מסירת נפש אפי' בלי דעת כי אמונה למעלה מן דעת. ברית מילה למעלה מן הדעת. ישמעאל וא”י. אהבה מסותרת. “נר ה' נשמת אדם” על פי חסידות.
Catalog entry: ספר התניא ב' י”ח no. 7 Pocket Guide p. 47 Yiddish 38 min
Listen
About this shiur
The Mashgiach explains that a Jew's emunah is above understanding, which is why even the simplest Jew gives up his life rather than deny Hashem, why bris milah is done on an eight-day-old baby, and how the soul is 'the candle of Hashem'.
Continuing Tanya chapter 18, the Mashgiach explains that every Jew, even the simplest, inherited emunah from the Avos and heard 'Anochi' at Har Sinai, and that this emunah is above daas: before Hashem everyone is a 'peti' who simply believes, and that is the greatest wisdom. Simple Jews who do not think about Hashem's greatness still give up their lives rather than deny Him, not out of fear of Gehinnom or hope for Gan Eden, but because the soul cannot cut itself off from Hashem, just as a person cannot jump off a roof. He then brings the argument of Yishmael and Yitzchak before the Akeidah and asks why milah, the greatest mitzvah, is given to a baby who has no kavanah. His answer: milah is emunah, above daas. He adds that a goy's milah is not milah, that Eretz Yisroel is 'the Jew of geography', and links Chevron to milah and Shechem to periah. Opening chapter 19, he explains 'ner Hashem nishmas adam' through the custom of lighting a Shabbos candle for each child, and begins the image of the flame that always rises.
Topics: Ahavah Mesuteres (Tanya ch. 18-25) · Simple Emunah, Above Reason · Bris Milah · Mesiras Nefesh
Order of the shiur
-
0:00 Emunah above daas: everyone a 'peti' listed in the guide
Continuing Tanya chapter 18, the Mashgiach explains that every Jew inherited emunah from the Avos and heard 'Anochi' at Sinai, and that emunah is above daas. He brings 'peti ya'amin lechol davar' and 'va'ani va'ar velo eida' to show that before Hashem everyone is a simple believer, and that this is the greatest wisdom.
-
6:11 Why simple Jews give up their lives listed in the guide
The Mashgiach asks why simple Jews, who do not contemplate Hashem and sin in other areas, still give up their lives rather than deny Him. He answers that it is not fear of Gehinnom or hope of reward, but that the soul cannot cut itself off from Hashem, just as a sane person cannot jump off a roof.
-
12:57 Yishmael's claim and milah without kavanah listed in the guide
The Mashgiach brings Rashi's account of the argument between Yishmael and Yitzchak before the Akeidah. Citing the Shulchan Aruch that milah is the greatest mitzvah, and the question whether mitzvos need kavanah, he contrasts the Ba'al Shem Tov's tefillin with an ordinary person's, and asks why such a mitzvah is given to a baby who cannot have kavanah: was Yishmael right? He answers that milah is above kavanah.
-
20:30 Milah is emunah; a goy's milah is not milah listed in the guide
The Mashgiach explains that milah binds a Jew to Avraham Avinu, the root of emunah, and is therefore done on a baby to show that the bond is above daas. Yishmael's milah is merely a cut: from the Mishnah in Nedarim and the episode of Shechem he shows that a goy, even circumcised, is not called circumcised, because he is entirely orlah while a Jew has orlah in one place only.
-
25:21 Eretz Yisroel, Chevron and Shechem listed in the guide
The Mashgiach calls Eretz Yisroel 'the Jew of geography' and explains that milah has two parts, milah and periah: Chevron, where Avraham was circumcised, is the place of milah, and Shechem, linked to Yosef and Yehoshua, is the place of periah, which is why Yaakov's sons cut off its inhabitants. He returns to milah at eight days as emunah above daas, and describes the custom in Eretz Yisroel of saying Shema with closed eyes before a bris.
