חילוק בין הנהגת יוסף ויהודה; הקב"ה יעשה שלום ביניהם

Catalog entry: פרשת השבוע ויגש no. ⁨1⁩ Pocket Guide p. 8 תשל"ג (1972–73) Yiddish 58 min

Listen

  1. Download · Length 58 min

Open in the listening app

Notes Notes prepared by AI from the recording; not reviewed, and not the Mashgiach's words. The recording is the source.

About this shiur

The Mashgiach explains that Hashem runs the world by two seemingly opposite ways, the way of Yosef, who keeps the Torah literally whatever the outcome, and the way of Yehuda, through whom Hashem's plan, and Moshiach himself, comes about even through an aveirah, and shows both in Yehuda and Tamar, Yosef and Potiphar's wife, and Pinchas and the sin of Shittim.

The Mashgiach opens with the haftarah's two sticks of Yehuda and Yosef that Hashem will make into one, bound by a covenant of peace. He compares history to a train running between creation and the perfected world on two tracks that seem to go opposite ways, knowledge and free choice, a question that remains a question. After a digression on the fasts of Teves, he names the two ways: Yosef's, of keeping the Torah literally without calculating results, and Yehuda's, in which Hashem brings about His plan even through an aveirah. The Midrash pairing Tamar with Potiphar's wife, both acting for Heaven's sake, shows Moshiach ben Dovid born through Yehuda while Yosef refuses to bring Moshiach ben Yosef. Moshiach comes hidden, through breaches like Peretz. He then reads the sin of Shittim the same way: the tribes sought Moshiach through Moav, Baal Peor was the idol of rationalization, Bilaam disguised Midianite women, and Pinchas, the ehrliche Yid, ruined the plan.

Topics: Moshiach ben Yosef and Moshiach ben Dovid · Hashgacha Pratis · Balak, Bilam and Pinchas · Yehuda and Tamar · Yosef and His Brothers

Order of the shiur

  1. 0:00 Two sticks made one; the train on two tracks listed in the guide

    The Mashgiach opens with the haftarah of Vayigash, where the sticks of Yehuda and of Yosef become one and Hashem makes a covenant of peace between them. He then compares history to a train running from creation to the perfected world on two tracks that seem to go opposite ways, knowledge and free choice, citing the Rambam and the Raavad and concluding that the question remains while the train runs on.

  2. 6:26 The darkness of the fasts of Teves

    The Mashgiach explains that in the dark there are moments of light that show the Conductor, and turns to the three fasts of Teves in Megillas Taanis: the Torah's translation into Greek, which brought cultural contact with the nations, the unexplained ninth of Teves, which the Selichos tie to Ezra's passing, and the siege of Yerushalayim on the tenth. Vayigash, he says, is always read in that week and must be connected to these days.

  3. 12:07 The way of Yosef and the way of Yehuda listed in the guide

    The Mashgiach defines the two ways: a tzaddik must act in the way of Yosef, keeping the Torah literally without weighing results, as Yeshaya told Chizkiyahu not to meddle in Hashem's secrets. Hashem, however, sometimes brings about His plan through an aveirah and even hires transgressors as His agents, and this is the way of Yehuda.

  4. 16:06 Tamar and Potiphar's wife, both for Heaven's sake listed in the guide

    The Mashgiach brings the Midrash that asks why the story of Yehuda and Tamar interrupts the story of Yosef, and answers that just as Tamar acted for Heaven's sake, so did Potiphar's wife, who saw in the stars that she would be bound to Yosef. He explains that even before Egypt began, the line of Dovid and Moshiach was being formed through Yehuda and Tamar, and brings the Midrash that the angel over desire turned Yehuda from his way against his will.

  5. 20:33 Yehuda's holy desire and 'from Me' listed in the guide

    The Mashgiach stresses the greatness of the Shevatim: Yehuda had no desire for this world, only a holy desire for Moshiach, and like the great tzaddikim of whom Rebbe Nachman of Breslov speaks, his yetzer was a holy angel that compelled him. The heavenly voice of 'from Me' testifies that it came from Hashem, so Yehuda's aveirah brought Moshiach; the next parsha, of Yosef, belongs to Moshiach ben Yosef.

