עריכות הפליאות יחד שייך דוקה ע”י הקב”ה
Catalog entry: אמונה ב' no. 4 Pocket Guide p. 40 Yiddish 40 min
Listen
About this shiur
The Mashgiach shows that the Torah foretold Jewish history, the return of baalei teshuvah, exile, a small and hated nation that survives, and that these wonders contradict one another so that only Hashem could have put them together.
The Mashgiach continues his series on the wonders of Jewish history. Jews always kept the Torah; the idol worship found in Tanach was a powerful yetzer hara, like today's trials, not a departure from the Torah. That departure began about two hundred years ago with the Haskalah in Germany, whose destruction the Meshech Chochmah foresaw. Now, unexpectedly, a movement of baalei teshuvah has begun, a drizzle before the storm of teshuvah that will come with Moshiach, as the Torah and the prophets foretold, together with the flowering of Eretz Yisrael. He then reviews the prophecies of exile, of the Jews remaining few, and of the hatred of the nations. His central point is that these wonders contradict each other: a scattered, tiny, hated people should not survive, yet the Torah says it is eternal and a light to the nations. No human mind could foresee such a combination; only the Creator, who leads history, could.
Topics: Foundations of Emunah · Netzach Yisroel · Torah Min HaShamayim and the Mesorah · Yisroel and the Nations
Order of the shiur
-
0:00 Jews kept the Torah until the Haskalah
Returning to the wonders of Jewish history, the Mashgiach explains that the idol worship in Tanach was a strong yetzer hara, abolished by the Anshei Knesses HaGedolah, comparable to today's trials of immorality and the internet, and not a departure from the Torah. That departure began only about two hundred years ago in Germany with the Haskalah and the Reform and Conservative movements.
-
4:14 From Haskalah to the baal teshuvah movement
The Mashgiach cites the Meshech Chochmah, who wrote that the Haskalah began in Germany and that destruction would begin there too, then mentions Zionism and communism. Then, some twenty or thirty years ago, a new phenomenon of baalei teshuvah began, which R' Shlomke of Zvhil foresaw; the Mashgiach notes the Lubavitcher Rebbe's strengthening of it and the fire of baalei teshuvah today.
-
7:50 Signs before Moshiach foretold in the Torah
The Mashgiach compares today's teshuvah to the drizzle that precedes a storm, and ties it to the signs of Moshiach: the fruits of Eretz Yisrael that now go out to the whole world, the prophet Amos's hunger to hear the word of Hashem, and the Torah's promise in Nitzavim that Jews will return. He concludes that such foreknowledge shows the truth of the Torah.
-
13:19 The prophecy of exile and a remnant
The Mashgiach brings Moshe Rabbeinu's prophecy, as the Jews are about to enter Eretz Yisrael, that they will sin and be exiled, noting that the Greek translation of the Torah shows it was written long before. He cites the pesukim in Bechukosai and Va'eschanan that they will be scattered and remain few, yet will survive because Hashem leads them there, unlike the vanished great empires.
-
17:49 The wonder of the nations' hatred
The Mashgiach describes the hatred of the nations toward Jews, seen most starkly in the cruelty of the Germans under Hitler, and shows that the Torah foretold in Ki Savo that Israel would be an object of scorn among the nations. He repeats that the Torah also promised the Jews would remain few in number.
-
20:56 The wonders contradict each other listed in the guide
Having gone through the wonders, the Mashgiach states the main point: they contradict one another, so reason could never connect them, and only the Ribono shel Olam could write them through Moshe and the prophets. Jewish history is unique, with no precedent a historian could extrapolate from; he frames this as one fact, A, contradicting another, B.
-
24:03 Eternal, scattered and hated: how can it be? listed in the guide
The Mashgiach applies the contradiction: no nation suffered such slaughter, and whole communities chose death over conversion, yet the Torah says the scattered few are an eternal people. He explains the hatred, citing Rashi's 'Esav hates Yaakov' and Haman's complaint that their laws differ, as the dislike of the unlike, and shows from the German Jews and Hitler that assimilation only increased it.
-
32:33 A light to the nations, and only the Creator foretold it listed in the guide
The Mashgiach sums up the contradictions and adds another: the small, hated, landless people is a light to the nations, prominent far beyond its numbers. He recalls the fruitfulness of Eretz Yisrael and tells how Ben Gurion agreed to fund yeshivos expecting them to fade, while they grew stronger. He concludes that only the Ribono shel Olam, who created and leads all, could foretell this history.
