Purim Katan
Catalog entry: זמנים פורים קטן no. 10 Yiddish 1 hr 4 min
Not in the 2012 Pocket Guide; the title is taken from the folder and file name.
Listen
About this shiur
The Mashgiach explains that because Purim stems from the fiftieth level that is above time, Adar Sheni only repeats Adar Rishon, so the Purim of Adar Sheni is already present on Purim Katan, and the joy Jews add on their own is the acceptance of the Torah with love.
After a niggun, the Mashgiach raises a question on the Bnei Yissaschar: Tu B'Shvat is forty days before 25 Adar, when creation began, but in a leap year it is sixty days. He brings the Maharal that the Purim miracle is above time, from the fiftieth level, and uses this to answer the Magen Avraham's question on calling Shavuos the time of the giving of the Torah when it was given on the fifty-first day. Like a page of Gemara reviewed the next day, Adar Sheni only repeats Adar Rishon. He then brings the Chasam Sofer that a miracle obligates a day of thanks from the Torah, and that zrizin makdimin is not pushed off for a hiddur. This is why Purim Katan forbids eulogies and fasting. He asks how a prohibition fulfils the remembrance and answers that the Purim of Adar Sheni is already present, and that the joy the Chachamim left to the Jews themselves is the acceptance of the Torah with love.
Topics: Purim Katan and the Leap Year · Chodesh Adar · Purim
Order of the shiur
-
0:00 Opening niggun (Singing)
-
9:26 Tu B'Shvat in a leap year; Purim above time
The Mashgiach asks how the Bnei Yissaschar's forty days from Tu B'Shvat to 25 Adar works in a leap year, when it is sixty days. He then brings the Maharal that the Purim miracle is above time, coming from the fiftieth level, and shows the haste of the Megillah's events.
-
12:49 The fiftieth day and the two Adars listed in the guide
The Mashgiach answers the Magen Avraham's question on 'the time of the giving of our Torah': the fiftieth day is above time and includes the fifty-first. With a mashal of a page of Gemara reviewed the next day, he explains that Adar Sheni repeats Adar Rishon, which answers the Bnei Yissaschar question, and that today is in truth also Purim.
-
16:59 Chasam Sofer: a miracle obligates thanks listed in the guide
The Mashgiach brings the Chasam Sofer that a miracle obligates a Jew from the Torah to make a day of thanks, learned from the Gemara's kal vachomer from the shirah at the Yam Suf, and that the Anshei Knesses HaGedolah set its details. He adds the Chasam Sofer's and Chacham Tzvi's ruling that zrizin makdimin is not pushed off for a hiddur.
-
20:10 Why Purim Katan forbids eulogy and fasting listed in the guide
The Mashgiach explains that because zrizin makdimin applies, Adar Rishon must already carry a remembrance of the miracle, which is the prohibition of eulogy and fasting; the other details move to Adar Sheni for semichas geulah l'geulah, using the Chasam Sofer's distinction from ein maavirin al hamitzvos. He then asks how a mere prohibition can be a fulfilment.
-
23:47 Purim Katan and accepting the Torah with love listed in the guide
The Mashgiach answers that the Purim of Adar Sheni is already present on Purim Katan, and that Purim's essence is the acceptance of the Torah with love. The Chachamim did not make the festive gathering a mitzvah, leaving it to the Jews to rejoice on their own, and this joy on Purim Katan is that acceptance with love.
-
27:14 Interlude and an announcement
The shiur, written up
Tu B'Shvat in a leap year; Purim above time
The Mashgiach opens with a question on the Bnei Yissaschar, who explains that Tu B'Shvat falls forty days before 25 Adar, when creation began. In a leap year, he asks, the gap is sixty days. He then brings the Maharal that the Purim miracle is above time, coming from the fiftieth level beyond the sevens of time, which is why everything in the Megillah rushes. a
The fiftieth day and the two Adars
From here he answers the Magen Avraham's question: how is Shavuos called the time of the giving of the Torah, if Moshe added a day and it was given on the fifty-first? The Mashgiach says the fiftieth day, being above time, can include the fifty-first. d,e
A page of Gemara learned on Sunday and reviewed on Monday is one page, not two. So too Adar Sheni only repeats Adar Rishon, and a leap year holds just thirty days of Adar. Today, in Adar Rishon, is therefore in truth also Purim.
