ישמעאל's Occupation of ארץ ישראל In our times
Catalog entry: PARSHA (English) וירא no. 1 Pocket Guide p. 54 תשס"ב (2001–02) English 53 min
Listen
About this shiur
The Mashgiach explains the debate between Yitzchak and Yishmael behind the Akedah: Klal Yisrael exists by miracle and is bound to Hashem by a love beyond reason, while Yishmael, the 'pere adam' fighting the Jews today, gives his life only for his own desires.
The Mashgiach opens with Rashi on the Akedah: Yishmael boasted that he was circumcised at thirteen, and Yitzchak answered that he would give all his limbs to Hashem. This debate, he says, is the seed of today's war between Yishmael and the Jews, and its outcome will bring Moshiach ben David from Yitzchak. Since Yitzchak's birth was a miracle, the very existence of Klal Yisrael is a miracle, seen in a small Eretz Yisrael surrounded by the Arabs, the 'pere adam' who follow no logic. He distinguishes love based on benefit from essential love, the love of a father for a son, and says this bond is why even sinners gave their lives rather than convert, as in the story of the Shpoler Zeide's two thieves. The Akedah was the greatest test because it shattered Avraham's life ambition, unlike martyrdom for an ideal or, as with the suicide bombers, for lust. Milah at eight days and the Akedah both show a bond above reason, which is why Jews recall the Akedah when asking for mercy.
Topics: Akeidas Yitzchak · Hashem's Love for Klal Yisroel · The Exiles and Their Kingdoms · Mesiras Nefesh
Order of the shiur
-
0:00 The debate before the Akedah
The Mashgiach chooses to speak about the Akedah from a new angle and brings Rashi on 'after these things': Yishmael boasted that he was circumcised at thirteen by choice, and Yitzchak answered that he would give all his limbs to Hashem, which the Akedah then proved.
-
3:34 Today's war between Yitzchak and Yishmael listed in the guide
The Mashgiach says the present conflict is the war between Yitzchak and Yishmael, bringing the Baal HaTurim that when Yishmael falls Moshiach ben David from Yitzchak will come. To understand its root he looks to the first seed of the dispute in this week's parsha, since the essence of a thing is seen at its beginning.
-
7:36 Klal Yisrael exists by a miracle; Yishmael the 'pere adam' listed in the guide
Yishmael was born naturally, while Yitzchak's birth to aged parents was a miracle, so Klal Yisrael's existence is a miracle, as Rabbi Yaakov Emden writes and as its survival of all the empires shows. A small Eretz Yisrael surrounded by Arabs is a miracle, since Yishmael is a 'pere adam', wild in essence and only human in appearance.
-
12:50 Why the Arabs do not overrun the Jews listed in the guide
The Mashgiach brings the Chofetz Chaim's words that a Yishmaelite stays a 'pere adam' whatever profession he takes, and points to the attack on the Twin Towers. He asks why such people, who ignore world opinion, do not attack the Jews of Eretz Yisrael, and answers that it is a miracle: Klal Yisrael has lived supernaturally since Avraham and Sarah.
-
17:02 Love of benefit and essential love
The Mashgiach distinguishes a love based on benefit, which is really self-love, from essential love like a father's for his son, and says the love between Hashem and Klal Yisrael is greater still and does not depend on behavior, as the navi says 'I love you'. This is why even sinners in the times of the Crusades gave their lives rather than convert.
-
25:33 The Shpoler Zeide and the two thieves Story
The Mashgiach tells how the Shpoler Zeide, who disliked noisy davening, explained what true hand-clapping is: two former students of his who became thieves were caught stealing from a church and, set on fire, refused to convert and clapped their hands declaring their belief in Hashem.
-
28:50 Why the Akedah was the greatest test
The Mashgiach asks why Hashem said that failing the Akedah would void the earlier tests, and why it was harder than Avraham's being thrown into Nimrod's fire before he was a navi. He then describes kinds of self-sacrifice among people: for fame, for a king, for a team or party.
