Purim Katan
Catalog entry: זמנים פורים קטן no. 11 תשע"ט (2018–19) Yiddish 39 min
Not in the 2012 Pocket Guide; the title is taken from the folder and file name.
Listen
About this shiur
The Mashgiach explains that although the Megillah is read in Adar Sheni, on Purim Katan it is read in Heaven in the yeshivah of Rabbi Yosi, and its lights come down to break the concealment of Adar Rishon.
The Mashgiach opens with the Mishnah's wording 'megillah nikreis', the Megillah 'is read', and notes that every word hints at many matters. He brings the passuk of the two great luminaries: the moon, the smaller light, is Knesses Yisrael, diminished both in its light and in its year, which is about ten days shorter than the sun's. Each year the moon falls further behind, until in Adar Sheni of the leap year the two are evened out, so Adar Rishon is the time of distance. The halachah follows Rabban Shimon ben Gamliel that the Megillah is read in Adar Sheni, but Rabbi Yosi holds Adar Rishon, and both are the words of the living G-d. In Rabbi Yosi's heavenly yeshivah the Megillah is read on Purim Katan, and its lights break the concealment. The Mashgiach closes with Purim as a new Matan Torah, unity, and brachos.
Topics: Purim Katan and the Leap Year · Chodesh Adar · Hester Panim and Suffering
Order of the shiur
-
0:00 Why the Mishnah says 'megillah nikreis' listed in the guide
The Mashgiach asks why the Mishnah says the Megillah 'is read' rather than stating an obligation. He answers simply that the villagers may read early on the day of gathering, and adds that every word hints at many matters without end.
-
8:45 The moon diminished and the leap year listed in the guide
The Mashgiach brings the passuk of the two luminaries: the moon, Knesses Yisrael, was diminished in its light and in its shorter year. It falls further behind the sun each year in its longing to unite with Hashem, until Adar Sheni of the leap year evens the two out.
-
12:24 Adar Rishon and the view of Rabbi Yosi listed in the guide
The Mashgiach explains that Adar Rishon is the time of distance. The halachah follows Rabban Shimon ben Gamliel that the Megillah is read in Adar Sheni, but Rabbi Yosi's view is also true, as illustrated by Rabbeinu Tam's tefillin; in Rabbi Yosi's heavenly yeshivah the Megillah is read in Adar Rishon.
-
16:47 The lights of Purim Katan break the concealment listed in the guide
The Mashgiach explains that when the Megillah is read in Heaven on Purim Katan, wondrous lights come down that break the concealment and annul decrees, doubled when Adar Sheni comes. He brings the Chasam Sofer on the light of reading the Megillah and the Arizal on the new lights of Purim.
-
20:24 Purim as a new Matan Torah; unity and brachos listed in the guide
The Mashgiach says Purim Katan is a great day for Jews, that Purim is a new Matan Torah bringing pure desire for Torah and mitzvos, and that unity brings the salvation. He closes with brachos for yeshuos and for the revelation of the light of Moshiach, followed by singing and dancing.
The shiur, written up
Why the Mishnah says 'megillah nikreis'
The Mashgiach turns to the Mishnah's wording, 'megillah nikreis', the Megillah 'is read'. If reading the Megillah is an obligation, he asks, one would expect the language of a duty. Simply, he answers, this is no question: villagers may make use of their privilege to read on the day of gathering, when they come into town, so the Megillah can be read on the eleventh or twelfth, and the passive wording fits. a
Yet, he adds, every word of this kind holds many matters within it and hints at them without end. This opens the deeper reading that follows.
The moon diminished and the leap year
The Mashgiach brings the passuk in Bereishis 1:16 of the two great luminaries, the greater to rule the day and the smaller to rule the night. The moon is Knesses Yisrael, the smaller light, and it was diminished in two ways. First, its light is not like the light of the sun, because in exile, through hester panim (the hiding of Hashem's face), its light was reduced. b
Second, its year was shortened: the sun's year is 365 days and the moon's about 355. So each year the moon moves further from the sun. Knesses Yisrael longs to unite with Hashem and runs to reach the sun, but cannot, and falls further behind, until the leap year comes. Then, in Adar Sheni, the sun's year and the moon's are evened out, and Purim in Adar Sheni is of a wholly different kind.
Adar Rishon and the view of Rabbi Yosi
From here the Mashgiach explains that the distance is in Adar Rishon, since only in Adar Sheni does the drawing near begin; the decree of the smaller luminary is in full force in Adar Rishon. The halachah follows Rabban Shimon ben Gamliel that the Megillah and all its mitzvos are in Adar Sheni, but Rabbi Yosi holds that it is read in Adar Rishon. c
Yet in a dispute between the Tannaim, eilu v'eilu divrei Elokim chayim, both are the words of the living G-d. The Sanhedrin rules by the majority, following the passuk to incline after the many, and that governs the keeping of mitzvos; but in truth both views are true. d,e
To show this, the Mashgiach notes that one is not obligated to wear Rabbeinu Tam's tefillin, yet one who never wore them will not be admitted to Rabbeinu Tam's heichal in Heaven, since each Tanna and sage has a heichal where one learns as he holds. So there is a heichal of Rabbi Yosi, where the Megillah is read in Adar Rishon.
