Shir Hashirim
Catalog entry: Shir Hashirim no. 4 Yiddish 42 min
Not in the 2012 Pocket Guide; the title is taken from the file name.
Listen
About this shiur
On the pasuk 'your oils have a good fragrance', the Mashgiach explains that Hashem's miracles and all holiness are hidden like silent oil, yet the final redemption will come with open wonders, and the memory of past miracles keeps Jewish love of Hashem alive even in times of concealment.
Continuing Shir Hashirim 1:3, the Mashgiach teaches that miracles and holiness are hidden: the Mishkan's beams were covered, and Elisha's staff failed because Gechazi publicized the miracle. Only rarely, as in a story of the Sanzer Rav in Oberland, does a tzaddik reveal a wonder to sanctify Hashem's name. From the Midrash on oil, which pours silently and does not mix, he turns to the Jewish people, who may not mix with the nations; the return under Nechemiah came without miracles because of foreign wives. He weighs the Rambam's Moshiach, who needs no miracles, against the Raavad's, and argues the Rambam's is greater, since moving every Jewish heart is the greatest wonder. With the Yismach Moshe he shows that a promise made with Hashem's Name cannot be lost, explains why Chanukah lights stand below ten tefachim, and closes that remembered miracles keep emunah alive in hester panim.
Topics: Shir HaShirim · Miracles and Nature · Moshiach and the Days of Moshiach · Hester Panim and Suffering
Order of the shiur
-
0:00 Miracles are hidden, like a fragrance listed in the guide
The Mashgiach returns to the third pasuk of Shir Hashirim, 'your oils have a good fragrance', and explains that Hashem's miracles, like all holiness, are hidden and only their fragrance comes out. He brings the gold-covered beams of the Mishkan, which Rashi explains as tznius, and Elisha's staff, which failed because Gechazi talked about the miracle on the way.
-
3:26 The Sanzer Rav in Oberland Story
The Mashgiach tells how the Sanzer Rav came to a wedding in Oberland, a non-Chassidic region of Hungary, and revealed the hidden origin of the chasan, a wonder he showed because there they did not know there is a Ribono shel Olam. He then restates the rule: such openness is the exception, the open miracles of Yetzias Mitzrayim were so the world would know Hashem, and holiness is always in tznius.
-
7:00 Oil that is silent and does not mix listed in the guide
From the Midrash the Mashgiach explains that poured oil makes no sound, and that oil does not mix: a drop of water in a full glass of oil pushes out a drop of oil, as a word of foolishness pushes out a drop of Torah. He applies this to the Jewish people, who may not mix with the nations, and shows that the return for the Second Beis Hamikdash came without miracles because of foreign wives, whom the people sent away at Nechemiah's word, contrasting this with today's assimilation.
-
12:56 The Rambam's Moshiach and the Raavad's listed in the guide
The Mashgiach brings the Rambam that Moshiach need not show miracles and is recognized by his deeds, and the Raavad who disputes this and expects great wonders. He argues that the Rambam's Moshiach is the greater one, since the greatest miracle is to bring Hashem into a Jewish heart, and that so great a Moshiach is needed for a people sunk in the fiftieth gate of impurity.
-
19:02 Gathering the exiles with one word listed in the guide
Illustrating the Rambam's sign of gathering the exiles, the Mashgiach pictures Moshiach calling out on 47th Street and everyone leaving their shops open to follow him. He compares this to Moshe Rabbeinu's sign 'pakod pakadti', whose power was that the words entered Jewish hearts, and brings the tradition that at Moshiach's shofar even the worst meshumad will run after him.
-
23:28 Where the Beis Hamikdash will stand listed in the guide
The Mashgiach points out that the place of the mizbe'ach must be exact, yet today nobody knows it, and every group would bring its own view; Moshiach will say one word and all will accept it. Recalling Nechemiah again, he concludes that although the Rambam makes miracles no requirement, the plain meaning of the pesukim and Midrashim is that there will be great miracles.
-
28:19 A promise made with Hashem's Name listed in the guide
The Mashgiach asks whether our generation, worse than that of the Second Beis Hamikdash, will merit miracles. He brings the Gemara that Israel deserved miracles in Ezra's days but sin caused, the pasuk 'ad ya'avor amcha Hashem', and the Yismach Moshe's answer that a promise made with the Shem Havayah is above time and cannot be cancelled, and the final redemption is promised that way.
-
32:26 Chanukah lights below ten tefachim listed in the guide
The Mashgiach explains that although the Shechinah never descends below ten tefachim, the Chanukah light is lit below ten, in the public domain, at night, on the left side and in the darkest season, all places where the forces of impurity rule. The seforim say it kindles the light of Moshiach, who will come down to the lowest Jews and lift them up.
