ברית מילה
Bris Milah (Vayetzei)
Catalog entry: Simchos ויצא no. 10 Yiddish 13 min
Not in the 2012 Pocket Guide; the title is taken from the file name.
Listen
About this shiur
At a bris in the week of Parshas Vayetzei, the Mashgiach explains why Yosef was born circumcised and Yehuda was not: milah shows that a person can perfect himself, which is the path of teshuvah of Yehuda and Moshiach ben David.
The Mashgiach notes that this week's parsha tells of the births of Yehuda and Yosef, the roots of the two Meshichim. Yosef was born circumcised and Yehuda was not, though Moshiach ben David is higher. He answers with the Chinuch: milah shows that man is created incomplete and can perfect himself. There are two paths, the tzaddik who never sinned, Yosef, the 'tzaddik yesod olam', and the baal teshuvah, Yehuda, from whom comes David, who taught teshuvah. So Yehuda was born with an orlah, to perfect himself. He then brings a vort that most fruits lose their status when crushed, while grapes and wheat rise to wine and bread. With this he explains why Malki-tzedek, born circumcised, consoled Avraham with bread and wine: they show that what is crushed can be raised. He closes with blessings that the child carry both qualities.
Topics: Bris Milah · Moshiach ben Yosef and Moshiach ben Dovid · Teshuvah
Order of the shiur
-
0:00 Why Yosef was born circumcised and Yehuda not listed in the guide
The Mashgiach asks why Yosef, root of Moshiach ben Yosef, was born circumcised while Yehuda, root of the higher Moshiach ben David, was not. With the Chinuch's reason for milah he explains that Yosef is the tzaddik who never sinned, while Yehuda and David stand for teshuvah, a person perfecting himself.
-
3:13 Malki-tzedek's bread and wine, and blessings listed in the guide
The Mashgiach brings a vort that grapes and wheat, unlike other fruits, are raised when crushed into wine and bread. With it he explains that Malki-tzedek, born circumcised, consoled Avraham with bread and wine to show that one can repair oneself, ties this to the two Meshichim, and blesses the child to carry both their qualities.
The shiur, written up
Why Yosef was born circumcised and Yehuda not
The Mashgiach asks why Yosef, root of Moshiach ben Yosef, was born circumcised while Yehuda, root of the higher Moshiach ben David, was not. Following the Chinuch, milah shows that a person can perfect himself. Yosef is the tzaddik who never sinned; Yehuda, through David, stands for teshuvah, so he was born with an orlah to repair himself. a
Malki-tzedek's bread and wine, and blessings
The Mashgiach brings a vort: most fruits lose their status when crushed, but grapes become wine and wheat, ground and baked, becomes bread, both raised to a higher blessing.
Sources
Torah
Kesuvim
Talmud Bavli
Midrash
- b Midrash (place not identified) 1:13
Rishonim
Key points
- 0:18 Yosef, root of Moshiach ben Yosef, was born circumcised, while Yehuda, root of the higher Moshiach ben David, was not.
- 1:07 Following the Chinuch, milah shows that a person is created incomplete and can perfect himself.
- 2:05 Yosef represents the tzaddik who never sinned, and Yehuda, through David, represents teshuvah.
- 3:57 Wine and bread show that what is crushed and worked can be raised to a higher level.
- 5:06 Malki-tzedek, born circumcised, could not show Avraham from milah that one can repair oneself, so he brought bread and wine.
Questions and answers
-
Question: 0:45 Moshiach ben David is higher than Moshiach ben Yosef, so why was Yosef born circumcised and not Yehuda?
Answer: 1:07 Milah shows that a person can perfect himself; Yehuda's path is teshuvah, so he was born with an orlah to repair himself, while Yosef is the tzaddik who never sinned.
-
Question: 4:45 Why did Malki-tzedek greet Avraham with bread and wine?
Answer: 5:30 To console him that a person can repair himself; since Malki-tzedek was born circumcised he could not show this from milah, so he showed it from bread and wine, which rise through being crushed.
Insights
- 2:08 Yehuda was not born circumcised precisely because his path is teshuvah: the orlah left for a person to remove is what milah teaches, that man perfects himself.
- 3:57 Grapes and wheat, unlike other fruits, gain a higher blessing when crushed and worked, a sign that being broken can raise a person.
- 5:06 Malki-tzedek, himself born circumcised, could not use milah as proof that one can repair oneself, so he brought bread and wine to console Avraham.
- 5:44 Moshiach ben David embodies teaching teshuvah, and Moshiach ben Yosef the tzaddik who is the foundation of the world.
Mentioned in this shiur
People Avraham Avinu, Dovid HaMelech, Malki-Tzedek, Rashi, Yehudah (son of Yaakov), Yosef HaTzaddik
Terms משיח בן יוסף, נולד מהול, ערלה, צדיק