סעודת הודאה

צריכים להודות לה' על כל נשימה ונשימה (צוואת יסוד ושורש העבודה)

Catalog entry: שונות no. ⁨8⁩ Pocket Guide p. 35 תשס"ח (2007–08) Yiddish 52 min

Listen

  1. Download · Length 52 min

Open in the listening app

Notes Notes prepared by AI from the recording; not reviewed, and not the Mashgiach's words. The recording is the source.

About this shiur

At a seudas hodaah in Kislev, the Mashgiach teaches that a Jew must thank Hashem for every breath and every small detail, drawing on the will of the author of Yesod V'Shoresh HaAvodah, and ends with the special thanks of a Jewish mother.

The Mashgiach opens with Kislev as the month of hodaah, the Chanukah days set for Hallel and thanks. He explains Modim d'Rabbanan, where we thank Hashem for putting into our hearts the wish to thank Him, and the four people who must thank. From Dovid Hamelech's closing words, 'kol haneshamah', he learns that one must thank for every breath. He then reads from the will at the end of Yesod V'Shoresh HaAvodah, whose author thanked Hashem aloud for a private room, warm clothes, a snuffbox that did not spill and glasses that did not break, and calls this an exercise in emunah. The four who must thank are only examples for the wise man to learn from; two of the ten must be rabbanan, because the second finds what the first left out. He applies this to the seudah, to the beis medrash and to Kislev, and ends with the mother's mesirus nefesh, the hidden heart of the miracle, and Leah's thanks for a child.

Topics: Thanks and Praise to Hashem · Hashgacha Pratis · Miracles and Nature

Order of the shiur

  1. 0:00 Kislev, Modim and the four who must thank

    The Mashgiach opens the seudas hodaah by calling Kislev the month of hodaah, explains Rashi on Modim d'Rabbanan that we thank Hashem for letting us thank, and asks why the Gemara gives the congregation its own text at Modim. He then brings the four who must thank and the rule that the thanks be said before ten, two of them rabbanan.

  2. 6:10 Thanks for every breath; the will of Yesod V'Shoresh HaAvodah listed in the guide

    From the end of Tehillim, 'kol haneshamah', the Mashgiach learns that one must thank for every breath. He introduces the author of Yesod V'Shoresh HaAvodah, whose avodah the Chozeh of Lublin praised, and his will, written to teach his children rather than to boast.

  3. 9:50 Reading the will: thanks for each small kindness listed in the guide

    The Mashgiach reads one item after another from the will: the author's thanks for a private room for avodah, for news of his children's health, for Shabbos clothes, a warm winter coat, answering Kedushah, having a needed item and the money for it, and for a fallen snuffbox, bottle and glasses that did not break. He calls this an exercise in emunah and adds that one must thank even when a shoelace does not tear.

    1. 9:50 A room, a letter, Shabbos clothes, a coat : The author thanks Hashem for a private room for learning and davening, for a letter saying his children are well, for fine Shabbos clothes, and for a warm coat each time he puts it on.
    2. 15:14 Kedushah, a needed item, a forgotten thing : He thanks for being able to answer Kedushah despite his long Shemoneh Esrei, for having a needed item and the money to buy even a small thing, and for remembering something forgotten before setting out.
    3. 19:20 Things that fell and did not break : He thanks when his snuffbox falls without spilling, a bottle is caught before it falls, and his glasses fall without breaking. The Mashgiach explains this as an exercise in emunah in hashgachah pratis and says one must thank even for a shoelace that does not tear.
  4. 22:18 The four are only examples: hidden daily miracles listed in the guide

    The Mashgiach explains that the four who must thank are only headings: Hashem does great wonders 'alone', hidden ones no one sees. He describes the body's many systems, more delicate than a car of steel, and says that 'mi chacham' teaches a wise man to learn from the four to everything.

  5. 26:42 Why two rabbanan, and why Modim d'Rabbanan

    The Mashgiach asks why two of the ten must be rabbanan and answers that the second chacham shows that after the first has finished there is still more to thank for, as Nishmas says. With this he answers his opening question: for hodaah the chazzan's words are not enough, so each one says Modim d'Rabbanan.

