Ach - Ked
Catalog entry: Y 05 Current אחרי מות קדושים no. 27 תשס"ט (2008–09) Yiddish 37 min
Not in the 2012 Pocket Guide; the title is taken from the file name.
Listen
About this shiur
The Mashgiach warns bachurim that leitzanus, the mocking spirit of the generation before Moshiach, uproots emunah, and through the last chapter of Malachi shows that in such a time those who fear Hashem must gather to strengthen one another.
The Mashgiach opens with the Gemara's signs of ikvesa diMeshicha, the heels of Moshiach, and the chutzpah of the time. To receive from a rebbe, he says, one must stand beneath him with derech eretz, as Reb Baruch of Mezhbizh taught with the cup and the bottle. Jokes about rebbeim and teachers destroy this, and can even cost a teacher his parnassah. Leitzanus is the opposite of emunah: Pharaoh withstood the plagues only by mocking, and a single joke in a class of Reb Shraga Feivel Mendlowitz wiped out the seriousness of his talk. Emunah grows through tefillah said word by word, each word a diamond. Malachi, the last prophet, spoke to every generation until Eliyahu comes; he foresees Jews saying that serving Hashem does not pay, and promises that those who fear Hashem and gather to strengthen each other are written in a book of remembrance.
Topics: Signs of the Generation Before Moshiach · Avodah of the Last Generation · The Neviim and Their Times
Order of the shiur
-
0:00 Receiving from a rebbe in the time of chutzpah
The Mashgiach recalls the Gemara's signs of ikvesa diMeshicha and the chutzpah of today, and brings Reb Baruch of Mezhbizh's mashal that a cup must be below the bottle to receive. He decries joking about rebbeim and teachers, notes that a teacher's parnassah is at stake, and tells how Reb Yaakov Kamenetsky rebuked a bachur who learned Mishnah Berurah during his English class.
-
8:11 Leitzanus uproots emunah: Pharaoh the letz
The Mashgiach explains that holiness is emunah and its opposite is leitzanus, and asks where the Torah shows Pharaoh joking. He tells of a boy's quip in Reb Shraga Feivel Mendlowitz's class, and answers that only mockery let Pharaoh stand up to plague after plague, since leitzanus dismisses even what one understands.
-
13:38 Tefillah as emunah, every word a diamond
The Mashgiach praises the bachurim's crying out in davening and explains that tefillah means emunah, a cry for help to the One who can help, not a mouth exercise. Like dollar bills or diamonds, each word must be counted slowly; he brings the pasuk that Torah is sweeter than honey, and ties this to preparing for Shavuos.
-
20:39 Malachi, the last prophet, speaks to all generations
The Mashgiach explains that because Malachi was the last prophet, his words were meant for every generation until Eliyahu, like a message to people setting out on a long sea voyage. He reads the closing pesukim about sending Eliyahu Hanavi and the opening of the chapter about the messenger who clears the way.
-
24:55 Eliyahu's sudden coming and 'it does not pay'
The Mashgiach brings a tradition from the Ba'al Shem Tov that Jews in a grocery store will suddenly hear that Eliyahu has come and run to shul. He continues through Malachi: who can endure the day of his coming, and the complaint of Jews that serving Hashem does not pay while the wicked enjoy life.
-
28:36 Those who fear Hashem gather together
The Mashgiach describes the time when people praise the wicked and their success, and explains the pasuk that then those who fear Hashem speak to one another. He applies it: Jews gathering for a mussar shmuess or a Shabbos meal with zemiros give Hashem great nachas, and it is written in His book of remembrance.
-
33:07 The day of judgment and 'remember the Torah of Moshe'
The Mashgiach explains the rest of the chapter: Hashem will have mercy on those who serve Him as a father on his son, the day will burn the wicked, and for those who fear Him a sun of righteousness will heal. He concludes that Malachi's last words, 'remember the Torah of Moshe' given at Chorev, must sustain Jews through the whole exile, even in dry times.
The shiur, written up
Receiving from a rebbe in the time of chutzpah
The Mashgiach recalls the Gemara's description of ikvesa diMeshicha, the heels of Moshiach, with its chutzpah toward elders. The Chofetz Chaim wrote that this period had already arrived, and it is already found in the Tanya. Today, he says, all these signs are visible, though most of the bachurim here are refined. a,b
To receive from a rebbe one must humble oneself beneath him. Reb Baruch of Mezhbizh compared this to pouring wine: the cup must stand below the bottle, and a cup that wants to be higher receives nothing. Mocking a rebbe, a principal or a teacher therefore blocks receiving in holiness.
A teacher, the Mashgiach notes, comes for parnassah; a class that mocks him can cost him his job. He tells how Reb Yaakov Kamenetsky sharply rebuked a bachur who learned Mishnah Berurah during English class, calling his supposed mitzvah bad middos and a great aveirah.
Leitzanus uproots emunah
Citing Reb Tzadok HaKohen, the Mashgiach says holiness is emunah and its opposite is leitzanus, mockery. The Gemara calls Pharaoh a letz, yet no joke of his appears in the Chumash. He tells how a boy's quip, 'Rebbi, I don't like fish', wiped out the seriousness of Reb Shraga Feivel Mendlowitz's talk about the Livyasan. c
This answers the question: only mockery let Pharaoh withstand plague after plague. Emunah believes even what one does not understand, while leitzanus dismisses even what one does, so a letz can have neither emunah nor yiras Shamayim.
Tefillah as emunah, every word a diamond
Before Moshiach, emunah weakens, yet the Mashgiach praises how the bachurim here cry out at Shema and Avinu Malkeinu. Tefillah means emunah: one davens because one believes Hashem can help, and the stronger that belief, the stronger the davening. Saying words by habit is a mouth exercise, not davening.
