Emunah - The Everlasting Essence of a Jewish Heart
Catalog entry: EMUNAH #1 (English) no. 1 Pocket Guide p. 71 English 26 min
Listen
About this shiur
The Mashgiach opens a series on the mitzvah of emunah, explaining that it is the foundation of all the mitzvos and a hereditary trait inherited from Avraham Avinu, a spark that cannot be extinguished in any Jewish heart.
The Mashgiach describes how, decades ago, he began teaching the mitzvos from the Sefer Chareidim, which arranges them by the limbs of the body and opens the mitzvos of the heart with emunah; over time his notes grew until he taught only emunah for a whole year. Emunah, he says, must be spoken about and fed constantly, like daily food, citing Yirmiyahu and Tehillim, and former students later thanked him for preparing them for challenges. Emunah is the first of the Ten Commandments and is renewed through Shema. He presents the dispute of the Rambam, who counts emunah among the 613 mitzvos, and the Ramban, who sees it as their prerequisite, since it is not phrased as a command. To approach the Rambam he distinguishes acquired from hereditary knowledge, using the bee, beaver and spider, and says emunah is a Jew's hereditary instinct from Sinai and Avraham Avinu. A kashya on this, like a helium balloon to a child, does not disprove it.
Order of the shiur
-
0:00 The Sefer Chareidim's order of the mitzvos
The Mashgiach recalls beginning to teach the mitzvos from the Sefer Chareidim, which arranges them by the limbs of the body rather than by the order of the Torah. He explains that the heart governs the emotional mitzvos such as tefillah, dveikus and love of Hashem, and that the first mitzvah of the heart is emunah.
-
4:42 Emunah must be fed constantly
The Mashgiach tells how his shiurim narrowed until he taught only the mitzvah of emunah for a whole year. Citing Yirmiyahu's rebuke and the passuk in Tehillim, he says emunah must be spoken about and nourished daily, and recounts how former students thanked him years later for preparing them for challenges to their emunah.
-
9:02 Rambam and Ramban: is emunah one of the 613?
The Mashgiach explains that emunah is the first of the Ten Commandments and is renewed through Shema several times a day. He presents the dispute of the Rambam, who counts emunah as a mitzvah, and the Ramban, who calls it the prerequisite of all the mitzvos, illustrated by tzedakah given without emunah. He adds that every mitzvah is phrased as a command while 'Anochi' is a statement, which seems to support the Ramban, and says the Rambam's view must be understood.
-
15:39 Hereditary knowledge: the bee, the beaver, the spider listed in the guide
The Mashgiach distinguishes hereditary traits such as hair color from acquired knowledge such as a sugya in Bava Metzia, then shows that some knowledge is inherited: a bee builds a honeycomb, a beaver a dam and a spider a web without being taught. He concludes that emunah in a Jew is such a hereditary instinct.
-
20:31 A spark of emunah from Sinai and Avraham Avinu listed in the guide
The Mashgiach says every Jew's soul remembers hearing 'Anochi Hashem' at Sinai, and that Avraham Avinu, the first believer, completed creation, so Jews are believers the sons of believers. He raises the kashya of Jews who do not believe and, with the mashal of a child seeing a helium balloon rise, explains that a kashya does not disprove an absolute truth. He closes that a spark of emunah in every Jewish heart cannot be extinguished, deferring the answers to the next shiur.
The shiur, written up
The Sefer Chareidim's order of the mitzvos
The Mashgiach recalls that when he began giving shiurim on the mitzvos, he used the Sefer Chareidim as the launching pad. Unlike other works that follow the order of the Torah or topics, it arranges the mitzvos by the limbs of the body. The heart governs the emotional mitzvos, such as tefillah, dveikus and love of Hashem, of the Torah and of Yisrael, and the first mitzvah of the heart is emunah. a
Emunah must be fed constantly
As his notes grew, the Mashgiach taught fewer mitzvos, until he spent an entire year on emunah alone, and even that was not enough. A person may think there is little to it, but emunah is the foundation of all the mitzvos. Yirmiyahu rebuked that emunah was lost and cut off from their mouths, and Tehillim calls on a person to nourish emunah. c,d
Just as no one eats one breakfast for his whole life, emunah must be fortified daily against the forces that challenge it. Former students thanked him decades later: when tests came, they were equipped, even against the apikorus within their own hearts.
Is emunah one of the 613?
Emunah is the first of the Ten Commandments, 'Anochi Hashem Elokecha', which shows it is the most important mitzvah, and it is reinforced through Shema, said twice a day from the Torah, with the Chachamim adding more. The Rambam counts emunah among the 613 mitzvos, while the Ramban holds it is above them: their foundation and prerequisite, for only one who believes there is a Commander can keep His commandments. e,f,g,h
A heretic who gives money gives charity but not tzedakah, since tzedakah means giving because Hashem commanded 'pasoach tiftach'. On the surface the Ramban seems right: every mitzvah is phrased as a command, like Kiddush or a fence on the roof, while 'Anochi' is a statement. Still, the Mashgiach says, the Rambam must be understood. i,j,k
Hereditary knowledge
To approach this, the Mashgiach distinguishes inherited traits, like hair and eye color, from acquired knowledge: a father who knows a sugya in Bava Metzia does not have a child born knowing it. Yet some knowledge is inherited. A bee builds a perfect honeycomb, a beaver a dam and a spider a web like its mother's, all without being taught. Emunah, he says, is such an instinct in a Jew, known to his neshamah because he is born a Jew.