The lights of Purim Katan break the concealment
On Purim Katan, the Mashgiach explains, the Megillah is read in Heaven in Rabbi Yosi's yeshivah, and wondrous lights come down for the sake of the Jewish people. They break the whole hester panim of Adar Rishon, the month of concealment, to which he alludes with the Gemara's question of where Esther is hinted in the Torah. Jews have a great salvation on Purim Katan, and it will be doubled and redoubled when Adar Sheni comes. f
He cites the Chasam Sofer, saying he is always afraid to repeat it, that the light which comes down through reading the Megillah is extraordinarily great. That light comes down on Purim Katan too, even though Jews do not read then, and it annuls the decrees and the concealment.
The Arizal says that on Purim new lights come down that were never yet in the world, not on Shabbos and not on Yom Tov. These come on Purim Katan as well, because in Heaven the Megillah is read even when Jews below do not read it. Reading the Megillah reveals what was hidden.
Purim as a new Matan Torah; unity and brachos
The Mashgiach says Purim Katan is a great day for Jews, who need great salvations. A good feeling on Purim Katan, he says, is a sign that one needs it, wants it and rejoices in it.
He describes how Hashem drew the Jewish people near at the Exodus and at Matan Torah. On Purim there is even more: a new Matan Torah, which they had not merited at Sinai. Purim brings a pure desire for Torah, for yiras Shamayim, for mitzvos and for drawing close to Hashem.
He asks that Hashem help the Jewish people, individuals and families, merit great salvations and a bright Purim Katan, Shushan Purim Katan and Purim itself. Those days bring unity, as in 'go gather all the Jews', and he stresses that the joy of Purim is everyone together, with all Jews as one. Through that bond, he says, the salvation is drawn down, and he ends with a brachah for the revelation of the light of Moshiach. g
Sources
Torah
Kesuvim
Mishnah
Talmud Bavli
Key points
- 9:02 The moon, the smaller luminary, represents Knesses Yisrael, and it was diminished both in its light and in the length of its year.
- 10:49 Each year the moon falls further behind the sun, until the leap year, when in Adar Sheni the sun's year and the moon's year are evened out; Adar Rishon is the time of distance.
- 13:17 Although the halachah follows Rabban Shimon ben Gamliel that the Megillah is read in Adar Sheni, Rabbi Yosi's view that it is read in Adar Rishon is also true, since both are the words of the living G-d.
- 16:16 On Purim Katan the Megillah is read in Heaven, in Rabbi Yosi's yeshivah, and great lights come down that break the concealment of Adar Rishon.
- 22:28 Purim is a new receiving of the Torah and brings a pure desire for Torah, yiras Shamayim and mitzvos.
Questions and answers
-
Question: 7:08 If reading the Megillah is an obligation, why does the Mishnah say 'megillah nikreis', the Megillah 'is read', rather than stating a duty?
Answer: 7:55 Simply, because the villagers may read early on the day of gathering, the Megillah can be read on several days; but every word also hints at many deeper matters.
-
Question: 13:17 If the halachah follows Rabban Shimon ben Gamliel that the Megillah is read in Adar Sheni, what is there on Purim Katan?
Answer: 14:31 Both views are true; in Rabbi Yosi's heavenly yeshivah the Megillah is read in Adar Rishon, and its lights come down.
Insights
- 11:18 The leap year is read as the moon's chase after the sun: each year Knesses Yisrael falls further behind in its longing to unite with Hashem, until Adar Sheni evens the two out, which makes Purim in Adar Sheni of a wholly different kind.
- 15:07 Every Tanna has his own heichal in Heaven where one learns as he holds; just as one who never wore Rabbeinu Tam's tefillin will not be admitted to Rabbeinu Tam's heichal, so in Rabbi Yosi's heichal the Megillah is read in Adar Rishon.
- 18:43 The Megillah is read in Heaven on Purim Katan even when Jews below do not read it, so the lights of Purim come down on Purim Katan as well.
- 17:29 Adar Rishon, the time of distance, is itself a month of hester panim, and Purim Katan is when that concealment is broken.
Mentioned in this shiur
People Rabban Shimon ben Gamliel, Rabbeinu Tam, Rabbi Yossi (ben Chalafta), the Arizal, the Chasam Sofer
Terms אדר, אדר שני, בית שמאי, הסתר פנים, כנסת ישראל, מאור הקטן, פורים קטן