Anti Semitism: It's Necessity, Its Irrationality, and It Is Inevitable
Catalog entry: PARSHA (English) ויצא no. 2 Pocket Guide p. 56 תשס"ד (2003–04) English 54 min
Listen
About this shiur
The Mashgiach explains that the hatred of the nations for the Jews is a natural, irrational decree from Har Sinai that preserves Klal Yisrael from assimilation, and shows it already in Lavan's sons accusing Yaakov of living off their father.
The Mashgiach opens with the Gemara that hatred came down to the nations at Har Sinai and Rashi's 'it is a halacha that Esav hates Yaakov'. This hatred is natural, like an animal's, and serves as a preservative against assimilation. He turns to the era of Ikvesa d'Meshicha, when much of Klal Yisrael left emunah altogether, and to Herzl's plan to end antisemitism with a Jewish state, which instead became its main cause. A fable of animals blaming a sheep for a plague illustrates how Jews are always the culprits. In the parsha, Lavan's sons call Yaakov a parasite although Lavan prospered through him. The Mashgiach explains Kabbalistically that Lavan's sheep held lofty souls Yaakov came to redeem, that his peeled rods were his tefillin, and tells of the Arizal smiling at the Alshich's drasha. He ends that no human solution removes the hatred, and that Hashem is guiding events in Eretz Yisrael toward the geulah.
Topics: Yisroel and the Nations · Netzach Yisroel · Yaakov, Lavan and the Imahos
Order of the shiur
-
0:00 Hatred from Sinai, a natural preservative listed in the guide
The Mashgiach opens with the Gemara that hatred came down to the nations at Har Sinai and Rashi's 'halacha' that Esav hates Yaakov. He calls it a natural, instinctive hatred that preserves Jews from assimilation, brings the Zohar that it stems from jealousy, and the Yismach Moshe that Hashem puts hatred between tzaddik and rasha so nothing rubs off.
-
5:20 Ikvesa d'Meshicha and the departure from emunah
The Mashgiach says that before the geulah there will be reshaim who leave Hashem entirely, as Malachi and the end of Daniel describe, and that the Chofetz Chaim saw the signs of Ikvesa d'Meshicha already in his time. Unlike the ancient pull of avodah zarah, today's trial is atheism, which began with the Haskalah in Germany; he brings the Meshech Chochmah that the punishment would also come from Germany.
-
11:23 Herzl's solution and its reverse listed in the guide
The Mashgiach describes Herzl's plan that a Jewish state would end antisemitism, and says the State of Israel has instead become its cause, citing a European poll naming Israel as the world's main troublemaker. He points to the hypocrisy of condemning Jews for defending themselves while America does the same in Iraq.
-
14:36 The animals' trial and the Black Plague Story listed in the guide
The Mashgiach tells a fable: during a plague in the jungle the beasts excuse the leopard and the wolf for their killings but convict a sheep that ate straw from a shepherd's shoe. So too the Jews are blamed for every trouble, as in the Black Plague, which Jews were spared through their cleanliness and were then accused of causing.
-
18:38 Lavan's sons: Yaakov the parasite listed in the guide
The Mashgiach brings the end of the parsha where Lavan's sons say Yaakov took everything from their father, though they themselves were born through Yaakov's blessing, as Rashi and Lavan's own words show. Without the Oral Torah Yaakov looks like a cheater; the nations always paint Jews so, as in Shakespeare's Shylock, because Jews prosper wherever they go and are then libeled out of jealousy.
-
24:43 The holy souls in Lavan's sheep
The Mashgiach brings Rashi that malachim brought Yaakov sheep from Lavan's flocks, then opens a deeper matter: according to the Arizal, based on the Zohar, the great souls of the Dor HaMabul, the Dor Haflagah and Sedom came down again in Lavan's sheep. Yaakov's task was to redeem these 600,000 souls from the sitra achra and bring them to their tikkun.
-
30:07 Lavan's power and Yaakov's switches
The Mashgiach brings the Zohar's question why Esav did not pursue Yaakov at Lavan's house: Lavan was the merkava of the Samech-Mem, and Esav relied on him, but Hashem protected Yaakov. Before Matan Torah the tzaddikim could fulfill mitzvos in their own way; mitzvos are like switches that light up the upper worlds, and Yaakov's peeled rods were his tefillin. The redeemed sheep went down to Mitzrayim and became Klal Yisrael.
-
36:49 The Arizal smiles at the Alshich's drasha Story
The Mashgiach praises the Alshich HaKadosh and tells how the Arizal attended his Shabbos drasha on Parshas Vayeitzei and smiled throughout. Asked why, the Arizal said that Lavan's soul had come to listen, and nodded at each of the hundred tricks the Alshich found in the pesukim, admitting he had tried it on Yaakov and it had failed.
-
40:00 The pattern of golus: blamed for prosperity listed in the guide
The Mashgiach returns to Lavan's sons, jealous of Yaakov although Lavan prospered through him, like the Jewish finance ministers of Europe accused of disloyalty. He explains that Jews turned to lending with interest only because the nations barred them from land and confined them to ghettos, and that the nations prospered from it, as Yaakov told Lavan. No solution, neither Herzl's nor communism, removes the hatred.
