A Coin of Fire
Catalog entry: ZMANIM (English) שקלים no. 1 Pocket Guide p. 64 תשמ"ט (1988–89) English 1 hr 13 min
Listen
About this shiur
The Mashgiach explains that the half-shekel is a 'coin of fire', the yud of Hashem's Name and the indestructible point in every Jew, and that this is why it defeated Haman's shekalim and why Yehoash is its haftarah.
For Parshas Shekalim the Mashgiach asks why the half-shekel was the merit that saved the Jews from Haman. He starts from Rashi's 'coin of fire' and a vort that a talmid of Rebbe Reb Bunim heard in Germany: Hashem wants the fire within a mitzvah, not its metal. The Alshich's reading of the apiryon shows the Beis Hamikdash was precious for the love inside it. Avraham's 400 shekalim for Me'aras HaMachpelah were compounded above, while Efron, named from afar (earth), kept cold metal. The four parshiyos match the four letters of Hashem's Name, and Shekalim is the yud, fire. The haftarah's Yehoash, whose soul came from shekalim, killed Zechariah on Yom Kippur in the Mikdash, forgetting a kindness as Haman did. Yet shekalim is the indestructible point in every Jew, where all are equal as children; it outweighed Haman's shekalim, and through it Yehoash too will be atoned.
Topics: The Four Parshiyos · The Pintele Yid: The Inner Point of Every Jew · Ahavas Hashem and Dveikus
Order of the shiur
-
0:00 Parshas Shekalim and the coin of fire listed in the guide
The Mashgiach introduces the four parshiyos and the Gemara that the Jews' shekalim came before Haman's ten thousand talents of silver. He then asks what 'this they shall give' means and brings Rashi that Hashem showed Moshe a coin of fire from under the Heavenly Throne.
-
3:33 The vort heard in Germany Story listed in the guide
The Mashgiach tells of a talmid of Rebbe Reb Bunim who heard a German preacher say that Hashem wants a coin of fire, the warmth and devotion that go with a mitzvah. He applies this to tefillin, tzitzis and tefillah, notes that shekel equals nefesh in gematria, and brings Rebbe Reb Bunim's explanation that the German Jews merited this vort through their hachnasas orchim.
-
10:54 The glowing love inside the Beis Hamikdash
The Mashgiach brings the Alshich on the apiryon of Shir Hashirim: Hashem lacks no silver or gold, and what He wanted in the Beis Hamikdash was the glowing love of the Jews inside it. He contrasts a cold Roman edifice and a bronze statue with living people who have a neshama.
-
17:19 Avraham's compounded shekalim
The Mashgiach asks what the Musaf piyut of Parshas Shekalim means by asking Hashem to remember the shekalim of Efron. A dollar given with love is multiplied as it rises, and Avraham, who knew the holiness of Me'aras HaMachpelah, gave his 400 shekalim with such love that they were registered above as endless sums.
-
21:50 Fire, earth and the yud of Hashem's Name listed in the guide
The Mashgiach explains the four elements, fire rising and earth falling. Efron, named for afar, kept only cold metal while Avraham's fire went up, and 'Machpelah' means compounding. The four parshiyos correspond to the four letters of the Shem Havayah, and Shekalim is the yud, the fire.
-
26:56 Yehoash and the mitzvah of shekalim
The Mashgiach explains that the haftarah tells how King Yehoash renewed the forgotten mitzvah of shekalim. Every Jew's neshama comes from a particular mitzvah, as with a tzaddik who dealt with his sukkah every day of the year, so Yehoash's neshama comes from shekalim.
-
32:06 Yehoash in the Kodesh HaKadashim and Zechariah's death
The Mashgiach tells how Yehoash, the last of the house of David, was hidden in the Kodesh HaKadashim for six years and crowned at seven. Later his servants made him a deity, and he killed Zechariah, the Kohen Gadol and Navi, on Yom Kippur in the Mikdash, forgetting Yehoyada's kindness; Zechariah's blood boiled until the Churban.
