זהירות בקדושה וכשרות המאכלים

Catalog entry: אמונה א' no. ⁨22⁩ Pocket Guide p. 39 Yiddish 29 min

Listen

  1. Download · Length 29 min

Open in the listening app

Notes Notes prepared by AI from the recording; not reviewed, and not the Mashgiach's words. The recording is the source.

About this shiur

The Mashgiach explains that the soul, like the body, loses its healthy appetite for Torah and emunah through forbidden food and through lapses in kedushah, and he teaches how to handle the doubts in emunah that come in their wake.

The Mashgiach compares the soul to a living organism: just as unhealthy food ruins the body's appetite, sins dull the heart, and forbidden food above all weakens a person's emunah. He supports this with a letter of the Rambam and with the Divrei Chaim's explanation of why German Jewry fell, and warns how hard kashrus is today, urging care about whose hechsher one relies on. The second cause of doubts is a lapse in kedushas Yisrael, guarding the eyes and thoughts. He explains that before Moshiach the power of Amalek, whose gematria equals safek, grows, so many sincere bochurim suffer doubts; their pain itself shows they believe. One must not argue with such thoughts, which are leitzanus rather than logic, but push them away; the Bnei Yissaschar says this fulfills the mitzvah of 'velo sasuru'. He closes by tying this to parshas Shelach and the summer travel season as a shlichus.

Topics: Kashrus and Kedushas HaAchilah · Doubts in Emunah and Amalek · Shmiras Einayim

Order of the shiur

  1. 0:00 Forbidden food dulls the soul's appetite listed in the guide

    The Mashgiach compares the soul to the body: unhealthy food ruins a person's appetite for good food, and sins take away the soul's natural desire for Torah and tefillah. He brings the Gemara that sin dulls the heart and says forbidden food above all causes a loss of emunah.

  2. 3:50 The Rambam, German Jewry and kashrus today listed in the guide

    The Mashgiach tells of a letter to the Rambam about techiyas hameisim, whose answer traced the questioners' weak emunah to forbidden food, and of the Divrei Chaim's explanation that German Jewry fell because its shochtim were not God-fearing. He then describes how hard kashrus is today with packaged ingredients, and says one may rely only on a hechsher of a rav known to be both a yerei shamayim and expert.

  3. 10:02 Kedushah, doubts and the power of Amalek listed in the guide

    The Mashgiach names the second cause of doubts: lack of care in kedushas Yisrael, from the passuk in the week's parsha about not straying after one's heart and eyes. He says many sincere bochurim come to him in tears over doubts, explains that before Moshiach Jews will enter the fiftieth gate of impurity, and that doubts come from Amalek, which equals safek in gematria.

  4. 15:02 Doubts before Moshiach are a test, not kefirah

    The Mashgiach compares today's spiritual atmosphere to physical pollution, and says the bochurim's tears over their doubts show they believe. He brings the Ohr Hameir and Reb Yisroel of Ruzhin on how hard emunah will be before Moshiach, and teaches that everyone faces such a period and should push the thought out like a fly that keeps returning.

  5. 20:02 Don't argue with the thoughts: 'velo sasuru'

    The Mashgiach tells of a man whom a tzaddik told to ignore a disturbing image during davening, and recalls his own shock as a bochur when a friend told Reb Shraga Feivel Mendlowitz he had doubts. He explains that such thoughts are leitzanus, not logic, so they must be pushed away rather than answered, and brings the Bnei Yissaschar that pushing them out fulfills the mitzvah of 'velo sasuru', with a remez from its trop.

  6. 25:29 A private geulah and the summer as a shlichus

    The Mashgiach says every Jew should await his own redemption from a period of trials and emerge from it with clearer emunah, strengthening himself in Torah and tefillah and ignoring the doubts. He contrasts the meraglim of the parsha with Yehoshua's successful spies of the haftarah, calls the summer travels a shlichus that can repair the meraglim's forty days, and parts with wishes for a successful summer.

The shiur, written up

Forbidden food dulls the soul's appetite

0:40

The Mashgiach opens with the Rambam's comparison of illnesses of the soul to illnesses of the body. Someone who eats unhealthy food loses his appetite for nourishing food; so too, sins take away the soul's natural desire for Torah, tefillah and Hashem's will. This, he says, is why people who want to learn and daven sometimes find their heart blocked: the Gemara says sin dulls a person's heart, and forbidden food does so most of all, weakening his emunah. a,b

The Rambam, German Jewry and kashrus today

3:50

To support this, the Mashgiach mentions a letter of the Rambam about techiyas hameisim, where the reply traced the questioners' weak emunah to forbidden food. He then relates that the Divrei Chaim explained why German Jewry, once so fine, suddenly fell into assimilation and Reform: their shochtim were not God-fearing, so they ate non-kosher meat. He adds that the Ohr Somayach in Meshech Chochmah foresaw that the trouble would begin in Germany. c

7:08

Today, he says, kashrus is very hard, since everything comes in packages built from dozens of other packages. One should rely only on a rav known to be both a yerei shamayim and expert in the field; one would not lend money to someone untrustworthy, so how can one trust his hechsher? He names Rav Belsky in the yeshiva as someone to ask.

