Nitzavim Vayelech
Catalog entry: Y 05 Current נצבים וילך no. 0 תשס"ט (2008–09) Yiddish 34 min
Not in the 2012 Pocket Guide; the title is taken from the file name.
Listen
About this shiur
Using the tradition that the ten sedras of Devarim correspond to the ten centuries of the sixth millennium, the Mashgiach reads the current century in Nitzavim-Vayelech: the hester panim of the Holocaust, the promise that the Torah will not be forgotten, and the geulah that is written before the galus.
The Mashgiach opens by noting that everything Moshe Rabbeinu foretold in Devarim about exile and return has come true, while the nations' scriptures avoid predictions, and the church now has a problem with Jews back in Eretz Yisroel and Jerusalem. He then brings a tradition in the name of the Vilna Gaon that the ten sedras of Devarim correspond to the ten centuries of the sixth millennium, the world's Erev Shabbos, with Nitzavim-Vayelech counted as one sedra and corresponding to the present century. He tells how, as a bochur on Rosh Hashanah of that century's first year, he learned that Hitler had invaded Poland. In Vayelech he reads the double hester panim, explained with a mashal of a child who does not even know his father is hiding, and the promise that the Torah will never be forgotten. Finally he asks why the geulah of Nitzavim precedes the galus of Vayelech, and answers from the Gemara that for Jews the cure comes before the blow. He closes urging the bochurim to prepare for Moshiach.
Topics: Hester Panim and Suffering · The Churban of Europe and Persecutions · Signs of the Generation Before Moshiach · The Time of the Geulah and the Ketz
Order of the shiur
-
0:00 Moshe's prophecies fulfilled before our eyes listed in the guide
The Mashgiach notes that everything Moshe Rabbeinu foretold in Devarim about exile and return has come true, while the nations' scriptures avoid predictions. He describes the church's problem with Jews, many of them Torah-observant, back in Eretz Yisroel and the Old City of Jerusalem.
-
5:01 The ten sedras of Devarim and the ten centuries listed in the guide
The Mashgiach brings in the name of the Vilna Gaon that the ten sedras of Devarim correspond to the ten centuries of the sixth millennium, the world's Erev Shabbos, with Nitzavim-Vayelech counted as one sedra. He tells of Rav Chaim of Volozhin asking the Gaon where he is hinted in Ki Seitzei, and concludes that the present century is found in Nitzavim-Vayelech.
-
11:25 Rosh Hashanah when Hitler entered Poland Story
The Mashgiach recounts how, as a bochur at the start of this century, he davened with his father on Rosh Hashanah and saw the congregation weeping because Hitler had invaded Poland. The war expected to last weeks lasted five years, and six million Jews were killed; the start of the century must therefore be found in Nitzavim-Vayelech.
-
15:52 Hester panim within hester panim listed in the guide
The Mashgiach reads the pesukim in Vayelech where Hashem foretells that He will hide His face and many evils will befall the people, and asks what the doubled hiding means. With a mashal of a child chased by a tiger who does not even know his father is inside, he explains it as hiding within hiding, the state of Jews who lost their emunah in the Holocaust.
-
19:20 The song as witness; the Torah will not be forgotten listed in the guide
The Mashgiach explains that Hashem commands writing the song of Ha'azinu as a witness that He foretold the troubles, and promises the Torah will not be forgotten from the Jews' children. The cultures of Rome, Greece and Bavel are forgotten while Jews still learn Torah, even though Hitler specifically targeted the yeshivos and talmidei chachamim.
-
23:13 Why the geulah comes before the galus listed in the guide
The Mashgiach reads the promise of return and ingathering in Nitzavim and asks two questions: why this century is split over two sedras, and why the geulah in Nitzavim precedes the galus in Vayelech. He answers both from the Gemara that for Jews the cure comes before the blow, illustrated by Esther and Mordechai, a surgeon and a mohel, and explains that galus and geulah are two separate themes.
-
29:47 Preparing for Moshiach on the world's Erev Shabbos
The Mashgiach tells the bochurim that Moshiach is near, comparing the world to a barrel of gunpowder with a lit fuse. Like Erev Shabbos, one must do teshuvah, put on the Shabbos clothes of Torah and mitzvos, and daven well with a minyan, starting together word by word; he urges them to make a kiddush Hashem on their Shabbos away and closes with l'chaim.
