“ולאדם לא מצא עזר כנגדו” - זה קוב"ה וכנסת ישראל
Catalog entry: פרשת השבוע בראשית no. 1 Pocket Guide p. 3 תשל"ו (1975–76) Yiddish 1 hr 17 min
Listen
About this shiur
Starting from the Mishnah's sign of rain in the sukkah, the Mashgiach explains that the yearly path from Rosh Hashanah to Shemini Atzeres repeats the creation of Chava, the bond of Hashem and Knesses Yisrael, and that a broken Sukkos can be rebuilt from Bereishis.
The Mashgiach opens with the Mishnah in Sukkah that rain driving one out of the sukkah is like a servant whose master throws the cup back in his face, and asks why the Rambam limits this sign to the start of the festival. He explains that only the first night carries an obligation, and that the mitzvah of sukkah is dwelling: like a home address, it stays even when rain sends a person out, while the kezayis on the first night is what fixes the sukkah as his home for all seven days. He then turns to the parsha: the creation of Chava for Adam repeats every year between Hashem and Knesses Yisrael, from Rosh Hashanah through Yom Kippur and Sukkos to the union of Shemini Atzeres. He contrasts erusin and nisuin, explains rain on Sukkos as the Satan's share at a time of great holiness, and closes that broken luchos lead back to Bereishis, where one can begin again.
Topics: Adam HaRishon and Gan Eden · Sukkos · Hashem's Love for Klal Yisroel · Shemini Atzeres and Simchas Torah
Order of the shiur
-
0:00 Rain in the sukkah: the Rambam's limit
The Mashgiach learns the Mishnah in Sukkah about leaving the sukkah in rain and its parable of the servant whose cup is thrown back at him. He brings the Rambam's commentary that the bad sign applies only at the start of the festival, and explains that only the first night is an obligation, so rain then cancels a mitzvah one had no choice about.
-
8:50 The sukkah as one's address
The Mashgiach asks why one who suffers is exempt from the sukkah, and why one must eat a kezayis there on the first night like matzah. He explains that the mitzvah is to dwell in the sukkah: like a person whose address stays on his street even when he is elsewhere, one who leaves for rain still lives in his sukkah.
-
15:14 The first night fixes the dwelling
The Mashgiach explains that the first-night kezayis is what establishes the sukkah as one's home for seven days, comparing it to the meal that fixes a person's place for an eruv, though sukkah needs a stronger fixing. If it rains that night the dwelling was never established, which is why the Mishnah stresses 'all seven days' and why the sign applies then.
-
22:00 Chava's creation, renewed every Tishrei listed in the guide
Turning to the parsha, the Mashgiach brings that the process from 'for Adam no helpmate was found' until Chava is brought to Adam happens every year with every Jew: Knesses Yisrael is the woman and Hashem the man. He traces it through Rosh Hashanah and the shofar, the separation of Yom Kippur, the sukkah as a chuppah and Shemini Atzeres as the climax, and returns to the Mishnah's servant: on Rosh Hashanah the Jews stood as servants.
-
27:55 Erusin and nisuin listed in the guide
The Mashgiach notes that Adam slept and was passive while Chava was built. He then asks why an arusah who sins is punished with stoning while a nesuah, more closely bound to her husband, receives the lighter death of strangling, and answers with the Ramban that what comes from love is lighter in punishment, as Yom Kippur is lighter than Shabbos; nisuin raises the wife to become one with her husband.
-
36:06 Souls already joined; lost item and find
The Mashgiach explains that a match is not made from outside: the souls of a man and his wife were bound together from the start, and Adam's rib showed this once for all later generations. He distinguishes, regarding shidduchim, between seeking a lost item and seeking a find, contrasting one who demands qualifications with one who accepts what is given.
-
41:01 Adam and Chava began with nisuin listed in the guide
The Mashgiach says Bereishis contains everything, and that the parsha ends with the 'sons of the powerful' taking wives, a decline that led to the world's destruction. He explains that the letter heh marks the completeness of a woman, attained at nisuin, and that Adam and Chava began at once with nisuin: 'this time' only, for later history would begin with erusin.
