אנכי ה' - האמונה למעלה מן השכל בחורים צעירים
Catalog entry: זמנים שבועות no. 7 Pocket Guide p. 31 תשס"ד (2003–04) Yiddish 40 min
Listen
About this shiur
The Mashgiach explains that the fiftieth day, on which the Torah and 'Anochi Hashem' were given, is above time, number and intellect, and that the emunah received there is what a Jew in the last generation must hold on to, driving out every thought of doubt.
The Mashgiach opens with three questions about Shavuos: we count only forty-nine days, Moshe added a day of his own, and we say 'the time of the giving of our Torah' on a day it was not given. He answers that the fiftieth day is above number and above this world, like the place of the aron that took up no space, and like the Torah, whose pesukim do not fit a count. 'Anochi Hashem' was given above intellect, and that is emunah, which is higher than knowledge. He brings the Ohr HaChaim that before Moshiach Jews will fall into the fiftieth gate of impurity, which is apikorsus, and says the task of this generation is simple faith. He speaks openly to bachurim troubled by doubts: the pain shows they believe, and driving such a thought out fulfills the mitzvah of 'velo sasuru'. With the parable of a building's main switch he shows how much each mitzvah and each sin does above.
Topics: Simple Emunah, Above Reason · Doubts in Emunah and Amalek · Matan Torah at Har Sinai
Order of the shiur
-
0:00 Three questions on the fiftieth day
The Mashgiach asks why the count is called fifty but only forty-nine days are counted, how Moshe could add a day, and why the first day of Shavuos is called the time of the giving of the Torah, especially in Eretz Yisrael. He begins to answer that the fiftieth day is above number, which belongs only to this world.
-
3:27 Above the world, above time and place
The Mashgiach explains that the world was made in seven days and the eighth week and fiftieth day are above it, so by Heaven's reckoning the day Moshe chose is the fiftieth. He compares it to the Kodesh HaKodashim, where the aron took up no space.
-
7:07 Anochi Hashem: emunah above knowledge listed in the guide
The Mashgiach notes that the Masorah's count of pesukim in parshas Yisro does not fit, because the Torah is above time and number. 'Anochi Hashem' was given above intellect, the redemption was completed on the fiftieth day, and that is why it is received as emunah, which is higher than knowledge.
-
11:00 The fiftieth gate and simple faith listed in the guide
The Mashgiach brings the Ohr HaChaim that before Moshiach Jews will fall into the fiftieth gate of impurity, which he identifies as apikorsus, spread today as never before. The task of the generation is simple faith in Hashem and in the whole Torah, its sages and their chiddushim, which those who learn lishmah see come with heavenly help.
-
16:17 Bachurim troubled by doubts listed in the guide
The Mashgiach tells of bachurim and older people who come to him troubled by doubts in emunah, and explains why he speaks about it: such doubts can befall anyone, often through pegamim. He says their pain shows that they believe, and that these are not real doubts but a confusion of the mind, like a person who keeps going back to check that the door is locked.
-
21:24 Driving out the thought: velo sasuru listed in the guide
The Mashgiach says that every Jew, even the greatest tzaddik, has a moment of doubt, so that he can fulfill the mitzvah of 'velo sasuru acharei levavchem'. Bringing the Bnei Yissaschar and the Tanya, he explains that one should not feel bad when such a thought comes, since it comes from the yetzer hara, and driving it out is one of the greatest mitzvos, especially now when the fiftieth gate must be broken.
-
27:31 The main switch: a person's hidden power
The Mashgiach says no person knows how important he is: his 248 limbs and 365 sinews are like buttons, as one push of the main switch lights the whole Empire State Building. A mitzvah lights up all the worlds and a sin like eating treif sets off destruction; he brings the Ba'al Shem Tov that a person must be told his strength, and the elephant that fears a fly.
-
32:42 Heavenly lamps and the week of malchus
The Mashgiach says a Jew who drives out a thought of doubt can save thousands of Jews, and brings the Maggid's reading that everything above comes from you. He describes each Jew's 248 heavenly lamps, brighter the greater he is, mentions Reb Mordechai of Chernobyl who passed away in the week of malchus, and closes with a brachah to receive the Torah with joy, love and fear of Hashem.
