ע"י הכנעה לתלמידי חכמים זוכים ליניקה משפע עליונה' והשפעה לפושעים ומורדים היא ע"י בחינת אחוריים.
Catalog entry: ספר התניא א' ב no. 9 Pocket Guide p. 41 Yiddish 45 min
Listen
About this shiur
The Mashgiach explains from Tanya chapter two that every Jew draws his life through bittul to the talmidei chachamim, while those who quarrel with them draw it only 'from behind', and that the parents' holiness shapes the body and its mazal but never the soul itself.
The Mashgiach continues Tanya chapter two: since all souls form one chain reaching up to Chochmah Ila'ah, even the simplest Jew must cleave to the talmid chacham, and through him to the Shechinah. He describes the order of the generation, like the banners in the desert, up to the tzaddik hador, revealed or hidden. Hachnaah is a foundation; a cup must be lower than the pitcher to receive. From Pharaoh he learns, with the Sfas Emes, that the sin is not wanting to be humble. Those who quarrel with talmidei chachamim still receive 'from behind', and their envy itself betrays a hidden bittul. He then explains why the parents' sanctity matters: they give the body, its mazal and nature, while Hashem gives the soul. Examples from Avraham, Dovid, Reb Shimon Yaroslaver and the influence of one's country show that a coarse body can be overcome, and that later generations have more refined bodies but smaller souls.
Topics: Hiskashrus to Tzaddikim and Emunas Chachamim · Anavah and Bittul · The Two Souls (Tanya ch. 1-8) · Levels and Root of the Soul
Order of the shiur
-
0:00 Cleaving to the talmid chacham listed in the guide
The Mashgiach reads the Tanya on cleaving to talmidei chachamim and explains that since all souls are one chain, the simple Jew is bound to Hashem through the talmid chacham. He describes the order of the generation, like the banners in the desert, up to the tzaddik hador, revealed or hidden.
-
5:12 Hachnaah as the root of receiving listed in the guide
The Mashgiach says one who does not respect tzaddikim tears himself from his source, and tells of a Rebbe whose concern, when a man did not stand for him, was for the man. He calls hachnaah a foundation, compares it to a cup below a pitcher, and learns from Pharaoh, with the Sfas Emes, that the real failing is not even wanting to be humble.
-
11:03 Receiving 'from behind' listed in the guide
The Mashgiach explains the Tanya's words that rebels and quarrelers draw from the talmidei chachamim 'from behind', within the order of giver and receiver that sustains all creation. Their hatred, he says, comes from envy: deep down they know the ehrlicher Jew is better, and that pain is itself a kind of hachnaah.
-
14:46 Why the parents' sanctity matters
The Mashgiach restates the Tanya's principle that the smallest soul is bound to Hashem like the greatest, then asks why the Zohar Chadash makes a child's greatness depend on the parents' thoughts. He answers with the Gemara's three partners: the parents give the body, Hashem gives the soul.
-
18:56 Mazal: the channel of the body's flow
The Mashgiach explains mazal as the star and channel through which bodily influence flows, from the word 'nozel', and with the Gemara of the angel who declares rich or poor, wise or foolish, strong or weak. He tells the Chofetz Chaim's answer about a poor man, and stresses that tzaddik or rasha is not declared.
-
27:31 A coarse body and a great soul
The Mashgiach explains that the parents also set the body's nature and refinement, as animals differ in temperament, so a child born in holiness finds avodas Hashem easier. Great tzaddikim had coarse bodies and worked through them, and he brings the Midrash that Avraham Avinu had the greatest soul and the lowest body.
-
31:02 Shaul and Dovid: measured by one's starting point
The Mashgiach brings the Gemara that Shaul was punished for one sin and Dovid not for two, and answers from the mekubalim that Dovid's body came from Lot's daughter, giving him a fierce yetzer hara that he killed. He adds Reb Shimon Yaroslaver's words about his father, and concludes that Heaven measures by what can be expected of a person.
-
34:58 The mazal of one's country
The Mashgiach reads 'Lech lecha me'artzecha' as leaving the mazal of one's land: a soul born outside Eretz Yisroel passes through the channel of that country's sar and its klipah. This explains why Jews from different countries cannot bear each other, and he compares it to entering a shul through the chimney, but says one can refine it, as Avraham did.
