אם אפי' קל שבקלים מוסר נפש לה'' למה היא חוטא? תירוץ - זה שטות.

Catalog entry: ספר התניא א' י"ט no. ⁨41⁩ Pocket Guide p. 45 Yiddish 43 min

Listen

  1. Download · Length 43 min

Open in the listening app

Notes Notes prepared by AI from the recording; not reviewed, and not the Mashgiach's words. The recording is the source.

About this shiur

The Mashgiach explains, on Tanya chapter 19, that even the lowest Jew is ready to give his life rather than deny Hashem because of the hidden love in his soul, and that he sins only because a spirit of folly enters him.

The Mashgiach reviews the Tanya's teaching that every Jew carries a hidden love for Hashem, so that even sinners give their lives for kiddush Hashem. This love comes from the chochmah of the G-dly soul, which in a sinner is like a glowing coal covered with ash. He then asks: if such a person is ready to die for Hashem, why does he sin all his life? The answer is folly, as people smoke knowing it shortens their lives. Only the spreading light of chochmah is in exile; its essence sleeps and wakes at a test of faith. He ties this to Adar and Purim, a month of hidden miracles for Jews whose faith is hidden. The Tanya adds that a Jew gives his life even over words or deeds he does not mean, a fear contained within love, like a mother holding her child on the stairs. The Mashgiach ends with a gloss of the Tzemach Tzedek limiting this rule.

Topics: Ahavah Mesuteres (Tanya ch. 18-25) · Mesiras Nefesh

Order of the shiur

  1. 0:00 The hidden love and the spirit of folly

    The Mashgiach reviews that every Jew has a hidden love for Hashem, so that even the lowest are ready to die rather than convert. He reads the Tanya: this love comes from the chochmah of the G-dly soul, hidden in a sinner like a coal under ash, and covered by the kelipah through a spirit of folly.

  2. 7:20 Why he sins: it is folly listed in the guide

    The Mashgiach asks why one who would die for Hashem sins all his life, and answers that it is folly. He compares it to smoking, which people do although they know it shortens life, something no animal would do, and traces this folly to Adam eating from the Tree of Knowledge.

  3. 11:34 Only the spreading light is in exile listed in the guide

    The Mashgiach explains the Tanya's distinction: only the spreading of chochmah into the body is in exile and darkened, while its root stays out of exile and only sleeps. At a test of faith it wakes, and even a simple Jew stands firm without reasons he can explain.

  4. 16:04 Nissan and Adar: open and hidden miracles

    Bringing the Sefer Yetzirah's parallel of world, time and soul, the Mashgiach contrasts Nissan, the month of open miracles, with Adar, the month of hidden ones. He shows that the Megillah's miracles are all within nature, yet perfectly timed by a higher hand.

  5. 21:00 Amalek, emunah and the melting of kelipah listed in the guide

    The Mashgiach explains that the Purim miracles were for sinful Jews whom Amalek could attack, and that Adar is for the lowest generation, whose faith is hidden. Moshe's strength against Amalek was emunah, and at a test of faith all the kelipos melt before Hashem like wax.

  6. 25:12 Mesiras nefesh over the garments of denial listed in the guide

    The Mashgiach explains the Tanya's point that the awakened love will not let the kelipah touch even the garments of thought, speech and action. Even a simple Jew forced to bow or to declare belief in idolatry gives his life, though he could say he does not mean it.

  7. 31:01 Fear contained within love listed in the guide

    The Mashgiach asks how fear fits a teaching about hidden love, and answers with the Tanya's 'fear contained in love': a mother grips her child on the stairs out of fear that comes from her love. So a Jew fears harming his love for Hashem, by nature and by faith.

  8. 34:51 The Purim decree and the merit of the Jews listed in the guide

    The Mashgiach brings the Gemara that Haman's decree came because the Jews bowed to the image, and says the merit pleaded for them is their hidden love, which is above reason and is revealed in Adar. This is why one drinks on Purim and why simple Jews rejoice on Purim more than scholars.

  9. 39:05 Summary and the Tzemach Tzedek's exception

    The Mashgiach sums up that even the lowest Jew gives his life rather than deny Hashem, even in speech or action alone, because he feels it would tear him from his root. He then reports a gloss of the Tzemach Tzedek, which he heard of but did not see, that this has exceptions.

