Techilah L'Mikraeh Kodesh
Catalog entry: Kedushas HaShabbos no. 1 Yiddish 38 min
Not in the 2012 Pocket Guide; the title is taken from the file name.
Listen
About this shiur
The Mashgiach explains why the first luchos give the creation of the world as the reason for Shabbos while the second luchos give the Exodus: at Matan Torah every Jew was a prophet who saw the Creator in the world, and after the sin of the golden calf they needed the miracles of Egypt that they had seen with their own eyes.
The Mashgiach opens a series on avodas Hashem by beginning with Shabbos, 'the first of the holy days', which Klal Yisroel was commanded at Marah even before Matan Torah. He contrasts the two versions of the Ten Commandments: in the first luchos Shabbos is 'zachor' and its reason is that Hashem made the world in six days; in the second luchos it is 'shamor' and the reason is the Exodus from Egypt, and Kiddush mentions both. He then describes at length the wonders and beauty of creation, from the seasons and fruits to the human body, and argues that heretics deny the Creator only because they do not want to be bound to Him, illustrating this with two stories and the Chovos HaLevavos's parable of the painting. The Exodus, witnessed by millions and handed down through the generations, could not be denied, and at Matan Torah every Jew became a prophet. That is the answer: prophets see the Creator in the world itself, but after the golden calf they lost that level, so the second luchos point to the Exodus, whose ten plagues mirror the ten utterances of creation in reverse.
Topics: Kedushas Shabbos · Creation and Its Wonders · Matan Torah at Har Sinai · The Golden Calf and the Thirteen Middos · Foundations of Emunah
Order of the shiur
-
0:00 Beginning with Shabbos, commanded at Marah listed in the guide
The Mashgiach opens a series of talks on avodas Hashem and begins with Shabbos, 'the first of the holy days'. He notes that he mostly repeats what is written in the holy sefarim, and that Shabbos was commanded at Marah, before Matan Torah, because it could not wait the forty-nine days.
-
3:30 Two luchos, two reasons for Shabbos
The Mashgiach reads the Shabbos commandment of the first luchos, 'zachor', whose reason is the six days of creation, and of the second luchos given after the sin, 'shamor', whose reason is the Exodus from Egypt. He notes that Kiddush on Friday night says both.
-
7:25 The wonders of creation and why heretics deny them
The Mashgiach describes the beauty of the world through the seasons, the fruits with their different colors and tastes, the human body and even a tiny fly, all showing the Creator. He says heretics refuse to admit it because they would have to obey, and tells of a woman who asked a newspaper to stop writing about the miracles of a war in Eretz Yisroel because they kept her from going to the beach on Shabbos.
-
16:24 The falling ceiling in Telz Story
The Mashgiach tells of a club of irreligious young men in Telz where one of them took his own life, after which the plaster of the ceiling below kept falling. Rav Bloch, the Rosh Yeshivah, answered from Shulchan Aruch that blood of the dead must be buried; once the soaked floorboards were buried the ceiling held, and one of the young men stopped coming to the club because he now saw there is a Ribono shel Olam.
-
24:00 The parable of the painting
The Mashgiach brings the Chovos HaLevavos's parable of a beautiful painting that someone claims came about when a wind spilled bottles of paint onto paper, and adds a house that built itself. Nobody would believe that, yet the heretic believes the far more wondrous world made itself, because he does not want to admit the truth he knows.
-
28:54 The Exodus and Matan Torah, seen by millions
The Mashgiach says there was one time when the truth had to be admitted: the Exodus, with the ten plagues that correspond to the ten utterances of creation and the splitting of the sea, seen by millions and handed down as history. At Matan Torah every Jew became a prophet and heard Hashem speak, and no other nation has such a tradition.
-
33:10 Why the reason changed after the golden calf
The Mashgiach answers his opening question: as prophets, like the Ba'al HaTanya who saw the Creator when he looked at the ceiling, the Jews at Matan Torah saw the Creator in the world, so the first luchos give creation as the reason for Shabbos. After the golden calf they lost that sight, so the second luchos point to the Exodus they had witnessed, whose ten plagues repeat the ten utterances of creation in reverse order.