The shiur, written up
Three questions on the fiftieth day
The Mashgiach opens with three questions. The count is called fifty days, yet only forty-nine are counted. The Gemara says Moshe added a day of his own, so the Torah came on the fifty-first day; how could he? And why do we say 'the time of the giving of our Torah' on the first day of Shavuos, especially in Eretz Yisrael, where there is only one day? He answers that the fiftieth day is above number, which is a limitation of this world alone. a
Above the world, above time and place
The world was made in seven days, so the fiftieth day, the start of an eighth week, is already above the world. By the calendar Moshe's day was the fifty-first, but by Heaven's reckoning it is the fiftieth. Holiness can stand above place too: the Gemara says the aron stood in the middle of the twenty-amah Kodesh HaKodashim with ten amos on each side, because it took up no space. b
Anochi Hashem: emunah above knowledge
The Mashgiach adds that the Masorah's count of pesukim at the end of parshas Yisro does not fit, and the root of the answer is that where the Torah is, it is above time and number. On that day 'Anochi Hashem Elokecha' was given, above intellect. That is why it is called emunah: what one understands is knowledge, what one believes without understanding is emunah, and emunah is higher. c,d
The fiftieth gate and simple faith
The Mashgiach brings the Ohr HaChaim in parshas Shemos: before Moshiach, Jews will fall into the fiftieth gate of impurity, which the Egyptians could not reach, and will survive only through the Torah. The fiftieth gate of holiness is emunah; its opposite is apikorsus, which has never been so widespread. Amalek, whose gematria equals 'safek', puts doubts into Jewish hearts. e
The task of this generation, he says, is simple faith in Hashem, in the Written and Oral Torah and in the accepted Rishonim and Acharonim. A responsum he cites calls a chiddush of one who learns properly ruach hakodesh, and those who learn see how answers come beyond their own strength.
Bachurim troubled by doubts
Bachurim and older people come to the Mashgiach troubled by doubts in emunah. He tells of a man who complained of doubts to a Rebbe, who asked him whether he believes or not. He would rather not speak of this, but if Moshiach does not come very soon anyone could face such doubts; they do not mean a bachur is not fine, and often come through pegamim, especially pegam habris.
Some bachurim cannot sleep from these doubts. Their pain is a sign that they believe; someone who did not believe would be glad of them. These are not real doubts but a confusion of the mind, like a person who keeps going back to check a door he knows he locked.
Driving out the thought: velo sasuru
Even the greatest tzaddik must have a moment of doubt, the Mashgiach says, as a gift from Heaven, so that he can fulfill 'velo sasuru acharei levavchem', which Chazal explain as minus. The Bnei Yissaschar says one should not feel bad when such a thought comes; whoever drives it out with all his strength has done one of the greatest mitzvos. The mitzvah is not that the thought never come but that one drive it out. f,g,h
The main switch
No one knows how important he is. Each person has 248 limbs, like buttons: one push of the main switch in the basement lights the whole Empire State Building, and a mitzvah done with a limb lights up all the worlds. Eating treif, through the 365 sinews, is like setting off a nuclear bomb above that brings destruction below.
The Ba'al Shem Tov said a person must be told his strength; an elephant flees a fly because it does not know its own. Of a bomb that killed thirteen soldiers in Eretz Yisrael, the Mashgiach says the Arab has no power of his own; a Jew's misdeed set it off, and he does not know it.
Heavenly lamps and the week of malchus
A Jew who drives out a thought of doubt can save thousands of Jews, according to the height of his soul, for every Jew is a switchboard that can light or destroy all the worlds. The Mashgiach brings the Maggid on 'da mah lema'alah mimcha': all that happens above comes from you. j
A simple Jew has 248 lamps in Heaven of 200 heavenly watts; as he grows more upright they are changed for 300 watts, and a tzaddik's for thousands, but then a sin brings greater destruction. Reb Mordechai of Chernobyl had very bright lamps and passed away in the week of malchus, and his son the Trisker Maggid applied to him 'and Mordechai went out from before the King'. That week begins tonight. k
He closes with a brachah that all receive the Torah with joy, love and fear of Hashem, good middos and good resolutions.
Sources
Torah
Kesuvim
Mishnah
Talmud Bavli
Acharonim and Chassidus
Other
- c apparently Masorah note at the end of parshas Yisro In the write-up: 7:27
Key points
- 2:43 The fiftieth day is above number and above the seven-day order of the world, so it cannot be counted, and by Heaven's reckoning the day Moshe chose is still the fiftieth.
