דברים שעושים טימטום הלב ואיך לתקן ולהזהר. בחינת האמת לפי מדריגתו. לפעמים אין התעוררות בשבת כי אז צריכים להיות במדריגה יותר זך. עצות כשיש טימטום הלב. למואס בגשמיות.
Catalog entry: ספר התניא ב' כ”ט no. 16 Pocket Guide p. 48 Yiddish 37 min
Listen
About this shiur
On Tanya chapter 29, the Mashgiach explains why a person suddenly cannot daven, why a higher level or a holier time demands a deeper teshuvah, and how to break the sitra achra through cheshbon hanefesh and seeing its nothingness before Hashem.
The Mashgiach continues Tanya chapter 29 on timtum halev, the closed heart that cannot daven. A hisorerus that fades after davening is still truth at a beinoni's level if it returns the next time. Sins of youth can block a person now, because above there is no time, and because each higher level needs a deeper teshuvah: Shabbos, Eretz Yisroel and every yahrzeit of a neshamah demand more than the weekday did. So a person who cannot daven should make a cheshbon hanefesh, like Dovid whose sin stood before him always. Even one without such sins can examine his wandering thoughts and his foolish dreams, as the Ba'al Shem Tov's Danzig story shows, yet without fear. He should then break himself with merirus, not atzvus, rebuke the sitra achra in his thoughts, and see that it is nullified before Hashem like darkness before light.
Order of the shiur
-
0:00 Timtum halev and truth by one's level listed in the guide
The Mashgiach recalls the Tanya's counsel for a heart that is closed and cannot daven: to chop at it like a log that will not catch fire, and to make a cheshbon hanefesh. Reading on in chapter 29 and referring to chapter 13, he explains that truth has many levels, so a beinoni's arousal that returns each time is truth at his level.
-
4:37 Sins of youth, time, and the holiness of Shabbos listed in the guide
The Mashgiach explains that above there is no time, so a sin of youth stands as if committed now. With the parable of dressing for the street, a wedding and a king, he answers why one can daven on weekdays but not on Shabbos: Shabbos is the king's court and demands a greater teshuvah, and so too a holy place like Eretz Yisroel.
-
10:17 The yahrzeit: a new judgment each year listed in the guide
The Mashgiach explains why on a yahrzeit people learn mishnayos and give tzedakah: each year the neshamah rises, and the cleansing that sufficed for last year's level is not enough for the next. In the same way a person in this world who is to rise higher needs a deeper teshuvah.
-
14:31 Cheshbon hanefesh and Dovid's sin before him listed in the guide
The Mashgiach says one who cannot daven should ask why, and consider that Heaven may want to raise him. He brings Dovid's words that his sin is before him always: at every higher step one sees the sin anew and must do teshuvah again. Even one who did not sin can make a cheshbon, as some do daily, for thoughts fly through the mind by the thousand.
-
18:15 Thoughts, dreams, and davening without fear listed in the guide
The Mashgiach explains that thoughts not for the sake of Heaven belong to the other side, and tells the Ba'al Shem Tov's story of a man whose mind was in Danzig during davening. He then reads that foolish dreams show the soul does not ascend, and adds that this cheshbon must be made without fear, citing the tzaddikim's saying to think good and it will be good.
-
24:27 Breaking oneself: merirus, not atzvus listed in the guide
The Mashgiach explains the Tanya's counsel to sit and think that one is nothing, not an honest servant of Hashem, and so break himself. He stresses the difference between merirus, which brings good counsel, and atzvus, which only puts one to sleep; through this the swollen sitra achra that blocks his davening is broken.
-
27:39 Rebuking the sitra achra in thought listed in the guide
The Mashgiach explains the Tanya's call to thunder at the yetzer hara: not aloud but in thought, asking how long it will hide the light of Hashem, who fills all worlds and is unchanged by creation. Seeing the truth, that all existence is nothing before Hashem, he illustrates with a story of the Ba'al haTanya at his passing.