-
34:35 What drives the suicide bombers listed in the guide
The Mashgiach explains that the Arab suicide bombers give their lives for lust: he brings Rashi that the sons of Yishmael refused the Torah because of 'do not commit adultery', and the Gemara that nine of ten measures of immorality went to the Arabs. They are promised such pleasure in the afterlife, and they give their lives for it.
-
38:19 Avraham's life ambition
Avraham's ambition, for which he gave his life in the fire, was to make Hashem known in the world. Hashem promised him Yitzchak, from whom the Jewish nation would spread the knowledge of one G-d, and the Mashgiach notes that the other religions took the idea of one G-d and of Moshiach from the Jews.
-
42:10 The Akedah shatters Avraham's ambition
Commanding him to slaughter Yitzchak meant destroying the nation that was to spread Hashem's name. Though Hashem only asked and did not command, Avraham did not argue, because he was bound to Hashem with an essential love; this self-sacrifice without reason, unlike his earlier one for an ideal, is found only among Jews.
-
47:38 Milah, the Akedah and today's Yishmael listed in the guide
The Mashgiach returns to the debate: Milah is done at eight days because it is above reason, and Yitzchak proved at the Akedah, going with joy, that a Jew is bound to Hashem beyond logic. He contrasts Yishmael's self-sacrifice for pleasure with Jewish martyrs, even simple people at the Spanish expulsion, and explains that Jews recall the Bris and the Akedah when asking for mercy.
The shiur, written up
The debate before the Akedah
The Mashgiach approaches the Akedah from a new angle. He brings Rashi on 'after these things': Yishmael taunted Yitzchak that he had been circumcised at thirteen by choice, while Yitzchak was an infant. Yitzchak answered that he was ready to give all his limbs to Hashem, and the Akedah let him prove it. a
Today's war between Yitzchak and Yishmael
The Mashgiach says the present war is that same combat between Yitzchak and Yishmael. He brings the Baal HaTurim that when Yishmael falls, Moshiach ben David, from Yitzchak, will appear, and Chazal's words that all nations will join the last war, as they now do. Since the essence of anything is seen at its beginning, like a tree in its seed, the first seed of this war, the debate in this parsha, reveals the difference between them. b
Klal Yisrael exists by a miracle
Yishmael was born naturally, the Mashgiach explains, while Yitzchak was born to Sarah, past childbearing, and Avraham at a hundred, as Hashem asked whether anything is beyond Him. Since Klal Yisrael began with a miracle, its existence is a miracle. Rabbi Yaakov Emden writes that one sheep surviving among seventy wolves is a great miracle, and the Jews outlived Bavel, Persia, Greece and Rome. c
Why the Arabs do not overrun the Jews
The Mashgiach brings the Chofetz Chaim, who told a man traveling to Eretz Yisrael that a Yishmaelite stays a 'pere adam' whether doctor, lawyer or diplomat. Such people ignore world opinion, as the attack on the Twin Towers showed. Why, then, do they not attack the Jews? It is a miracle: Klal Yisrael has lived by miracles since Avraham and Sarah, and Yishmael has not.
Love of benefit and essential love
One who loves chicken, the Mashgiach says, really loves himself, since he eats it. Love based on benefit, even for a helpful friend, is logical love. Essential love is a father's for his son, who is an extension of him: in a fire he would save even a troublesome son before a helpful friend.
Greater still is the love between Hashem and Klal Yisrael, since a Jew is a part of G-dliness, bound by a tie that cannot be severed. It does not depend on behavior: the navi says Hashem loves Yaakov and hates Esav even when Yaakov sins like Esav. Hashem punishes, but the love remains. e
This is why in the Crusades whole communities, even sinners who ate treif and desecrated Shabbos, let themselves be burned rather than kiss the cross. Gentile martyrs were trained in loyalty; these sinners had none, yet when it came to emunah the spark awoke.