- 9:05 'Anochi Hashem Elokecha' was given above intellect, time and place, and so it is received as emunah, which is higher than knowledge.
- 11:49 Before Moshiach Jews are pulled into the fiftieth gate of impurity, which is apikorsus, and the task of this generation is to hold on to simple faith in Hashem and in the whole Torah.
- 19:58 Doubts that torment a person are not real doubts but a confusion of the mind, and his pain is itself a sign that he believes.
- 22:08 Even the greatest tzaddik has a moment of doubt, so that he can fulfill the mitzvah of 'velo sasuru' by driving the thought out.
- 27:33 A person does not know his own power: each of his limbs is a switch, and a mitzvah lights up all the worlds while a sin brings destruction.
Questions and answers
-
Question: 1:24 How could Moshe add a day, and how can we call the first day of Shavuos the time of the giving of the Torah when it was given on the fifty-first day?
Answer: 2:43 The fiftieth day is above number and above the world; by Heaven's reckoning the day of the giving of the Torah is the fiftieth.
-
Question: 6:36 How could there be ten amos on each side of the aron in a Kodesh HaKodashim of twenty amos, if the aron itself took up space?
Answer: 6:54 The aron took up no space; it was above place, as the Torah is above time.
-
Question: 7:27 Why does the Masorah's count of pesukim in parshas Yisro not fit the number of pesukim there?
Answer: 8:35 Where the Torah is given it is above time and number, so it need not fit a count.
-
Question: 22:10 Why must even the greatest tzaddik have a moment of doubt in his life?
Answer: 22:19 It is a gift from Heaven so that he can fulfill the mitzvah of 'velo sasuru' by driving the thought out.
Stories
-
16:46 The Rebbe who asked: do you believe?
The Mashgiach tells that a man once came to a Rebbe and complained that he was troubled by doubts. The Rebbe answered him with a question: does he believe or does he not believe? The Mashgiach tells this to the people who come to him with similar complaints.
Insights
- 2:52 Number and counting are a limitation of this world; the fiftieth day belongs to Heaven, so by Heaven's reckoning the day Moshe chose is the fiftieth even though the calendar calls it the fifty-first, and both days of Shavuos can be 'the time of the giving of our Torah'.
- 6:04 The place of the aron that took up no space, the pesukim of the Ten Commandments whose count does not fit, and the fiftieth day that is not counted all express one idea: where the Torah is, it is above time, place and number.
- 9:14 Emunah was received on the fiftieth day precisely because 'Anochi' was given above intellect; something understood is knowledge, and only something above understanding is believed.
- 12:27 The fiftieth gate of impurity is the mirror of the fiftieth gate of holiness: as holiness peaks in emunah, impurity peaks in apikorsus, and Amalek, whose gematria equals 'safek', puts doubt into Jewish hearts.
- 19:57 The suffering a bachur feels over his doubts is itself proof of his faith: someone who did not believe would be glad of the doubts.
- 23:13 A thought of doubt is sent from Heaven as an opportunity: the mitzvah of 'velo sasuru' is not that the thought never comes, but that one drives it out when it does.
What the Mashgiach says to take from it
- 23:04 The Mashgiach says that when a thought of doubt enters, a person should not feel bad about himself but drive it out with all his strength, and thereby fulfill a great mitzvah.
- 13:32 The Mashgiach says the task of this generation is to believe with simple faith in Hashem, in the Written and Oral Torah and in the accepted Rishonim and Acharonim.
- 25:05 The Mashgiach asks that bachurim remember, if doubts ever come to them, that they were told the doubts are a confusion of the mind and that driving them out is a mitzvah.
Mentioned in this shiur
People Moshe Rabbeinu, Rabbi Mordechai (Mottel) of Chernobyl, the Baal Shem Tov, the Bnei Yissaschar (Rabbi Tzvi Elimelech of Dinov), the Maggid of Mezritch, the Ohr HaChaim HaKadosh, the Trisker Maggid
Terms אמונה, אמונה פשוטה, אנכי ה' אלקיך, אפיקורס, ולא תתורו, למעלה מן הזמן, מלכות שבמלכות, מקום ארון אינו מן המדה, מתן תורה, ספק, עמלק, עקבתא דמשיחא, פגם הברית, רוח הקודש, רמ"ח אברים, שער החמישים