קויתי ה' קותה נפשי
Catalog entry: תפילה no. 39 Pocket Guide p. 50 Yiddish 42 min
Listen
About this shiur
On the closing verses of Shir HaMa'alos 'MiMa'amakim', the Mashgiach teaches that a Jew keeps hoping and waiting for Hashem and for the geulah even when every awaited 'morning' passes, and that one who takes shelter in Hashem is redeemed even beyond strict judgment.
The Mashgiach reads 'Kivisi Hashem kivsa nafshi' as a call to keep hoping and praying even when a tefillah is not answered. 'Nafshi la-Hashem mishomrim laboker' is the waiting for the geulah: there is a fixed time that must come, and there are 'mornings' when it can come earlier. He speaks of Moshiach ben Yosef and Moshiach ben Dovid, of how little anyone knows about the order of the redemption, and of the Arizal's words about the year 5765. After stories of tzaddikim who foresaw the fall of Russia, he lists awaited dates that passed and answers that a Jew never gives up: 'Yachel Yisrael el Hashem'. Adam's sin and the Golden Calf were failures to wait. The chapter ends with pedus from sins: Hashem, like a king, can rise above judgment for one who takes shelter in Him, as the Akeidah, the extra verse of Tehillim 34, and the story of Rebbi and the ox show.
Topics: Awaiting Moshiach · The Time of the Geulah and the Ketz · Moshiach ben Yosef and Moshiach ben Dovid
Order of the shiur
-
0:00 Keep hoping; waiting for the morning listed in the guide
The Mashgiach explains 'Kivisi Hashem kivsa nafshi': one who prayed and was not answered must keep hoping and praying. He reads 'mishomrim laboker' as waiting for the geulah, distinguishing a set time that must come (with the Ramban at the end of Haazinu) from earlier times when it can come.
-
4:19 Two Moshiachs and the unknown order
The Mashgiach distinguishes Moshiach ben Yosef, who can come any day, from Moshiach ben Dovid and the full geulah, and connects the two to Moshe Rabbeinu's two comings in this week's sedra. He adds that, as the Rambam says, nobody knows exactly how the redemption will happen.
-
8:26 The Torah's promise and the Arizal on 5765
What is certain is the Torah's promise in Bechukosai and Nitzavim. The Mashgiach cites the Arizal that a great day of judgment will come in 5765, urges taking it seriously, and explains why the Arizal's words carry weight: before Moshiach tzaddikim greater than their generation can appear.
-
12:04 Tzaddikim who foresaw Russia's fall Story
The Mashgiach tells of R' Elya Roth in Yerushalayim, who said Russia would soon crumble, and of the Stoliner Rebbe R' Yochanan, who said Russia would last seventy years. He adds R' Elya Roth's tradition that Christianity cannot last more than two thousand years, and a tzaddik's custom of wishing Jews a good year on the gentile New Year.
-
17:31 When the awaited morning passes
The Mashgiach lists awaited times that brought troubles instead of redemption: the Zohar's year 5408, the Malbim's calculation of 1914, a year in the 5700s, and 5746. He asks whether a Jew then gives up, and answers with 'Yachel Yisrael el Hashem': Yiddishkeit is hoping, waiting and believing.
-
21:28 Adam, the Calf and the Malbim: a Jew waits
Hashem too waits impatiently to help His people. The Mashgiach shows that Adam's sin was not waiting for Shabbos and the Golden Calf was not waiting for Moshe, so a Jew's tikkun is to wait. He tells how the Malbim explained to his students that the maskilim 'can do more' than he can.
-
25:37 Pedus from sins and the transfer of decrees
The Mashgiach explains that the chapter's last verse speaks of redemption from sins, greater than rescue from troubles. One who finds favor before Hashem can have his decrees transferred to another, as with the se'ir hamishtalei'ach, kaparos on Erev Yom Kippur, 'nasati koferecha Mitzrayim' and the ransom paid for a goring ox.
-
30:10 Rising above judgment: Tehillim 34 and the Akeidah
Hashem runs the world by judgment, but like a king He reserves the right to pardon. The Mashgiach shows this in Tehillim 34, whose alphabet maps the order of creation and judgment, while the extra verse 'Podeh Hashem nefesh avadav' stands outside it. He explains the Akeidah as chesed binding din, renewed each Rosh Hashanah and Yom Kippur.