-
37:09 Loving Hashem in times of concealment listed in the guide
Returning to the pasuk, the Mashgiach says the Chanukah miracle came through oil, which does not mix, to purify Klal Yisrael, and reads 'alamos' as from 'he'elem', concealment: Jews love Hashem even in hester panim, as after the destruction in Europe. Their emunah holds because they remember the miracles of Yetzias Mitzrayim, Chanukah and Purim, whose fragrance still remains.
The shiur, written up
Miracles are hidden, like a fragrance
The Mashgiach returns to Shir Hashirim 1:3, 'your oils have a good fragrance': Hashem's miracles are hidden, and only their fragrance comes out. All holiness is concealed; Rashi explains the gold-covered beams of the Mishkan as tznius. Elisha's staff failed in Gechazi's hand, Rashi says, because he told about it on the way, while the honor of a miracle is that it stay hidden. a,c
The Sanzer Rav in Oberland
Rarely, tzaddikim showed open wonders to sanctify Hashem's name. The Sanzer Rav came to a wedding in Oberland, a non-Chassidic part of Hungary, learned from the chasan's father that the boy had been found in a river and adopted, and revealed that he was the kallah's lost brother. There, he said, they did not know there is a Ribono shel Olam.
Oil that is silent and does not mix
The Midrash notes that poured oil makes no sound, unlike water or wine; so Hashem's miracles, His tzaddikim and the good deeds of every Jew work quietly. It adds that oil does not mix: a drop of water in a full glass of oil pushes out a drop of oil, as a word of foolishness pushes out a drop of Torah. d
The Rambam's Moshiach and the Raavad's
The Rambam writes that Moshiach need not show miracles: one who fights Hashem's wars and returns Jews to the mitzvos is presumed Moshiach, and once he builds the Beis Hamikdash and gathers the exiles he is certainly Moshiach. The Raavad disputes this and expects great wonders. h
Which Moshiach is greater? The Mashgiach argues for the Rambam's: tzaddikim also work wonders, but, as Rabbi Aharon of Karlin said, the greatest wonder is bringing Hashem into a Jewish heart. So great a Moshiach is needed because much of the people has sunk into the fiftieth gate of impurity, as the Ohr HaChaim describes. k
Gathering the exiles with one word
To picture the gathering of the exiles, the Mashgiach imagines Moshiach calling out on 47th Street and everyone leaving their shops unlocked to follow him. So it was with Moshe Rabbeinu's sign 'pakod pakadti': anyone could say it, but his words entered Jewish hearts. At Moshiach's shofar, he adds, even the worst meshumad will run after him. l
Where the Beis Hamikdash will stand
The Rambam writes that the place of the mizbe'ach is exact, yet today nobody knows it, and every group would hold its own view; Moshiach will say one word and all will accept it. Recalling Nechemiah, the Mashgiach concludes that although the Rambam makes miracles no requirement, the plain meaning of the pesukim and Midrashim is that great miracles will come. n,g
A promise made with Hashem's Name
Will our generation, worse than that of the Second Beis Hamikdash, see miracles? The Gemara says Israel deserved miracles in Ezra's days, but sin caused. The Yismach Moshe explains that a promise made with the Shem Havayah is above time: in 'ad ya'avor amcha Hashem' the first phrase carries the Name and the second does not, and the final redemption is promised with that Name. o,q,p
Chanukah lights below ten tefachim
The Gemara in Sukkah teaches that the Shechinah never descends below ten tefachim, yet the Chanukah light is lit below ten, at night, in the public domain, in the darkest season, where the forces of impurity rule. The seforim say it kindles the light of Moshiach, who will come down to the lowest Jews and lift them up. s
Loving Hashem in times of concealment
Oil, which does not mix, carried the Chanukah miracle that purifies Klal Yisrael. The pasuk's 'alamos', the Mashgiach explains, comes from 'he'elem', concealment: Jews love Hashem even in hester panim, as after the destruction in Europe, because they remember the miracles of Yetzias Mitzrayim, Chanukah and Purim. The fragrance of those oils still remains. a
Sources
Torah
Nevi'im
Kesuvim
Talmud Bavli
Midrash
Zohar and Kabbalah
Rishonim
Acharonim and Chassidus
Key points
- 1:07 Hashem's miracles, like all holiness and good deeds, are normally hidden, and an open miracle is the exception, used only to sanctify Hashem's name.
- 9:04 The Jewish people, like oil, do not mix with others, and the return for the Second Beis Hamikdash lacked miracles because many had married foreign wives.
- 13:04 The Rambam's Moshiach, who is known by his deeds rather than by miracles, is the greater Moshiach, since the greatest miracle is to bring Hashem into a Jewish heart.
- 31:01 A promise Hashem makes with the Shem Havayah stands above time and cannot be cancelled by sin, so the final redemption will come with miracles and wonders.