Davening today is rushed. A banker counts large bills and diamonds slowly; every word of Torah and tefillah is a diamond, more precious than pearls and sweeter than honey, to be savored like ice cream, not gulped. d,e
With Shavuos approaching, he describes an Ahavah Rabbah that took four hours, said by those who knew they were speaking to the Ribono shel Olam.
Malachi, the last prophet
Hashem sent prophets to rebuke Israel, and the last was Malachi. As the last prophet, the Mashgiach explains, Malachi spoke to all generations, like someone instructing travelers before a long sea voyage: no further word will come until they reach the shore of Moshiach.
'It does not pay'
Those who fear Hashem gather together
Remember the Torah of Moshe
Sources
Nevi'im
- f Malachi 3:23-24 text index In the write-up: 22:34, 36:05
- g Malachi 3:1 text index In the write-up: 22:34
- h Malachi 3:2 text index In the write-up: 25:00
- i apparently Malachi 3:4 26:17 index
- j Malachi 3:13-14 text index In the write-up: 26:41
- k Malachi 3:15 text index In the write-up: 28:37
- l Malachi 3:16 text index In the write-up: 28:37, 30:27
- m Malachi 3:17-18 text index In the write-up: 33:19
- n Malachi 3:19 text index In the write-up: 33:19
- o Malachi 3:20 text index In the write-up: 33:19
- p Malachi 3:22 text index In the write-up: 36:05
Kesuvim
Talmud Bavli
Acharonim and Chassidus
Key points
- 1:54 To receive from a rebbe one must be humble and stand beneath him, like a cup that must be lower than the bottle.
- 3:06 Joking about a rebbe or a teacher makes it impossible to receive from him in holiness and brings in bad middos.
- 8:30 Leitzanus is the opposite of emunah and uproots it, so a letz can have neither emunah nor yiras Shamayim.
- 14:38 Tefillah is emunah: one davens because one believes Hashem can help, and each word should be weighed like a diamond.
- 21:02 Malachi, as the last prophet, addressed all generations until Eliyahu Hanavi, and his last chapter speaks to the time before Moshiach.
- 27:15 When many say serving Hashem does not pay, those who fear Hashem gather and strengthen each other, and this is written in Hashem's book of remembrance.
Questions and answers
-
Question: 4:41 Why does a teacher come to teach the class at all?
Answer: 5:04 Because he needs parnassah; if the class mocks him and he cannot control it, the principal may replace him and he loses his livelihood.
-
Question: 8:49 Where in the whole Chumash do we find that Pharaoh was a letz, a mocker?
Answer: 11:14 There is no recorded joke, but only leitzanus could have let him withstand plague after plague, since mockery dismisses everything.
-
Question: 21:02 Why did Malachi's prophecy address all generations and not only his own?
Answer: 21:06 Because he was the last prophet; until Eliyahu comes there will be no other, so his words must suffice for thousands of years.
Stories
-
6:13 The bachur who learned Mishnah Berurah in English class
A diligent bachur sat at the back of his English class learning a Mishnah Berurah hidden under his desk. When his rosh yeshivah, Reb Yaakov Kamenetsky, found out, he called him in and rebuked him sharply. He told him that the teacher wants him to know arithmetic or English, and by ignoring him he is in effect telling him to talk to the wall; this is bad middos, and what he thinks is a great mitzvah is a great aveirah.
-
9:28 'Rebbi, I don't like fish'
Reb Shraga Feivel Mendlowitz, who taught children when he came to America, once gave a talk about reward and punishment, saying the tzaddikim will eat the Shor Habor and the Livyasan. The children absorbed it with joy at being Jews. Then one boy raised his hand and said, 'Rebbi, I don't like fish', and the class laughed. With that one remark the whole seriousness of the talk was lost.
Insights
- 11:14 The Mashgiach defines emunah as believing even what one does not understand, and leitzanus as dismissing even what one does understand; this is how Pharaoh could shrug off plague after plague.
- 8:49 Although no joke of Pharaoh's appears in the Chumash, the Mashgiach infers he was a joker from the fact that nothing else could have let him withstand the plagues.
- 21:02 Since Malachi was the last prophet, he spoke not only to his own generation but to all generations until Eliyahu, like someone instructing travelers before a long voyage with no word until they reach the shore of Moshiach.
- 29:54 The Mashgiach reads Malachi's 'then those who fear Hashem spoke to one another' as a description of Jews in ikvesa diMeshicha gathering at a mussar shmuess or a Shabbos table with zemiros to strengthen emunah.
- 36:20 He explains Chorev, where the Torah was given, as dry and desolate land, teaching that even when times are dry one must remember Hashem's Torah.
What the Mashgiach says to take from it
- 1:54 The Mashgiach says that to receive from a rebbe one must humble oneself before him, obey him and have awe and derech eretz for him.
- 7:32 He says one must take a person's feelings into account and not mock a teacher or create an atmosphere of leitzanus in class.
- 15:49 He says davening must be done word by word, counting each word slowly like precious bills or diamonds, not rushed.
- 30:27 He calls on Jews to come together, hear a mussar shmuess, and sit at a Shabbos meal singing zemiros to strengthen emunah in the coming of Moshiach.
Mentioned in this shiur
People Eliyahu HaNavi, Malachi, Pharaoh, Rabbi Tzadok HaKohen of Lublin, Rav Shraga Feivel Mendlowitz, Rav Yaakov Kamenetsky, Rebbe Reb Baruch'l of Mezhibuzh, the Baal Shem Tov, the Chofetz Chaim
Terms אהבה רבה, אמונה, דרך ארץ קדמה לתורה, הכנעה, לויתן, ליצנות, עקבתא דמשיחא, רבונו של עולם