ויחי יעקב - The Eternity of צדיקים
Catalog entry: PARSHA (English) ויחי no. 2 Pocket Guide p. 56 תשמ"ט (1988–89) English 1 hr 18 min
Listen
About this shiur
The Mashgiach explains that Yosef asked for his bones, the part of him that came from his father, to be carried out of Mitzrayim in honor of Yaakov, since a son is the continuation of his father and every Jew still carries something of Yaakov Avinu.
The Mashgiach opens with Yaakov's request not to be buried in Mitzrayim and asks why Yosef answered by saying he too would be carried out, why he made his brothers rather than his sons swear, why he cared about his brothers' bones, and why he said 'my bones' rather than 'me'. He shows from Rabbi Elazar ben Rabbi Shimon and from stories he witnessed about the Stoliner Rebbe and the Rebbe Reb Elimelech that a tzaddik's body does not decompose, so Yosef did not mean his bones alone. From the Gemara that the bones come from the father, and that a son is the continuation of his father, he answers all the questions: Yosef wanted no part of Yaakov to remain in impure Mitzrayim. Every Jew carries a residue of Yaakov, which can hold a person back in a test. He adds that Torah is alive, so this Shabbos we stand at the bedside of Yaakov and Yosef, and ends with a long explanation of the night of Nittel.
Topics: Vayechi and the Shevatim · Kibud Av VaEm · The Passing of a Tzaddik
Order of the shiur
-
0:00 Yaakov's request and Yosef's strange reply listed in the guide
The Mashgiach reads Yaakov's request not to be buried in Mitzrayim and the Midrash that Yosef answered by saying he too would have his bones carried up. He asks why Yosef gave no assurance, and why he made his brothers rather than his own children swear to it.
-
6:28 Why 'my bones', and Rabbi Elazar ben Rabbi Shimon listed in the guide
The Mashgiach adds two questions: why Yosef had his brothers' bones brought up as well, as Rashi learns from 'with you', and why he said 'my bones' rather than 'carry me' as Yaakov did. He brings the Gemara that Rabbi Elazar ben Rabbi Shimon's body stayed intact for over twenty years before burial.
-
10:39 The Stoliner Rebbe found intact Story listed in the guide
The Mashgiach tells what he saw when the Stoliner Rebbe, who had died of diabetes, was disinterred after sixteen months to be brought to Eretz Yisrael: his body was intact, his shrouds white, and the casket would not fit into the El Al plane.
-
19:12 The Rebbe Reb Elimelech and the Nazis Story listed in the guide
The Mashgiach tells of a Jew from Lizhensk, later supported by the Skverer Rebbe, who was forced by the Nazis to open the Rebbe Reb Elimelech's grave; after some 150 years the body lay intact and the Nazis fled. He concludes that time leaves no mark on a tzaddik.
-
22:58 Whatever Yosef touched endured listed in the guide
The Mashgiach brings Rashi that the grain Yosef stored did not rot, and shows a letter whose signature by the Rebbe stayed black while the gabbai's writing browned. Since Yosef surely did not decompose, he asks again why Yosef said 'bring up my bones'.
-
26:53 Three partners: the bones come from the father listed in the guide
The Mashgiach brings the Gemara in Niddah that the father gives the bones and sinews and the mother the flesh and blood, warns that such statements of Chazal hold hidden meaning, and explains that the white bones carry chesed and so endure. He adds that a son inherits not as a relative but as the continuation of his father.
-
34:22 The answer: no part of Yaakov in Mitzrayim listed in the guide
The Mashgiach answers all the questions: Yaakov's remains would stay in Mitzrayim through his sons, so Yosef promised more than he was asked and had his own bones, the part from his father, carried up, and commanded his brothers because honoring Yaakov is more on his sons than his grandsons. He explains the levels of distance that made Yaakov leave at once and Yosef wait for the geulah.
-
42:00 Every Jew carries something of Yaakov listed in the guide
The Mashgiach explains from Rashi that every Jew, as an extension of Yaakov, will be brought to Eretz Yisrael through tunnels when Moshiach comes. He says that in a test a person should remind himself that a sin would cast a shadow on the kedushah of Yaakov, who stands for holiness.