-
45:14 Knesses Yisrael's Tishrei, and the Satan's bone listed in the guide
The Mashgiach applies the parsha to Klal Yisrael, sanctified to Hashem as 'Yisrael is holy to Hashem', rising through Rosh Hashanah, Yom Kippur and Sukkos to the union of Shemini Atzeres, after the seventy nations, like wedding guests, have gone home. With a parable of a dog at a laden table he explains that at a time of great holiness the Satan demands a share, and so the rain came on Sukkos.
-
51:20 Servant and son; holiness kept hidden
The Mashgiach explains that a Jew serves as a servant through the deeds of the mitzvos and as a son through his heart, so being driven from the sukkah pains the servant within while the heart is still bound. He then says that what is done in public draws harm, as the first luchos were broken, and that matters of kedushah must be kept hidden so the Satan does not interfere.
-
56:43 Moshiach comes concealed: Peretz and Zerach
The Mashgiach explains that the soul of Moshiach comes in concealment, as with Yehudah and Tamar, and that the main union of Knesses Yisrael is at the kedushah of Simchas Torah. He brings the birth of Peretz and Zerach and Rashi's teaching that Achan descended from Zerach, describing how the Satan sought to block Moshiach's line.
-
1:03:16 This year's rain; from broken luchos to Bereishis
The Mashgiach speaks of the unprecedented rain of this Sukkos as an accusation that prepares the salvation of Shemini Atzeres, brings the Gemara in Avodah Zarah on the nations kicking the sukkah, and asks his listeners to hold firm to emunah in Moshiach's coming. He links the breaking of the luchos at the Torah's end to Bereishis, which contains everything, so that after a broken Sukkos one can start again.
-
1:11:43 Words to the yeshiva
The Mashgiach addresses the yeshiva: with a saying contrasting sugar and rock candy he explains that a chassid sweetens others, and he asks older bochurim to give time to help the younger ones. He mentions learning Kiddushin this year and closes with a wish for union with Hashem in Yerushalayim.
The shiur, written up
Rain in the sukkah: the Rambam's limit
The Mashgiach opens with the Mishnah in the second chapter of Sukkah: all seven days a person makes his sukkah his fixed home and his house temporary; when rain falls he may leave once the food would spoil; and the Mishnah gives a parable for it, a servant who came to pour a cup for his master, and the master poured a pitcher in his face. a
The Rambam in his commentary on the Mishnah adds that this bad sign applies only at the beginning of the festival, a point the Mashgiach notes is not found in other Rishonim. He asks why. On the first night there is an obligation to eat in the sukkah; on the other nights, in the Gemara's words, one may eat or not eat, so one who leaves for rain had a choice. A sign is only where there is no choice: on the first night Hashem pours the cup back and does not let a Jew fulfil what he is obliged to do. b,c
The sukkah as one's address
Going to the root, the Mashgiach asks why the first night requires a kezayis like matzah, and why one who suffers is exempt. Building a sukkah takes great effort, hauling boards and hammering nails, yet in the middle of a meal the rain lets a person walk out. c
He answers from the verse 'in sukkos you shall dwell seven days': the mitzvah is dwelling. A man who lives on Fiftieth Street and is now somewhere else still gives Fiftieth Street as his address. So the sukkah must become one's address; one who leaves it for rain, as he would leave an apartment that rained in, still lives there. d
The first night fixes the dwelling
But on the first night, the Mashgiach explains, a person who has not yet eaten in the sukkah has not yet made it his dwelling. For an eruv, placing the meal somewhere is enough to fix one's place for one day. The sukkah needs a stronger fixing, a dwelling for seven days, so an actual eating is required, the kezayis of the first night.
Chava's creation, renewed every Tishrei
Turning to the parsha, the Mashgiach brings the verse that for Adam no helpmate was found, until Hashem took one of his ribs and brought the woman to him. The seforim say this process happens every year with every Jew: Knesses Yisrael is the woman, and Hashem is the man. f,g
Rosh Hashanah stands under the attribute of judgment; the shofar breaks through its harsh and its soft judgment; Yom Kippur is the separation that lets the bride face her groom; the sukkah's walls surround Knesses Yisrael like a chuppah; and Shemini Atzeres is the climax. Returning to the Mishnah's servant, he says that on Rosh Hashanah the Jews still stood before Hashem as servants. a
Erusin and nisuin
The Mashgiach notes that Adam was asleep while Chava was built: his own efforts could not achieve it, and he was passive while it came about.
