leaving its origin. The daughters of Tzelafchad, married into Machir's family, received Gilad and showed the third Beis HaMikdash.

The great eis ratzon of Shabbos Chazon

1:15:43

The Zohar, the Mashgiach says, explains why Shabbos afternoon is a great eis ratzon though afternoon is a time of din: on Shabbos there is no din. The three weeks are days of din, but Shabbos Chazon is entirely one great eis ratzon. ac

1:17:31

He urges using every moment of it as the most precious Shabbos of the year, and closes with a brachah to see the Beis HaMikdash with physical eyes, and that Tisha B'Av become joy (Zechariah 8:19). ad

Sources

Torah

  1. a Devarim 3:15 text index In the write-up: 1:10:32
  2. b Bamidbar 36:7 text index In the write-up: 3:31
  3. c Bamidbar 27:7 text index In the write-up: 3:31
  4. d Bamidbar 36:11 text index In the write-up: 8:55
  5. f Bereishis 2:7 text index In the write-up: 19:34
  6. g Bereishis 2:23 text index In the write-up: 19:34
  7. j Shemos 20:21 text index In the write-up: 19:34
  8. o Bamidbar 36:13 text index In the write-up: 33:43
  9. p apparently Devarim 2:9, 2:19 index In the write-up: 36:35
  10. q Bamidbar 32:39 text index In the write-up: 36:35
  11. u apparently Vayikra 25:10 index In the write-up: 49:26

Nevi'im

  1. r Yehoshua 15:15-17 text index In the write-up: 40:00
  2. t apparently Malachi 3:24 index In the write-up: 49:26
  3. v apparently Melachim I 17:1 index In the write-up: 49:26
  4. w Melachim I 18:39 text index In the write-up: 49:26
  5. y apparently Yirmiyahu 31:14-16 index In the write-up: 56:04
  6. z Yeshayahu 1:1 text index In the write-up: 59:32
  7. ad Zechariah 8:19 text index In the write-up: 1:17:31

Kesuvim

  1. h apparently Koheles 12:7 index In the write-up: 17:05
  2. aa apparently Koheles 1:16 index In the write-up: 1:02:35

Mishnah

  1. m Mishnah Gittin 1:1 text index In the write-up: 26:32

Talmud Bavli

  1. l Gittin 90b text index In the write-up: 24:08
  2. n apparently Bava Basra 119b index In the write-up: 29:38
  3. s Temurah 16a text index In the write-up: 40:00

Midrash

  1. e Midrash (place not identified) In the write-up: 8:55
  2. k Midrash (place not identified) In the write-up: 24:08

Zohar and Kabbalah

  1. ac Zohar (place not identified) index In the write-up: 1:15:43

Rishonim

  1. i apparently Rashi, Bereishis 2:7 index In the write-up: 19:34
  2. x apparently Rambam, Hilchos Megillah 2:18 index In the write-up: 53:14
  3. ab apparently Rashi, Devarim 1:5 index In the write-up: 1:04:01

Key points

  1. 17:05 Everything is drawn back to its origin: the isha to the ish she came from, and Adam to the earth of the mizbeach from which he was formed.
  2. 15:49 The Mashgiach explains that a person with a pure heart can rely on the inclination of his heart in choosing a shidduch, because it draws him to his true match.
  3. 31:59 The daughters of Tzelafchad found their shidduch only after they received a nachalah, because that joined them to Eretz Yisrael, the root of their root.
  4. 48:45 Yovel is the law of return, and Eliyahu HaNavi, who lived in Gilad, is the one who will announce the great return of Klal Yisrael.
  5. 56:57 Gilad, the land of return, could be conquered only by Rachel's children, which is why Moshe left it for the Bnei Machir of Menashe.
  6. 59:32 Shabbos Chazon is not only a Shabbos of sorrow; the Mashgiach calls it a Shabbos of hope, when the heart can see the third Beis HaMikdash, and a great eis ratzon.

Questions and answers

  1. Question: 1:57 Why does Moshe in Devarim retell that he gave Gilad to Machir, something the people knew from only months earlier?