The shiur, written up
Jews kept the Torah until the Haskalah
The Mashgiach returns to the wonders of Jewish history, now the phenomenon of the baal teshuvah. For nearly four thousand years Jews kept the Torah. The idol worship in Tanach was a powerful yetzer hara, which the Anshei Knesses HaGedolah abolished, as the Gemara relates; it resembles today's trials of the internet and texting, faced even by Jews who keep Shabbos and kashrus. Leaving the Torah began only some two hundred years ago in Germany, with the Haskalah and the Reform and Conservative movements. a
From Haskalah to the baal teshuvah movement
The Meshech Chochmah already wrote that the Haskalah had begun in Germany and that destruction would begin there too, though nobody then could imagine it of so cultured a land. Zionism and communism followed. Then, twenty or thirty years ago, baalei teshuvah appeared. R' Shlomke of Zvhil told a R' Eliyahu that an awakening of teshuvah had begun, and R' Eliyahu could not grasp it. Today, strengthened greatly by the Lubavitcher Rebbe, they number in the tens of thousands, often with more fire than those born frum. b
Signs before Moshiach foretold in the Torah
The Gemara in Taanis says a heavy rain is preceded by a drizzle; today's teshuvah is that drizzle, and when Moshiach comes there will be a storm of teshuvah. The Gemara counts the fruit of Eretz Yisrael as the greatest sign, and today its produce goes out to the whole world. c,d
The prophet Amos foretold a hunger not for bread but to hear the word of Hashem, and the Mashgiach sees it in those who come to learn because the world feels empty and meaningless. The Torah in Nitzavim promised that Jews would return to Hashem from among the nations. Such foreknowledge, he says, shows the truth of the Torah. e,f
The prophecy of exile and a remnant
Another wonder is the exile. As Moshe Rabbeinu brings the Jews into Eretz Yisrael he tells them they will sin and be exiled, and the Greek translation of the Torah shows this was written long before it came true. Bechukosai says they will be scattered and the land left desolate; in Va'eschanan Moshe warns they will be dispersed and remain few among the nations, yet Hashem will lead them there. Mighty Rome, Greece and Bavel vanished, while the small Jewish people remains. g,h,i,j
The wonder of the nations' hatred
Next is the hatred of the nations, which the Mashgiach describes at its starkest in the Germans' cruelty under Hitler. The Torah in Ki Savo foretold that Israel would be an object of scorn among the nations, and their novels indeed tell of the cursed Jew. There, too, the Torah says the Jews will remain few. k,l
The wonders contradict each other
Having reviewed the wonders, the Mashgiach states his point: they contradict one another and reason, so no one could have joined them together. Only the Ribono shel Olam could have written through Moshe and the prophets what would befall the Jewish people. Jewish history is unique, without precedent from which a historian might predict; it is as if fact A contradicts fact B.
Eternal, scattered and hated
He begins with eternity. The Torah foretold slaughter among the nations, and no people has endured as much. Before Hitler, persecutors offered conversion, yet whole communities let themselves be killed, unlike individual Arab suicide bombers. A nation scattered to the ends of the earth and few in number should not survive, yet the Torah calls it eternal; others assimilated, while the Jews kept their Torah and their own language.
On the hatred he brings Rashi in Vayishlach, that it is a known rule that Esav hates Yaakov, and Haman's complaint that the Jews' laws differ. He explains it as dislike of the unlike: the greater the difference, the greater the hatred, and none is greater than between Israel and the nations. The German Jews thought assimilation would end it, but it grew; Hitler counted as Jews even those whose families converted three generations earlier. m,n
A light to the nations
The Mashgiach sums up: the Torah says the Jews will be few, different and hated, yet eternal, which reason cannot grasp, while Bavel, Persia, Greece and Rome left no trace. More than that, the prophets call this small, landless people a light to the nations. The nations took their belief in one G-d from the Jews, who stand out among ministers, in Congress, in medicine and in law far beyond their one percent. o
He recalls that Eretz Yisrael bears fruit when Jews return. Ben Gurion agreed to state support for yeshivos, expecting Jews in a Jewish state to drop the Torah; instead the yeshivos grew stronger. Only the Ribono shel Olam, Creator and guide of all creations, could have foretold this history. p
Sources
Torah
- f Devarim 30:1-4 text index In the write-up: 10:28
- g Devarim 31:29 text index In the write-up: 13:38
- i Vayikra 26:33 text index In the write-up: 13:38
- j Devarim 4:26-27 text index In the write-up: 13:38
- k Devarim 28:37 text index In the write-up: 18:08
- l Devarim 28:62 text index In the write-up: 18:08
Nevi'im
Kesuvim
Talmud Bavli
Rishonim
Acharonim and Chassidus
Tefillah and Piyut
Other
Key points
- 1:11 The idol worship recorded in Tanach was a strong yetzer hara that people stumbled in, not an abandonment of the Torah, which began only with the Haskalah about two hundred years ago.