Kedushah, doubts and the power of Amalek

10:02

The second cause of doubts, the Mashgiach says, is carelessness in kedushas Yisrael, about which the parsha warns not to stray after one's heart and eyes. Many sincere bochurim come to him in tears over doubts. He explains, citing the Ohr HaChaim, that in Mitzrayim Jews reached the forty-ninth gate of impurity, while before the final geulah they will enter the fiftieth, the gate of heresy, yet will hold on through the Torah. d,g

14:17

These doubts are the shell of Amalek: the Torah places 'Is Hashem among us' right before 'Amalek came', and the seforim say Amalek equals safek in gematria. h

Doubts before Moshiach are a test, not kefirah

15:06

Just as the physical world today has a polluted atmosphere never seen before, the Mashgiach says, there is a spiritual pollution, the strengthening of Amalek before Moshiach. The bochurim's crying over their doubts proves they believe; a real non-believer would welcome doubts as freedom.

17:19

He brings the Ohr Hameir, who told his students before his passing that before Moshiach even the finest Jews will have thoughts of kefirah, and Reb Yisroel of Ruzhin, who compared simple emunah then to climbing a smooth wall. Everyone must face such a test at some time; one should be prepared, not be frightened, and push the thought away like a fly that keeps returning.

Don't argue with the thoughts: 'velo sasuru'

20:05

The Mashgiach tells of a man who could not daven because he imagined a gentile with a cross before him; the tzaddik told him to let the gentile do his business while he davens. He recalls being shocked as a bochur when a friend told Reb Shraga Feivel Mendlowitz he had doubts, and only later understood that everyone has such periods.

21:31

One must not argue with these thoughts, since they are leitzanus, not logic. The Bnei Yissaschar says that pushing them out fulfills 'velo sasuru', which means exploring, as the meraglim scouted the land; welcoming a thought is the sin. The best way is to fill the mind with Torah. i,j

A private geulah and the summer as a shlichus

25:29

As Klal Yisrael awaits the geulah, the Mashgiach says, each Jew in a time of trial awaits his own, since Hashem does not cast off forever; one who conducts himself well emerges with clearer emunah. He should daven, strengthen himself in Torah and tefillah, and ignore the doubts. l

26:58

Contrasting the meraglim of the parsha with the successful spies of the haftarah, he calls summer travel a shlichus that repairs the meraglim's forty days, and blesses the bochurim with a successful summer. m

Sources

Torah

  1. d Bamidbar 15:39 text index In the write-up: 10:02
  2. f Shemos 13:18 12:31 text index
  3. h Shemos 17:7-8 text index In the write-up: 14:17
  4. j apparently Bamidbar 13 index In the write-up: 21:31
  5. k apparently Shemos 20:2-3 24:57 index

Nevi'im

  1. m apparently Yehoshua 2 index In the write-up: 26:58

Kesuvim

  1. l Eichah 3:31 text index In the write-up: 25:29

Talmud Bavli

  1. b Yoma 39a text index In the write-up: 0:40
  2. e apparently Sotah 49b 12:04 index

Rishonim

  1. a apparently Rambam, Hilchos De'os 2:1 index In the write-up: 0:40

Acharonim and Chassidus

  1. c Meshech Chochmah (place not identified) index In the write-up: 3:50
  2. g apparently Ohr HaChaim, parshas Shemos index In the write-up: 10:02
  3. i Bnei Yissaschar (place not identified) index In the write-up: 21:31

Key points

  1. 0:37 The soul is a spiritual organism: just as bad food ruins the body's appetite, sin dulls the heart and takes away the soul's natural desire for Torah, tefillah and Hashem's will.
  2. 2:53 Of all sins, eating forbidden food in particular causes a person to lose his emunah.
  3. 7:08 Kashrus today is very difficult, so one must know that the rav giving a hechsher is both a yerei shamayim and competent in the field.
  4. 10:02 The second cause of doubts in emunah is a lapse in kedushas Yisrael, guarding one's eyes and thoughts.
  5. 14:12 Doubts in emunah before Moshiach come from the strengthening of Amalek, and a person who suffers from them is not a non-believer; his very pain shows that he believes.
  6. 19:30 One must not argue with doubting thoughts or answer them with logic; one pushes them away and ignores them, and they will pass.

Questions and answers

  1. Question: 2:20 Why do some people who want to learn and daven find their heart closed and their mind dull?

    Answer: 2:40 Because their soul has been dulled by sin, and most of all by forbidden food.