The Shpoler Zeide and the two thieves
The Shpoler Zeide, who disliked noisy davening, told a man clapping in shul what real clapping is. Two students he had taught Shema Yisrael became thieves and were caught robbing a church. Smeared with tar, they refused to convert, and when the priest lit their fingers they clapped, declaring that they were thieves but believed in Hashem.
Why the Akedah was the greatest test
The Mashgiach brings the Midrash that Hashem asked Avraham to pass the Akedah, for otherwise the earlier tests would be worthless. Why lose nine passed tests? And the first test seems greater: Avraham preached that one Creator made everything and was thrown into Nimrod's fire for a G-d he had never seen, while at the Akedah he was a navi who heard Hashem speak. f
To answer, he describes kinds of self-sacrifice: a general who dies to go down in history, a soldier devoted to his king, a man who dies for his team or party because it stands for something.
What drives the suicide bombers
The suicide bombers show another kind. The Mashgiach brings Rashi that the sons of Yishmael rejected the Torah over 'do not commit adultery', and the Gemara that nine of ten measures of immorality went to the Arabs. Asking his listeners to keep their thoughts pure, he explains that the bombers are promised immoral pleasure after death and give their lives for it. g,h
Avraham's life ambition
Avraham's ambition, for which he went into the fire, was to let the world know there is one Creator; Rashi explains that he built a mizbeach to proclaim it. Hashem promised him Yitzchak, from whom the Jewish nation would spread this knowledge, and it succeeded: Christians and Muslims took belief in one G-d from the Jews, and the Rambam says they took the idea of Moshiach too. i,j
The Akedah shatters Avraham's ambition
Then Hashem told him to slaughter Yitzchak, shattering the nation promised in 'through Yitzchak your offspring will be called'. Avraham could have argued, as Bilaam did, especially since, as the commentators explain, Hashem only asked and did not command. k,l
But he was bound to Hashem with an essential love that could not be severed, even against his life's ambition. In the fire he died for an ideal, as soldiers die for a king; here he shattered his ideal. This is the climax of the ten tests, a self-sacrifice without reason found only among Jews.
Milah, the Akedah and today's Yishmael
Returning to the debate, the Mashgiach asks why Milah, which the Shulchan Aruch calls the greatest mitzvah, is done at eight days rather than with an adult's intention. Milah shows that a Jew's bond to Hashem is above intellect. Yishmael could not grasp Yitzchak's claim, but at the Akedah, going with joy, Yitzchak proved it. m
Today Yishmael gives his life for his own pleasure, while Jews, even sinners, did so for Hashem; the Or HaChaim writes that at the Spanish expulsion the unlearned and the women left penniless rather than convert. So Jews recall the Bris and the Akedah on Rosh Hashanah, asking mercy from a bond beyond reason, though undeserved. n,o
Sources
Torah
Nevi'im
Talmud Bavli
Rishonim
- a Rashi on Bereishis 22:1 text index In the write-up: 1:23
- b apparently Baal HaTurim on Bereishis 25:18 index In the write-up: 3:52
- g apparently Rashi on Devarim 33:2 index In the write-up: 35:53
- i Rashi (place not identified) index In the write-up: 38:45
- j Rambam (place not identified) index In the write-up: 38:45
Acharonim and Chassidus
Tefillah and Piyut
Key points
- 3:52 The debate between Yitzchak and Yishmael before the Akedah is the root of today's war between Yishmael and the Jews, which will end with Yishmael's fall and Moshiach ben David from Yitzchak.
- 7:42 Because Yitzchak was born by a miracle, the essence and the continued existence of Klal Yisrael are a miracle, while Yishmael was born naturally.
- 19:21 The bond between Hashem and a Jew is an essential love, like a father's love for his son, which does not depend on behavior or benefit.
- 43:02 The Akedah was the greatest test because it meant destroying the very ambition for which Avraham had been willing to die, without any reason except his bond to Hashem.
- 48:54 Milah at eight days, without understanding, and the Akedah express the same thing: a Jew's bond to Hashem is above reason.