-
32:04 Like darkness before light; despising physicality listed in the guide
The Mashgiach explains that the sitra achra is nullified like darkness when a candle is lit, since its life is only sparks of kedushah it holds. He adds that darkness is itself a creation, and there is a holy darkness of tzimtzum, which is why the Tanya specifies physical light. He closes with the Tanya's counsel to despise physicality, which the yetzer uses to keep a person from davening.
The shiur, written up
Timtum halev and truth by one's level
Sins of youth, time, and Shabbos
Why should sins of youth block a person now? The Mashgiach explains that time is itself a creation, as the Rambam explains on the word Bereishis; above there is no time, so an old sin stands as if done now, and an old teshuvah may not suffice.
He compares this to dress: the street, a wedding and the king each demand more. One may daven well all week yet feel nothing on Shabbos, because Shabbos is the king's court and requires a greater teshuvah. The same holds for a place like Eretz Yisroel, and for the level of the soul itself.
The yahrzeit
The Mashgiach asks why people learn mishnayos and give tzedakah on a yahrzeit. Each year, he explains, the neshamah is judged anew as it rises, and the cleansing that sufficed for last year's level is not enough for the next, so it must pass through it again. So too a living person who is meant to rise needs a deeper teshuvah.
Cheshbon hanefesh
Therefore, the Mashgiach says, one who cannot daven should ask why, and consider that Heaven may want to raise him; yesterday's teshuvah no longer suffices today. This is why Dovid said his sin was before him always: Dovid sinned only so that he could teach teshuvah, and at every higher moment he saw his sin anew. c,d
Even one who did not sin in youth can make a cheshbon, as some do every day, since thousands of thoughts fly through the mind.
Thoughts, dreams, and without fear
Thoughts not for the sake of Heaven, the Mashgiach explains, belong to the other side. The Ba'al Shem Tov once greeted a man after davening as if he had returned from Danzig; the man had not been there for half a year, but during davening his mind had been there. A person is where his thoughts are.
The Tanya adds that foolish dreams show the soul does not ascend, as the passuk asks who shall ascend the mountain of Hashem, the clean of hands. Yet the Mashgiach insists this cheshbon must be made without fear: one needs yiras shamayim, not dread, and the tzaddikim said, think good and it will be good. e
Merirus, not atzvus
The Tanya's counsel is to sit and think that one is nothing, not an honest servant of Hashem, and so break himself. The Mashgiach stresses merirus, which leads to counsel, not atzvus, which only puts one to sleep. This breaks the sitra achra that swelled up and blocks his davening.
Rebuking the sitra achra
The Tanya then says to thunder at the yetzer hara. The Mashgiach explains this is not aloud but in thought: how long will it hide the light of Hashem, who fills all worlds and is unchanged since creation? The yetzer has many names, he notes, and they are true names. a,f
A man of truth sees that all existence is nothing before Hashem. The Mashgiach tells that the Ba'al haTanya, at his passing, looked at the ceiling and said he saw the truth there, not what conceals it.
Like darkness before light
The sitra achra is nullified like darkness when a candle is lit, the Mashgiach explains, because its life is not its own but sparks of kedushah it holds.
Yet darkness is itself a creation, as the passuk says Hashem forms light and creates darkness, and there is a holy darkness of tzimtzum, greater than light. Therefore the Tanya specifies darkness before physical light. He closes with the Tanya's call to despise physicality, through which the yetzer keeps a person from davening. g,a
Sources
Nevi'im
Kesuvim
Talmud Bavli
Acharonim and Chassidus
Key points
- 3:36 A beinoni's hisorerus that fades after davening is still truth at his level, as long as it comes back the next time.
- 5:25 Above there is no time, so a sin of long ago stands as if it were now, and teshuvah done once may not suffice for the present.
- 8:16 A higher level, whether in time (Shabbos), place (Eretz Yisroel) or the soul itself, demands a greater teshuvah, so a person may feel blocked exactly there.