- 38:01 Jews keep loving Hashem even in times of hester panim because they remember the miracles of Yetzias Mitzrayim, Chanukah and Purim.
Questions and answers
-
Question: 2:28 Why could Gechazi not revive the child with Elisha's staff?
Answer: 2:33 Because he told everyone on the way what Elisha had sent him to do, and, as Rashi explains, the honor of a miracle is that it be done in tznius.
-
Question: 15:06 Which is the greater Moshiach, the Rambam's, who needs no miracles, or the Raavad's, who will show great wonders?
Answer: 16:01 The Rambam's, since tzaddikim too can work wonders, while the greatest wonder is to bring Hashem into a Jewish heart and draw the whole people after him.
-
Question: 21:35 What was special about Moshe Rabbeinu's sign 'pakod pakadti', if anyone could say those words?
Answer: 21:55 The sign was that when he said them, the words would break through into Jewish hearts and they would feel the light of the redemption.
-
Question: 30:05 If Hashem promised, how could sin hold back the miracles of the return in Ezra's time?
Answer: 30:29 The Yismach Moshe answers that an ordinary promise can be lost through sin, but one made with the Shem Havayah is above time; the first 'ad ya'avor' carries the Name and the second does not.
-
Question: 32:56 Why is the Chanukah light lit below ten tefachim, though the Shechinah never descends below ten?
Answer: 33:22 Because the Chanukah light kindles the light of Moshiach, who will come down to the lowest Jews and lift them up from there.
-
Question: 39:33 Where does the Jews' hold on Hashem come from, even in times of hester panim?
Answer: 39:37 From the miracles Hashem did for them, which they recall every year on Pesach, Chanukah and Purim, so that their emunah stays strong.
Stories
-
3:32 The Sanzer Rav at a wedding in Oberland
The Sanzer Rav, the Divrei Chaim, came with great honor to Oberland, a part of Hungary with an Ashkenazi, non-Chassidic population. There he spoke with the father of the chasan and asked whether he remembered when the boy was born. The father recalled that he had found the child in a river, taken pity on him and adopted him. The Sanzer Rav revealed that the chasan was in fact the kallah's brother, who had been kidnapped as a child, and this was confirmed by a mark on his body. The Sanzer Rav explained that in Oberland they did not know there is a Ribono shel Olam, and he had come to sanctify Hashem's name there.
In the story: the Divrei Chaim (Rabbi Chaim of Sanz)
Insights
- 7:01 Oil makes no sound when it is poured, unlike water or wine, and so Hashem's 'oil', His miracles, His tzaddikim and the good deeds of every Jew, works quietly and in hiding.
- 8:15 Just as a drop of water poured into a full glass of oil pushes out a drop of oil, a word of foolishness that a person says or hears pushes out a drop of Torah.
- 16:01 The Rambam's Moshiach, who shows no wonders but draws the whole people after him and brings them to Eretz Yisrael, is greater than a wonder-working Moshiach, since moving every heart is the greatest miracle.
- 31:06 Following the Yismach Moshe, the first 'ad ya'avor' in the pasuk carries Hashem's Name and so could not be lost, while the second does not, which is why sin could hold back the miracles of the Second Beis Hamikdash.
- 33:04 The Chanukah light is lit below ten tefachim, in the public domain, at night, in the darkest season, because Moshiach will come down to the lowest place of the Jewish people and lift them from there.
- 37:56 The Mashgiach reads 'alamos' in the pasuk as coming from 'he'elem', concealment: the fragrance of the old miracles is what keeps Jews loving Hashem even when He hides His face.
What the Mashgiach says to take from it
- 1:41 The Mashgiach says that whoever wants to merit holiness must keep it hidden and not display it, and one need not publicize a person's good deeds.
- 3:04 He adds that one must use judgment, since sometimes revealing is needed to arouse others or to sanctify Hashem's name.
- 39:52 The Mashgiach says Jews must remember the miracles of Yetzias Mitzrayim, Chanukah and Purim so that their emunah stays strong and bright even in times of concealment.
Mentioned in this shiur
People Avraham Avinu, Dovid HaMelech, Elisha HaNavi, Ezra HaSofer, Gechazi, Moshe Rabbeinu, Nechemiah, Rabbi Aharon of Karlin (Rabbi Aharon HaGadol), Rabbi Shimon bar Yochai, Rashi, the Divrei Chaim (Rabbi Chaim of Sanz), the Ohr HaChaim HaKadosh, the Raavad, the Rambam, the Yismach Moshe, Yaakov Avinu, Yosef HaTzaddik
Terms בחזקת משיח, הסתר פנים, למטה מעשרה, מקום המקדש, נ' שערי טומאה, סטרא אחרא, פקידה, פרסומי ניסא, צניעות, רשות הרבים, שם הוי"ה, תקופת טבת