The shiur, written up
Beginning with Shabbos, commanded at Marah
The Mashgiach opens a series of talks on avodas Hashem, on Torah, tefillah, middos and the festivals, and begins with Shabbos, 'the first of the holy days', as Kiddush calls it. He notes that he mostly repeats what is written in the holy sefarim. Shabbos, he explains, could not wait the forty-nine days until Matan Torah, so the Jews were already commanded about it at Marah, soon after leaving Egypt. a
Two luchos, two reasons for Shabbos
At Matan Torah Shabbos was repeated in the Ten Commandments of the first luchos as 'zachor', remember the day, because Hashem made heaven and earth in six days and rested on the seventh. After the sin, when Moshe Rabbeinu broke the luchos, the second luchos say 'shamor', which the Mashgiach explains with the Gemara as the negative commandment beside zachor's positive one. b,d
The wonders of creation and why heretics deny them
The Mashgiach dwells on the beauty of Hashem's world. In winter the trees stand bare and white; in autumn the leaves turn red, yellow and purple; in Nissan the trees blossom and one says the blessing that Hashem created good trees for people to enjoy. Every fruit has its own color, taste and charm, though Hashem could have made food plain; He feeds the world with grace and kindness, as Birkas HaMazon says. e,f
With the verse in Iyov he turns to the wonders of the human body, the heart, lungs and brain, and even a tiny fly. Heretics refuse to admit this, he says, because then they would have to obey Hashem. He tells of a woman who asked a newspaper to stop writing about the miracles of a war in Eretz Yisroel, since they kept her from the beach on Shabbos: this is how the yetzer hara works. g
The falling ceiling in Telz
In Telz, the Mashgiach relates, young men who had left their parents' ways opened a club with a dormitory, where they ate forbidden food and smoked on Shabbos. One of them, broken by an unfulfilled desire, cut his wrists and bled to death in his room. Afterwards the plaster of the ceiling below kept falling, however often it was repaired.
One young man who still had some feeling for what he had seen at home asked Rav Bloch, the Rosh Yeshivah, who answered that he was no mekubal but knew from Shulchan Aruch that the blood of the dead must be buried. They buried the soaked floorboards and the ceiling held, and that young man left the club: he had seen there is a Ribono shel Olam and could no longer follow his desires. h
The parable of the painting
Even the wicked know there is a Creator, the Mashgiach says, and he brings the Chovos HaLevavos's parable: someone claims a beautiful painting of fields, trees and a stream came about when a wind knocked over bottles of paint onto fine paper. Nobody would believe it, nor that a heretic's own house built itself, yet he believes the far more wondrous world did. Deep down he knows the truth; he denies it because admitting it would mean obeying Hashem. i
The Exodus and Matan Torah, seen by millions
Once, the Mashgiach says, the truth had to be admitted: at the Exodus. The ten plagues correspond to the ten utterances of creation, and the sea split before millions of people, so it entered history and was handed down from generation to generation. At Matan Torah every Jew became a prophet, hearing Hashem speak face to face amid the sound of the shofar, and no other nation has such a tradition. j,k
Why the reason changed after the golden calf
This answers the opening question. As prophets the Jews saw the Creator in the world itself, as the Ba'al HaTanya said that looking at the ceiling he saw only Hashem who made it; looking at the sky or a tree, they saw the words of creation fulfilled. So the first luchos tell them to keep Shabbos because Hashem created the world. m
Sources
Torah
- b Shemos 20:8-11 text index In the write-up: 3:40
- c Devarim 5:12-15 text index In the write-up: 6:12
- j apparently Shemos 20:15 index In the write-up: 29:06
- k apparently Devarim 5:4 index In the write-up: 29:06
- l apparently Devarim 4:32-33 32:37 index
- m apparently Bereishis 1:6, 1:11 index In the write-up: 33:13
- n apparently Shemos 10:23 index In the write-up: 34:49
Kesuvim
Talmud Bavli
Rishonim
Acharonim and Chassidus
Tefillah and Piyut
Key points
- 2:14 Shabbos could not wait until Matan Torah: Klal Yisroel was already commanded about it at Marah, soon after leaving Egypt.