-
41:45 Like Haman: Kodesh HaKadashim defiled
The Mashgiach compares Yehoash to Haman, who did not remember Shaul's mercy to Agag. Using Sefer Yetzirah's three dimensions of world, year and soul, he shows that Yehoash killed the Kohen Gadol, the Kodesh HaKadashim of souls, in the holiest place on the holiest day.
-
45:48 The kotzo shel yud and the indestructible nucleus
The Mashgiach asks why the small mitzvah of shekalim saved the Jews from Haman. Shekalim is the yud, and the yud has a kotz, the nucleus; every Jew has an indestructible point, like the luz bone, from which he is rebuilt however deep he falls.
-
51:50 One root of all Jews
The Mashgiach explains that shekalim corresponds to that nucleus, so in its merit the Jews, who cannot be totally destroyed, were saved. He brings the Chasam Sofer that all Jews share one root to which teshuvah returns, his reading of the passuk comparing Jews to the children of Kush, and the future circle dance where every point is equally close to the center.
-
57:22 Equal half-shekalim: children, not servants
The Mashgiach contrasts other mitzvos, which each Jew performs on his own level, with shekalim, where rich and poor give the same. Shekalim, called the money of atonement, belongs to Yom Kippur, the day of the circle dance and of forgiveness, where Jews are children and not servants, and where the lot chooses without a reason, as with Purim.
-
1:02:13 Haman's shekalim against ours; Yehoash is not Haman listed in the guide
The Mashgiach explains why the Jews' shekalim came before Haman's: theirs are fire, the yud, given with the joy of Adar, while Haman's are earth. Yehoash fits the haftarah because, though guilty of Haman's crime, his neshama of shekalim cannot be destroyed, which shows every Jew that he can never be lost forever.
-
1:07:54 The rising fire and the gates of mercy listed in the guide
The Mashgiach says that even today the eagerness for the mitzvah of shekalim is fire that rises to the heavenly Beis Hamikdash. He finds a hint that Yom Kippur will atone for Yehoash, who came from the Kodesh HaKadashim, and closes with the Gemara on Mordechai ben Yair ben Shimi ben Kish, who knocked on the gates of mercy that open on Yom Kippur and Purim.
The shiur, written up
Parshas Shekalim and the coin of fire
The Mashgiach opens with Parshas Shekalim, the first of the four parshiyos. He brings the Gemara in Megillah that when Haman offered ten thousand talents of silver against the Jews, Hashem answered that their shekalim had already come first. He then asks what 'this they shall give' means, and brings Rashi that Moshe did not understand, so Hashem showed him a coin of fire from under the Heavenly Throne. a,b,c
The vort heard in Germany
The Mashgiach tells of a talmid of Rebbe Reb Bunim who went to Germany on business when assimilation and Reform had already taken root there; he adds that the Meshech Chochmah predicted the punishment would also begin in Germany. Asked on his return whether he had heard any Torah, the talmid repeated a German preacher's vort: Hashem showed a coin of fire because He wants the fire of the heart along with the coin, not its silver. d
The Mashgiach applies this to tefillin, tzitzis and tefillah: the fire within a mitzvah is what Hashem accepts. The sefarim say shekel equals nefesh in gematria, so one gives his soul with the coin. Rebbe Reb Bunim explained that the German Jews merited this vort through their warm hachnasas orchim.
The glowing love inside the Beis Hamikdash
The Mashgiach brings the Alshich on the passuk in Shir Hashirim describing the apiryon, with pillars of silver, a base of gold, crimson upholstery and an inside paved with love. Hashem, the King to whom all perfection belongs, lacks no silver or gold; what He wanted in the Beis Hamikdash was the glowing love inside it. e,f
A Roman or Greek edifice, he explains, is cold stone and metal however artistic, like a bronze statue in Prospect Park beside the plain people gazing at it, who have a neshama. The Beis Hamikdash was alive through the dedication with which the Jews gave, because the fire in a mitzvah registers above, not its material.