  6. 31:31 Korban todah, seudas hodaah and tonight's simcha

    Without a Beis Hamikdash, the seudas hodaah takes the place of the korban todah. The Mashgiach brings the mefarshim on why the todah is eaten only for a day and a night: to bring more people and spread the thanks. He then names tonight's thanks for a child who came home well, to the doctors' wonder.

  7. 34:46 Thanks for the beis medrash and for every toothpick

    The Mashgiach says the chaburah must thank Hashem for a beis medrash of serious ovdei Hashem with a warm, good davening, rare in today's cold times, and should use that gift. As Kislev comes, he urges taking on to thank for every detail, even a toothpick, as a fruit of emunah, hashgachah pratis and bitachon.

  8. 41:25 Thanking mothers: the hidden heart of the miracle

    The Mashgiach praises the Oberland custom of thanking the mother after a meal and brings the Gemara that Leah was the first to thank Hashem. Through the Rashbam, that women were the main cause of the miracle, and Tosafos' question on him, he explains that the women's mesirus nefesh in Mitzrayim was the hidden heart of the redemption while Moshe and Aharon led openly.

  9. 47:20 Leah's thanks for a child; closing brachah

    The Mashgiach explains that Leah, who already had three children, thanked for another as a mother building Klal Yisroel, a new kind of thanks; such is a mother's devotion at her child's hospital bed. He ties this to Chanukah, then blesses that all Jews thank Hashem together at the redemption, when even the galus will be understood as kindness.

The shiur, written up

Kislev, Modim and the four who must thank

0:44

The Mashgiach opens by calling Kislev the month of hodaah, thanksgiving, since the Chanukah days were set, as the Braisa says, for Hallel and thanks. At Modim d'Rabbanan, he notes, Rashi explains that we thank Hashem for putting into our hearts the wish to thank Him. Everything that happens to a person, large or small, comes from Hashem, and thanking Him opens the gates to still more reasons to thank. a,c

3:44

He then asks why the Gemara gives the congregation its own text at Modim, when for every other blessing answering amen to the chazzan is enough. He brings the four who must thank and the rule that the thanks be said before ten, two of them rabbanan. b,d,f

Thanks for every breath

6:42

Tehillim ends with 'kol haneshamah', which Chazal expound to mean that one must thank Hashem for every single breath. The Mashgiach then introduces the will at the end of Yesod V'Shoresh HaAvodah. The Chozeh of Lublin said its author's avodah was precious in Heaven, and the author asks his children to believe he writes not to boast but to teach them. g,h,i

Reading the will: thanks for each small kindness

11:19

The Mashgiach reads from the will item after item. The author thanked Hashem many times a day for having a private room for his avodah, which the Mashgiach calls a great thing in those days, a place to learn and daven undisturbed. He thanked when a letter came that his children were well, for fine clothes in honor of Shabbos while greater tzaddikim had none, and every time he put on his warm winter coat. i

15:14

Because he davened a long Shemoneh Esrei he usually missed Kedushah, so when he did manage to answer he thanked Hashem in his thoughts. He thanked when he needed even a small thing and had both the item and the money for it, and when he remembered something he had forgotten before setting out.

19:31

When his snuffbox fell and did not spill, when a bottle was caught before it hit the floor, and when his glasses fell without breaking, he said a set thanks to Hashem. The Mashgiach explains that this is more than thanks: it is an exercise in emunah, knowing that nothing happens by chance and everything comes with hashgachah pratis. He adds that one must thank even when a shoelace holds and does not tear.

The four are only examples

22:34

The four who must thank, the Mashgiach explains, are only headings. Hashem 'does great wonders alone', which Chazal read to mean that only He knows of them. He describes the body's many systems, each linked to thousands of tiny parts, and notes that even a car of steel needs constant repair, yet a person passes a day in health; that is a daily miracle. 'Mi chacham' teaches that a wise man learns from the four to everything. j,l

Why two rabbanan, and why Modim d'Rabbanan

27:04

The Mashgiach asks why exactly two of the ten must be rabbanan. A simple man will not think of all the hidden kindnesses, so a chacham must list them; then a second chacham finds still more, proving that hodaah is never finished, as Nishmas says that even a mouth full of song could not thank enough for one. m

30:23

This answers his opening question: for other blessings the chazzan's words suffice, but for hodaah one is never enough, so each person adds Modim d'Rabbanan.