  6. 23:54 Yosef refuses to bring Moshiach ben Yosef listed in the guide

    The Mashgiach explains that Potiphar's wife wanted to bring Moshiach ben Yosef, as Yehuda had done for Moshiach ben Dovid, and argued it was a great mitzvah. Yosef, as Rashi explains, refused; he held to his own way, that he is not obligated to bring Moshiach but to be an ehrliche Yid, and the Mashgiach says this is the way from man's side, while Hashem uses the way of Yehuda, especially in bringing Moshiach.

  7. 27:16 Moshiach hidden from the Satan listed in the guide

    The Mashgiach shows that Moshiach comes from Lot through Moav and Rus, and brings from the early sources that the Satan blocks Moshiach, so Hashem hides him where no one would look, like a diamond hidden in garbage. Everything, even the stormy wind, serves Hashem's will; such things happen to the great ones of Yehuda because Yehuda, as king, is fully nullified to Hashem and through him Malchus Shamayim is revealed.

  8. 30:46 Peretz, the breach of malchus, and the sale of Yosef listed in the guide

    The Mashgiach explains that a king breaks through barriers, so Peretz, ancestor of Moshiach, was born by breaking through ahead of Zerach. He then brings the Midrash that once Yosef was sold all the strife of the brothers vanished, because Yehuda's plan had accomplished Hashem's plan, as the passuk in Yeshayahu suggests that Hashem put hatred in their hearts. He warns that one who reads these Midrashim and seeks to do great things through an aveirah falls, as many have.

  9. 36:33 Pinchas and the tribes' intention at Shittim

    The Mashgiach turns to Pinchas: his covenant of peace, which the Targum Yonasan explains as his becoming Eliyahu, the herald of the redemption, and the tribes' mockery of him despite his ten miracles. He asks why Midian, not Moav, was punished, links Bilaam with Lavan and Amalek, and explains that the generation of knowledge, Zimri among them, knew that Moshiach would come from Moav and sought contact with Bnos Moav purely for Heaven's sake, with mesirus nefesh, citing the Lubliner; but one aveirah led to the idol of Baal Peor.

  10. 44:43 Baal Peor, the idol of rationalization

    The Mashgiach asks why the sin led specifically to Baal Peor. From the Rambam on the generation of Enosh he shows that idolatry began with a lofty-seeming intention, and he defines idolatry as rationalization, the natural refusal to admit one's own weakness, as in the Gemara that Jews served idols only to permit forbidden relations. Baal Peor, a disgusting service, was the idol that justifies a disgusting deed by a good intention, fitting those who began with Bnos Moav to bring Moshiach; its gematria equals 'the king Moshiach'.

  11. 51:01 Bilaam's disguise and Pinchas's zeal

    The Mashgiach notes the change in the pesukim from Bnos Moav to Bnos Midian: Bilaam, fearing that Moshiach would come, had Midianite women appear dressed as Moavite women, so Kozbi was in truth of Midian. Pinchas, an ehrliche Yid, killed her and ruined the whole plan, and the tribes mocked him, holding he lacked their lofty grasp; the Mashgiach brings a Tosafos on Miriam and Moshe, and concludes that Pinchas, rooted in the holiness of Aharon, knew one must act by the Shulchan Aruch and not be over-wise, and could not let Moshiach be stained.