-
38:15 Rebbi and the ox: asking asylum from Hashem
The Mashgiach tells the Gemara of the ox that fled to Rebbi and the suffering that followed, and a ba'al mussar's question why Rebbi was punished if he was right. The answer: one who asks asylum must be saved. A Midrash parable of a man who claimed to be the king's relative shows that whoever takes shelter in Hashem cannot be held guilty.
The shiur, written up
Keep hoping; waiting for the morning
The Mashgiach explains 'Kivisi Hashem kivsa nafshi' (Tehillim 130:5): one who hoped and prayed and was not answered must keep hoping and keep praying, as 'Kaveh el Hashem' (Tehillim 27:14) teaches. a,b
'Nafshi la-Hashem mishomrim laboker' (Tehillim 130:6) he reads, with Rashi's sense of 'shamar' as waiting for fulfillment, as waiting for the geulah. There is a set time, 'b'itah', when it must come whether or not Jews do teshuvah, as the Ramban says at the end of Haazinu; and there are 'mornings' when it can come sooner. c,d,e,f
Two Moshiachs and the unknown order
Moshiach ben Yosef can come any day, the Mashgiach says, while the dispute over Nissan or Tishrei (Rosh Hashanah 11a) concerns Moshiach ben Dovid. He links them to Moshe Rabbeinu in this week's sedra: his first coming, after which the bondage grew worse, and his second, which brought the redemption. g
The Torah's promise and the Arizal on 5765
What is certain is the Torah's promise, clearest in Nitzavim (Devarim 30:4), of a redemption greater than the days of Shlomo HaMelech and the Avos. The Mashgiach then cites the Arizal that 5765 will bring a great day of judgment, and says this must be taken seriously. Per the Kisvei HaArizal, before Moshiach tzaddikim greater than their generation appear, and the Arizal was one of them. m,n
Tzaddikim who foresaw Russia's fall
A Jew told the Mashgiach that years ago R' Elya Roth of Yerushalayim, whom the Mashgiach knew, said that Russia, then so strong that America trembled before it, would soon crumble to pieces. It sounded like a joke at the time.
The Mashgiach had known it earlier: about thirty years before, the Stoliner Rebbe, R' Yochanan, told young men in Williamsburg that Russia would last seventy years, and when it fell the headlines noted exactly that. R' Elya Roth also said, as a tradition from his rebbes, that Christianity cannot last more than two thousand years.
When the awaited morning passes
Adam, the Calf and the Malbim
Hashem too waits impatiently to help His people (Yeshayahu 30:18). Adam's sin, as the Ohr HaChaim brings, was eating from the Tree of Knowledge on Friday instead of waiting to make Kiddush on its grapes. At the Golden Calf, had the Jews waited for Moshe they would have been like Adam before the sin (Tehillim 82:6-7; Rashi on Shemos 32:1). A Jew's tikkun is to wait. r,s,t,u
So the Malbim told his students the maskilim 'can do more' than he: they call for breakfast in bed, while he must first wash, daven, wash again and make hamotzi.
Pedus from sins and the transfer of decrees
Earlier chapters spoke of rescue from troubles; this one, said in the Aseres Yemei Teshuvah, ends with 'v'hu yifdeh es Yisrael mikol avonosav' (Tehillim 130:8), redemption from sins, the greatest pedus. v
When one finds favor before Hashem, his decrees can pass to another: the se'ir hamishtalei'ach carries the sins (Vayikra 16:22); the Arizal explains kaparos, since a rooster is called 'gever', a man; and 'nasati koferecha Mitzrayim' (Yeshayahu 43:3). When sins are too great, Hashem finds a gentile to take them over. w,y
Rising above judgment: Tehillim 34 and the Akeidah
The world runs by judgment, 'melech b'mishpat ya'amid aretz' (Mishlei 29:4): the tzaddik is rewarded, the sinner punished. Yet as a king can pardon one who finds favor, Hashem reserves the right to rise above judgment, on Yom Kippur or in an eis ratzon, and this is called pedus. aa
Tehillim 34 shows this. Its verses follow the alphabet, the order of creation, and from ayin, 'Einei Hashem el tzaddikim' (34:16), the order of judgment. After tav comes an extra verse, 'Podeh Hashem nefesh avadav' (34:23), outside the alphabet: for one who throws himself on Hashem, judgment is not considered. ab,ac,ad
At the Akeidah Hashem did not want Yitzchak slaughtered, but wanted Avraham, chesed, to bind Yitzchak, din, so that din loses its power. Each Rosh Hashanah and Yom Kippur, through shofar, teshuvah and fasting, the same happens.
