למצוא בדברי רשות נקודת אלקות' להשתמש בדברים גשמיים לשם שמים.
Catalog entry: ספר התניא א' ז no. 22 Pocket Guide p. 43 Yiddish 44 min
Listen
About this shiur
On Tanya chapter 7, the Mashgiach explains that permitted worldly things come from kelipas nogah and that a Jew can raise them to holiness by using them for the sake of Heaven, as Yitzchak found living water in the wells he dug.
The Mashgiach opens chapter 7 of Tanya: after showing that Torah and mitzvos clothe a person in holiness and sins clothe him in the sitra achra, the Alter Rebbe turns to permitted things. The animal soul of a Jew, kosher animals and permitted food come from kelipas nogah, a middle level that can tip either way. Eating, drinking and business are neutral in themselves; done for the sake of Heaven they rise to holiness, done for pleasure they fall to the kelipos. The world was created with the Torah, so every thing holds a point of G-dliness, and this is what Yitzchak's wells and Yaakov's sheep mean. Only a Jew can raise nogah. A plain person needs some pleasure, but with a measure each must judge for himself, as the Bnei Yissaschar explains. Pleasure taken for its own sake leaves a residue that needs chibut hakever, while forbidden things stay bound until the end of days.
Topics: Serving Hashem in Physical Life · Kedushah and Kelipah · The Two Souls (Tanya ch. 1-8)
Order of the shiur
-
0:00 Permitted things and kelipas nogah listed in the guide
The Mashgiach recalls the previous chapter, where Torah and mitzvos clothe a person in holiness and sins in the sitra achra, and introduces chapter 7 on permitted things. The animal soul of a Jew is from kelipas nogah, so permitted things are neutral and depend on intent, which he shows with matzah, chametz and bread with butter.
-
6:05 The Tanya text: a middle level in a mostly evil world listed in the guide
The Mashgiach reads the Tanya: the vital soul of a Jew, kosher animals and permitted plants, and every permitted deed, word and thought not done for Heaven draw their life from kelipas nogah. He explains nogah as a middle level, like a scale that can tip either way, and shows that this world is mostly evil with a little good mixed in.
-
13:32 Yitzchak's wells: finding G-dliness in the earth listed in the guide
The Mashgiach applies the idea to eating and business done to serve Hashem, then turns to the parsha's account of Yitzchak's wells. Since the world was created with the Torah, the world is the composition and the Torah its commentary, and digging wells means finding the point of G-dliness in earthly things; he connects the three wells to weekday and Shabbos.
-
19:55 Yaakov's sheep and Yitzchak's blessing listed in the guide
The Mashgiach contrasts a modern biography with the Torah's account of Yaakov tending sheep for twenty years; only one who learns with emunah knows these were not plain dealings. Yitzchak's wells were dug for all of Klal Yisroel, and his blessing of dew, fat of the land, grain and wine shows the Avos could enter material things and raise the holy sparks in them.
-
24:30 Business for Heaven; only a Jew raises nogah listed in the guide
Citing seforim on Noach and Vayetzei, the Mashgiach says that business done in holiness, honestly and to have money for Torah, mitzvos and tzedakah, raises kelipas nogah and can reach great heights. Only a Jew can do this; he brings the Midrash that a non-Jew offers only olos, while a Jew can eat shelamim for the sake of Heaven.
-
27:41 A person needs pleasure, with a measure listed in the guide
The Mashgiach reads the Tanya on eating fat meat and drinking wine to broaden the mind for Hashem and His Torah, and explains that a plain person who is hungry cannot learn or daven. He tells of a psychologist's example of feeding through a zipper and of Rebbe Nachum of Chernobyl, and concludes that great tzaddikim aside, one must take pleasure with a measure.
-
33:01 Kedoshim tihyu, oneg Shabbos and Rabbah's joke listed in the guide
The Mashgiach brings the Bnei Yissaschar on kedoshim tihyu and the Ramban's 'naval birshus haTorah': the Torah cannot fix how much to eat because people differ, so each must judge for himself. He adds that on Shabbos the pleasure itself is the mitzvah, and explains Rabbah's joke before the shiur as bringing the students into a good mood so the joke was absorbed into holiness.
-
37:47 Pleasure for its own sake, chibut hakever and forbidden things listed in the guide
The Mashgiach reads the Tanya: one who eats only for pleasure brings the food's vitality down temporarily into the three impure kelipos, but because it was kosher it rises again when he learns and davens with its strength. The imprint of the pleasure remains and needs chibut hakever, while forbidden things stay bound to the kelipos until the end of days when death and impurity are removed.