-
30:44 Hidden love and a candle for each child listed in the guide
Opening Tanya chapter 19, the Mashgiach recalls that every Jew has a hidden love of Hashem that comes out at mesiras nefesh, and introduces 'ner Hashem nishmas adam'. He describes the widespread Ashkenazi custom of lighting two Shabbos candles from the wedding, for zachor and shamor, and adding a candle for each child, because each child is another soul, another light.
-
35:04 The soul as a flame that rises listed in the guide
The Mashgiach explains 'ner Hashem nishmas adam' as the Tanya does: the soul is like the light of a candle, which constantly flickers upward. He notes that fire has no solidity, yet unlike water on a slope it does not fall but rises, and leaves the question of why for the next shiur.
The shiur, written up
Emunah above daas: everyone a 'peti'
Continuing chapter 18 of Tanya, the Mashgiach explains that every Jew, even the lowest soul, women and the unlearned included, believes in Hashem, because emunah is above daas. It is an inheritance from Avraham, Yitzchak and Yaakov, and it was implanted in every soul at Har Sinai, where all Jews heard 'Anochi' from Hashem Himself. a,b
Why simple Jews give up their lives
The Tanya continues that even the simplest Jews give up their lives rather than deny Hashem. Yet they do not contemplate His greatness; they blow shofar without asking what shofar is, and they transgress Shabbos or speak lashon hara despite Gehinnom. So why do they give up their lives here? a
The Mashgiach answers that it is neither reward nor punishment. A sin does not cut a Jew off from Hashem, but denying emunah does, and the soul cannot let itself be cut off. Just as a sane person told to jump off a roof simply cannot, a Jewish soul cannot do what would kill it.
Yishmael's claim and milah without kavanah
Rashi tells that before the Akeidah Yishmael argued that he was greater, having let himself be circumcised at thirteen, while Yitzchak was circumcised as a baby who could not object. Yitzchak answered that he would give himself entirely to Hashem, and the Akeidah followed. f
The Mashgiach finds this puzzling. The Shulchan Aruch opens the laws of milah calling it the greatest mitzvah, and whether mitzvos need kavanah is a Gemara dispute left unresolved. Even if one fulfils a mitzvah without intent, the Ba'al Shem Tov's tefillin, worn with love, fear and deveikus, were a different mitzvah from an ordinary person's. Why then give milah to a baby without kavanah? Was Yishmael right? The answer, he says, lies in milah itself: it is above kavanah. g,h
Milah is emunah
Milah binds a Jew to Avraham Avinu, the root of Jewish emunah, and emunah is above daas. That is why it is done on an eight-day-old: to show that the bond with Avraham is above understanding.
Yishmael's milah is merely a cut. From the Mishnah in Nedarim, which does not count circumcised Yishmaelim as circumcised, and from Shechem, whose people circumcised themselves and were still destroyed, the Mashgiach shows that a goy is entirely orlah, while a Jew has orlah in one place only. i,j
Eretz Yisroel, Chevron and Shechem
Eretz Yisroel, the Mashgiach says, is the Jew of geography. Milah has two parts: milah, given to Avraham, whose place is Chevron, and periah, for Jews alone, begun by Yehoshua, whose place is Shechem, equal to 'periah' in gematria. So Yaakov's sons cut off Shechem's orlah. m
Because emunah is above daas, a child is circumcised at eight days, while Yishmael, without such emunah, at thirteen. In Eretz Yisroel some say Shema with closed eyes before a bris, to express emunah above daas.
Hidden love and a candle for each child
Opening chapter 19, the Mashgiach recalls that every Jew, even a sinner, has a hidden love of Hashem that comes out at mesiras nefesh. To explain it the Tanya brings 'ner Hashem nishmas adam': the soul is Hashem's candle. p,o
Besides other customs, many Ashkenazim light two Shabbos candles from the wedding, for zachor and shamor, and add one for each child, because each child is another soul, another light.