Rebbi and the ox: asking asylum
Sources
Torah
Nevi'im
Kesuvim
- a Tehillim 130:5 text index In the write-up: 0:21
- b Tehillim 27:14 text index In the write-up: 0:21
- c Tehillim 130:6 text index In the write-up: 1:45
- q Tehillim 130:7 text index In the write-up: 21:03
- t Tehillim 82:6-7 text index In the write-up: 21:47
- v Tehillim 130:8 text index In the write-up: 26:36
- aa Mishlei 29:4 text index In the write-up: 30:38
- ab Tehillim 34 text index In the write-up: 32:41
- ac Tehillim 34:16 text index In the write-up: 32:41
- ad Tehillim 34:23 text index In the write-up: 32:41, 40:25
Talmud Bavli
- e apparently Sanhedrin 98a index In the write-up: 1:45
- g apparently Rosh Hashanah 11a index In the write-up: 4:19
- h Gemara (place not identified) 4:21 index
- k apparently Sanhedrin 98a index In the write-up: 7:16
- o Gemara Taanis (place not identified) 11:34 index
- x Gemara (place not identified) 28:13 index
- ae Bava Metzia 85a text index In the write-up: 38:21
Midrash
- af Midrash (place not identified) In the write-up: 40:25
Zohar and Kabbalah
Rishonim
Acharonim and Chassidus
Other
- n Kisvei HaArizal (place not identified) In the write-up: 8:30
Key points
- 0:21 When a tefillah is not answered, a person must keep hoping to Hashem and keep praying.
- 2:47 'Mishomrim laboker' describes waiting for the geulah: a set time must come regardless, but there are 'mornings' when it can come earlier, and when one passes a Jew waits for the next.
- 7:16 Nobody knows exactly how the redemption will unfold; what is certain is the Torah's promise that it will be greater than anything that came before.
- 21:03 Even after many awaited dates have passed, a Jew does not give up hope; hoping, waiting and believing are the essence of Yiddishkeit and the tikkun of the world.
- 22:02 Adam's sin and the sin of the Golden Calf both came from not waiting, and a Jew's whole tikkun is to wait.
- 26:46 Beyond rescue from troubles, 'v'hu yifdeh es Yisrael mikol avonosav' speaks of redemption from sins, the greatest pedus.
- 31:06 Like a king who can pardon, Hashem can rise above strict judgment for one who throws himself upon Him and takes shelter in Him.
Questions and answers
-
Question: 20:52 If the morning passes, and the second morning passes, and still nothing happens, will a Jew give up hope?
Answer: 21:06 No: 'Yachel Yisrael el Hashem', a Jew keeps hoping, for Yiddishkeit consists of hoping, waiting and believing.
-
Question: 24:22 How can the maskilim 'do more' than the Malbim?
Answer: 24:37 A Jew must wait for every act through mitzvos and preparations, while they simply take what they want; the Jew's strength is his waiting.
-
Question: 26:59 What does 'v'harbeh imo pedus' add beyond the redemptions spoken of until now?
Answer: 27:08 That Hashem redeems Israel from all its sins, the greatest pedus.
-
Question: 39:25 Why was Rebbi punished, if the ox truly was created for slaughter?
Answer: 39:42 Because the ox threw itself under Rebbi and asked protection, like one who asks asylum at an embassy, and such a one must be saved.
Stories
-
12:04 R' Elya Roth foresees Russia's collapse
A Jew told the Mashgiach that many years earlier he was with R' Elya Roth, a great tzaddik in Yerushalayim whom the Mashgiach knew personally. At a time when Russia was so strong that America trembled before it, R' Elya Roth said it would not take long before Russia crumbled to pieces. It seemed a joke then. He also said, as a tradition from his rebbes, that Christianity could not last more than two thousand years.