The shiur, written up
Permitted things and kelipas nogah
The Mashgiach recalls that in the previous chapter the Alter Rebbe showed that one who occupies himself with Torah and mitzvos is clothed entirely in holiness, and one who sins is clothed in the sitra achra. Chapter 7 now turns to permitted things. The animal soul of a non-Jew comes from the three wholly impure kelipos, but that of a Jew comes from kelipas nogah, a 'shining' husk that holiness can penetrate and that can be turned to good. a
Some say there is no 'davar reshus' at all, only mitzvah or sin. The Mashgiach explains that this is the meaning: the thing itself stands on the scale, and what one does with it decides. Eating matzah on Pesach is a mitzvah, chametz a sin, and bread with butter is permitted; eaten for Heaven's sake it turns to good, eaten for appetite it falls to the kelipos.
A middle level in a mostly evil world
Reading the Tanya, the Mashgiach explains that the vital soul of a Jew, clothed in his blood, draws from kelipas nogah, and so do kosher animals, permitted plants and every permitted deed, word and thought. A person has two souls, the G-dly and the animal; an animal has only one. A kosher animal's soul is from nogah because it may be eaten and elevated, while forbidden animals belong to the impure kelipos. a
Even what a person needs to live, if his intention is not for Heaven, is no better than the animal soul itself. Nogah is a middle level, like a scale that can tip to either side. This world is mostly evil with a little good mixed in: there are more animals than people, more impure animals than pure, more non-Jews than Jews, more wicked than tzaddikim. Yet whatever is not forbidden can be turned to good. a
Yitzchak's wells
The Mashgiach applies this to eating and to business. One who does business so he can serve the Ribono shel Olam, to have money for food, clothing, tuition for his children, a tallis, a lulav and tzedakah, brings it all into holiness; otherwise it goes into kelipas nogah. This, he says, is what the week's parsha, Toldos, shows in its long account of the wells Yitzchak dug and named. d
The world was created with the Torah, so every thing has Torah in it, not only a Gemara but business too. The Creator made a composition and a commentary on it: the world is the composition and the Torah its commentary. Digging wells means finding the well of living water, the point of G-dliness in earthly things. The wells of Esek and Sitnah, where one meets resistance, are the weekday's work; Rechovos is already Shabbos. c,e
Yaakov's sheep and Yitzchak's blessing
A biographer of a great man would never write about twenty years of tending sheep, yet the Torah tells this of Yaakov Avinu, because one who learns with emunah knows these were not plain dealings. So too Yitzchak's wells were not plain wells; there he found the well of living water, a path for all of Klal Yisroel in exile to find it amid earthliness. f
Business for Heaven; only a Jew raises nogah
The Mashgiach says it is bold, but the Likutei Torah on Noach and the Me'or Einayim on Vayetzei write that business done in holiness, honestly and by its halachos, to have money for Torah, mitzvos and tzedakah, can reach great heights and raises kelipas nogah. Only Jews can do this. The Midrash says a non-Jew offers only olos, since a Jew can eat shelamim for Heaven's sake. h,i,j
A person needs pleasure, with a measure
The Tanya continues: one who eats fat meat and drinks fine wine to broaden his mind for Hashem and His Torah, as Rava said that wine and fragrance sharpen the mind, raises it to holiness. The Mashgiach explains that a person has a body that must be satisfied; a hungry man cannot learn or daven. A psychologist once told him that a man fed daily through a zipper in his stomach would soon break down, lacking any taste of food. k,l
Great tzaddikim, like Rebbe Nachum of Chernobyl who ate very little, take their pleasure from Torah and mitzvos. A plain person must have some pleasure, but with a reckoning and no more than he needs; excess goes to the kelipos.
Kedoshim tihyu and Rabbah's joke
The Bnei Yissaschar asks on kedoshim tihyu, which the Ramban explains as not being a glutton within the Torah's permission, why the Torah does not say how much to eat. People differ: what is for Heaven's sake for one is too much for another. The Torah can forbid treif, but each must measure his own needs. m,n,o
Pleasure for its own sake and chibut hakever
One who eats only for pleasure, not for health or peace of mind, brings the food's vitality down temporarily into the three impure kelipos, as if he had eaten treif. But because the meat and wine were kosher, when he learns and davens with their strength they rise again.
The imprint of the pleasure taken not for Heaven remains in the body, and the seforim speak of chibut hakever, where angels beat it out like a mattress. Forbidden things are bound to the kelipos and cannot rise even through later Torah and tefillah, until the day death is swallowed forever and all that the sitra achra holds captive rises. r,s
Sources
Torah
Nevi'im
Kesuvim
Talmud Bavli
Midrash
- j Midrash (place not identified) In the write-up: 24:38
Zohar and Kabbalah
Rishonim
Acharonim and Chassidus
- a Tanya ch. 7 text index In the write-up: 0:41, 6:24, 8:44
- h Likutei Torah (place not identified) index In the write-up: 24:38
- i apparently Me'or Einayim, Vayetzei index In the write-up: 24:38
- k Tanya ch. 7 text index In the write-up: 28:22
- m Bnei Yissaschar (place not identified) index In the write-up: 33:01
Key points
- 2:31 The animal soul of a Jew comes from kelipas nogah, not from the three wholly impure kelipos, so the permitted things it uses can be turned to holiness.