-
47:41 Rebbi and Nebuchadnezzar: Torah is alive
The Mashgiach brings the Midrash that Rebbi cursed Nebuchadnezzar when teaching Megillas Esther but not when teaching Yirmiyah, since one may not curse a king. Since he was long dead in both cases, the Mashgiach concludes that learning Torah means reliving the moment it describes.
-
52:09 At the bedside of Yaakov and Yosef this Shabbos listed in the guide
The Mashgiach brings Elisha's request for a double portion and the Chasam Sofer's regret at not being at his Rebbe's passing, and explains that one at a tzaddik's passing receives as much as his vessel holds. Since the Shabbos is woven of its parsha, this Shabbos Chazak one stands at the bedside of Yaakov and Yosef and can receive their blessings.
-
58:39 The night of the tekufah and Chanukah
The Mashgiach turns to the coming night of Nittel: the shortest night, the tekufah, was a day of avodah zarah from Adam HaRishon's thanksgiving onward, and Chanukah, on the 25th like the 25 letters of Shema, brings light against it, which the other side imitates.
-
1:03:55 Two tekufos and the name Nittel
The Mashgiach explains the two tekufos, Shmuel's and Rav Adda's, and why the dates of the gentile calendars differ. He connects their new year to the eighth day of Chanukah and says that the gematria of 'Nittel' equals 'Chanukah', the opposing force, and that many do not learn on that night.
-
1:10:49 Time, place and soul; Shabbos Vayechi as fuel
The Mashgiach explains from Sefer Yetzirah that time, place and soul mirror each other, so as there is a place where Torah is not learned there is such a time, and brings the Gemara in Gittin. Chanukah and the kedushah of Shabbos Vayechi carry a Jew through that night, and he notes that time is holier than place and that customs differ.
The shiur, written up
Yaakov's request and Yosef's strange reply
The Mashgiach opens with Yaakov's last request of Yosef: swear not to bury me in Mitzrayim, but carry me to the Me'aras HaMachpelah. According to the Midrash, Yosef answered that he too would have his own bones carried up. The Mashgiach asks why, at his father's last moment, when Yaakov wanted an oath, Yosef gave him no assurance at all and spoke about himself instead. a,b
Why 'my bones'?
In Beshalach, Rashi learns from the word 'with you' that the bones of all the brothers were brought up too, and the Mashgiach asks why that was Yosef's concern. He also asks why Yosef said 'my bones' rather than 'carry me up', as Yaakov did. Here he brings the Gemara that Rabbi Elazar ben Rabbi Shimon lay unburied in an attic for over twenty years without decaying, as he himself had foreseen. d,e
The Stoliner Rebbe found intact
To show the greatness of tzaddikim, the Mashgiach tells what he saw in his own time. He davened at the Stoliner shul in Williamsburg, and calls the Stoliner Rebbe, Rabbi Yochanan, a man who was in control of the world. The Rebbe died of diabetes, which ordinarily hastens decay, and was buried outside New York. After a long dispute among the chassidim, a beis din ruled that he had wanted to be buried in Eretz Yisrael.
When he was disinterred after sixteen months, he lay intact, his skin pink and his shrouds pure white, with no trace of decay, as many saw. The Rebbe had once told people not to fly El Al because it flew on Shabbos, and when his sealed standard-size casket was brought to the El Al plane it would not fit even with the doors removed, so it went on another plane. In Eretz Yisrael, before many Stoliner chassidim, the body was again found intact.
The Rebbe Reb Elimelech and the Nazis
The Mashgiach knew a refugee from Lizhensk whom the Skverer Rebbe supported to learn all day. When the Nazis could not unearth the Rebbe Reb Elimelech themselves, they forced ten Jews, this man among them, to open the grave. After some 150 years the Rebbe lay intact; the Nazis fled and the Jews covered him again. The Mashgiach concludes that a tzaddik does not decay: time leaves no mark on him.