In the story: Rabbi Eliyahu Roth, Reb Shlomke of Zvhil
-
13:46 The Stoliner Rebbe: Russia will last seventy years
About thirty years earlier the Stoliner Rebbe, R' Yochanan, lived in Williamsburg; the Mashgiach describes him as a very great man with many wonders. Young men of the Stoliner shtibel asked him what would be with Russia, which was causing Jews such suffering. He answered that Russia would last seventy years. When Russia fell, the newspaper headlines noted that it had lasted seventy years.
In the story: the Stoliner Rebbe, Rabbi Yochanan of Stolin
-
23:51 The Malbim: the maskilim can do more
The Malbim was rav in a town with maskilim and defeated them in every debate. Once he said the maskilim can do more than he can, and his students were astonished. He explained that when he wakes up hungry he cannot eat: he must wash negel vasser, daven, wash his hands, make hamotzi and dip the bread three times. The maskilim open their eyes and call for breakfast in bed. In that sense they can do more.
In the story: the Malbim
-
38:20 Rebbi and the ox that fled to him
The Gemara tells that an ox being led to slaughter ran and hid under Rebbi's garment, pleading to be saved. Rebbi told it to go, for it was created for this, and because he had no mercy he suffered for thirteen years. He was freed from his suffering when he had mercy on small creatures that someone wanted to sweep away.
In the story: Rabbi Yehudah HaNasi (Rebbi)
-
40:43 The man who claimed to be the king's relative
A man was taken to prison and beaten, and he protested that he could not be beaten because he was a relative of the king. He was brought before the king, who did not know him, and admitted that he was not a relative but had shielded himself with that claim. The king ordered him released, since he had used the king's name.
Insights
- 1:58 The Mashgiach reads 'mishomrim laboker' with Rashi's sense of 'shamar' as waiting for fulfillment: the soul watches for each 'morning' of possible redemption, and when one passes it waits for the next.
- 5:25 Moshe Rabbeinu's first coming, after which the bondage grew harsher, and his second coming that brought the redemption, parallel Moshiach ben Yosef and Moshiach ben Dovid.
- 18:05 At times set for a ketz, troubles often come instead of redemption, because the will in heaven to redeem awakens accusation that the Jews are unworthy.
- 22:02 The Tree of Knowledge was meant for squeezing its grapes for Kiddush on Friday night; Adam's sin was eating before Shabbos, so the root failure of the world was not waiting.
- 32:59 The alphabetical verses of Tehillim 34 represent the fixed order of creation and judgment, while the extra verse 'Podeh Hashem nefesh avadav' stands 'outside the brackets' because pedus is beyond that order.
- 36:29 At the Akeidah Hashem wanted Avraham, the attribute of chesed, to bind Yitzchak, the attribute of din, so that din loses its power; this repeats every Rosh Hashanah and Yom Kippur.
- 39:31 Rebbi was punished though the ox was truly created for slaughter, because one who asks asylum must be saved, and so Hashem saves whoever seeks shelter in Him even if guilty.
What the Mashgiach says to take from it
- 0:36 The Mashgiach says that one who prayed and was not answered must keep hoping and keep praying.
- 9:41 The Mashgiach says the Arizal's words about 5765 must be taken seriously and one must prepare for it.
- 9:22 The Mashgiach says a Jew must wait: wait for the geulah and wait in his daily service of Hashem.
- 38:02 The Mashgiach says one should rely on Hashem, throw oneself before Him and run to Him for shelter.
Mentioned in this shiur
People Adam HaRishon, Avraham Avinu, Moshe Rabbeinu, Rabbi Chaim Vital, Rabbi Chanina ben Dosa, Rabbi Eliezer (ben Hurkenos), Rabbi Eliyahu Roth, Rabbi Tzadok HaKohen of Lublin, Rabbi Yehoshua ben Chananya, Rabbi Yehudah HaNasi (Rebbi), Rabbi Yochanan of Stolin, Rashi, Reb Shlomke of Zvhil, the Arizal, the Baal Shem Tov, the Malbim, the Ohr HaChaim HaKadosh, the Rambam, the Ramban, Yitzchak Avinu
Terms בעתה אחישנה, כפרות, מדת הדין, מדת החסד, משיח בן יוסף, עץ הדעת, עקידה, קץ