- 4:06 A permitted thing is neutral in itself; whether it rises to holiness or falls to the kelipos depends on whether it is done for the sake of Heaven.
- 16:41 Since the world was created with the Torah, every thing in it holds a point of G-dliness, and a Jew came into the world to find it.
- 25:41 Only a Jew can raise kelipas nogah; for a non-Jew everything belongs to the three impure kelipos.
- 29:37 A plain person needs some pleasure from this world in order to learn and daven, but it must be taken with a measure that each one judges for himself.
- 38:51 Permitted food eaten for pleasure falls temporarily into the impure kelipos but can rise again when its strength is used for Torah and tefillah; its residue needs chibut hakever, while forbidden things stay bound until the end of days.
Questions and answers
-
Question: 3:52 If, as some hold, there is no such thing as a 'davar reshus' and everything is either a mitzvah or a sin, how can the Tanya speak of permitted things?
Answer: 4:04 The thing itself is neutral, on the scale; doing it for Heaven makes it a fulfillment of Hashem's will and doing it for pleasure does not.
-
Question: 15:38 Why does the Torah describe at such length the wells Yitzchak dug and the names he gave them?
Answer: 18:41 They were not plain wells for water; digging in the earth was finding the well of living water, the point of G-dliness in every thing, for all of Klal Yisroel.
-
Question: 23:21 Why did Yitzchak bless Yaakov with dew, the fat of the land, grain and wine, when one would wish a child success in Torah?
Answer: 24:00 The strength of the Avos was to enter material matters and raise the holy sparks that lie in them.
-
Question: 33:50 Why does the Torah not state how much a person may eat?
Answer: 33:55 As the Bnei Yissaschar explains, people differ: what is for Heaven's sake for one is too much for another, so each must judge for himself.
Stories
-
30:02 The psychologist and the zipper
The Mashgiach recounts that he once spoke with a great psychologist about this. The psychologist gave the example of a person whose doctor made an opening in his stomach with a zipper, so that each day a bit of meat and bread could be put in and he would live. Within a short time, he said, the man would have a nervous breakdown, because he gets no taste from eating.
-
31:44 Rebbe Nachum of Chernobyl
The Mashgiach tells that Rebbe Nachum of Chernobyl, the Me'or Einayim, was a stout, heavy man, yet he ate very little. The Mashgiach brings this to show that great tzaddikim have their pleasure from Torah and mitzvos, unlike a plain person.
In the story: Rabbi Menachem Nachum of Chernobyl (the Me'or Einayim), the Baal Shem Tov
Insights
- 3:55 The view that nothing is truly 'reshus' and everything is either a mitzvah or a sin fits the Tanya: the thing itself stands on the scale, and only what one does with it decides.
- 17:36 The Creator made a composition and wrote a commentary on it: the world is the composition and the Torah is its commentary, so only one who learns Torah understands what the world is.
- 18:29 The wells Avraham and Yitzchak dug are the search for the 'well of living water', the point of G-dliness inside earthly things, and Yitzchak dug them as a path for all of Klal Yisroel in exile.
- 20:05 The Torah can tell at length of Yaakov tending Lavan's sheep, which no biographer would write of a great man, because one who learns with emunah knows these were not plain dealings.
- 23:21 Yitzchak blessed Yaakov with material bounty rather than Torah because the strength of the Avos was to enter material things and raise the holy sparks hidden in them.
- 33:50 The Torah cannot set how much a person should eat, because what is for Heaven's sake for one is too much for another; it can only forbid treif.
- 41:20 Even when the food itself rises through later Torah and tefillah, the imprint of the pleasure taken not for Heaven remains, and this is what chibut hakever removes.
What the Mashgiach says to take from it
- 24:58 The Mashgiach says business should be done for Heaven: honestly, keeping all the halachos of business, so as to have money for Torah learning, mitzvos and tzedakah.
- 30:58 The Mashgiach says he often tells young bochurim not to fly into the heavens but to know where they stand.
- 32:28 The Mashgiach says a person must take what he needs of physical pleasure with a measure, not too much, and each must assess for himself how much he needs for Heaven's sake.
Mentioned in this shiur
People Avraham Avinu, Rabbah (bar Nachmani), Rabbi Menachem Nachum of Chernobyl (the Me'or Einayim), Rabbi Yisrael Salanter, Rachel Imeinu, Rav Moshe Feinstein, the Baal HaTanya (Rabbi Shneur Zalman of Liadi), the Ramban, Yaakov Avinu, Yitzchak Avinu
Terms חיבוט הקבר, לשם שמים, ממוצע, ניצוצות, נפש הבהמית, סטרא אחרא, עולם העשיה, עונג שבת, קליפת נוגה, שלש קליפות הטמאות