Mamed Technology 01 Mashgiach
Catalog entry: שונות no. 45 Yiddish 22 min
Not in the 2012 Pocket Guide; the title is taken from the file name.
Listen
About this shiur
The Mashgiach applies the Gemara's rule that one who takes a path of temptation when another path exists is called a rasha to the use of smartphones, and teaches that the whole Torah turns on obeying the Sages of each generation.
The Mashgiach opens with the passuk in Yeshaya praising one who shuts his eyes from seeing evil, and the Gemara that applies it to a man who passes women washing clothes at the river. If he had another road and chose this one, Rashbam says he is a rasha even if he closes his eyes; only when there is no other way may he go. The Mashgiach applies this to a smartphone: if business truly requires it, he may use it with great care, but if a plain phone with a hechsher would do, he earns that title. He then turns to the obligation to obey the Sages of every generation: the Rambam and the passuk 'al pi haTorah', the Gemara in Eruvin, and the Gemara in Berachos on eating before Maariv. Shaarei Teshuvah explains that disobeying the Sages comes from belittling them. This, he says, is the axis of the Torah, the middle passuk of Devarim. The story of Shlomo HaMelech shows the danger of relying on oneself; one who submits to the Sages gains Hashem's help against the yetzer hara.
Topics: Technology and the Internet · Hiskashrus to Tzaddikim and Emunas Chachamim · Shmiras Einayim · The Yetzer Hara and Nisyonos
Order of the shiur
-
0:00 Shutting the eyes, and the smartphone listed in the guide
The Mashgiach brings the passuk in Yeshaya and the Gemara about a man passing women washing clothes at the river: if he had another road, Rashbam calls him a rasha even if he does not look. He applies this to a smartphone: one who truly needs it for business may use it with care, but if a plain phone with a hechsher would do, he earns that title.
-
6:23 The mitzvah to obey the Sages of each generation
The Mashgiach brings the Rambam on the passuk 'al pi haTorah', that one must obey not only the Great Sanhedrin but the Sages of every generation, including their fences and enactments. He adds the Gemara in Eruvin on 'chadashim gam yeshanim' and the Gemara in Berachos on eating before Maariv, and asks why that carries such a severe liability.
-
13:04 Shaarei Teshuvah: disobedience as contempt
The Mashgiach brings Shaarei Teshuvah, that one who disobeys the Sages does so because he belittles them and thinks he knows better, like the rebellious elder. He concludes that submitting to the Sages is the axis of the whole Torah, and notes that the middle passuk of Sefer Devarim is 'al pi haTorah'.
-
16:55 Shlomo HaMelech and help against the yetzer hara
The Mashgiach tells how Shlomo HaMelech relied on himself regarding the limit on a king's wives, and the yud of 'yarbeh' complained before the Kisei HaKavod. He explains that one who keeps the Torah as the Sages direct is guarded by Heaven against the yetzer hara, while one who belittles them loses that help, and closes with the blessing of long days for those who follow the Sages.
The shiur, written up
Shutting the eyes, and the smartphone
The Mashgiach opens with the passuk in Yeshaya that praises one who shuts his eyes from seeing evil, and the Gemara in Bava Basra that applies it to a man whose road runs along a river where women wash clothes. Rashbam explains that if he could have taken another road, he is a rasha even though he does not look. Only when there is no other way, since a person must go to daven, to learn and to do business, may he walk there and turn his eyes away. a,b,c
The Mashgiach applies this to a smartphone. One who needs it for business and has no other way may use it, but must take great care not to look around out of curiosity. If a plain phone with a hechsher would serve him, he earns the title Chazal give in that Gemara.
