פדיון הבן
Pidyon Haben (Vaeara)
Catalog entry: Simchos וארא no. 60 Yiddish 14 min
Not in the 2012 Pocket Guide; the title is taken from the file name.
Listen
About this shiur
At a pidyon haben, the Mashgiach explains that holiness hidden in parents is revealed in their children, and that both havdalah and pidyon haben protect a place from which holiness has departed.
The Mashgiach opens with the Gemara on how many havdalos one says, where Rabbi Menachem bar Simai, called 'the son of holy ones', says only one. He was called this because he never looked at the image on a coin, and the Yerushalmi says he never did so at all, so he was born that way and drew the holiness from his parents. The Mashgiach explains with the Ramban on 'a root bearing gall and wormwood' that what is hidden in parents comes out openly in the children: his parents never thought about money, so their son would not even look at it. He then brings the Or HaChaim on why tumas ohel applies to Jews: where great holiness departed, the impure forces gather. Every motza'ei Shabbos the extra soul leaves, so people make three havdalos for protection, while Rabbi Menachem needed only one to fulfil the mitzvah. Finally he links pidyon haben to 'pedus' as separation, and blesses the family.
Order of the shiur
-
0:00 The 'son of holy ones' and inherited holiness
The Mashgiach brings the Gemara about Rabbi Menachem bar Simai, who never looked at the image on a coin, and asks why he is called 'son of holy ones'. Using the Ramban on 'a root bearing gall and wormwood', he explains that what is hidden in parents is revealed in their children.
-
5:55 Havdalah and the empty place left by Shabbos
The Mashgiach explains havdalah as protection against the forces of impurity when the extra soul of Shabbos departs, bringing the Or HaChaim on tumas ohel. Ordinary people make three havdalos, but Rabbi Menachem bar Simai needed only one, to fulfil the mitzvah.
-
10:22 Pidyon haben as a separation, and a brachah listed in the guide
The Mashgiach connects 'pedus' in the passuk to a separation between Jews and the nations, and explains that the firstborn must be redeemed because the holiness meant for him has departed. He closes by blessing the child that the holiness of his parents be revealed in him.
The shiur, written up
The 'son of holy ones' and inherited holiness
The Mashgiach opens with the Gemara on how many havdalos one says, where Rabbi Menachem bar Simai is called 'son of holy ones' because he never looked at the image on a coin. Why credit his parents? The Yerushalmi says he never looked at all, even as a child, so he was born that way and drew this holiness from his parents. a,c
Havdalah and the empty place left by Shabbos
The Or HaChaim on Chukas explains that tumas ohel applies to Jews because impurity gathers where great holiness departed, like flies around an emptied vessel. Every motza'ei Shabbos the extra soul leaves such a place, so people say three havdalos, drawing on the strength of three, to keep the harmful forces away. g
Rabbi Menachem bar Simai needed no such protection, only the mitzvah itself, so one havdalah sufficed for him.
Pidyon haben as a separation, and a brachah
'Pedus' in the passuk 'I will put a pedus between My people and your people' is read by the commentators as a separation between Jews and the nations. The firstborn's holiness has departed, so he is redeemed for protection. The Mashgiach blesses the child that his parents' holiness be revealed in him. i
Sources
Torah
Nevi'im
Talmud Bavli
Talmud Yerushalmi
Rishonim
Acharonim and Chassidus
Key points
- 3:05 Rabbi Menachem bar Simai never looked at the image on a coin, and since he never did so even as a child, his holiness came from his parents.
- 4:01 What is hidden and inward in the parents becomes openly revealed in the children.
- 6:58 A place from which great holiness has departed draws the forces of impurity, which is why tumas ohel applies to Jews.
- 8:13 Havdalah protects the place left empty when the extra soul of Shabbos departs; ordinary people say three havdalos, while Rabbi Menachem needed only one.
- 10:28 Pidyon haben is connected to 'pedus', which the commentators read as a separation, like havdalah, between Jews and the nations.
Questions and answers
-
Question: 1:32 Why is Rabbi Menachem bar Simai called 'son of holy ones', crediting his parents, if he himself was the holy one?
Answer: 3:05 He never looked at a coin's image even as a child, so his holiness was inborn from his parents; what was hidden in them was revealed in him.
-
Question: 8:36 Why may Rabbi Menachem bar Simai say only one havdalah, when others say three?
Answer: 8:57 Three havdalos protect against the forces that seek the place left by the departing extra soul; he was so holy that he needed none of that protection, only the mitzvah.
Insights
- 3:05 Since the Yerushalmi says Rabbi Menachem never looked at a coin's image at all, even as a child, his holiness was inborn, and so the title 'son of holy ones' credits his parents.
- 5:02 Because his parents were not taken up with money, as people are when making a shidduch, their son was born unable even to look at it.
- 8:04 The Or HaChaim's reason for tumas ohel among Jews, that impurity gathers where great holiness departed, applies in a small way every motza'ei Shabbos when the extra soul leaves.
- 9:23 Rabbi Menachem bar Simai said only one havdalah because, being so holy, he did not need havdalah's protection, only the mitzvah itself.
- 10:47 Pidyon haben is a kind of havdalah: the firstborn must be redeemed because the holiness of the bechor that should have been his has departed, leaving a place that needs protection.
Mentioned in this shiur
People Rabbi Menachem bar Simai, the Avos, the Ohr HaChaim HaKadosh, the Ramban
Terms הבדלה, טומאת מת, מזיקים, נשמה יתירה, פדיון הבן