Avraham's compounded shekalim
The Mashgiach asks what the Musaf piyut of Parshas Shekalim means by asking Hashem to remember the shekalim of Efron that Avraham weighed out. A dollar given to tzedakah with love, he explains, is compounded on its way up. Avraham paid 400 shekalim, a high price, but he knew the cave was the gate to Gan Eden and a place where Kalev would later daven, so his shekalim registered above as endless billions. g,h
Fire, earth and the yud of Hashem's Name
Everything, the Mashgiach explains, consists of four elements; fire rises, earth falls, and metal is earth. Avraham gave coins of fire, but Efron, named for afar, loved cold metal: by the time the coins reached his hands their fire had risen, and 'Machpelah' means compounding. The sefarim say the four parshiyos correspond to the four letters of the Shem Havayah; Shekalim is the yud, the source of fire, so it must be a coin of fire.
Yehoash and the mitzvah of shekalim
The haftarah, which the Gemara at the end of Megillah says always carries the parsha's theme, tells how King Yehoash enforced the forgotten mitzvah of shekalim. Every Jew, the Mashgiach explains, has his root in one mitzvah, like a tzaddik whose soul came from sukkah and who dealt with his sukkah every day. Since Yehoash was eternalized in the Navi through shekalim, his neshama comes from that mitzvah. j,k
Yehoash in the Kodesh HaKadashim and Zechariah's death
Examining Yehoash's soul, the Mashgiach tells from Melachim how, after Queen Asalyah killed the royal seed of David, Yehoyada the Kohen Gadol hid the infant in the Kodesh HaKadashim. The Gemara in Yoma tells how unworthy Kohanim Gedolim died there, yet Yehoash lived there six years, because he was the last of the house of David, from whom Moshiach must come. l,m
Crowned at seven, he did right all the days Yehoyada taught him, but, as Divrei Hayamim recounts, his servants called him a deity and he let them bow to him. When Zechariah, Yehoyada's son and the Kohen Gadol, rebuked the people on Yom Kippur in the Mikdash, Yehoash killed him; the Mashgiach says this killing caused the Churban and answers the Navi's complaint in Eichah. Zechariah's blood was still boiling when Nevuzaradan came, and the passuk faults Yehoash for not remembering Yehoyada's kindness. n,p,q,r
Like Haman: Kodesh HaKadashim defiled
This passuk, the Mashgiach says, echoes the line said after the Megillah, that Haman did not remember Shaul's mercy to Agag, his ancestor. As Sefer Yetzirah teaches, creation is duplicated in place, time and soul: the Kodesh HaKadashim, Yom Kippur, and the Kohen Gadol, Aharon who was set apart as kodesh kodashim. Yehoash killed the Kohen Gadol in the Mikdash on Yom Kippur, defiling all three. s,t,u
The kotzo shel yud and the indestructible nucleus
Returning to Shekalim, the Mashgiach asks why so easy a mitzvah saved the Jews from Haman. Shekalim is the yud, and the yud has a kotz, its tip; among the chumashim, Bereishis is that tip, as Rashi says Yisrael is called reishis. As the passuk told David, no one is pushed away for good: every Jew has a nucleus that no aveirah touches, like the luz, from which he is rebuilt. When the decree in Haman's time was total annihilation, this point could not be destroyed. v,w
One root of all Jews
Shekalim, the Mashgiach explains, corresponds to that nucleus, showing that Hashem has sworn every Jew will be rebuilt, even after Gehinnom. The Chasam Sofer teaches that all Jews share one root where they are united, and that is teshuvah. He explains the passuk likening Jews to the children of Kush: under the skin all are alike. So too the Gemara's future circle dance means every point is equally close to Hashem in the center. x,y,z
Equal half-shekalim: children, not servants
In other mitzvos, the Mashgiach says, each Jew acts on his own level, one rushing through davening, another davening with kavanah. In shekalim the rich may not give more nor the poor less, because it is kesef hakippurim, from Yom Kippur, the day of machol, both circle dance and mechilah. There Jews are children, not servants, all equally sons, and the Yom Kippur goral, like Haman's lot, chooses without a reason. aa,ab
Haman's shekalim against ours; Yehoash is not Haman
This, the Mashgiach explains, is why Hashem told Haman, who gave ten thousand shekalim to charity as the Midrashim say, that the Jews' shekalim came first: theirs come from the yud, fire, and his from earth, the last. The yud is the smallest letter but the greatest, and Adar, when shekalim are announced, brings simcha, mitzvos done with fire. ad,ae
So Yehoash is the fitting haftarah. Though guilty of Haman's crime of forgetting a kindness, he is a Jewish neshama with a point of shekalim that can never be destroyed. The Mashgiach says he shows every Jew that he can get lost but never forever, so he might as well return now.