A spark of emunah from Sinai and Avraham Avinu
Every Jew believes, whether he says so or not, because his neshamah, which stood at Sinai, remembers hearing 'Anochi Hashem', even when his conscious mind does not. Creation was missing something until Avraham Avinu, the first believer, with whom the Torah first mentions emunah, 'v'he'emin baShem'. Therefore Jews are called believers the sons of believers, having inherited emunah from him. e,l,m
Why, then, are there Jews who do not believe? The Mashgiach answers that a kashya on an absolute truth is not a refutation: a child who sees a helium balloon rise has a question, but things still fall. A spark of emunah in every Jewish heart cannot be extinguished, and he defers the kashyos to the next shiur.
Sources
Torah
- e Shemos 20:2 text index In the write-up: 9:26, 20:49
- f Devarim 6:4 text index In the write-up: 9:26
- i Devarim 15:8 text index In the write-up: 12:37
- j apparently Shemos 20:8 index In the write-up: 12:37
- k Devarim 22:8 text index In the write-up: 12:37
- l Bereishis 15:6 text index In the write-up: 20:49
Nevi'im
Kesuvim
Talmud Bavli
Rishonim
Acharonim and Chassidus
Key points
- 4:21 Emunah is the first mitzvah of the heart in the Sefer Chareidim and the first of the Ten Commandments, which shows it is the most important mitzvah.
- 6:14 Emunah must be constantly fortified and fed, just as a person cannot eat one breakfast for his whole life.
- 11:00 The Rambam counts emunah among the 613 mitzvos, while the Ramban holds it is above them, their foundation and prerequisite, since without emunah no act is a mitzvah.
- 17:25 Some knowledge is hereditary rather than acquired, as with the bee, the beaver and the spider, and emunah in a Jew is such a hereditary instinct.
- 20:54 Every Jew's soul remembers hearing 'Anochi Hashem' at Sinai, and Jews inherited emunah from Avraham Avinu, so a spark of emunah remains in every Jewish heart.
Questions and answers
-
Question: 5:36 If a person already believes in Hashem, what more is there to the mitzvah of emunah?
Answer: 5:42 There is very much to it: emunah must be spoken about and fortified constantly, like food eaten every day, because many forces challenge it.
-
Question: 11:30 Why does the Ramban hold that emunah is not one of the 613 mitzvos?
Answer: 11:40 Because it is higher than them: it is their foundation and prerequisite, since only one who believes there is a Commander can keep His commandments.
-
Question: 23:57 If every Jew believes by inheritance, why are there Jews who do not believe?
Answer: 24:14 A kashya on something absolute does not refute it, just as a helium balloon rising does not mean things do not fall; the Mashgiach defers the full answer to a later shiur.
Stories
-
7:29 Former students thank the Mashgiach for the shiurim on emunah
The Mashgiach recounts that bochurim listened to his series on emunah, some more attentively and some less. Ten, twenty and thirty years later he met them, and they thanked him. When challenges to their emunah came up in life, they were equipped with the ideas of emunah and were able to face them and be victorious.
Insights
- 1:02 The Sefer Chareidim, unlike other counts of the mitzvos, orders them by the limbs, and by opening with the heart rather than the head it signals that emunah, the first mitzvah of the heart, comes first of all.
- 12:35 Without emunah an act loses its identity as a mitzvah: a heretic who gives money gives charity, but not tzedakah, because tzedakah means giving because Hashem commanded it.
- 8:07 The 'apikorus' one must be ready to answer is not only the one standing opposite, but the one within a person's own heart.
- 18:44 Emunah in a Jew resembles the inborn knowledge of animals: just as a bee or beaver builds without being taught, a Jew believes by instinct, as an inheritance of the soul.
- 22:08 Creation was incomplete until Avraham Avinu, the first believer, came to perfect it, and the Jewish people's emunah traces back to him.
- 24:14 A kashya against an absolute truth is only a question, not a refutation, just as a helium balloon does not make a child doubt that things fall.
What the Mashgiach says to take from it
- 6:12 The Mashgiach says one must keep talking about emunah and keep fortifying it, giving it extra nutrition, especially nowadays.
- 7:57 The Mashgiach says a person must be prepared and equipped to answer the apikorus, including the one within his own heart, and keep his emunah in good working condition.
Mentioned in this shiur
People Avraham Avinu, the Rambam, the Ramban, Yirmiyahu HaNavi
Terms אמונה, אפיקורס, יסוד, ירושה, מאמינים בני מאמינים, מעמד הר סיני, נסיון, קבלת עול מלכות שמים, קושיא, רבונו של עולם, רמ"ח אברים, תרי"ג מצוות