- 37:13 Yishmael's self-sacrifice, as with the suicide bombers, is for his own pleasure, while a Jew's self-sacrifice comes from his bond to Hashem.
Questions and answers
-
Question: 15:30 Why do the Arabs, who ignore world opinion and hate the Jews, not attack the Jews of Eretz Yisrael?
Answer: 16:06 It is a miracle; Klal Yisrael began with a miracle and exists by miracles.
-
Question: 23:55 Why would a sinner who fears no punishment give his life rather than kiss the cross?
Answer: 24:23 His bond to Hashem is an essential love; when it comes to emunah it awakens and he cannot cut himself off.
-
Question: 29:22 Why would failing the Akedah make all the earlier tests worthless, and why is it harder than the fire, when Avraham was already a navi?
Answer: 46:33 The fire was self-sacrifice for his ambition; the Akedah meant destroying that ambition for no reason except his bond to Hashem.
-
Question: 44:23 Since Hashem only asked and did not command, why did Avraham not plead to keep Yitzchak for the sake of spreading Hashem's name?
Answer: 44:52 He was bound to Hashem by his neshamah and would not let that bond be broken.
-
Question: 48:23 Why is Milah done at eight days, when the child cannot have intention, rather than as an adult?
Answer: 48:54 Milah shows that a Jew's bond to Hashem is above understanding, so it needs no intellect.
Stories
-
25:59 The Shpoler Zeide's two thieves
The Shpoler Zeide disliked noisy davening, and when a man in his shul clapped his hands in excitement, he told him what real clapping is. In his youth he had taught two students who would not learn; he still taught them Shema Yisrael, and they grew up to be thieves. Caught stealing from a church, a crime punishable by death, they refused to convert, were smeared with tar, and when the priest set their fingers alight they clapped their hands, declaring that they were thieves but believed in Hashem.
In the story: the Shpoler Zeide
-
12:50 The Chofetz Chaim's blessing for a traveler
A man came to the Chofetz Chaim for a brachah before going to Eretz Yisrael. The Chofetz Chaim told him he would encounter the Yishmaelim, who are difficult to deal with because they are a 'pere adam': whether doctor, lawyer, engineer or diplomat, he remains a 'pere adam'.
In the story: the Chofetz Chaim
Insights
- 5:57 The Mashgiach reads the debate between Yitzchak and Yishmael over Milah as the first seed of the war being fought between Yishmael and the Jews today.
- 12:25 'Pere adam' puts the wildness as the noun and 'adam' as the description: Yishmael is wild in essence and only looks like a man, so his education or profession does not change him.
- 17:46 Loving chicken is really loving oneself; true essential love, like a father's for his son, does not rest on any benefit.
- 46:25 Avraham's first test, the fire, was self-sacrifice for his life's ideal; the Akedah demanded sacrificing that very ideal, which is why without it the other tests would lack their value.
- 48:54 Milah at eight days and the Akedah are one idea: a Jew's bond to Hashem does not need understanding, so an infant's Milah is equal to an adult's.
- 52:37 Recalling the Bris and the Akedah when asking for mercy asks Hashem to respond from a bond beyond reason, even when Jews do not deserve it.
What the Mashgiach says to take from it
- 36:42 Before mentioning what drives the suicide bombers, the Mashgiach asks his listeners to keep their thoughts pure, saying one must struggle not to let impure thoughts into the mind.
- 52:25 The Mashgiach explains that whenever Jews need mercy, daily and on Rosh Hashanah and Yom Kippur, they recall the Akedah, asking Hashem to have mercy even though they do not deserve it.
Mentioned in this shiur
People Avraham Avinu, Bilaam, Hagar, Nimrod, Rabbi Yaakov Emden (the Yaavetz), Rashi, Sarah Imeinu, the Baal HaTurim, the Chofetz Chaim, the Rambam, the Shpoler Zeide, Yishmael, Yitzchak Avinu
Terms מילה, מסירות נפש, משיח בן דוד, נס, נסיון, עקידה, פרא אדם, רבונו של עולם