The rising fire and the gates of mercy
Even without the Beis Hamikdash, the Mashgiach says, the eagerness for shekalim creates fire, which rises to the heavenly Beis Hamikdash waiting to descend. He hints that Yom Kippur will atone for Yehoash, who came from the Kodesh HaKadashim and was sheltered there. He closes with the Gemara on Mordechai ben Yair ben Shimi ben Kish: he knocked on the gates of mercy that open on Yom Kippur and Purim. af,ag
Sources
Torah
Nevi'im
Kesuvim
- e Shir Hashirim 3:9-10 text index In the write-up: 10:54
- p apparently Divrei Hayamim II 24:17-22 index In the write-up: 36:34
- q apparently Eichah 2:20 index In the write-up: 36:34
- r Divrei Hayamim II 24:22 text index In the write-up: 36:34
- u Divrei Hayamim I 23:13 text index In the write-up: 42:04
- af Esther 2:5 text index In the write-up: 1:08:22
Talmud Bavli
- a Megillah 13b text index In the write-up: 1:19
- j Gemara Megillah (place not identified) index In the write-up: 27:05
- m apparently Yoma 8b-9a index In the write-up: 33:00
- o Gemara (place not identified) 36:48 index
- z apparently Taanis 31a index In the write-up: 51:56
- ae Taanis 29a text index In the write-up: 1:02:42
- ag Megillah 12b text index In the write-up: 1:08:22
Midrash
Zohar and Kabbalah
Rishonim
Acharonim and Chassidus
Tefillah and Piyut
Key points
- 7:59 The coin of fire Hashem showed Moshe teaches that what counts in a mitzvah is the fire and devotion within it, not its outward material.
- 18:50 A gift given with love is multiplied as it rises; Avraham's 400 shekalim for Me'aras HaMachpelah were registered above as endless sums.
- 25:07 The four parshiyos correspond to the four letters of the Shem Havayah, and Shekalim is the yud, the source of fire.
- 29:35 Every Jew's neshama comes from a particular mitzvah, and Yehoash, who renewed the mitzvah of shekalim, has a neshama from shekalim.
- 50:07 Shekalim is the kotzo shel yud, the nucleus in every Jew that no aveirah can destroy, and in its merit the Jews could not be annihilated in Haman's time.
- 59:04 In shekalim rich and poor give alike because it touches the root where Jews are Hashem's children, all equally His, as on Yom Kippur.
Questions and answers
-
Question: 7:24 Why should a half-shekel of silver be so important that it decided the miracle of Purim?
Answer: 7:56 Because what Hashem wants is not the coin but the fire and warmth that go with it.
-
Question: 9:50 How did such a fine vort reach Germany in a time of assimilation?
Answer: 10:00 The German Jews merited it through hachnasas orchim done with warmth and dedication.
-
Question: 12:55 If Hashem needs no silver or gold, what did He want the Beis Hamikdash for?
Answer: 13:06 For the glowing love with which the Jews gave, which was the inner content of the building.
-
Question: 17:58 What does the piyut mean by asking Hashem to remember the shekalim of Efron?
Answer: 24:14 Avraham's shekalim, given with fire, were compounded above, while Efron, who loved earth, received only cold metal.
-
Question: 46:31 Why was the small mitzvah of shekalim, rather than a harder mitzvah, the one that saved the Jews from Haman?
Answer: 51:50 Shekalim is the yud and its kotz, the nucleus in every Jew that can never be destroyed, so a decree of total annihilation could not stand.
-
Question: 1:04:58 Why is Yehoash, who did such terrible things, the haftarah of Parshas Shekalim?
Answer: 1:05:35 Though guilty of Haman's crime, his neshama comes from shekalim and can never be destroyed, which shows the worth of every Jewish neshama.