The mitzvah to obey the Sages of each generation
The Mashgiach then brings the Rambam in Hilchos Mamrim on the passuk 'al pi haTorah' in Devarim: it is a mitzvah to obey the Sages, not only the Great Sanhedrin in the Lishkas HaGazis but the Sages of later generations, even in the time of exile. This includes the fences and enactments they make when their time requires it. d,e
He adds the Gemara in Eruvin on the passuk 'chadashim gam yeshanim' in Shir HaShirim, which says that one who transgresses the words of the Sages is liable to death, and the same Gemara in Berachos about eating before Maariv. As Rashi writes on 'al pi haTorah', one must listen even when they seem to say that right is left. The Mashgiach then asks why such a severe liability applies. f,g,j,k
Shaarei Teshuvah: disobedience as contempt
To answer, the Mashgiach brings Shaarei Teshuvah: one who disobeys the Sages is not overcome by desire; he belittles them and thinks he understands better, like the rebellious elder. Submitting to the Sages, the Mashgiach says, is the axis of the whole Torah, and the Masorah notes that the middle passuk of Sefer Devarim is 'al pi haTorah'. l,m,e
Shlomo HaMelech and help against the yetzer hara
The Torah in Devarim limits a king's wives so that they not turn his heart. Shlomo HaMelech took a thousand, sure they would not sway him, and the yud of 'yarbeh' rose before the Kisei HaKavod to complain. The Mashgiach notes that the Arizal explains his intent was for the sake of Heaven. n
The yetzer hara grows stronger every day, as the Gemara in Kiddushin says, and only Hashem's help saves a person. One who keeps the Torah as the Sages direct has that help; one who belittles them loses it. The Mashgiach closes with the blessing of long days in Devarim for those who heed the Sages. o,q
Sources
Torah
Nevi'im
Kesuvim
Talmud Bavli
Rishonim
- c apparently Rashbam on Bava Basra 57b index In the write-up: 0:36
- d Rambam, Hilchos Mamrim (place not identified) index In the write-up: 6:23
- h Rashi (place not identified) 9:18 index
- k apparently Rashi on Devarim 17:11 index In the write-up: 9:02
- l apparently Shaarei Teshuvah, Shaar 3 index In the write-up: 13:04
Other
- m Masorah (place not identified) In the write-up: 13:04
Key points
- 2:20 One who walks a road of temptation when he could have taken another road is called a rasha, even if he shuts his eyes and does not look.
- 4:22 The Mashgiach applies this to a smartphone: one who truly needs it for business may use it with care, but one who could manage with a plain phone with a hechsher falls under that title.
- 7:13 There is a mitzvah to obey the Sages of every generation, not only the Great Sanhedrin, including the fences and enactments they make for their time.
- 13:04 According to Shaarei Teshuvah, one who disobeys the Sages does so out of belittling them, and that is why Chazal treat it so severely.
- 15:14 Submitting to the Sages of the generation is the axis around which the whole Torah turns.
- 19:13 One who follows the Sages is helped by Hashem against the yetzer hara, while one who belittles them loses that help.
Questions and answers
-
Question: 2:12 In what case does the Gemara call one who shuts his eyes on the river path a rasha?
Answer: 2:20 When he could have taken another road; if there is no other way, he may walk there and must turn his eyes away.
-
Question: 12:53 Why does Chazal impose such a severe liability on one who transgresses the words of the Sages, such as eating before Maariv?
Answer: 13:04 Shaarei Teshuvah explains that such disobedience comes from belittling the Sages and thinking he knows better, which resembles the rebellious elder.
-
Question: 19:21 How can a person stand up to the yetzer hara, which grows stronger against him every day?
Answer: 20:00 Hashem helps one who is firm in emunah and yiras Shamayim and follows the Sages, so the yetzer hara cannot overcome him.
Stories
-
17:34 Shlomo HaMelech and the yud of 'yarbeh'
The Torah limits how many wives a king may take, so that they not turn his heart away from the Torah. Shlomo HaMelech, as the passuk relates, took a thousand wives, confident that he was master over his yetzer hara and that they would not sway him. The yud of the word 'yarbeh' came up before the Kisei HaKavod and complained that Shlomo was uprooting it. Hashem answered that Shlomo and a thousand like him would pass away, but not one letter of the Torah. The Mashgiach notes that the Arizal explains Shlomo's intent was for the sake of Heaven, but does not go into it here.
In the story: Shlomo HaMelech, the Arizal
Insights
- 3:36 The Mashgiach reads the Gemara's case of the river path as a model for technology: whether a smartphone is permitted depends on whether there is truly no other way.
- 2:48 Not looking is not enough: Chazal's harsh title falls on the choice to enter the test needlessly, even if he passes it.
- 12:53 Following Shaarei Teshuvah, the Mashgiach explains that the severity of disobeying a rabbinic enactment, such as eating before Maariv, lies not in the act but in the contempt for the Sages behind it.
- 16:02 The Mashgiach finds a hint that obeying the Sages is the center of the Torah in the Masorah's note that the middle passuk of Sefer Devarim is 'al pi haTorah'.
- 20:22 The Mashgiach ties Hashem's help against the yetzer hara to submission to the Sages: one who belittles them loses that help, and then the yetzer hara truly is stronger than him.
What the Mashgiach says to take from it
- 4:25 The Mashgiach says that one who truly needs a smartphone for business may use it, but must take great care not to look at what he should not and not to browse out of curiosity.
- 5:35 The Mashgiach says that if a plain phone with a hechsher is enough for one's needs, one must use that and not a smartphone.
- 21:30 The Mashgiach says one must submit to the guidance of the rabbonim and the Sages who lead the generation.
Mentioned in this shiur
People Rashi, Shlomo HaMelech, the Arizal, the Rambam, the Rashbam
Terms זקן ממרא, יצר הרע, כסא הכבוד, לשכת הגזית, סייעתא דשמיא