He then asks: nisuin binds a wife to her husband far more than erusin, yet an arusah who sins is stoned, the harshest death, and a nesuah is strangled, the lightest. The Gemara in Kiddushin compares the betrothed woman to hekdesh, forbidden to all the world. h
To answer, he brings the Ramban that a positive mitzvah comes from love and a prohibition from fear, and explains likewise that Yom Kippur carries karet while Shabbos carries stoning because Yom Kippur is chesed, forgiveness. So too nisuin comes from chesed: the wife is raised up to be one with her husband, a part of him, and the punishment is lighter. i
Souls already joined
The Mashgiach explains that a certain man and a certain woman were always bound together; their souls were joined before they came into the world. Adam's rib, of which he said 'this time', showed this once to the world, so that it would know how man differs from the animals, whose bodies alone were created. j
He distinguishes in shidduchim between a lost item, one's own that one seeks, and a find, someone else's.
Adam and Chava began with nisuin
Knesses Yisrael's Tishrei, and the Satan's bone
The Mashgiach applies this to Klal Yisrael, whose soul is a part of G-d above. As the verse says, Yisrael is holy to Hashem: sanctified to Him, with no share in the nations' cultures. From Rosh Hashanah through Yom Kippur and Sukkos they rise to the union of Shemini Atzeres, after the seventy nations, for whom seventy bulls are offered, have gone home like wedding guests. l,m
Then a parable: when a fine meal is on the table and a dog smells it, one throws it a bone so it will not leap onto the table. At a time of great holiness the Satan wants his share; the greater the holiness, the greater the accusation. The rain on Sukkos is a sign that a year of union is approaching.
Servant and son; holiness kept hidden
The Mashgiach explains that a Jew serves as a servant through the deeds of the mitzvos, tied to this world, and as a son through the fire of his heart. When he cannot sit in the sukkah, the servant in him feels it is not good, and he would rather sit there.
He adds that publicity does not help: the first luchos were broken because they were given with publicity. Matters of holiness must be kept hidden, so the Satan does not interfere.
Moshiach comes concealed
The soul of Moshiach, the Mashgiach explains, comes in concealment, as with Yehudah, who thought Tamar was a harlot. The main union of Knesses Yisrael is at the kedushah of Simchas Torah. Shemini Atzeres is not called a chag, since a chag is a circle and Shemini Atzeres is already its center, the purpose.
This year's rain; from broken luchos to Bereishis
The Mashgiach says that old people he spoke with could not remember a Sukkos with so much rain. It is an accusation, a breaking that comes before every rebuilding, and a preparation for Shemini Atzeres and for salvation. He brings the Gemara in Avodah Zarah that Hashem will give the nations the mitzvah of sukkah and bring out the sun, and they will leave, and the Gemara's question that Jews too leave when they suffer. p
Jews, he says, have mixed feelings: they know it is for the good, yet they wanted to sit in the sukkah. He hopes all will hold firm to emunah in Moshiach's coming, even when they do not understand what they see.
The breaking of the luchos 'before the eyes of all Israel' at the Torah's end is joined to Bereishis, which holds everything like a seed. The fallen sukkah of David becomes Bereishis again, as the Midrash says Hashem made a sukkah at the beginning. Looking back at a broken Rosh Hashanah through Sukkos, one can start again from Bereishis. q,r,s
Words to the yeshiva
The Mashgiach quotes a saying: a chassid is like sugar and a misnaged like rock candy. Sugar dissolves and sweetens the tea; rock candy stays a rock. A chassid wants to make the other better without losing himself.
He asks the older bochurim to give of their time to help the younger ones, mentions that Kiddushin is learned this year, and closes with a wish for union with Hashem in Yerushalayim.