Korban todah and tonight's simcha

31:35

Without a Beis Hamikdash, a seudas hodaah with songs of praise stands in for the korban todah. The Mashgiach brings the mefarshim on why the todah, unlike other shelamim, is eaten for only a day and a night: so that the owner must invite more people and the miracle becomes known more widely. He then names tonight's thanks for a child who came home, to the doctors' wonder.

Thanks for the beis medrash and for every toothpick

35:01

The Mashgiach says the chaburah must also thank Hashem for its beis medrash, a group of serious ovdei Hashem by today's standards, known in town for a good, warm davening. Before the war such a group might have been laughed at, but in a time of coldness and frost in avodah, a warm corner in Boro Park is a rare gift. He asks that it last until Moshiach comes.

39:04

Having thanked for it, one should use the gift and say Pesukei d'Zimra with feeling so it leaves an impression on the whole day. With Kislev coming, he urges taking on to thank Hashem for every detail, even a toothpick when needed, which surely the author of Yesod V'Shoresh HaAvodah did. Such thanks is a fruit of emunah, hashgachah pratis and bitachon. i

Thanking mothers: the hidden heart of the miracle

41:47

Parents, too, must be thanked. The Mashgiach calls the Oberland custom of kissing one's mother's hand after a meal very beautiful. He brings the Gemara that no one thanked Hashem before Leah, though Adam HaRishon said 'tov lehodos'; a mother's thanks is a different kind. p,q,r

43:47

Women are obligated in Chanukah lights since they too were in the miracle, and the Rashbam says they were its main cause; Tosafos asks why the Gemara then says 'too'. The Mashgiach answers that Moshe and Aharon led openly, but the righteous women who bore children with mesirus nefesh were the hidden heart of the redemption. s,t,u

Leah's thanks for a child; closing brachah

48:06

Leah already had three children, yet she thanked for another, knowing she was building Klal Yisroel; such a mother's thanks for a child had not existed since creation. The Mashgiach sees the same devotion in mothers who give up Shabbosim to stay by a child in hospital.

51:00

He closes with a brachah that all Jews together thank Hashem at the redemption, when they will understand that even the galus was a kindness. x

Sources

Torah

  1. q Bereishis 29:35 text index In the write-up: 41:47

Nevi'im

  1. x Yeshayahu 12:1 text index In the write-up: 51:00

Kesuvim

  1. f Tehillim 107:32 text index In the write-up: 3:44
  2. g Tehillim 150:6 text index In the write-up: 6:42
  3. j Tehillim 136:4 text index In the write-up: 22:34
  4. l Tehillim 107:43 text index In the write-up: 22:34
  5. n Tehillim 107:8 32:38 text index
  6. r Tehillim 92:1-2 text index In the write-up: 41:47
  7. v Tehillim 128:3 44:39 text index

Talmud Bavli

  1. a Shabbos 21b text index In the write-up: 0:44
  2. b Sotah 40a text index In the write-up: 3:44
  3. d Berachos 54b text index In the write-up: 3:44
  4. o Taanis 2a 35:50 text index
  5. p Berachos 7b text index In the write-up: 41:47
  6. s Shabbos 23a text index In the write-up: 43:47

Midrash

  1. h apparently Bereishis Rabbah 14:9 index In the write-up: 6:42

Rishonim

  1. c apparently Rashi on Sotah 40a index In the write-up: 0:44
  2. t apparently Rashbam on Pesachim 108b index In the write-up: 43:47
  3. u apparently Tosafos on Megillah 4a index In the write-up: 43:47

Acharonim and Chassidus

  1. e apparently Shulchan Aruch Orach Chaim 219 5:06 index
  2. i apparently Yesod V'Shoresh HaAvodah, Tzava'ah index In the write-up: 6:42, 11:19, 39:04
  3. w Bnei Yissaschar (place not identified) 49:34 index

Tefillah and Piyut

  1. k apparently Shemoneh Esrei, blessing of Modim 23:11 index
  2. m apparently Nishmas Kol Chai index In the write-up: 27:04

Key points

  1. 2:05 Since everything that happens to a person comes from Hashem with hashgachah pratis, he must thank Him for every pleasure, large or small.
  2. 6:42 The verse 'kol haneshamah' teaches, as Chazal expound it, that one must thank Hashem for every single breath.
  3. 8:38 The will of Yesod V'Shoresh HaAvodah shows a Jew who thanked Hashem aloud, with joy, for each small kindness of his day.
  4. 22:34 The four who must thank are only headings; a wise man learns from them that there are hidden miracles every day, beginning with the workings of the body.
  5. 28:37 Hodaah is never finished, which is why two of the ten at a seudas hodaah must be rabbanan and why everyone adds his own Modim d'Rabbanan.
  6. 43:58 The hidden heart of the miracles of Yetzias Mitzrayim and Chanukah was the mesirus nefesh of righteous women, and a mother's thanks for a child is a thanks of its own kind.