- 14:33 When he cannot daven, a person should make a cheshbon hanefesh, perhaps Heaven wants to raise him higher and he must first do more teshuvah.
- 20:17 Even one without sins of youth can examine his thoughts and dreams, which show his soul does not ascend.
- 26:29 The breaking must come through merirus, which brings good counsel, and not through atzvus, which only puts one to sleep.
- 32:18 The sitra achra has no life of its own; it is nullified before Hashem like darkness before a lit candle.
Questions and answers
-
Question: 7:57 Why can a person daven well all week but feel nothing on Shabbos?
Answer: 8:16 Shabbos is a higher level, the king's court, and demands a greater teshuvah; what was overlooked during the week is not overlooked there.
-
Question: 10:31 Why do people learn mishnayos and give tzedakah on a yahrzeit?
Answer: 10:52 Each yahrzeit there is a new judgment as the neshamah rises, and the cleansing that sufficed for the earlier level is not enough for the higher one.
-
Question: 14:36 If he already did teshuvah for his sins, why is he blocked now?
Answer: 14:40 Perhaps Heaven wants to raise him, and the teshuvah that sufficed yesterday is not enough for today's higher level.
-
Question: 27:59 What does it mean to thunder at the yetzer hara with a loud voice?
Answer: 28:08 Not to shout aloud but in his thoughts, to rebuke it for hiding the light of Hashem.
Stories
-
19:03 The Ba'al Shem Tov and the man from Danzig
After davening the Ba'al Shem Tov greeted a man with shalom aleichem, as one welcomes someone back from Danzig, then a large trading city. The man said he had not been in Danzig for half a year. The Ba'al Shem Tov answered that during davening his thoughts had been in Danzig. The Mashgiach concludes that a person is where his thoughts are.
In the story: the Baal Shem Tov
-
30:57 The Ba'al haTanya looking at the ceiling
At the time of his passing, the Ba'al haTanya looked up at the ceiling and asked someone with him what was there. After the answer, the Ba'al haTanya said that he saw the truth there, not the covering that conceals it. The Mashgiach brings this to show what it means to see that the world is nothing before Hashem.
In the story: the Baal HaTanya (Rabbi Shneur Zalman of Liadi)
Insights
- 3:51 Truth for a beinoni is measured by return, not permanence: an arousal that fades but comes back each time proves it was inwardly true at his level.
- 5:25 Because time is a creation and does not exist above, a sin of youth stands before Heaven as if done now.
- 8:16 Not feeling anything on Shabbos, when weekdays are fine, is a sign of Shabbos's greater holiness: at the king's court one is not forgiven what was overlooked during the week.
- 10:52 The yahrzeit customs reflect that a neshamah must pass through cleansing again before each yearly ascent, and the same holds for a living person rising in avodah.
- 15:40 Dovid's sin was always before him because at each higher moment he saw it anew and needed a fresh teshuvah.
- 33:51 Darkness is a real creation and there is a holy darkness of tzimtzum, which is why the Tanya compares the sitra achra's nullification specifically to darkness before physical light.
What the Mashgiach says to take from it
- 14:33 The Mashgiach says that when a person cannot daven, he should make a cheshbon hanefesh and ask why.
- 23:45 The Mashgiach says this cheshbon should be made without fear; one needs yiras shamayim but not dread, as the tzaddikim said to think good and it will be good.
- 26:44 The Mashgiach says the breaking should come with merirus, which leads to counsel, and not with atzvus.
Mentioned in this shiur
People Dovid HaMelech, the Baal HaTanya (Rabbi Shneur Zalman of Liadi), the Baal Shem Tov, the Rambam, Yaakov Avinu
Terms בינוני, גשמיות, חשבון הנפש, טמטום הלב, ממלא כל עלמין, מרירות, סטרא אחרא, עצבות, פגם הברית, צמצום