    Answer: 1:10:32 Because Machir and Gilad stand for the return at the end of galus; Moshe retold it as a comfort for the depths of galus, where Eliyahu HaGiladi will emerge.

  2. Question: 11:44 Why are the daughters of Tzelafchad praised for waiting for a fitting match, while Nadav and Avihu are criticized for the same?

    Answer: 30:15 The daughters were tzidkaniyos who could rely on the inclination of their heart, and it did not draw them to anyone until their nachalah joined them to their root.

  3. Question: 13:38 Why, after forty years, did the daughters suddenly find their match in their own cousins?

    Answer: 32:28 Once Moshe said they would receive a nachalah, they were joined to Eretz Yisrael, the root of their root, and so they were joined to their chassanim.

  4. Question: 16:33 Why should the heart be the deciding factor in a shidduch?

    Answer: 17:05 Because everything is drawn to its origin, and a pure heart draws a person to the match that was once one with him.

  5. Question: 39:02 Why did Moshe not conquer Gilad himself but leave it to the Bnei Machir?

    Answer: 56:57 Gilad is the place of Yovel, which belongs to Rachel's children; like Amalek, only they could conquer it, and Machir of Menashe descends from Rachel.

  6. Question: 1:12:08 Why were only the Bnei Machir the ones to complain that a nachalah must not pass to another shevet?

    Answer: 1:12:17 They were neshamos of Yovel, of return, and could not bear that a nachalah be cut off from its origin.

Insights

  1. 17:48 The Mashgiach reads the law of gravity as the Torah's principle that everything returns to its origin: earth falls to the earth, fire rises to its source, and the neshamah rises to where it came from.
  2. 20:00 A shidduch has two origins: the isha's origin in the ish, and the origin of that origin, Adam's in the earth of the mizbeach. Therefore one cut off from his wife is cut off from Eretz Yisrael, which the Mashgiach sees in the first Mishnah of Gittin speaking of a get from outside the land.
  3. 30:20 The difference between the daughters of Tzelafchad and Nadav and Avihu: the daughters were tzidkaniyos whose heart was a true magnet; it drew them to no one because their match was tied to a nachalah not yet given, and the moment it was given they married their nearby cousins without being choosy.
  4. 45:18 Land in Eretz Yisrael returns at Yovel because a field is bound to its owner's neshamah and his portion of Torah; what was bought belongs to someone else's neshamah and must go back to its origin.
  5. 52:03 Gilad is the land of return: Eliyahu, herald of the final Yovel, chose to live there, and like Amalek it could be conquered only by Rachel's children, the neshamah of return, which is why Moshe left it for Machir.
  6. 1:06:51 Moshe's explaining the Torah in seventy languages prepared the people for the seventy levels of galus, so that the Torah would reach down with them into the lowest one.

What the Mashgiach says to take from it

  1. 25:35 The Mashgiach says that a person choosing between two shidduchim should not toss a coin but follow the inclination of a pure heart.
  2. 1:01:12 The Mashgiach says one should approach Shabbos Chazon with hope, not only as the Shabbos before a day of sorrow.
  3. 1:17:31 The Mashgiach urges using every moment of Shabbos Chazon as the most precious Shabbos of the year and not letting any of it go to waste.

Mentioned in this shiur

People Achav, Adam HaRishon, Avihu, Chava, Eliyahu HaNavi, Isaac Newton, Kalev ben Yefuneh, Machir ben Menashe, Menashe, Mordechai HaTzaddik, Moshe Rabbeinu, Nadav, Og, king of Bashan, Osniel ben Kenaz, Rachel Imeinu, Rashi, Shaul HaMelech, Sichon, the Arizal, the daughters of Tzelofchad, the Rambam, Tzelofchad, Yaakov Avinu, Yehoshua bin Nun, Yosef HaTzaddik

Terms ארץ חמדה, בית המקדש השלישי, יובל, מחיית עמלק, מקום המקדש, נחלה, עבד עברי, עת רצון, שבת חזון, שורש, שידוך, שפחה כנענית

Report an error on this page