Whatever Yosef touched endured
Yosef was surely a tzaddik, and even the grain he stored did not rot, as Rashi brings. The Mashgiach shows an old letter whose gabbai's writing browned while the Rebbe's signature stayed black. So Yosef certainly did not decay, and the question is sharper: if Rabbi Elazar, a dwarf beside Yosef, knew he would not rot, why did Yosef say 'my bones'? f
The bones come from the father
One answer resolves all the questions. The Gemara in Niddah says there are three partners in a person: Hashem gives the neshamah, the father the bones and sinews, the mother the flesh and blood. The Mashgiach cautions that such statements of Chazal, especially medical ones, are not to be taken at face value; the Ramchal and others teach that they hide secrets. On the deeper level the father stands for chesed, which is white, so the white bones endure while the red flesh, of din, decays. g,h
No part of Yaakov in Mitzrayim
Yaakov did not want his remains in the impure earth of Mitzrayim. But even if he was carried out, he would remain there through his sons. So Yosef replied that he would do more than asked: in his father's honor, he, Yaakov's extension, would also be carried up. Lest anyone think he meant himself, he said 'my bones', the part from his father; he knew his whole body would stay intact.
Because it was for Yaakov's honor, he commanded his brothers, since honoring a father rests more on sons than on grandsons, as Rashi says. And it would not help if the other tribes stayed, so all twelve sons, Yaakov's extension, were to go up. j
Asked why Yaakov did not request this himself, the Mashgiach explains that there are levels. Yaakov could not tolerate even temporary burial in Mitzrayim. Yosef, one level removed, knew the coming galus would prevent it, so he asked to be brought up at the geulah.
Every Jew carries something of Yaakov
The same applies to all Jews buried anywhere, still Yaakov's extension. As Rashi explains in this sedra, when Moshiach comes every body will travel through tunnels to Eretz Yisrael and live again, in stages according to distance, for nothing of Yaakov can remain forever on impure earth. k
This should thrill a person. In a test, when the yetzer hara burns, the Mashgiach says one should ask himself whether he, a part of Yaakov, may cast a shadow on the kedushah of Yaakov, who could not bear even Mitzrayim's soil. Holiness is the virtue in which Yaakov excelled, the third brachah of Shemoneh Esrei.
Torah is alive
The Mashgiach brings a Midrash: teaching Megillas Esther, Rebbi cursed Nebuchadnezzar, though teaching Yirmiyah he had not. He explained that the passuk forbids cursing a king, who is vested with heavenly majesty, while in the Megillah Nebuchadnezzar was already dead. l,m
But in Rebbi's day he was long dead in both cases. The lesson, the Mashgiach says, is that Torah is alive. Learning it is not history; one relives the moment it describes, and in Yirmiyah Nebuchadnezzar is still king.
At the bedside of Yaakov and Yosef
Elisha asked Eliyahu for a double portion of his spirit and received it by seeing him taken. The Chasam Sofer lamented that he was not at the bedside of his rebbe, Rabbi Nosson Adler, when he passed away, for he would have received a double portion. One present at a tzaddik's passing receives as much as his vessel can hold, and the Mashgiach adds that the Shulchan Aruch says not to leave the bedside of the dying. n,o,p
Since Torah is alive and the Shabbos is woven of its sedra, as the Magen Avraham brings from the Zohar, this Shabbos one stands at the passing of Yaakov and Yosef. The Mashgiach believes everyone can receive according to his vessel. It is Shabbos Chazak, ending Bereishis, and the Gemara counts every Jew a child of Yosef. q,r
The tekufah and Chanukah
After so holy a Shabbos comes Nittel. Whatever exists in kedushah has a counterpart in tumah. The tekufah, the shortest night, has long been a day of avodah zarah: the Gemara tells that Adam HaRishon feared the days were shrinking for his sin, and when they lengthened he made a day of thanksgiving, which the nations turned into worship. s
Against this stands Chanukah, which a sefer shows fell on the tekufah. It is on the 25th of Kislev, not by chance, says the Mashgiach, since nothing happens by chance; the Zohar ties it to the 25 letters of Shema Yisrael. The other side, like a monkey imitating a man, places its holiday on the 25th too. t
Two tekufos and the name Nittel
