מאברהם אבינו התחיל אומה שמאמין בה'
Catalog entry: אמונה א' no. 4 Pocket Guide p. 39 Yiddish 29 min
Listen
About this shiur
The Mashgiach explains that Avraham and Sarah had to be barren so that with Avraham a new kind of being would begin, one that believes in Hashem by instinct, and that this emunah passes to every Jew as an inheritance through the mother.
The Mashgiach recalls that every Jew inherits his emunah from the Avos, so a denier is not a true heretic but is deceiving himself. He then asks why Avraham and Sarah had to be barren, since nothing in the world is chance; even the word 'mikreh' belongs to the language of impurity. Following the seforim, he explains that barrenness cut Avraham off from the chain of generations: a new creation began with him, a species that believes in Hashem as knowledge in the blood, not only in the mind. This is why Avraham was exempted from honoring his father, and why the world's creation was completed only with Avraham. A kofer, like the pitch on Noach's ark, merely covers over a belief that fills his whole body. Through the three matzos and four cups he shows that intellect comes from the father and feeling from the mother, so emunah, which is feeling, comes from the mother, as the word itself shows, and Jewishness follows the mother. Denial is rationalization, like Eisav blaming his wife.
Topics: Avraham Avinu · Foundations of Emunah
Order of the shiur
-
0:00 Inherited emunah and the barren Avos
The Mashgiach recalls that every Jew inherits emunah from the Avos and a denier only fools himself. He asks why Avraham and Sarah had to be barren, stressing that nothing is chance and that the word 'mikreh' is a language of impurity.
-
5:42 A new species begins with Avraham listed in the guide
Bringing the Yismach Moshe, the Mashgiach explains that barrenness cut Avraham and Sarah off from the continuity of the generations, so that a new creation began with Avraham: a species that believes in Hashem by instinct.
-
9:10 Freed from honoring Terach; creation ends with Avraham listed in the guide
The Mashgiach explains why the Torah records Terach's death before Avraham leaves Charan, through the Midrash that Avraham was exempted from honoring his father, since he was a new species. From the pesukim said in the morning davening he shows that creation was completed with Avraham, whose heart was found faithful.
-
14:13 The kofer only covers over his belief
The Mashgiach explains the word 'kofer' from the pitch that covered Noach's ark and from the kofer hakol of the Gemara, who knows he owes the money: a denier only paints over his belief. Emunah, he says, is not in the brain but in the whole body.
-
17:30 Matzos and cups: emunah comes from the mother
The Mashgiach asks why the Seder has three matzos and four cups, and explains that grain gives intellect and corresponds to the Avos, while wine gives feeling and corresponds to the Imahos. Since emunah is feeling, it comes from the mother, which is why Jewishness follows the mother while shevet follows the father.
-
23:18 Emunah from 'em'; denial as rationalization
From the rule that a noun drops the final nun of its verb (shen, gan), the Mashgiach shows that emunah is tied to 'em', mother. He concludes that every Jew believes, and that denial is rationalization, like Eisav blaming his wife for losing the brachos.
The shiur, written up
Inherited emunah and the barren Avos
The Mashgiach recalls that every Jew has emunah as an inheritance from the Avos. A kofer who denies Hashem is no true heretic: deep inside, in his subconscious, he knows there is a Ribono shel Olam and is only trying to excuse himself.