Questions and answers

  1. Question: 3:44 Why does the Gemara give the congregation its own text at Modim, when for every other blessing answering amen to the chazzan suffices?

    Answer: 30:28 With hodaah one person's words are never enough; just as a seudas hodaah needs several rabbanan, each one must add his own thanks.

  2. Question: 27:04 Why must exactly two of the ten at a seudas hodaah be rabbanan?

    Answer: 28:14 The first shows what one must thank for, and the second shows that after the first has finished there is still more to thank for.

  3. Question: 32:19 Why is the korban todah eaten only for a day and a night, when other shelamim are eaten for two days?

    Answer: 32:54 So that the owner must call more people to eat it, and more people hear of the miracle.

  4. Question: 44:14 The Rashbam says women were the main cause of the miracle; why then does the Gemara say 'they too' were part of it, as Tosafos asks?

    Answer: 46:03 Outwardly the leaders, like Moshe and Aharon, are the main figures, but the hidden heart of the miracle was the women's mesirus nefesh.

Stories

  1. 11:19 The author of Yesod V'Shoresh HaAvodah thanks for small things

    In his will, the author of Yesod V'Shoresh HaAvodah tells his children how he thanked Hashem aloud and with joy. He thanked many times a day for a private room for his avodah, and every time he put on his warm winter coat. When his snuffbox fell and did not spill, when a bottle was caught before it hit the ground, and when his glasses fell and did not break, he said a thanks to Hashem in set words.

Insights

  1. 1:35 Following Rashi, the Mashgiach explains that in Modim d'Rabbanan we thank Hashem for the very ability to thank, and that thanking arouses heaven and opens the gates of more thanks.
  2. 20:50 Thanking Hashem for every detail is not only thanks; it is an exercise in emunah, training a person to see that nothing happens by chance.
  3. 28:14 The second rabbi at a seudas hodaah is required to show that hodaah has no end: after one chacham has finished listing reasons to thank, another still finds more.
  4. 3:21 Modim d'Rabbanan is assembled from the versions of many rabbanan, because with hodaah one person's words, even the chazzan's, can never suffice.
  5. 32:54 The korban todah's short eating time was meant to force its owner to invite more people, so that more would hear of the kindness.
  6. 46:03 The Mashgiach resolves Tosafos' question on the Rashbam by distinguishing the open leaders of a miracle from its hidden cause: Moshe and Aharon led, but the righteous women's mesirus nefesh was the hidden heart of the redemption.
  7. 48:10 Leah's thanks was new in the world because it was a mother's thanks for a child, born of her devotion to building Klal Yisroel.

What the Mashgiach says to take from it

  1. 21:58 The Mashgiach says one must thank Hashem for every small thing, even a shoelace that does not tear.
  2. 22:57 He says a person should reflect at night before sleeping on what miracles happened to him that day.
  3. 39:04 He urges the chaburah to use the gift of a warm beis medrash, saying Pesukei d'Zimra with feeling so that it leaves an impression on the whole day.
  4. 39:58 With Kislev coming, he says to take on thanking Hashem for every detail, saying one can grow used to it.
  5. 41:56 He calls the custom of thanking one's mother after a meal very beautiful, since a mother gives of herself for her children.

Mentioned in this shiur

People Adam HaRishon, Aharon HaKohen, Avraham Avinu, Daniel, Dovid HaMelech, Esther HaMalkah, Leah Imeinu, Moshe Rabbeinu, Rashi, Sarah Imeinu, the Baalei Tosafos, the Chozeh of Lublin, the Rashbam, Yehudis

Terms הודאה, השגחה פרטית, מסירות נפש, נשים צדקניות, קרבן תודה, רבונו של עולם

Report an error on this page