-
45:21 Hatred, freedom, and the wandering of Torah listed in the guide
The Mashgiach says hatred in golus is a decree that keeps Jews from assimilating, and now that there is freedom, assimilation in America and elsewhere is enormous. Yaakov at Lavan is a mirror of all of golus. He then speaks of the Torah's stations through the exile, bringing the Gra that America would be the last golus of Torah, and describes the flowering of Torah in Williamsburg after the war.
-
50:30 Eretz Yisrael: an unfinished painting
The Mashgiach says Torah has now moved to Eretz Yisrael and keeps growing despite a leadership that fights it. What is happening there is beyond understanding, like black splashes in a painting not yet finished; Hashem has a master plan, and when it is complete every step will be understood.
The shiur, written up
Hatred from Sinai, a natural preservative
Ikvesa d'Meshicha and the departure from emunah
Before the geulah, the Mashgiach says, there will be reshaim who leave Hashem entirely, as Malachi and the end of Daniel describe. The Chofetz Chaim said his generation had already reached Ikvesa d'Meshicha, the period whose signs the Gemara in Perek Chelek lists, and about a hundred years ago many Jews left emunah to the point of apikorsus. f,g,h
Herzl's solution and its reverse
Herzl sought to end antisemitism by giving Jews a nation of their own. The Mashgiach calls it ironic: in a European poll most named Israel as the world's main troublemaker, and Jews are condemned for defending themselves while America does the same in Iraq.
The animals' trial and the Black Plague
The Mashgiach tells a fable. During a plague the beasts held a trial: the leopard who ate a child and the wolf who took a chicken were excused, since that is their nature, but a sheep that ate straw from a sleeping shepherd's shoe was convicted. So the Jews are blamed for everything; spared the Black Plague by their cleanliness and mikveh, they were accused of causing it and suffered pogroms.
Lavan's sons: Yaakov the parasite
The holy souls in Lavan's sheep
Lavan's power and Yaakov's switches
Yaakov hid unknown in the yeshiva of Shem and Ever, but at Lavan's he was not hidden, so why did Esav not come? The Zohar answers that Lavan was the merkava of the Samech-Mem; Esav relied on him to destroy Yaakov, but Hashem protected him. r,s
Before Matan Torah tzaddikim could fulfill mitzvos their own way. Every mitzvah is a switch that lights the upper worlds; Hashem teaches the Jewish people the switches, but the Avos could make their own. The Zohar says Yaakov's peeled rods were his tefillin, not trickery. t
Yaakov took these 600,000 souls to Mitzrayim, where they became human again: the Jews of the Exodus and Matan Torah.
The Arizal smiles at the Alshich's drasha
The Arizal once attended the Alshich's Shabbos drasha on Vayeitzei in Tzfas and smiled throughout. He explained that Lavan's soul was present: Chazal read Lavan's 'ten times' as a hundred tricks, and as the Alshich uncovered each from the pesukim, Lavan nodded that he had tried it and failed. u,v
The pattern of golus: blamed for prosperity
Though Lavan prospered, his sons envied Yaakov as a parasite who stole from their father, just as Jewish finance ministers were accused of disloyalty. This, says the Mashgiach, is the fate of Jews in golus.
Hatred, freedom, and the wandering of Torah
The Mashgiach says Hashem keeps the Jews in golus with a decree that the nations hate them so they do not assimilate; now, with freedom, assimilation in America is over fifty percent. Yaakov at Lavan is a mirror of golus, and the nations hate the Jews with a country or without.
Torah migrated from land to land, and the Gra said America would be its last golus. After the war Williamsburg flourished with Torah and great Rebbes, which lasted thirty or forty years.
Eretz Yisrael: an unfinished painting
Torah has now returned to Eretz Yisrael and grows despite leaders who fight it; the Mashgiach says Hashem takes care of the Torah. What happens there is like black splashes on an unfinished painting: Hashem has a master plan, and when the picture is complete every step will be understood.
Sources
Torah
Nevi'im
Kesuvim
Talmud Bavli
Midrash
- q Midrash (place not identified) In the write-up: 27:06
Zohar and Kabbalah
Rishonim
Acharonim and Chassidus
Key points
- 0:00 Hatred of the nations for Klal Yisrael came down at Har Sinai; it is natural and instinctive, like the hatred between animals, and needs no reason.
- 1:03 The hatred has a purpose: it is a preservative that keeps Jews in golus from assimilating, and where Jews have freedom, assimilation spreads.
- 11:28 Herzl's plan to end antisemitism through a Jewish state failed; the State itself has become a main cause of hatred, and no solution of those who left the Torah has helped.
- 19:09 Lavan's sons calling Yaakov a parasite, although Lavan was blessed through him, is the pattern of Jews in every golus: they bring prosperity and are accused of robbing it.