Stories
-
3:33 The coin of fire heard in Germany
A talmid of Rebbe Reb Bunim traveled to Germany on business, at a time when assimilation was already widespread there. When he returned, Rebbe Reb Bunim asked whether he had heard any words of Torah, and he said he had heard a German preacher explain that Hashem showed Moshe a coin of fire because one must give with fire and devotion. Rebbe Reb Bunim wondered how such a fine vort reached Germany, and explained that the German Jews merited it through their warm hachnasas orchim.
In the story: Rebbe Reb Bunim of Peshischa
-
30:21 The tzaddik whose soul came from sukkah
The Mashgiach tells of a great tzaddik of several generations ago whose neshama, the tzaddikim said, came from the mitzvah of sukkah. Every day of the year he was busy with his sukkah: fixing something in it, talking about it or buying something for it.
-
33:00 Yehoash, Yehoyada and Zechariah
When Asalyah killed the royal seed of David, the Kohen Gadol Yehoyada saved the infant Yehoash and hid him in the Kodesh HaKadashim for six years, where he was fed and cared for. Crowned at seven, Yehoash was righteous while Yehoyada lived, but later his servants told him he must be a deity and he let them worship him. When Yehoyada's son Zechariah, the Kohen Gadol, rebuked the people on Yom Kippur in the Beis Hamikdash, Yehoash had him killed. Long afterwards, at the Churban, Nevuzaradan found Zechariah's blood still boiling and killed many Jews over it.
In the story: Yehoash, Yehoyada HaKohen, Asalyah, Zechariah ben Yehoyada, Nevuzaradan
Insights
- 12:33 Following the Alshich, the Mashgiach reads the apiryon passuk as saying that Hashem, who lacks no silver or gold, wanted the Beis Hamikdash only for the glowing love inside it; that love gave the building a neshama, unlike the cold marble of Rome.
- 23:49 Efron's name comes from afar, earth: when Avraham's shekalim reached his hands their fire had already risen, leaving him cold metal, while 'Machpelah' alludes to Avraham's gift being compounded above.
- 1:10:00 Yehoash survived six years in the Kodesh HaKadashim because his neshama came from there, from the mitzvah of shekalim, the money of atonement linked to Yom Kippur.
- 44:07 By killing the Kohen Gadol in the Mikdash on Yom Kippur, Yehoash defiled the Kodesh HaKadashim in all three of Sefer Yetzirah's dimensions: place, time and soul.
- 51:27 Because Haman's decree was total annihilation, it could not take effect: the shekel touches the nucleus in every Jew that can never be destroyed.
- 1:00:04 The equal half-shekel reflects the level where Jews are children rather than servants: a servant can be better or worse as a servant, but a son is never more or less a son.
- 1:03:22 The Jews' shekalim came before Haman's because theirs are the yud, the first letter and fire, while his are earth, the last; the yud is the tiniest letter but the greatest.
What the Mashgiach says to take from it
- 8:13 The Mashgiach says tefillin, tzitzis and tefillah should be done not with a yawn but with fire, warmth and thankfulness for the merit of doing the mitzvah.
- 9:14 The Mashgiach says that when one gives a shekel, or a dollar to tzedakah, one should give one's neshama with it, not just the cold coin.
- 1:07:38 The Mashgiach tells every Jew to know that he is a neshama that can never be lost forever and will return to Hashem, so he might as well return now.
Mentioned in this shiur
People Adam HaRishon, Agag, Aharon HaKohen, Asalyah, Avraham Avinu, Chava, Efron, Haman, Kalev ben Yefuneh, Mordechai HaTzaddik, Moshe Rabbeinu, Nevuzaradan, Rashi, Rebbe Reb Bunim of Peshischa, Shaul HaMelech, the Alshich, the Chasam Sofer, the Meshech Chochmah (Rabbi Meir Simcha of Dvinsk), Yehoash, Yehoyada HaKohen, Zechariah HaNavi
Terms ארבע יסודות, גורל, הכנסת אורחים, לוז, מחול, מחצית השקל, מטבע של אש, מערת המכפלה, ניצוצות, קודש הקדשים, קוצו של יו"ד, רבונו של עולם, שם הוי"ה