- 4:18 The first luchos give creation as the reason for Shabbos, the second luchos give the Exodus, and Kiddush mentions both.
- 11:00 The whole world, its seasons, fruits and creatures and the human body, is full of wonders that show a Creator.
- 14:02 Heretics know the truth deep down; they deny it only because admitting it would oblige them to obey Hashem.
- 30:07 The miracles of the Exodus, seen by millions and passed down from generation to generation, cannot be denied, and at Matan Torah every Jew became a prophet.
- 34:37 As prophets they saw the Creator in the world, so the first luchos speak of creation; after the golden calf they lost that level, so the second luchos speak of the Exodus they had witnessed.
Questions and answers
-
Question: 6:12 Why do the first luchos give creation as the reason for Shabbos, while the second luchos give the Exodus?
Answer: 34:37 At Matan Torah every Jew was a prophet who saw the Creator in the world; after the golden calf they lost that level and could only be pointed to the miracles of the Exodus they had seen.
-
Question: 20:37 Why did the ceiling plaster keep falling after the young man took his life?
Answer: 21:22 Rav Bloch answered from Shulchan Aruch that the blood of the dead must be buried, and the blood had soaked into the floor.
-
Question: 13:57 If the world plainly shows a Creator, why do heretics deny it?
Answer: 14:08 Because admitting it would oblige them to obey Hashem, and they prefer to follow their desires.
Stories
-
14:45 The woman who wanted to go to the beach
During a great war in Eretz Yisroel, when the surrounding Arab countries fought against a small number of Jews and the Jews won with Hashem's help, even irreligious newspapers wrote about the miracles. A woman wrote a letter to one paper asking them to stop writing about the miracles. Every Shabbos she went to spend her time at the beach, and reading about the miracles she saw that there is a Ribono shel Olam and could no longer go. The Mashgiach uses this to show how the yetzer hara works.
-
16:46 Rav Bloch and the falling plaster
In Telz a group of young men who had left their parents' ways opened a club with a dormitory, where they ate forbidden food and smoked on Shabbos. One of them, broken over a desire he could not fulfill, cut his wrists in his room and bled until he died. Afterwards the plaster of the ceiling below that room kept falling, no matter how often a craftsman repaired it. One young man who still had some connection to what he had seen at home went to ask Rav Bloch, the Rosh Yeshivah and rav of the town, who answered that he was no mekubal but knew from Shulchan Aruch that blood of the dead must be buried. They tore out the blood-soaked floorboards and buried them, and the ceiling no longer fell; that young man stopped coming to the club, saying he now saw there is a Ribono shel Olam and could no longer follow his desires.
In the story: Rabbi Yosef Leib Bloch (Telzer Rosh Yeshiva)
Insights
- 2:45 Shabbos could not wait the forty-nine days of the long Exodus until Matan Torah, so it was already given at Marah.
- 35:10 The different reasons for Shabbos in the two luchos match the people's level: prophets see the Creator in nature itself, while after the golden calf they needed the remembered miracles of Egypt.
- 37:03 The ten plagues repeat the ten utterances of creation in reverse: the first utterance corresponds to the last plague, the firstborn, and 'let there be light' to the ninth plague, darkness.
- 27:23 Denial of the Creator is not an intellectual position but a refusal: the heretic does not believe his own house built itself, yet claims the world did, because admitting the truth would bind him.
- 30:07 An event seen by millions cannot be invented, so the Exodus entered history and was handed down from generation to generation, a tradition no other nation has.
Mentioned in this shiur
People Moshe Rabbeinu, Rabbi Yosef Leib Bloch (Telzer Rosh Yeshiva), the Baal HaTanya (Rabbi Shneur Zalman of Liadi)
Terms אפיקורס, חטא העגל, יצר הרע, מעשה בראשית, נבואה, נפלאות, עשר מכות, עשרה מאמרות, קריעת ים סוף, רבונו של עולם, שבירת הלוחות