The Gemara speaks of two tekufos: Shmuel's, used in galus though not exact, and Rav Adda's, which is precise. The tekufah in use now falls around January 6th. The gentiles celebrated on December 25th by the common reckoning; later their calendar was corrected, while the Greek Orthodox kept the old date, which today falls on January 7th. u
The Bnei Yissaschar calls the eighth day of Chanukah a kind of Rosh Hashanah, and the Mashgiach says the gentiles' new year eight days after the tekufah imitates it. Nittel, he explains, comes from the Latin for birth, and its gematria equals Chanukah, ours against theirs. Many do not learn on that night because of its impurity. v
Time, place and soul
Sefer Yetzirah teaches that creation is duplicated in place, time and soul: Yom Kippur, the Kodesh HaKodashim and the Kohen Gadol meet on one day. As there is a place where Torah may not be learned, the lavatory, there is such a time. The Gemara in Gittin tells of Onkelos raising that man's soul, judged in filth, which fits. w,x
But Chanukah is behind us: lighting its candles, the only avodah of the Beis HaMikdash done today as the Sfas Emes explains, brings the Mikdash home, and Shabbos Vayechi's kedushah should carry one through Nittel. Time is holier than place, so one who finds someone learning should let him learn; customs differ. y
Sources
Torah
Nevi'im
Kesuvim
Talmud Bavli
- e apparently Bava Metzia 84b index In the write-up: 6:28
- g Niddah 31a text index In the write-up: 26:53
- i apparently Eruvin 70b index In the write-up: 32:12
- r Gemara (place not identified) index In the write-up: 55:20
- s apparently Avodah Zarah 8a index In the write-up: 58:50
- u Gemara (place not identified) index In the write-up: 1:04:05
- x apparently Gittin 57a index In the write-up: 1:11:07
Midrash
Zohar and Kabbalah
Rishonim
Acharonim and Chassidus
- o Derashos Chasam Sofer (place not identified) index In the write-up: 52:18
- p Shulchan Aruch (place not identified) index In the write-up: 52:18
- q Magen Avraham (place not identified) index In the write-up: 55:20
- v Bnei Yissaschar (place not identified) index In the write-up: 1:08:30
- y Sfas Emes (place not identified) index In the write-up: 1:13:56
Key points
- 22:40 A tzaddik's body does not decompose; time leaves no mark on him, and so certainly Yosef remained intact.
- 27:28 According to the Gemara the bones come from the father, and since a son is the continuation of his father, that continuation lies in the bones.
- 35:54 Yosef asked that his bones be brought up so that no extension of Yaakov would remain in the impure land of Mitzrayim, in honor of his father and not for himself.
- 37:54 Yosef commanded his brothers rather than his sons because the mitzvah of honoring Yaakov rests more on his sons than on his grandsons, and he had all twelve brothers carried up.
- 42:17 Every Jew still carries a residue of Yaakov Avinu, and for that reason no Jew will remain on impure earth when Moshiach comes.
- 50:52 Torah is alive: learning it is not history but reliving the events, so this Shabbos one stands at the bedside of Yaakov and Yosef.
Questions and answers
-
Question: 3:39 Why did Yosef not assure his father, but instead say that he too would be carried up?
Answer: 35:24 Through his sons Yaakov would still remain in Mitzrayim, so Yosef promised more than asked: in his father's honor, he as Yaakov's extension would also be carried up.
-
Question: 5:29 Why did Yosef command his brothers rather than his own children?
Answer: 37:54 Because it was for Yaakov's honor, and the mitzvah of honoring a father rests more on his sons than on his grandsons.
-
Question: 7:08 Why was Yosef concerned that his brothers' bones be brought up too?
Answer: 38:32 His own going up would help little if the other tribes, also Yaakov's extension, remained; so all twelve sons had to leave the impure earth.
-
Question: 8:10 Since Yosef surely knew his body would not decompose, why did he say 'bring up my bones' and not 'carry me up' as Yaakov did?
Answer: 33:47 The bones are the part that comes from the father, and Yosef wanted to make clear that he meant his father's extension, not himself.
-
Question: 39:48 Why did Yaakov not ask that all his sons be carried out of Mitzrayim as well?
Answer: 40:12 There are levels: a person's own bones are more himself than his children's, so Yaakov could not tolerate even temporary burial there, while Yosef, one level removed, could wait for the geulah.
-
Question: 50:18 If Nebuchadnezzar was long dead both when Rebbi taught Yirmiyah and when he taught Esther, why did he curse him only in the Megillah?
