bachurim bamidbar
Catalog entry: Y 05 Current במדבר no. 17 תשע"ג (2012–13) Yiddish 37 min
Not in the 2012 Pocket Guide; the title is taken from the file name.
Listen
About this shiur
Learning the opening of Tanya chapter two with bachurim, the Mashgiach explains how the Jewish soul, 'truly a part of G-d above', stays pure in its innermost point and comes from Hashem's own thought, which no created mind can grasp.
The Mashgiach reviews Tanya chapter one: a Jew has an animal soul from kelipas nogah, which can be elevated when he eats for the sake of Heaven, and a G-dly soul, the subject of chapter two, 'truly a part of G-d above'. He shows this inner point through the Rambam's explanation of why a man forced to say 'I want' brings a valid korban, and through the Ramban's reason for forty lashes: the forty days of a child's formation, of which the first point never sinned, so only thirty-nine are given. The same point appears in the forty days from Rosh Chodesh Elul to Yom Kippur. He explains 'vayipach' as blowing from one's innermost depth, tied to the shofar, and the soul as coming from Hashem's thought and wisdom. Through the mashal of a watch and its maker, and of the five senses, he shows that a creation cannot understand its Creator. He closes with the Tanya's question of why souls differ in level, leaving the answer for next time.
Topics: The Two Souls (Tanya ch. 1-8) · Levels and Root of the Soul · The Pintele Yid: The Inner Point of Every Jew
Order of the shiur
-
0:00 Two souls and kelipas nogah listed in the guide
The Mashgiach reviews Tanya chapter one: the animal soul of a Jew comes from kelipas nogah, so kosher food eaten for the sake of Heaven is elevated, while the three impure kelipos cannot be. He then opens chapter two, the G-dly soul, 'truly a part of G-d above'.
-
4:02 The Rambam on 'rotzeh ani' listed in the guide
The Mashgiach brings the halachah that one who refuses to bring his korban is beaten until he says 'I want', and the Rambam's answer: every Jew's good inclination truly wants, and the beating only weakens the evil inclination. He then introduces the Torah's forty lashes, of which only thirty-nine are given.
-
7:35 Forty days of formation and the untouched point listed in the guide
The Mashgiach brings the Ramban that forty lashes correspond to the forty days of a child's formation, and explains why only thirty-nine are given: the first point, the G-dly soul, never sinned. He finds the same in the forty days from Rosh Chodesh Elul to Yom Kippur, the day of that point.
-
12:20 Vayipach: blowing from within listed in the guide
The Mashgiach reads the Tanya's proof from 'vayipach be'apav nishmas chayim' and contrasts blowing with speaking: blowing comes with force from one's innermost self. He connects it to Rosh Hashanah and the shofar, to 've'atah nefachtah bi' in the morning blessing, and to the Zohar that one who blows, blows from within.
-
17:04 Souls from Hashem's thought and wisdom listed in the guide
The Mashgiach explains that the world was created for the sake of man, who arose first in Hashem's thought, and that like a child drawn from the father's mind, Jewish souls are drawn from Hashem's wisdom. With the Rambam that Hashem and His wisdom are one, and the mashal of a watch and its maker, he shows why this is beyond understanding.
-
22:06 Not like our thoughts: the picture and the niggun listed in the guide
From 'ki lo machshevosai machshevoseichem' the Mashgiach argues that more intelligence would not help a creation understand its Creator. He gives the mashal of a man who says he heard a beautiful picture or saw a niggun: each thing is grasped only by its own faculty.
-
26:00 Five senses and the bat listed in the guide
The Mashgiach points out that our whole contact with the world comes through five senses, a small number, and that some creatures, like the bat that senses its surroundings by sound in a dark cave, have senses we lack. Even with a million senses, he says, a person would not understand Hashem, because he is the watch and Hashem is the watchmaker.
-
30:41 Back to the Tanya: why do souls differ? listed in the guide
Returning to the Tanya, the Mashgiach reads the Rambam that Hashem is the knower and the known, beyond human grasp, and repeats that Jews come from the 'mind of the Father'. He then raises the Tanya's question: if all souls come from Hashem's thought and Hashem is One, why are there souls of the Avos and Moshe Rabbeinu and souls of the lowest generations? He leaves the answer for the next shiur.
The shiur, written up
Two souls and kelipas nogah
The Mashgiach reviews the first chapter of Tanya: a Jew has an animal soul, with which he eats and sleeps like an animal, and in a Jew it comes from kelipas nogah. Kosher things eaten for the sake of Heaven are therefore turned to holiness, which the three impure kelipos can never be. Now, in chapter two, the Tanya speaks of the second soul, 'truly a part of G-d above'. a,b
The Rambam on 'rotzeh ani'
To show this inner point, the Mashgiach brings the Gemara: a korban must be brought 'lirtzono', willingly, yet one who refuses his chatas is beaten until he says 'I want'. How can that be willing? The Rambam answers that every Jew has a spark of holiness that wants Hashem's will; the beating weakens the evil inclination, and then the Jewish soul itself speaks. c,d,e
Forty days and the untouched point
The Mashgiach notes that the Torah says forty lashes, yet the Gemara gives thirty-nine. The Ramban explains forty as corresponding to the forty days of a child's formation, known from the Gemara in Berachos about praying for a son. The Mashgiach resolves the difficulty: each day adds formation, but the first point, the G-dly soul, never agreed to the sin, so only thirty-nine are given. f,g,h,i
He adds that the year too is formed in forty days, from Rosh Chodesh Elul to Yom Kippur, which corresponds to that point; therefore one does not eat on it. He also notes that 'rotzeh ani' equals Yom Kippur in gematria.