  2. Question: 5:50 Why did German Jewry fall so suddenly from such a high level?

    Answer: 6:07 According to the Divrei Chaim, because their shochtim were not God-fearing and they ate non-kosher meat.

  3. Question: 14:12 Does a person who has doubts in emunah thereby not believe?

    Answer: 14:15 No; the doubts come from Amalek, and his suffering over them shows that he does believe.

  4. Question: 21:28 Should one answer doubting thoughts with logical arguments?

    Answer: 21:47 No; the seforim say it is dangerous to argue with them, since they are leitzanus and not logic, so one simply drives them away.

  5. Question: 22:21 Is it a sin to have a bad thought of doubt enter one's mind?

    Answer: 22:27 According to the Bnei Yissaschar, if he drives it out he has no sin; on the contrary, he fulfills the mitzvah of 'velo sasuru'.

Stories

  1. 4:47 The Divrei Chaim on the fall of German Jewry

    The Mashgiach relates that the Divrei Chaim asked why German Jewry, once so fine and full of great and holy sages, suddenly fell so low, giving rise to assimilation and the Reform movement. He answered that they were not careful about their shochtim, who were not God-fearing, so they ate non-kosher meat, and that is what brought it about.

    In the story: the Divrei Chaim (Rabbi Chaim of Sanz)

  2. 20:05 The man who saw a figure while davening

    A man came to a tzaddik, whom the Mashgiach calls Reb Mendel, saying he could not daven because whenever he stood to pray he imagined a gentile with a cross in his hand standing before him. The tzaddik told him to let the gentile stand there and do his business while he does his own and davens.

    In the story: the Vilna Gaon

  3. 20:37 A friend's doubts and Reb Shraga Feivel

    The Mashgiach recalls that when he was a bochur, one of his friends told their rebbe, Reb Shraga Feivel Mendlowitz, that he had doubts in emunah. Hearing this bothered the Mashgiach greatly, since he thought such a Jew must be a heretic. Only later did he understand that it is not so, and that every person has such periods in his life.

    In the story: Rav Shraga Feivel Mendlowitz

Insights

  1. 1:34 Loss of desire for Torah and tefillah is like loss of appetite: the soul's natural hunger for good spiritual food is spoiled by what it has taken in.
  2. 15:58 The pain and tears of a bochur over his doubts are themselves proof that he believes; a real non-believer would be glad of them, since they would free him to do as he pleases.
  3. 14:20 Doubts in emunah are Amalek, equal to safek in gematria; just as the Torah juxtaposes 'Is Hashem among us' with 'Amalek came', the doubts will vanish when Amalek is erased.
  4. 21:47 Thoughts of heresy cannot be defeated with logic because they are not logical; they are leitzanus, the shell of Amalek the scoffer, and leitzanus does not respond to reasoning.
  5. 22:39 'Velo sasuru' means not to go exploring, like the meraglim who scouted the land: welcoming a thought and discussing it is the sin, while pushing it out is the mitzvah, hinted at by the gerish note on those words.
  6. 25:29 Just as Klal Yisrael awaits the geulah, each Jew in a period of trial awaits his private geulah, and one who conducts himself properly emerges with clearer emunah than before.

What the Mashgiach says to take from it

  1. 6:22 The Mashgiach says one must be very careful about what one eats, and rely only on a hechsher of a rav known to be a yerei shamayim and expert in kashrus.
  2. 19:28 When a thought of doubt comes, the Mashgiach says to push it out of the mind, not to argue with it, and to ignore it.
  3. 25:10 The Mashgiach says the best way to drive out such thoughts is to replace them with thoughts of Torah.
  4. 26:07 In a period of trial, the Mashgiach says one should daven to Hashem, know that it will pass, hold fast to emunah and strengthen oneself in Torah and tefillah.
  5. 28:44 The Mashgiach tells the bochurim to regard their summer travels not as a vacation but as a shlichus from Hashem.

Mentioned in this shiur

People Kalev ben Yefuneh, Pinchas, Rabbi Yisrael of Ruzhin (the Ruzhiner), Rav Belsky, Rav Shraga Feivel Mendlowitz, the Baal Shem Tov, the Bnei Yissaschar (Rabbi Tzvi Elimelech of Dinov), the Divrei Chaim (Rabbi Chaim of Sanz), the Meshech Chochmah (Rabbi Meir Simcha of Dvinsk), the Ohr HaChaim HaKadosh, the Ohr HaMeir (Rabbi Ze'ev Wolf of Zhitomir), the Rambam, Yehoshua bin Nun

Terms השכלה, ולא תתורו, טמטום הלב, ליצנות, מאכלות אסורות, מרגלים, ספק, עמלק, קדושת ישראל, שער החמישים

Report an error on this page