The shiur, written up

Two sticks made one; the train on two tracks

0:26

The Mashgiach opens with the haftarah: the prophet Yechezkel takes one stick for Yehuda and one for Yosef in the hand of Ephraim, two factions with a long tradition of strife, and they miraculously become one in his hand. Hashem then promises a covenant of peace between them. a,b,c

2:49

He compares history to a train running between two terminals, the creation and the perfected world, on two tracks that seem to lead in opposite directions, one up to heaven and one down. The tracks are knowledge and free choice: the Rambam in Hilchos Teshuvah requires belief in both, and the Raavad objects to his answer. The question remains a question, but the train keeps running, in the dark. d,e

The darkness of the fasts of Teves

6:27

From time to time a light shines, and then one can see the Conductor of the train. The Mashgiach brings Megillas Taanis on the fasts of Teves: on the eighth the Torah was translated into Greek and darkness came for three days; the ninth has no stated reason; on the tenth Yerushalayim was besieged. Since Vayigash always falls in that week, it must be connected to them. f

8:51

The translation brought Jews into cultural contact with the nations, which led to the Greek exile. The Selichos say Ezra died on the ninth, so why does Megillas Taanis not say so? The Mashgiach answers that the fast is for not understanding: in that darkness Ezra could pass, others could take over the leadership, and no one would feel the loss, until in the end the wall of Klal Yisroel is breached. f,g

The way of Yosef and the way of Yehuda

12:23

There are two ways in the world, the Mashgiach says, those of Yosef and of Yehuda. A tzaddik must act like Yosef: an aveirah is an aveirah, without weighing what is good for him or for Klal Yisroel. So Yeshayahu told Chizkiyahu not to meddle in Hashem's secrets but to do what the Torah says. i

14:27

Hashem, however, sometimes carries out His plan through an aveirah, and as the passuk in Mishlei says, hires even transgressors for it. That is the way of Yehuda. j

Tamar and Potiphar's wife, both for Heaven's sake

16:10

The Midrash asks why the Torah interrupts Yosef's story with Yehuda and Tamar, and answers: just as Tamar acted for Heaven's sake, so did Potiphar's wife, who saw in the stars that she would be bound to Yosef, though it was really her daughter. k

18:25

The Mashgiach explains with Chazal that before the first oppressor came the last redeemer: as the descent to Egypt begins, the house of Dovid forms through Yehuda and Tamar. The Midrash says that the angel over desire stopped Yehuda and asked where kings and redeemers would come from, and turned him aside against his will. l,m,n

Yehuda's holy desire

20:47

This shows the greatness of the Shevatim. Yehuda had no desire for this world, only a holy desire for Moshiach; as Rebbe Nachman of Breslov says, the yetzer of great tzaddikim is a holy angel, and it compelled him. When Yehuda said 'she is more righteous than I', the Gemara says a heavenly voice declared that it came from Hashem. So Yehuda's aveirah brought Moshiach ben Dovid, and the next parsha, Yosef's, concerns Moshiach ben Yosef. o,p

Yosef refuses

24:15

Potiphar's wife wanted to bring Moshiach ben Yosef, the same as Yehuda had done. Yosef refused, and Rashi explains that he did not want to be with her in the World to Come; he held to his own way. In the Mashgiach's words, Yosef would not be swayed: he was not obligated to bring Moshiach, only to be an ehrliche Yid and keep the Torah. q

26:25

This, the Mashgiach says, is man's side: to keep the Torah literally, as the Shulchan Aruch says, without calculations. Hashem uses the way of Yehuda, especially for bringing Moshiach.

Moshiach hidden from the Satan

27:30

Moshiach came from Lot through Moav and Rus. The Mashgiach brings from early sources that the Satan blocks Moshiach, so Hashem hides him where no one would look, like a diamond hidden in garbage. As the passuk says, even the stormy wind does His word: everything is harnessed to Hashem's plan. These things happen to the great ones of Yehuda because Yehuda, the king, is entirely nullified to Hashem, and through him Malchus Shamayim is revealed. r

Peretz and the sale of Yosef

30:55

A trait of malchus is that a king breaks through barriers. Peretz, the spark of Moshiach, was born by breaking through ahead of Zerach, who had put out his hand first, because malchus must come through a breach. s

33:43

The Midrash on the passing Midianites reads 'midanim', strife: once Yosef was sold, the brothers' strife vanished, because Hashem's plan was done, and the plan was Yehuda's, 'what gain is there'. A Midrash on the passuk in Yeshayahu says Hashem put hatred in their hearts, so the brothers were compelled. But the Mashgiach warns that one who reads these Midrashim and seeks great things through an aveirah falls, as many have. u,v,w,y