Answer: 50:52 Torah is alive: learning Yirmiyah one relives the time when Nebuchadnezzar was a reigning king, while in the Megillah he was already dead.
Stories
-
12:12 The Stoliner Rebbe's body after sixteen months
The Stoliner Rebbe, Rabbi Yochanan, at whose shul the Mashgiach davened in Williamsburg, died of diabetes and was buried near New York. After a long dispute a beis din ruled that he had wished to be buried in Eretz Yisrael. When he was disinterred after sixteen months, his body was intact with pink skin and his shrouds pure white, as many people saw. The standard sealed casket would not fit into the El Al plane even with the doors removed, so it was sent on another plane, and when it was opened in Eretz Yisrael before many Stoliner chassidim the body was again intact.
In the story: Rabbi Yochanan of Stolin
-
20:02 The Nazis open the Rebbe Reb Elimelech's grave
A refugee from Lizhensk, later one of the men the Skverer Rebbe supported to learn all day, told the Mashgiach what he saw. The Nazis came to the cemetery to unearth the Rebbe Reb Elimelech but could not, so they forced ten Jews, among them this man, to dig. When the coffin was opened, after some 150 years, the Rebbe lay intact as he had been buried; the Nazis fled and the Jews covered the grave again.
In the story: Rebbe Elimelech of Lizhensk (the Noam Elimelech), the Skverer Rebbe
-
23:46 The Rebbe's signature that did not fade
The Mashgiach has a letter, some seventy or eighty years old, written by a gabbai and signed by the Stoliner Rebbe's father. The gabbai's writing has turned brown with age, while the Rebbe's signature remained black as if just written, and the Mashgiach offers to show it.
In the story: Rabbi Yisrael of Stolin
Insights
- 36:34 Yosef said 'my bones' not because he feared decay but to point to the part of him that came from his father, so the request was about Yaakov, not himself.
- 32:41 A son's inheritance is not ordinary inheritance by a relative: he inherits because he is the father's own continuation, and that continuation lies in the bones he received from him.
- 29:39 The bones endure because they are white and carry the quality of chesed from the father, while the red flesh and blood carry din from the mother and decompose.
- 40:25 Closeness to Yaakov comes in levels: Yaakov could not bear even temporary burial in Mitzrayim, Yosef, one level removed, could wait for the geulah, and later generations will be brought up only when Moshiach comes.
- 50:22 Rebbi did not curse Nebuchadnezzar while teaching Yirmiyah because in learning Torah one is present at the moment described, when he was still a living king.
- 1:11:15 Since time, place and soul mirror one another, just as there is a place where Torah may not be learned there is a corresponding time, which is the night of Nittel; yet time is holier than place, so the impurity has less grip on it.
What the Mashgiach says to take from it
- 45:12 The Mashgiach says that in a time of test a person should remind himself that he is an extension of Yaakov Avinu, and that a sin would cast a shadow on the kedushah of Yaakov.
- 56:46 The Mashgiach says that by learning about the passing of Yaakov and Yosef this Shabbos, one can receive from them as much as one's vessel can hold.
- 57:11 The Mashgiach urges using Shabbos Chazak to take chizuk and inspiration.
- 1:14:29 The Mashgiach says the kedushah of Shabbos Vayechi should give enough strength to pass through the night of Nittel and remain in kedushah.
Mentioned in this shiur
People Adam HaRishon, Avraham Avinu, Elisha HaNavi, Eliyahu HaNavi, Nevuchadnetzar, Onkelos, Rabbi Elazar ben Rabbi Shimon, Rabbi Nosson Adler, Rabbi Yehudah HaNasi (Rebbi), Rabbi Yochanan of Stolin, Rav Ada bar Ahava, Rebbe Elimelech of Lizhensk (the Noam Elimelech), the Chasam Sofer, the Ramchal (Rabbi Moshe Chaim Luzzatto), the Skverer Rebbe, Yaakov Avinu, Yosef HaTzaddik
Terms השגחה פרטית, זה לעומת זה, כיבוד אב, מערת המכפלה, ניטל, עבודה זרה, עולם שנה נפש, פי שנים, שבועה, תקופה