Vayipach: blowing from within
The Mashgiach explains that the Tanya proves its words from 'vayipach be'apav nishmas chayim'. Everything else was made with 'vayomer', but for man the Torah says He blew. Speaking uses the air of the mouth; blowing comes with force from one's innermost depth. b,j
Since man was created on Rosh Hashanah, he says, a Jew blows the shofar with great strength, giving his soul back with teshuvah; the Arizal's kavanos explain why the one blowing turns red. The Mashgiach also cites 've'atah nefachtah bi' from the morning blessing and the Zohar that one who blows, blows from within. k,l
Souls from Hashem's thought
The Mashgiach explains that Hashem created the world for man, who arose first in His thought. 'Beni bechori Yisrael' and 'banim atem laHashem' teach that as a child is drawn from the father's mind, Jewish souls are drawn from Hashem's thought and wisdom. m,n
He contrasts a bachur who learned Bava Metzia and took in wisdom from outside; with Hashem, His wisdom is Himself, which we believe but cannot grasp. A watchmaker understands his watch, but the watch cannot understand him, because he made it.
The picture and the niggun
Citing 'ki lo machshevosai machshevoseichem', the Mashgiach says that man is the watch, and even a billion times more intelligence would not help, for the created mind cannot grasp its Creator. Someone who says he heard a beautiful picture in a museum, or saw a lovely niggun, is a fool: a picture is seen and a niggun heard, and no strength of the eyes will hear a niggun. p
Five senses and the bat
The Mashgiach asks the bachurim whether five is a large number; usually it is small. Yet all our contact with the world comes through five senses: sight, hearing, taste, touch and smell.
He notes that some creatures have senses we lack. A bat flies in a dark cave among hundreds of others without colliding, sensing everything by the noises that bounce back. Even with a million senses a person would not understand Hashem, because he is the watch and Hashem the watchmaker.
Sources
Torah
Nevi'im
Talmud Bavli
Zohar and Kabbalah
Rishonim
Acharonim and Chassidus
Tefillah and Piyut
Key points
- 0:51 The animal soul of a Jew comes from kelipas nogah, so permitted things done for the sake of Heaven are turned to holiness, unlike the three impure kelipos.
- 5:40 According to the Rambam, every Jew has a spark of holiness that truly wants Hashem's will; beating only weakens the evil inclination, so his 'I want' is true.
- 8:50 The Ramban ties forty lashes to the forty days of a child's formation; since the first point of the soul never agreed to the sin, only thirty-nine are given.
- 13:03 'Vayipach', blowing, means bringing out breath from one's innermost being, which shows that the soul comes from Hashem's inner self.
- 18:30 The souls of Jews come from Hashem's thought and wisdom, which is one with Him and cannot be understood by any created mind.
- 21:28 A creation cannot understand its Creator, just as a watch cannot understand its maker, not for lack of intelligence but because it is a different realm entirely.
Questions and answers
-
Question: 5:09 How can a korban brought under compulsion be valid, if it must be brought willingly?
Answer: 5:40 The Rambam answers that every Jew's good inclination truly wants Hashem's will; the beating weakens the evil inclination, and then his own soul says 'I want'.
-
Question: 9:12 If the Ramban says the lashes correspond to the forty days of formation, why are only thirty-nine given?
Answer: 9:30 Each of the forty days adds a stage of formation; the first point, the G-dly soul, never sinned and never agreed to the sin, so it receives no lash.
-
Question: 12:53 Why does the Torah say 'vayipach', He blew, for the creation of man, and not 'vayomer' as with everything else?
Answer: 13:27 Speaking uses the air in the mouth, while blowing brings out breath with force from one's innermost depth; the soul comes from Hashem's inner self.
-
Question: 22:37 Why can a person not understand Hashem, even if he were far smarter?
Answer: 21:42 Because a creation cannot understand its Creator, as a watch cannot understand the one who made it; the human mind is itself created.
Insights
- 9:12 The Mashgiach reads the Ramban's forty lashes together with the Gemara's thirty-nine: of the forty days of formation, the first point, the G-dly soul, never sinned, so it is not punished.
- 11:15 The forty days from Rosh Chodesh Elul to Yom Kippur form the year like the forty days of a child, and Yom Kippur corresponds to the untouched point of G-dliness, which is why one does not eat on it.
- 11:53 The Mashgiach notes that 'rotzeh ani' equals Yom Kippur in gematria: the point that says 'I want to serve Hashem' is the point revealed on that day.
- 14:28 Since Hashem blew the soul into Adam on Rosh Hashanah and renews creation each year, on Rosh Hashanah a Jew blows the shofar with great force from within, giving his soul back with teshuvah, which is why the one blowing turns red.
- 22:53 A person cannot understand Hashem not because he is not smart enough; even a billion times more intelligence or a million senses would not help, just as eyes cannot hear a niggun.
Mentioned in this shiur
People Adam HaRishon, Dovid HaMelech, Moshe Rabbeinu, the Arizal, the Baal HaTanya (Rabbi Shneur Zalman of Liadi), the Rambam, the Ramban
Terms ויפח באפיו נשמת חיים, חלק אלוק ממעל, יצירת הולד, יצר הרע, יצר טוב, מוח האב, מלקות, נפש האלקית, נפש הבהמית, עקבתא דמשיחא, קליפת נוגה, רוצה אני, שלש קליפות הטמאות