The shiur, written up
Moshe's prophecies fulfilled before our eyes
The Mashgiach opens with Moshe Rabbeinu's words in Devarim, above all in Nitzavim, Vayelech and Ha'azinu, foretelling everything that would befall the Jews, from the exiles to the final ingathering and geulah. All of it, he says, has come true. The nations' scriptures, by contrast, contain no prophecies, because their authors feared being proven false.
The one prediction they did make was that the Jews would never return to Eretz Yisroel. Now the church has a problem: the Old City of Jerusalem is inhabited by Jews, many of them devoted to Torah and mitzvos, so it calls for Jerusalem to become an international city.
The ten sedras of Devarim and the ten centuries
The Mashgiach brings a tradition in the name of the Vilna Gaon that Devarim is a sefer of its own, as Tosafos also says, and that its ten sedras correspond to the ten centuries of the sixth millennium. Since the Gemara says the world exists for six thousand years, corresponding to the six days of Creation, this millennium is the world's Erev Shabbos, and it is already past chatzos, the time for the mikveh and preparing the candles. b,c
Nitzavim and Vayelech are read together and count as one sedra. Whatever happens in a century is written in its sedra: when Rav Chaim of Volozhin asked the Gra where he is hinted in Ki Seitzei, the Gra answered 'even shleimah', the initials of his own name. The present century is therefore found in Nitzavim-Vayelech. d
Rosh Hashanah when Hitler entered Poland
This century began, the Mashgiach recounts, when he was a bochur helping his father daven Shacharis on Rosh Hashanah. The congregation wept, and his father explained that Hitler had invaded Poland, where they had many relatives. Friends whose wealthy parents owned a radio reported that England and France would crush Hitler within weeks. The war lasted five years, and six million Jews were killed: the hardest period in Jewish history, which must be found in Nitzavim-Vayelech.
Hester panim within hester panim
In Vayelech Hashem tells Moshe that the people will sin, He will hide His face, and many troubles will befall them. The Mashgiach asks why the hiding is doubled, and explains with a mashal: a child outside sees a tiger and screams for his father inside. If he knows his father is there, that is hiding; if he does not even know it, that is hiding within hiding. This, he says, is the state of those who lost their emunah in the Holocaust. e,f
The song as witness; the Torah will not be forgotten
Hashem then commands writing the song of Ha'azinu as a witness that He foretold these troubles. He also promises that the Torah will not be forgotten from Jewish children. The Mashgiach notes that the culture of Rome, Greece and Bavel is forgotten, while after two thousand years of exile Jews still learn Torah, though Hitler specifically targeted the yeshivos and talmidei chachamim of Poland, Galicia and Lita. g,h
Why the geulah comes before the galus
Nitzavim promises that Hashem will return the exiles, gather them from all the nations and bring them to the land. The Mashgiach asks two questions: if each sedra is a century, why is this one split over two sedras; and why is the geulah in Nitzavim written before the galus in Vayelech? i
He answers both with the Gemara in Megillah: with the nations Hashem strikes and then heals, but for Jews the cure precedes the blow, as Esther became queen and Mordechai revealed the plot before Haman rose. A stabbing in a quarrel comes before the cure; a surgeon, like a mohel, lays out the bandages first, showing the cutting itself is healing. So the geulah stands before the galus. Galus and geulah are separate themes, each sedra a thread of its own, because in the geulah no pain of galus will remain. j
Preparing for Moshiach on the world's Erev Shabbos
The Mashgiach tells the bochurim that Moshiach is near; the world is like a barrel of gunpowder with a burning fuse. As on Erev Shabbos, one must do teshuvah, put on the Shabbos clothes of Torah and mitzvos, and daven well with a minyan, starting together word by word. Those going away with the yeshivah should make a kiddush Hashem through davening, learning and zemiros, and so bring the geulah.
Sources
Torah
Talmud Bavli
Rishonim
Key points
- 0:14 Everything Moshe Rabbeinu foretold about the Jewish people's exile and return has been fulfilled, while the nations' scriptures do not dare to predict the future.
- 5:40 The ten sedras of Devarim correspond to the ten centuries of the sixth millennium, and Nitzavim-Vayelech, counted as one sedra, corresponds to the present century.