He then asks why Avraham and Sarah had to be barren, since nothing in the world is chance. Even coffee that is a little too cold, or a straw a breeze carries two feet, is hashgacha pratis. The word 'mikreh', he adds, is a language of impurity, as Rashi says on Vayikra and as in 'mikreh laylah'; it does not belong in a believer's vocabulary. a,b
A new species begins with Avraham
Citing the Yismach Moshe, the Mashgiach explains that the Avos had to be barren to cut off their link with earlier generations, since normally each generation is a continuation of the last. With Avraham a new species began, one that believes in Hashem by instinct, not only with the intellect; the miracle of their child was a new power of birth. c
Freed from honoring Terach
This explains why the Torah records Terach's death before Avraham leaves Charan, although Rashi calculates that Terach was still alive. The Mashgiach brings the Midrash that Hashem exempted Avraham from honoring his father: kibbud av is a son's bond with his father, and Avraham, a new species, was cut off from him. His emunah is knowledge in his blood, and it passes to his children. f,g
The kofer only covers over
Matzos and cups: emunah comes from the mother
The Mashgiach asks why the Seder has three matzos and four cups. Grain gives intellect, as the Gemara says a child cannot say 'father' until he tastes grain, while wine gives feeling and gladdens the heart. The story of the Exodus must be passed on with both mind and heart. l,m
Intellect comes from the father, so the three matzos stand for the Avos; feeling comes from the mother, so the four cups stand for the Imahos. Shevet and inheritance follow the father, but Jewishness follows the mother, since it rests on emunah, which comes from the mother.
Sources
Torah
Kesuvim
Talmud Bavli
Midrash
- g apparently Bereishis Rabbah 39:7 In the write-up: 9:19
Rishonim
Acharonim and Chassidus
Key points
- 0:09 Every Jew inherits emunah from the Avos; one who denies Hashem believes deep inside and is only trying to excuse himself.
- 2:01 Nothing in the world is chance, down to a cup of coffee or a straw moved by the wind; all is hashgacha pratis.
- 6:05 Avraham and Sarah had to be barren to cut them off from the previous generations, so that a new kind of being, one that believes in Hashem by instinct, could begin with them.
- 15:17 Emunah is not a matter of intellect but is part of the Jew's whole body, so a kofer only covers it over.
- 17:30 Intellect comes from the father and feeling from the mother; emunah, being feeling, comes from the mother, which is why a child's Jewishness follows the mother.
- 26:39 Denying Hashem is rationalization, as Eisav blamed his wife for losing the brachos instead of himself.
Questions and answers
-
Question: 1:53 Why did Avraham and Sarah have to be barren, if nothing is chance?
Answer: 5:59 To cut them off from the continuity of the generations, so that a new species that believes in Hashem would begin with them.
-
Question: 10:24 Why was Avraham exempted from honoring his father?
Answer: 10:33 Kibbud av is a son's bond with his father, and Avraham, as a new species, was cut off from his father.
-
Question: 18:22 Why does the Seder have three matzos but four cups?
Answer: 19:23 Matzah, from grain, gives intellect and corresponds to the three Avos; wine gives feeling and corresponds to the four Imahos.
-
Question: 21:27 Why does a child's Jewishness follow the mother when lineage follows the father?
Answer: 22:06 Because Jewishness rests on emunah, which is instinct and feeling and comes from the mother, not from intellect.
Insights
- 6:09 The barrenness of Avraham and Sarah was needed to break the natural continuity from father to son, so that what was born to them would be a new creation rather than an extension of Terach.
- 10:24 Avraham's exemption from honoring his father follows from his being a new species: kibbud av expresses a son's bond with his father, and that bond was cut.
- 14:54 The kofer is named for the pitch, 'kofer', that covered Noach's ark: his denial is only a coating over a belief that remains underneath.
- 19:23 The three matzos correspond to the Avos because grain gives intellect, which comes from the father, and the four cups to the Imahos because wine gives feeling, which comes from the mother.
- 21:27 Although lineage and inheritance follow the father, Jewishness follows the mother because it rests on emunah, which is transmitted through the mother.
- 24:06 Just as the noun drops the final nun of its root (shen, gan), 'emunah' is linked to 'em', mother, showing that emunah comes from the mother.
What the Mashgiach says to take from it
- 14:23 The Mashgiach says that when a kofer claims he does not believe in Hashem, one should tell him he is lying, since deep inside he believes.
Mentioned in this shiur
People Avraham Avinu, Esav, Noach, Rashi, Sarah Imeinu, Terach, Yaakov Avinu, Yishmael, Yitzchak Avinu
Terms אבות הקדושים, אמונה, אפיקורס, השגחה פרטית, כיבוד אב, כפירה, מאמינים בני מאמינים, מקרה, רבונו של עולם