Pinchas and the tribes' intention at Shittim

36:45

The Mashgiach turns to Pinchas and his covenant of peace. The Targum Yonasan explains that Pinchas would become Eliyahu, herald of the redemption. Yet, as Rashi says, the tribes mocked him, though the Gemara tells of ten miracles done for him. Why? z,aa,ab,ac

38:42

The story begins with Bnos Moav and Baal Peor, but Hashem then commands vengeance on Midian, implying the failure was really in the Midianite women. Bilaam, who is connected with Lavan and Amalek, followed Amalek's tactic of disguise, as Rashi says on the Canaanite king. ad,ae,af

41:51

The generation of knowledge, Zimri among them, knew that the house of Dovid would come from Lot through Moav, and sought contact with Moav purely to bring Moshiach. The Lubliner said that for Moshiach one must be ready to give up even one's soul. But one aveirah led to another, to Baal Peor.

Baal Peor, the idol of rationalization

45:04

Why Baal Peor? The Rambam explains that idolatry began in the generation of Enosh with a lofty intention, honoring Hashem's servants. At root, the Mashgiach says, idolatry is rationalization: a person never admits his weakness. One who hits his finger blames the hammer; one who fails in learning blames the rebbi, the chavrusa, the windows. So the Gemara says Jews served idols only to permit forbidden relations openly. ag,ah

49:02

Baal Peor, a disgusting service, justified disgusting deeds by a good intention. Those who began with Bnos Moav to bring Moshiach needed such an idol, and the Mashgiach notes that Baal Peor equals 'the king Moshiach' in gematria.

Bilaam's disguise and Pinchas's zeal

51:01

The pesukim shift from Bnos Moav to Bnos Midian. Bilaam knew that if Jews joined with Moav, Moshiach might come, so he sent Midianite women dressed as Moavites. Zimri thought Kozbi was of Moav, but she was of Midian.

53:42

Then Pinchas, a frum Jew, came and ruined the whole plan by killing Kozbi. The tribes mocked him as lacking their grasp and courage to do even an aveirah for Moshiach. The Mashgiach brings a Tosafos about Miriam and Moshe on accepting a greater stringency. ai

57:10

He concludes that Pinchas was an ehrliche Yid who knew to act by the Shulchan Aruch and not be over-wise, and one should be like him. His zeal came from the holiness of Aharon, of the Beis HaMikdash; he knew how precious the geulah is and could not let Moshiach be stained.

Sources

Torah

  1. n Bereishis 38:16 text index In the write-up: 18:25
  2. o Bereishis 38:26 text index In the write-up: 20:47
  3. s Bereishis 38:29 text index In the write-up: 30:55
  4. u Bereishis 37:28 text index In the write-up: 33:43
  5. w Bereishis 37:26-27 text index In the write-up: 33:43
  6. x Bereishis 45:5 34:27 text index
  7. z Bamidbar 25:11-12 text index In the write-up: 36:45
  8. ad Bamidbar 25:1-3 text index In the write-up: 38:42
  9. ae Bamidbar 31:2 text index In the write-up: 38:42

Nevi'im

  1. a Yechezkel 37:16 text index In the write-up: 0:26
  2. b Yechezkel 37:19 text index In the write-up: 0:26
  3. c Yechezkel 37:26 text index In the write-up: 0:26
  4. y Yeshayahu 63:17 text index In the write-up: 33:43

Kesuvim

  1. j Mishlei 26:10 text index In the write-up: 14:27
  2. r Tehillim 148:8 text index In the write-up: 27:30

Targum

  1. aa apparently Targum Yonasan on Bamidbar 25:12 index In the write-up: 36:45

Talmud Bavli

  1. i apparently Berachos 10a index In the write-up: 12:23
  2. p Gemara (place not identified) index In the write-up: 20:47
  3. ac apparently Sanhedrin 82b index In the write-up: 36:45
  4. ah apparently Sanhedrin 63b index In the write-up: 45:04