-
39:39 The garment of the soul
The Mashgiach reads the Tanya on the Zohar Chadash: the soul must be clothed in a garment from the parents, through which it does mitzvos and receives even material bounty, while the soul itself can be lofty even in a child of lowly parents, as with Dovid HaMelech. He ends that our bodies are more refined than earlier generations' though their souls were greater, which explains the sins recorded in Tanach.
The shiur, written up
Cleaving to the talmid chacham
The Mashgiach reads the Tanya on one who cleaves to talmidei chachamim, answering the Gemara's question how a person can cleave to the Shechinah. Since all souls form one chain up to Chochmah Ila'ah, the heel is bound to the head: the simple Jew cleaves to the talmid chacham, who cleaves to the Shechinah. a,b
Hachnaah as the root of receiving
One who disparages tzaddikim, the Mashgiach says, tears himself from his source and must draw from a foreign place. He tells of a Rebbe in Warsaw: when a man did not stand for him, his worry was what would pull that man out of Gehinnom.
Hachnaah, he says, is among the foundations the Ba'al Shem Tov set down. A cup held above the pitcher receives nothing, and one who bows before a tzaddik learns to bow before Hashem.
Receiving 'from behind'
The Mashgiach explains that rebels who quarrel with talmidei chachamim still draw from them, but from behind, without facing them, since all creation runs on giver and receiver. Their hatred is envy: deep down they know the ehrlicher Jew is better and cannot bear it, and that pain is itself a kind of hachnaah.
Why the parents' sanctity matters
Mazal: the channel of the body's flow
The Mashgiach explains mazal: each person has a star, a channel through which bodily influence flows, not the soul's. The Gemara says that before birth an angel declares rich or poor, wise or foolish, strong or weak. This is why, he notes, Even HaEzer advises marrying in the first half of the month, though this is no absolute rule. j,k
A coarse body and a great soul
The parents also set the body's nature, as animals differ by temperament. A child born in holiness finds avodas Hashem easy; otherwise it is like climbing a smooth wall. Great tzaddikim had coarse bodies and struggled through, and the Midrash says Avraham Avinu, with perhaps the greatest soul, had the lowest body. m
Shaul and Dovid
The Gemara says Shaul was punished for one sin and Dovid not for two. The mekubalim answer that Dovid's body came from Lot's daughter, giving him a fierce yetzer hara, which he killed until he could say 'my heart is hollow within me'. n,o
Reb Shimon Yaroslaver, whose father was coarse, said that had his father gone once to the mikveh, his avodah would have been easy. Heaven measures by what can be expected of a person.
The mazal of one's country
The Mashgiach reads 'Lech lecha me'artzecha' as leaving the mazal of one's land. A soul born outside Eretz Yisroel passes through the channel of that country's sar, and something of its klipah rubs off, as on one who enters a shul through the chimney. p
So when a Hungarian Jew hates a Polish one, it is the bit of 'goy' in each that hates. Yet it can be refined, as Reb Shimon Yaroslaver and Avraham Avinu did.
The garment of the soul
Returning to the Tanya on the Zohar Chadash, the Mashgiach explains that a soul must be clothed in a garment from the parents; through it a person does mitzvos and receives even material bounty. The soul itself can be lofty in a child of lowly parents, like Dovid HaMelech, descended from Moav. g,h
Parents are well advised to sanctify themselves for their child's sake. Our bodies, refined by generations of mesiras nefesh in galus, are better than earlier generations', though their souls were greater; this explains sins in Tanach that seem beyond us.
Sources
Torah
Kesuvim
Targum
Talmud Bavli
Midrash
- m Midrash (place not identified) In the write-up: 28:21
Zohar and Kabbalah
Rishonim
Acharonim and Chassidus
Other
Key points
- 0:51 Because all souls are linked in one chain, even the lowest must be bound to the talmid chacham, who is bound to the Shechinah.
- 4:41 Hachnaah, submitting to those greater than oneself, is the channel through which a person receives, as a cup must stand lower than what is poured into it.
- 11:20 Those who quarrel with talmidei chachamim still draw from them, but only 'from behind', without a face-to-face bond.
- 18:18 The parents give the body, its nature and its mazal; Hashem gives the soul, which does not depend on them.
- 29:15 A coarse body makes avodas Hashem harder but can be broken through, and Heaven judges a person by what can be expected of him.
- 35:38 Being born in a given country brings something of that country's nature onto a Jew's body, which he can refine.
