'Rebbi, I don't like fish'

About: Rav Shraga Feivel Mendlowitz

The story

Retold here from 4 tellings; details differ from one to another. Hear it in the shiur.

Reb Shraga Feivel Mendlowitz, who taught children when he came to America, once gave a talk about reward and punishment, saying the tzaddikim will eat the Shor Habor and the Livyasan. The children absorbed it with joy at being Jews. Then one boy raised his hand and said, 'Rebbi, I don't like fish', and the class laughed. With that one remark the whole seriousness of the talk was lost.

Where he tells it

In order of year where it is known; the undated ones last.

The shiurim in which the story is told
Shiur Occasion Year Language At
דיבורים המעוררים את הלב 1 אלול תשל"ה (1974–75) Yiddish 31:19
מלחמה לה' בעמלק - קליפה של ליצנות 6 בשלח תש"נ (1989–90) Yiddish 6:57
חבירים טובים; ליצנות 19 אמונה א' not known Yiddish 22:40
חסידות -- עיקרים וטפלים 14 שיעורים לבחורים not known Yiddish 4:31