Sources
Torah
- d Vayikra 23:42 text index In the write-up: 14:00
- f apparently Bereishis 2:20 index In the write-up: 22:11
- g Bereishis 2:21-22 text index In the write-up: 22:11
- j Bereishis 2:23 text index In the write-up: 36:19, 42:56
- k Bereishis 6:2 text index In the write-up: 41:08
- n Bereishis 38:29 text index In the write-up: 59:52
- q Devarim 34:12 text index In the write-up: 1:07:03
Nevi'im
Mishnah
Talmud Bavli
Midrash
- s Midrash (place not identified) In the write-up: 1:07:03
Rishonim
Key points
- 4:16 According to the Mashgiach, rain is a bad sign only on the first night of Sukkos, because only then is there an obligation to eat in the sukkah; on other days a person has a choice.
- 14:19 The mitzvah of sukkah is to dwell there; like an address, the sukkah stays one's home even when rain sends him out.
- 18:23 The kezayis eaten on the first night establishes the sukkah as one's dwelling for all seven days, a stronger fixing than the meal placed for an eruv.
- 22:57 The creation of Chava and her coming to Adam repeats every year between Hashem and Knesses Yisrael, from Rosh Hashanah to Shemini Atzeres.
- 29:46 Nisuin is a closer bond than erusin, yet its punishment is lighter, because it comes from the attribute of chesed.
- 48:14 The rain on Sukkos is the Satan's share at a time of great holiness, and a sign that a year of union with Hashem is approaching.
- 1:07:10 The breaking of the luchos is joined to Bereishis: after a broken Sukkos one can begin again.
Questions and answers
-
Question: 4:01 Why does the Rambam say the bad sign of rain applies only at the start of the festival?
Answer: 5:31 Only the first night carries an obligation to eat in the sukkah; on other nights one has a choice, so rain then is no sign.
-
Question: 11:37 Why is one who suffers in the sukkah exempt from it?
Answer: 14:00 The mitzvah is to dwell there as one dwells at home, and a person also leaves his home when it is unbearable; his sukkah remains his address.
-
Question: 18:08 Why must one eat a kezayis in the sukkah on the first night?
Answer: 18:23 Eating then establishes the sukkah as one's dwelling for all seven days, a fixing stronger than an eruv requires.
-
Question: 30:33 Why is the nesuah, more closely bound to her husband, punished more lightly than the arusah?
Answer: 33:27 Nisuin comes from chesed and love, and what comes from love carries a lighter punishment, as with Yom Kippur compared to Shabbos.
Insights
- 5:47 The Mashgiach reads the Rambam's limit as a matter of choice: a bad sign is only where a person had no choice, and only the first night of Sukkos obliges him to eat in the sukkah.
- 14:34 Leaving the sukkah for rain does not end one's dwelling there, just as a man's home address does not change when he steps out; therefore the exemption of one who suffers fits the mitzvah of dwelling.
- 18:28 An eruv is fixed for one day by placing a meal, but the sukkah must be fixed as a home for seven days, which needs an actual eating on the first night; this is why the kezayis is learned from matzah.
- 23:38 Tishrei is the yearly rebuilding of Chava for Adam: Rosh Hashanah as back to back, the shofar breaking through judgment, Yom Kippur as the separation, the sukkah as chuppah, and Shemini Atzeres as 'He brought her to the man'.
- 30:38 The Mashgiach applies the Ramban's rule, that what comes from love carries a lighter punishment, to explain why a nesuah is punished by strangling while an arusah is stoned.
- 42:56 The missing heh in the Torah's word for a young woman points to what she lacks until nisuin, when she receives the heh and is raised to be one with her husband.
- 1:07:08 The breaking of the luchos at the end of the Torah is joined to its first word, Bereishis, which holds everything like a seed; so a broken Sukkos becomes a new beginning.
What the Mashgiach says to take from it
- 1:06:20 The Mashgiach expresses the hope that everyone hold firm together to emunah in the coming of Moshiach, even when a Jew does not understand what he sees.
- 1:10:05 The Mashgiach teaches that after a broken Sukkos one can start again from Bereishis.
- 1:13:31 The Mashgiach asks the older bochurim of the yeshiva to give of their time to help the younger ones.
Mentioned in this shiur
People Achan, Adam HaRishon, Chava, Peretz, Rashi, Tamar, the Chasam Sofer, the Rambam, the Ramban, Yehudah (son of Yaakov), Zerach
Terms כנסת ישראל, סוכה, שבירת הלוחות, שטן, שמיני עצרת