Midrash

  1. f Megillas Taanis (place not identified) index In the write-up: 6:27, 8:51
  2. k apparently Bereishis Rabbah 85:2 index In the write-up: 16:10
  3. l apparently Bereishis Rabbah 85:1 index In the write-up: 18:25
  4. m apparently Bereishis Rabbah 85:8 index In the write-up: 18:25
  5. v Midrash (place not identified) In the write-up: 33:43

Rishonim

  1. d apparently Hilchos Teshuvah ch. 5 index In the write-up: 2:49
  2. e apparently Raavad on Hilchos Teshuvah 5:5 index In the write-up: 2:49
  3. h apparently Hilchos Melachim 12:5 8:30 index
  4. q apparently Rashi on Bereishis 39:10 index In the write-up: 24:15
  5. t apparently Rashi on Bereishis 25:26 32:14 index
  6. ab apparently Rashi on Bamidbar 25:11 index In the write-up: 36:45
  7. af apparently Rashi on Bamidbar 21:1 index In the write-up: 38:42
  8. ag apparently Hilchos Avodah Zarah 1:1 index In the write-up: 45:04
  9. ai Tosafos on Gemara Shabbos (place not identified) index In the write-up: 53:42

Tefillah and Piyut

  1. g Selichos of Asarah b'Teves (place not identified) index In the write-up: 8:51

Key points

  1. 2:55 Hashem leads the world on two tracks that seem to contradict each other, like knowledge and free choice, and the contradiction is beyond human understanding, yet the train of humanity keeps moving toward the perfected world.
  2. 12:33 From the side of man, the way of Yosef: a Jew must keep the Torah to the letter and not weigh what good might come of an aveirah.
  3. 14:27 From Hashem's side, the way of Yehuda: Hashem sometimes carries out His plan precisely through an aveirah, as with Yehuda and Tamar, from whom Moshiach descends.
  4. 24:15 Potiphar's wife wanted to bring Moshiach ben Yosef, and Yosef refused, saying in effect that he is not obligated to bring Moshiach but to be an ehrliche Yid who keeps the Torah.
  5. 27:30 Moshiach comes through hidden and unexpected roots, like Lot and Moav and Peretz, because malchus breaks through barriers.
  6. 43:49 The sin of Shittim began with an intention to bring Moshiach through Bnos Moav, and one aveirah led to another, to Baal Peor, the idol that justifies disgusting deeds by a good intention.
  7. 54:03 Pinchas, who acted as an ehrliche Yid by the Shulchan Aruch, overturned Bilaam's scheme, and the Mashgiach says one should be like Pinchas and not try to be over-wise.

Questions and answers

  1. Question: 4:32 If Hashem knows everything a person will do, how can the person have free choice?

    Answer: 4:59 The Rambam says these matters are above human understanding; the question remains, yet the world runs on both tracks.

  2. Question: 9:24 If Megillas Taanis knew Ezra died on the ninth of Teves, why does it say the reason for the fast is unknown?

    Answer: 9:59 The fast is precisely for not understanding: it continues the darkness of the eighth, in which a leader like Ezra could pass and his loss go unnoticed.

  3. Question: 17:04 Why does the Torah interrupt the story of Yosef with the story of Yehuda and Tamar?

    Answer: 17:18 To teach that just as Tamar acted for Heaven's sake, so did Potiphar's wife; both sought to bring Moshiach, ben Dovid and ben Yosef.

  4. Question: 39:28 Why did Hashem command vengeance on Midian and not on Moav, whose daughters began the sin?

    Answer: 40:09 Because the failure was really through Midian: Bilaam sent Midianite women disguised as Moavites, as the change in the pesukim from Bnos Moav to Bnos Midian shows.

  5. Question: 44:42 Why did the sin lead specifically to Baal Peor?

    Answer: 49:24 Baal Peor is the idol that justifies a disgusting deed by a good intention, the idolatry needed by those who began with Bnos Moav to bring Moshiach.