- 16:54 The doubled hester panim in Vayelech means that even the hiding itself is hidden, which the Mashgiach calls the confused state of Jews after the Holocaust.
- 20:23 The promise that the Torah will not be forgotten from the mouths of Jewish children has held, while the cultures of the great nations have been forgotten.
- 26:27 For Jews Hashem prepares the cure before the blow, which is why the geulah of Nitzavim is written before the galus of Vayelech.
- 29:54 Moshiach is near, and the Mashgiach says one must prepare for him like for Shabbos: teshuvah, Torah and mitzvos, and good davening.
Questions and answers
-
Question: 8:39 There are 54 sedras, so how can the sedras be said to correspond to 53?
Answer: 8:24 Nitzavim and Vayelech are read together and count as one sedra.
-
Question: 17:21 What does the doubled expression of hiding Hashem's face mean?
Answer: 18:41 Hiding within hiding: not only is the father hidden, but the child does not even know he is there.
-
Question: 25:39 If each sedra corresponds to a century, why is this century spread over two sedras?
Answer: 29:09 Each sedra has its own theme like a thread through pearls; galus and geulah are two separate matters, since in the geulah no pain of galus will remain.
-
Question: 25:49 Why is the geulah in Nitzavim written before the galus in Vayelech, when the order should be reversed?
Answer: 26:27 For Jews Hashem prepares the cure before the blow, as with Esther and Mordechai before Haman's decree.
Stories
-
11:42 Rosh Hashanah of the war's outbreak
As a bochur the Mashgiach went with his father, who davened Shacharis for the amud on Rosh Hashanah, and helped him. The congregation wept, and after davening he asked his father why this year was different; his father answered that Hitler had invaded Poland, where they had many relatives. His friends at yeshivah whose wealthy parents owned a radio reported that England and France had declared war and would defeat Hitler within a few weeks. Instead the war lasted five years, and six million Jews were killed.
-
9:17 The Vilna Gaon and Rav Chaim of Volozhin on Ki Seitzei
When the Gra lived, at the beginning of the century corresponding to Ki Seitzei, his talmid Rav Chaim of Volozhin asked him where the Gra himself is hinted in that sedra. The Gra answered with the words 'even shleimah', whose letters spell Eliyahu ben Shlomah, his own name. Rav Chaim then asked where he himself is hinted, and the Gra answered him, but Rav Chaim never wanted to reveal that answer to his talmidim.
Insights
- 1:44 The Mashgiach argues that the fulfillment of Moshe's prophecies is a proof the nations' scriptures cannot offer, since they avoided predictions, and the one they made, that Jews would never return, has failed.
- 6:20 He describes the present as late afternoon of the world's Erev Shabbos: after chatzos of the sixth day, when one is already going to the mikveh and preparing the candles.
- 18:15 Hester within hester is a child who not only cannot see his hidden father but does not even know a father is there; this, says the Mashgiach, is the state of those who lost their emunah in the Holocaust.
- 27:12 The difference between a blow followed by a cure and a cure prepared before the blow is the difference between a stabbing and surgery: a surgeon who prepared the bandages beforehand shows the cutting itself is for healing.
- 29:13 Nitzavim and Vayelech are one sedra in count, matching one century, yet two sedras in theme, because galus and geulah are separate; in the geulah no pain of galus will remain.
What the Mashgiach says to take from it
- 30:33 The Mashgiach says one must do teshuvah and prepare for Moshiach as one prepares for Shabbos on Erev Shabbos.
- 30:45 He says the Shabbos clothes to put on are Torah and mitzvos, and the songs to sing are working on love and fear of Hashem and davening well.
- 31:06 He urges the bochurim to daven with a minyan, begin together with the congregation word by word, and not come late and rush.
- 32:27 To those spending Shabbos away with the yeshivah he says to make a kiddush Hashem through good davening, learning and zemiros, and so bring the geulah.
Mentioned in this shiur
People Esther HaMalkah, Haman, Hitler, Mordechai HaTzaddik, Moshe Rabbeinu, Rabbi Chaim of Volozhin, the Vilna Gaon
Terms אלף השישי, גאולה, הסתר פנים, קיבוץ גליות, קידוש השם