Chasam Sofer: a miracle obligates thanks
The Mashgiach brings the Chasam Sofer's responsa: when a miracle happens to Jews, even to one person, he is obligated from the Torah to make that day a day of thanks, as the Gemara learns from the shirah at the Yam Suf. The Anshei Knesses HaGedolah set its form: the Megillah, mishloach manos, matanos la'evyonim and the seudah. The Chasam Sofer, like the Chacham Tzvi, holds that zrizin makdimin is never pushed off for a hiddur mitzvah. f,g,h,i
Why Purim Katan forbids eulogy and fasting
So although joining one redemption to the next is a hiddur, Adar Rishon must already carry a remembrance of the miracle: the prohibition of eulogy and fasting. The other details move to Adar Sheni, since by the Chasam Sofer's distinction ein maavirin al hamitzvos, unlike zrizin, yields to a hiddur. The Mashgiach then asks how a mere prohibition can be an active fulfilment. j,h
Purim Katan and accepting the Torah with love
He answers that Purim Katan already holds the Purim of Adar Sheni, and that Purim is the acceptance of the Torah with love. The Chachamim knew Jews would gather, say l'chaim and eat kugel on their own, so they made no mitzvah of it; rejoicing unbidden is that acceptance with love.
Sources
Kesuvim
Talmud Bavli
Acharonim and Chassidus
- a apparently Bnei Yissaschar, Ma'amarei Chodesh Shevat index In the write-up: 9:32
- d apparently Magen Avraham, Orach Chaim 494 index In the write-up: 12:54
- f Shu"t Chasam Sofer (place not identified) index In the write-up: 17:01
- h Chasam Sofer (place not identified) index In the write-up: 17:01, 20:40
Other
Key points
- 11:13 The Mashgiach brings the Maharal that the miracle of Purim comes from the fiftieth level, which is above time.
- 15:21 Because Adar comes from the fiftieth day, Adar Sheni is a review of Adar Rishon, so the calendar's sixty days hold only thirty days of Adar.
- 17:16 According to the Chasam Sofer, a miracle obligates a Jew from the Torah to make a day of thanks to Hashem, and zrizin makdimin is not pushed off for a hiddur mitzvah.
- 20:40 The Mashgiach explains that the prohibition of eulogies and fasting on Purim Katan is how the Torah obligation of remembering the miracle is fulfilled in Adar Rishon.
- 24:24 Purim is an acceptance of the Torah with love, and the Chachamim left the festive joy to the Jews themselves so that they would do it of their own accord.
Questions and answers
-
Question: 10:43 How does the Bnei Yissaschar's forty days from Tu B'Shvat to 25 Adar work in a leap year, when it is sixty days?
Answer: 15:39 Adar Sheni repeats Adar Rishon, so only thirty days of Adar are counted and Tu B'Shvat is still forty days before.
-
Question: 12:54 The Magen Avraham asks how Shavuos is called the time of the giving of the Torah if it was given on the fifty-first day.
Answer: 13:32 Besides the Magen Avraham's own answer, the Mashgiach says that the fiftieth day is above time and so can include the fifty-first.
-
Question: 21:49 How may the Purim details be pushed off to Adar Sheni when there is a rule of ein maavirin al hamitzvos?
Answer: 21:57 The Chasam Sofer distinguishes: zrizin makdimin is not pushed off for a hiddur, but ein maavirin may yield to a hiddur such as semichas geulah l'geulah.
-
Question: 23:16 How is the remembrance of the miracle fulfilled on Purim Katan merely by not eulogizing or fasting, when it needs an active fulfilment?
Answer: 23:52 The Purim of Adar Sheni is already present on Purim Katan, and the joy Jews make on their own, as acceptance of the Torah with love, is the fulfilment.
Insights
- 13:32 The fiftieth day, being above time, can stretch to include the fifty-first, so Shavuos can be called the time of the giving of the Torah even on the view that it was given on the fifty-first day.
- 14:29 Like a page of Gemara learned on Sunday and reviewed on Monday, which is one page and not two, Adar Sheni is a review of Adar Rishon, so a leap year still has only thirty days of Adar.
- 20:27 Since zrizin makdimin is not pushed off for a hiddur, Adar Rishon must carry a Torah-level remembrance of the miracle, and the prohibition of eulogy and fasting on Purim Katan is that remembrance.
- 25:32 The Chachamim deliberately did not make the festive gathering of Purim a mitzvah, knowing Jews would rejoice on their own, because doing it unbidden is what acceptance with love means.
Mentioned in this shiur
People Adam HaRishon, Moshe Rabbeinu, the Bnei Yissaschar (Rabbi Tzvi Elimelech of Dinov), the Chacham Tzvi, the Chasam Sofer, the Magen Avraham, the Maharal of Prague
Terms אדר, אדר שני, זכר לנס, זריזות, יום החמישים, יצירת הולד, מהדרין, מתן תורה, פורים קטן, שער החמישים