Questions and answers
-
Question: 8:52 Pharaoh was not humble; why is he rebuked for 'refusing' to be humbled?
Answer: 9:11 Following the Sfas Emes: not being humble is one thing, but he did not even want to be; a Jew who fails still wants to, and that wish binds him to Hashem.
-
Question: 13:15 Why do the wicked hate talmidei chachamim so fiercely?
Answer: 12:58 Out of envy: deep down they know the ehrlicher Jew is better and cannot bear it.
-
Question: 17:18 If every soul is a part of G-d, why should a child's greatness depend on his parents' thoughts?
Answer: 18:11 The parents give only the body; Hashem gives the soul, which does not depend on them.
-
Question: 31:14 Why was Shaul punished for one sin while Dovid was not for two?
Answer: 31:58 Dovid's body came from a coarse root and carried a fierce yetzer hara, so his failings were judged against his background.
-
Question: 36:53 Why do Jews from different countries often cannot bear each other?
Answer: 37:18 Each carries a bit of 'goy' from his country's mazal; that part hates the other, not the Jew himself.
-
Question: 43:57 How could people in Tanach commit sins we would never commit?
Answer: 44:04 Our bodies have been refined by thousands of years of trials and mesiras nefesh, while they had greater souls but coarser bodies and stronger yetzer haras.
Stories
-
5:53 The man who did not stand up
A Rav known in Warsaw as a great gaon, whom everyone respected, later became a Rebbe. Once, walking in the street with his students, where people usually stood up for him, a man passed by and did not stand. The students were upset, but the Rebbe's concern was for the man: if he is not moved by a talmid chacham, what will pull him out of Gehinnom?
-
25:33 The Chofetz Chaim and the poor man
A poor man passed by the Chofetz Chaim, who gave him tzedakah. Someone objected that the man could work for a living. The Chofetz Chaim answered that when the angel declared him poor, his legs were filled with lead: he lacks the courage and energy, and it is not his fault.
In the story: the Chofetz Chaim
-
33:31 Reb Shimon Yaroslaver on his father
Reb Shimon Yaroslaver's father was a coarse, unlearned man, while Reb Shimon became a holy man. He said that had his father immersed in a mikveh even once before he was conceived, his avodah would have been far easier. He refined himself nonetheless.
In the story: Rabbi Shimon of Yaroslav
Insights
- 3:34 The order of the generation mirrors the banners in the desert: each Jew draws through his officer of ten, fifty and a hundred, up to the tzaddik hador, whether or not people know who he is.
- 9:05 Pharaoh's complaint 'until when do you refuse to be humbled' means, with the Sfas Emes, that failing to be humble is one thing, but not even wanting to be humble cuts the last thread; a desire to have a desire still binds a Jew to Hashem.
- 12:58 The resentment of the wicked toward an ehrlicher Jew is envy, born of knowing deep down that he is better; that very pain is a hidden form of hachnaah, which is how they still draw from him 'from behind'.
- 31:58 Dovid was not punished for sins for which Shaul was, because Dovid's body came from a coarse root through Lot's daughter, and Heaven measures a person against what can be expected of him.
- 37:18 When a Hungarian Jew hates a Polish Jew, it is the bit of 'goy' each absorbed from his country's mazal that hates, not the Jew himself.
- 43:16 Later generations have more refined bodies, purified by generations of mesiras nefesh in galus, though earlier generations had greater souls; this is why sins recorded in Tanach seem incomprehensible to us.
What the Mashgiach says to take from it
- 4:27 The Mashgiach says every simple Jew must be humble before talmidei chachamim greater than himself and bind himself to the tzaddik, whether or not he knows who he is.
- 42:55 The Mashgiach calls it good counsel for parents to sanctify themselves, to make things easier for their child by giving him a better body.
Mentioned in this shiur
People Avraham Avinu, Balak, Dovid HaMelech, Eglon, king of Moav, Lot, Pharaoh, Rabbi Shimon of Yaroslav, Rashi, Shaul HaMelech, the Baal Shem Tov, the Chofetz Chaim, the Ramak (Rabbi Moshe Cordovero), the Sfas Emes, Yishai
Terms אחוריים, הכנעה, חכמה עילאה, חלק אלוק ממעל, יניקה, לבושים, מזל, משפיע ומקבל, צדיק הדור, רבונו של עולם, תלמיד חכם