The soul as a flame that rises
Sources
Torah
Kesuvim
Mishnah
Talmud Bavli
Rishonim
Acharonim and Chassidus
Key points
- 1:01 Every Jew, even the simplest, has emunah inherited from Avraham, Yitzchak and Yaakov and implanted at Har Sinai, and this emunah is above daas.
- 4:14 Before Hashem every person is a 'peti' who simply believes, and believing that way is the greatest wisdom.
- 8:56 Simple Jews give up their lives for emunah not out of reward or punishment but because the soul cannot cut itself off from Hashem.
- 20:26 Milah is given to an eight-day-old baby because milah is emunah, the bond with Avraham Avinu that is above daas.
- 23:46 A goy's milah is not considered milah, since he is entirely orlah, while a Jew has orlah only in one place.
- 32:08 The soul is the 'candle of Hashem', which is why many light another Shabbos candle for each child born.
Questions and answers
-
Question: 8:25 Why do simple Jews, who sin in other matters and do not think about Gehinnom, give up their lives for emunah?
Answer: 8:56 Not because of reward or punishment, but because denying emunah cuts one off from Hashem and the soul cannot allow itself to be cut off.
-
Question: 17:55 What makes the Ba'al Shem Tov's tefillin greater than an ordinary person's, if both fulfil the mitzvah?
Answer: 18:29 He put them on with love, fear and deveikus; the difference between Jews is not what they do but how, with what kavanah and fervor.
-
Question: 19:18 If milah is the greatest mitzvah and mitzvos with kavanah are far greater, why is it given to an eight-day-old who cannot intend it; was Yishmael right?
Answer: 20:08 Milah is above kavanah: it is emunah, the bond with Avraham Avinu that is above daas, so it is done precisely on a baby.
-
Question: 23:28 Why were the people of Shechem killed though they had circumcised themselves?
Answer: 23:46 A goy's milah is not milah, for he is entirely orlah; and Shechem is the place of periah, so its orlah had to be cut off.
Stories
-
13:18 Yishmael and Yitzchak argue over milah
Following Rashi, the Mashgiach tells that before the Akeidah Yishmael argued with Yitzchak. Yishmael said Yitzchak was circumcised at eight days, when as a baby he could not object, while he himself allowed himself to be circumcised at thirteen, so he was greater. Yitzchak answered that he was ready to give his whole self to Hashem, and the Akeidah followed to show it.
In the story: Yishmael, Yitzchak Avinu, Avraham Avinu
Insights
- 4:59 Relative to Hashem every person is a 'peti' who believes without understanding, and the verse calls this simple belief the greatest wisdom.
- 11:22 Self-sacrifice for emunah works like the instinct of life: just as a sane person cannot jump off a roof, a Jewish soul cannot do something, such as denying Hashem, that would kill the soul.
- 20:08 Giving milah to a baby without kavanah answers Yishmael's claim: precisely because milah is emunah, above daas, it is fitting for an eight-day-old who has no daas.
- 24:35 A goy is entirely orlah from head to foot, so cutting does not make him circumcised, while a Jew's orlah is in one place only.
- 25:30 Just as among souls there is a Jew, in geography Eretz Yisroel is the Jew and other lands are the goyim; within it Chevron is the place of milah and Shechem, whose name equals 'periah' in gematria, the place of periah.
- 33:12 The custom of adding a Shabbos candle for each child expresses 'ner Hashem nishmas adam': every child born is another soul, another light.
Mentioned in this shiur
People Avraham Avinu, Dinah, Rashi, the Arizal, the Baal HaTanya (Rabbi Shneur Zalman of Liadi), the Baal Shem Tov, the Shelah HaKadosh, Yaakov Avinu, Yehoshua bin Nun, Yishmael, Yitzchak Avinu, Yosef HaTzaddik
Terms אהבה מסותרת, אמונה, התבוננות, כוונה, למעלה מן הדעת, מילה, מסירות נפש, נר ה' נשמת אדם, ערלה, עתיקא קדישא, פריעה, רבונו של עולם