- 6:07 The rise of baalei teshuvah, unforeseen even a generation ago, fulfills the Torah's and the prophets' words that before Moshiach Jews will return and hunger to hear the word of Hashem.
- 14:25 The Torah foretold the exile, that the Jews would remain few among the nations, and that they would be an object of scorn among them.
- 21:10 These prophecies contradict one another and reason, so no historian could have predicted them together; only Hashem could foretell them.
- 32:36 A people scattered, tiny and hated should have disappeared like mighty Bavel, Persia, Greece and Rome, yet the Jews remain a people and even a light to the nations.
Questions and answers
-
Question: 1:04 Does the idol worship recorded in Tanach mean the Jews abandoned the Torah?
Answer: 3:25 No: it was a powerful yetzer hara in which many stumbled, but the Jews always kept the Torah until the Haskalah.
-
Question: 16:10 Why did the Jews, exiled for thousands of years, not assimilate and disappear like other nations?
Answer: 17:26 Because, as the pasuk says, Hashem leads them there; He guides them and watches over them to this day.
-
Question: 26:27 How can a people scattered to the ends of the earth, few in number and hated, continue to exist?
Answer: 27:28 By reason it cannot; the Torah nevertheless says they are an eternal people, and that contradiction is itself the wonder only Hashem could foretell.
-
Question: 29:26 Why do the nations hate the Jews so intensely?
Answer: 29:33 Because people naturally dislike whoever is unlike them, and the Jews, holding fast to their Torah and refusing the nations' faith, are as different as can be.
-
Question: 37:54 Why did Ben Gurion agree to have the government support the yeshivos?
Answer: 38:02 He expected that in a Jewish state Jews would eventually abandon the Torah and the yeshivos would wither; instead the yeshivos grew stronger and more separate.
Stories
-
6:18 R' Shlomke of Zvhil foresees the teshuvah awakening
The Mashgiach recounts what a R' Eliyahu, whom he says he knew well, told him. R' Shlomke of Zvhil once told R' Eliyahu that an awakening of teshuvah was now beginning. R' Eliyahu did not understand what the Rebbe meant, since at the time nobody imagined Jews returning; only later did the baal teshuvah movement appear.
In the story: Reb Shlomke of Zvhil
Insights
- 2:39 The idolatry in Tanach is no more a rejection of the Torah than the trials of the internet are for observant Jews today: both are a powerful yetzer hara in which people stumble while still keeping the Torah.
- 7:52 The present wave of baalei teshuvah is the drizzle that, as the Gemara describes, signals the coming downpour: the storm of teshuvah when Moshiach comes.
- 21:10 The proof lies not in any single prophecy but in their combination: each wonder contradicts the others and reason, like fact A contradicting fact B, so no historian could have extrapolated them.
- 30:14 Hatred of the Jews follows the natural dislike of the unlike: the greater the difference, the greater the hatred, and the separation between Israel and the nations is the greatest of all.
- 31:18 The German Jews' mistake was to think assimilation would end the hatred; instead it grew, and Hitler counted as Jews even those whose families had converted three generations earlier.
- 24:51 Unlike individual suicide bombers, whole Jewish communities chose death rather than conversion, a mesiras nefesh no other nation has shown.
Mentioned in this shiur
People David Ben-Gurion, Haman, Hitler, Mark Twain, Moshe Rabbeinu, Rashi, Reb Shlomke of Zvhil, the Lubavitcher Rebbe, the Meshech Chochmah (Rabbi Meir Simcha of Dvinsk)
Terms אנשי כנסת הגדולה, בעלי תשובה, השכלה, יצר הרע, נצח, עריות, רבונו של עולם