  6. Question: 38:14 Why did the tribes mock Pinchas after Heaven made ten miracles for him?

    Answer: 54:38 They held that he, a simple frum Jew, lacked their lofty grasp and courage to do even an aveirah for Moshiach, and that he had ruined the plan to bring Moshiach.

Stories

  1. 19:06 The angel turns Yehuda from his way

    The Mashgiach retells the Midrash that as Yehuda walked on, the angel appointed over desire came to him and asked where he was going, saying that kings and redeemers, and Moshiach, must come from somewhere. Yehuda was turned aside against his will, not knowing the woman was Tamar. The Mashgiach explains that Yehuda's desire was a holy one for Moshiach, and his yetzer was a holy angel that compelled him.

    In the story: Yehudah (son of Yaakov), Tamar

  2. 37:43 Pinchas and Kozbi

    The Mashgiach describes how the tribes at Shittim, believing they could bring Moshiach through Bnos Moav, were met by Midianite women in disguise. Pinchas came and killed Kozbi, and although ten miracles happened to him, the tribes mocked him as a descendant of one who fattened calves for idolatry, holding that he lacked their lofty understanding and their readiness for mesirus nefesh.

    In the story: Pinchas, Kozbi bas Tzur, Zimri ben Salu

Insights

  1. 2:29 History is a train running between two terminals, creation and the perfected world, on two tracks that seem to lead opposite ways, knowledge and free choice; the question stays unanswered, yet the train keeps running toward its goal.
  2. 9:06 The ninth of Teves is a fast for a reason not understood, because it continues the darkness that came when the Torah was translated and Jews began to mix culturally with the nations, a darkness in which even Ezra's passing and the loss of true leadership could go unnoticed.
  3. 23:48 The pairing of Tamar with Potiphar's wife shows two Moshiachs: Moshiach ben Dovid came about through Yehuda's deed, while Potiphar's wife sought Moshiach ben Yosef and Yosef refused, holding that he was obligated only to keep the Torah.
  4. 27:38 Because the Satan blocks Moshiach, Hashem hides him in the least expected places, like a diamond in garbage, which is why Moshiach's roots pass through Lot, Yehuda and Tamar, and Dovid and Bas Sheva.
  5. 46:43 Idolatry is rationalization: a person will not admit his weakness and finds an outside justification, and Baal Peor was the idol that made a disgusting act into service of Hashem by its good intention, fitting a sin that began with the intention to bring Moshiach; its gematria equals 'the king Moshiach'.
  6. 51:01 The pesukim shift from Bnos Moav to Bnos Midian because Bilaam, who knew that Moshiach could come from a union with Moav, sent Midianite women disguised as Moavites, so the tribes' intention could never succeed.

What the Mashgiach says to take from it

  1. 14:09 The Mashgiach says a Jew must conduct himself by the Torah literally, without calculating outcomes or what good an aveirah might bring.
  2. 36:01 The Mashgiach warns that one who learns these Midrashim and tries to achieve great things through an aveirah falls, as many already have.
  3. 57:10 The Mashgiach says one should be like Pinchas, acting by the Shulchan Aruch and not trying to be over-wise.

Mentioned in this shiur

People Aharon HaKohen, Balak, Bas Sheva, Bilaam, Chizkiyahu HaMelech, Dovid HaMelech, Eliyahu HaNavi, Ephraim, Ezra HaSofer, Kozbi bas Tzur, Lavan, Lot, Miriam, Moshe Rabbeinu, Peretz, Pinchas, Rashi, Rebbe Nachman of Breslov, Rus, Tamar, the Chozeh of Lublin, the Raavad, the Rambam, Yehudah (son of Yaakov), Yeshayahu HaNavi, Yosef HaTzaddik, Zerach, Zimri ben Salu

Terms מסירות נפש, משיח בן יוסף, עולם התיקון, עשרה בטבת, רבונו של עולם, תאוה

Report an error on this page