The shiur, written up

The hidden love and the spirit of folly

0:37

The Mashgiach recalls that every Jew has a hidden love for Hashem. That Jews gave their lives in times of persecution is not itself the novelty, since other faiths have martyrs too. The novelty is that even the lowest, who transgress the whole Torah, chose death over conversion when tested.

2:44

He reads the Tanya in chapter 19: this love comes from the chochmah of the G-dly soul, the starting point of everything. In a sinner it is like a glowing coal covered with ash, in exile under the animal soul, which rules him. The love is hidden because the kelipah covers it, letting in a spirit of folly, as Chazal say that no one sins unless such a spirit enters him. a,b

Why he sins: it is folly

7:20

The Mashgiach asks the question of the shiur: if this Jew would let himself be killed rather than convert, why does he keep sinning? His answer is that it is folly. People knowingly do what harms them; a smoker knows each cigarette brings him closer to the grave, yet if someone threatened to shoot him unless he stopped, he would refuse to die.

9:18

No animal acts against its own survival; only man can choose to be a fool. Sin is the same folly. This entered man when Adam ate from the Tree of Knowledge, as the serpent promised. c

Only the spreading light is in exile

12:02

What happens to the soul in a sinner? The Tanya distinguishes the essence of chochmah from its spreading into the body, like the sun and its light. Only that spreading, which fills the body with a longing to do Hashem's will, is in exile and darkened. a

13:33

The root stays out of exile; it only sleeps. When a test of faith comes, that spark wakes, and even a simple Jew stands firm without being able to explain why. a

Nissan and Adar

16:25

The Mashgiach links this to the month. As the Sefer Yetzirah teaches that creation is in world, time and soul, Nissan, first of the months, is the head of time and the month of open miracles, a nes like a raised banner. Adar is twelve months down, and it is covered. d,e

17:49

The Gemara finds Esther hinted in 'hiding'. The Megillah contains nothing outside nature, unlike the Exodus, yet everything was timed exactly, so a higher hand was guiding it. f

Amalek and emunah

21:00

Why are Adar's miracles hidden? Because they were done for Jews whom Amalek could attack, sinners whose love for Hashem is concealed. Adar thus strengthens the lowest, our final generation before Moshiach, and its work is to wake that faith.

23:04

Moshe's power against Amalek, when he raised his hands, was emunah. At a test of faith the hidden love is uncovered, and the Tanya says all the kelipos then become as nothing before Hashem, melting like wax before fire. g,a,h,i

Even the garments of denial

26:01

The love that wakes at a test, coming from what Jews heard from Hashem Himself at Sinai, is so strong that it will not let the kelipah touch even the garments of the soul. Thought means believing that there is no G-d; beyond it lie speech and action. l,a

27:10

If a gentile forces a simple Jew to bow to an idol, or to say he believes in it, the Jew could tell himself he does not mean it and save his life. The Mashgiach notes that the halachah does not allow even this, and the Jew gives his life even over the garments of denial, though in his heart he still believes.

Fear contained within love

31:01

The Mashgiach asks: the Tanya spoke of hidden love, so where does fear of denying Hashem come from? The Tanya calls it fear contained in love. A mother carrying her baby up the stairs grips it tightly because she is afraid it will fall, and she is afraid because she loves it. a

33:03

So a Jew, whose soul longs like a flame to cleave to its root, fears that his love will be harmed, and gives his life by nature and by faith. a

The merit of the Jews at Purim

35:15

Returning to Adar, the Mashgiach brings the Gemara that the students of Rabbi Shimon bar Yochai asked why that generation deserved destruction, and he answered that they bowed to the image. The merit pleaded for them is that every Jew loves Hashem with a love above reason, revealed in Adar. m

37:05

This is why one drinks on Purim: when reason departs, drunk Jews speak of giving their lives for Hashem. Simple Jews rejoice on Purim more than scholars, for it is their festival. n

Summary and an exception

39:41

The Mashgiach sums up: even the lowest Jew gives his life rather than deny Hashem in speech or action, because it would tear him from his root, which is above reason.