- 25:03 Yaakov did not cheat Lavan: the sheep were brought by malachim, his peeled rods were his way of fulfilling tefillin, and his task was to redeem the holy souls held in Lavan's flocks.
- 51:50 What Hashem is doing in Eretz Yisrael now cannot be understood, like black splashes in an unfinished painting, but when the picture is complete every step will be understood.
Questions and answers
-
Question: 2:59 Why do the nations hate the Jews?
Answer: 3:04 The Zohar says it is jealousy; deep down they know the Jews are the chosen people. But at root it is an instinctive hatred that Hashem made, like that between animals.
-
Question: 30:30 Why did Esav not come to Lavan's house to kill Yaakov, when Yaakov was no longer in hiding?
Answer: 30:47 The Zohar answers that Lavan was the merkava of the Samech-Mem, so Esav reckoned Lavan would finish Yaakov better than he could; Hashem did not let him.
-
Question: 21:06 Was Yaakov's carving of stripes on the rods a way of cheating Lavan?
Answer: 31:38 No: before Matan Torah tzaddikim could fulfill mitzvos in their own form, and the peelings were his tefillin; the sheep themselves were brought by malachim.
-
Question: 38:11 Why was the Arizal smiling throughout the Alshich's drasha?
Answer: 39:31 Lavan's soul was present and nodded at each trick the Alshich uncovered, admitting he had tried it on Yaakov.
-
Question: 41:45 Why did Jews in golus make their living from lending with interest?
Answer: 41:47 They were naturally an agricultural and shepherding people, but the nations barred them from owning land and confined them to ghettos, so they had to turn to business and banking.
Stories
-
15:30 The animals' trial during a plague
During a plague in the jungle, the animals gathered to find which sinner had caused it, with the lion, the bear and the tiger as judges. One witness told of a leopard that ate a child, and another of a wolf that snatched a chicken; the judges excused both, since that is their nature. A third told of a sheep that ate the straw a poor shepherd had stuffed into a hole in his shoe, and the judges declared the sheep the culprit. The Mashgiach applies it to the Jews, who are blamed for every trouble in the world.
In the story: Rebbe Reb Bunim of Peshischa
-
37:51 Lavan's soul at the Alshich's drasha
The Alshich used to give a drasha every Shabbos for the townspeople of Tzfas, and once the Arizal came to his drasha on Parshas Vayeitzei and smiled throughout. His talmidim wondered why, since the Arizal was far greater than the Alshich. The Arizal explained that Lavan's soul had come to the drasha, and each time the Alshich showed from the pesukim another of Lavan's hundred tricks against Yaakov, Lavan nodded, admitting he had tried it and it had not worked.
In the story: the Arizal, the Alshich, Lavan, Yaakov Avinu
Insights
- 1:05 The hatred of the nations is not something to be explained away; like the hatred between animals it is instinctive, and it serves as a preservative that keeps Jews from mixing with them.
- 12:16 The Jewish state, meant to cure antisemitism, has itself become its leading cause: the hatred simply follows the Jews whether they have a country or not.
- 29:10 Lavan's sheep were not ordinary property: they held the souls of the Dor HaMabul, the Dor Haflagah and Sedom, numbering 600,000, which Yaakov redeemed and which became the Jews who left Mitzrayim.
- 31:38 Before Matan Torah the tzaddikim could build their own 'switches' for the upper lights; Yaakov's peeled stripes on the rods were his way of fulfilling the mitzvah of tefillin, not a trick.
- 30:41 Esav did not chase Yaakov at Lavan's house because Lavan, the merkava of the Samech-Mem, was a greater danger than Esav himself; only Hashem's protection saved Yaakov there.
- 40:54 Yaakov's years with Lavan are a mirror of all of golus: Jews bring prosperity to their hosts and are accused of being parasites, as in the libels against Jewish finance ministers.
What the Mashgiach says to take from it
- 26:22 The Mashgiach says that when we see things in Hashem's conduct of the world that we do not understand, we have questions, and a time will come when all of them will be answered.
- 51:33 The Mashgiach says not to worry about the efforts to strangle Torah in Eretz Yisrael, because Hashem takes care of the Torah.
Mentioned in this shiur
People Avraham Avinu, Charles de Gaulle, Daniel, Esav, Lavan, Malachi, Rabbeinu Bachya, Rashi, the Alshich, the Arizal, the Baal Shem Tov, the Chofetz Chaim, the Meshech Chochmah (Rabbi Meir Simcha of Dvinsk), the Satmar Rav (Rabbi Yoel Teitelbaum), the Skverer Rebbe, the Vilna Gaon, the Yismach Moshe, Theodor Herzl, Yaakov Avinu, Yosef HaTzaddik
Terms אפיקורס, גלגול, גלות, דור המבול, דור הפלגה, השכלה, מעמד הר סיני, מרכבה, סטרא אחרא, סמאל, עבודה זרה, עקבתא דמשיחא, קנאה, רבונו של עולם, שבעים אומות, שנאה, תורה שבעל פה, תיקון, תרי"ג מצוות