41:04

He reports hearing of a gloss of the Tzemach Tzedek, which he has not seen himself, that this rule has exceptions for those connected with three specific things.

Sources

Torah

  1. c Bereishis 3:5 text index In the write-up: 9:18
  2. e Shemos 12:2 text index In the write-up: 16:25
  3. g Shemos 17:11-12 text index In the write-up: 23:04

Nevi'im

  1. h apparently Yeshayahu 40:17 index In the write-up: 23:04

Kesuvim

  1. i Tehillim 68:3 text index In the write-up: 23:04
  2. j Tehillim 97:5 25:14 text index

Talmud Bavli

  1. b Sotah 3a text index In the write-up: 2:44
  2. f Chullin 139b text index In the write-up: 17:49
  3. k apparently Sukkah 52a 25:14 index
  4. l apparently Makkos 24a index In the write-up: 26:01
  5. m Megillah 12a text index In the write-up: 35:15
  6. n apparently Megillah 7b index In the write-up: 37:05

Zohar and Kabbalah

  1. d Sefer Yetzirah (place not identified) index In the write-up: 16:25

Acharonim and Chassidus

  1. a apparently Tanya ch. 19 index In the write-up: 2:44, 12:02, 13:33, 23:04, 26:01, 31:01, 33:03

Key points

  1. 0:37 Every Jew, even the lowest sinner, has a hidden love for Hashem that comes out when he is tested and ready to die rather than convert.
  2. 6:26 A Jew sins only because a spirit of folly enters him; sin is no more logical than smoking while knowing it kills.
  3. 12:02 Only the spreading of the soul's chochmah into the body is in exile; its root and essence stay untouched and only sleep.
  4. 20:14 Adar and Purim are the time of hidden miracles and of revealing the hidden love of even the lowest Jews.
  5. 27:33 A Jew gives his life even over a denial in speech or action he does not mean, because he fears being cut off from Hashem.
  6. 32:08 This fear is a fear contained within love, like a mother who grips her child on the stairs because she loves it.

Questions and answers

  1. Question: 7:20 If even the lowest Jew is ready to give his life for Hashem, why does he sin all his life?

    Answer: 7:41 Because a spirit of folly enters him; sin is illogical, like smoking while knowing it shortens life.

  2. Question: 31:37 How can the Tanya speak of fear of denying Hashem when it has been teaching about a hidden love?

    Answer: 32:08 It is a fear contained within love, like a mother who holds her child tightly because she loves it.

  3. Question: 27:27 Why would a Jew give his life over saying or doing something against his faith that he does not mean in his heart?

    Answer: 28:52 Because the awakened love does not let the kelipah touch even the garments of speech and action; he feels it would tear him from his root.

  4. Question: 35:20 Why did the Jews in Haman's time deserve the decree?

    Answer: 35:46 The Gemara answers that they bowed to the image; the Mashgiach adds that their merit was the hidden love in their hearts.

Insights

  1. 8:56 The Mashgiach treats the sinner's readiness for martyrdom and his daily sinning as the same human folly, illustrated by the smoker who would refuse to be shot yet keeps smoking.
  2. 9:18 Only man can choose to act against his own survival; no animal ever does, which shows that sin is folly rather than strong desire.
  3. 20:14 Adar, from the word for a covering cloak, is the month of hidden miracles, just as the hidden love belongs to Jews whose faith is covered; Adar Sheni is further still from Nissan.
  4. 37:00 Purim is above all the festival of the simple and the sinful, and the drinking of Purim reveals the hidden love that lies above reason.
  5. 36:15 The merit for the Jews who bowed to the image in Haman's time is that in their hearts they never denied Hashem, which comes out on Purim.

Mentioned in this shiur

People Achashverosh, Adam HaRishon, Haman, Mordechai HaTzaddik, Moshe Rabbeinu, Nevuchadnetzar, Rabbi Shimon bar Yochai, the Baal HaTanya (Rabbi Shneur Zalman of Liadi), the Tzemach Tzedek

Terms אהבה מסותרת, גלות השכינה, מסירות נפש, נס, נפש האלקית, סטרא אחרא, פושעי ישראל, קל שבקלים, רוח שטות

Report an error on this page