Emunah - Concealed Behind Layers of Rationalization and Impurity

Catalog entry: EMUNAH #1 (English) no. ⁨2⁩ Pocket Guide p. 71 English 28 min

Listen

  1. Download · Length 28 min

Open in the listening app

Notes Notes prepared by AI from the recording; not reviewed, and not the Mashgiach's words. The recording is the source.

About this shiur

The Mashgiach explains that every Jew inherits emunah from Avraham Avinu, and that a Jew who denies Hashem is only covering his inner belief with a layer of rationalization, which is what the word 'kofer' means.

The Mashgiach begins with the point of the previous week: a Jew has emunah by inheritance, the way a newborn instinctively knows how to nurse and a migrating bird finds its way back to the same tree, and the ba'al teshuvah's return to his roots shows it. He then asks why so many Jews declare that they do not believe. His answer is that they do believe, but disbelief is comfortable, so they suppress their emunah through rationalization. He explains rationalization with the fable of the wolf and the sour grapes, everyday examples, and the story of Chiel of Beis El, who explained away the death of his sons. He contrasts people driven by taivah, who do teshuvah in old age, with those driven by ga'avah, who never admit their mistake. He then explains Avraham Avinu as a new species that believes in Hashem, which is why the Avos were barren and why a hey was added to Avraham's name. Finally he explains that a kofer is one who covers over the truth, like the tar on Noach's ark.

Topics: Foundations of Emunah · Simple Emunah, Above Reason · Doubts in Emunah and Amalek

Order of the shiur

  1. 0:00 Emunah as an inherited instinct listed in the guide

    The Mashgiach recalls that the children of Avraham, Yitzchak and Yaakov have emunah by inheritance, and compares it to a newborn who knows how to nurse and a bird that finds its way back to the same tree. He sees the same instinct in ba'alei teshuvah returning to their roots.

  2. 4:13 Why do Jews deny? Rationalization listed in the guide

    The Mashgiach asks why so many Jews say they do not believe, and answers that they do believe but suppress it, through the psychological law of rationalization. He notes that all of psychology is in the Torah, with the Chazon Ish's answer about psychology books, and explains rationalization with the fable of the wolf and the sour grapes.

  3. 8:55 Examples of rationalization: Chiel of Beis El listed in the guide

    The Mashgiach gives everyday examples of blaming something else, a bochur who blames the lighting and an inexperienced sukkah builder who blames the hammer, and then tells how Chiel of Beis El rebuilt Yericho despite Yehoshua's curse and found an excuse for the death of each son.

  4. 13:14 Taivah, ga'avah and teshuvah in old age listed in the guide

    After the bird that hides its head in the sand, the Mashgiach describes old people in a nursing home who return to Yiddishkeit once they can no longer indulge, and explains that those driven by taivah do teshuvah while those driven by ga'avah never admit their life was folly. A weak person who does not want to fight his yetzer says the fault is in religion.

  5. 18:22 Avraham Avinu, a new species of believer listed in the guide

    The Mashgiach says that a professed atheist really believes, because every Jew inherits the emunah of Avraham Avinu, of whom the Torah first says that he believed in Hashem. He explains that Avraham was a new species, severed from the previous generations, which is why he was barren and needed the hey added to his name, as with Sarah and Bilhah.

  6. 24:42 A kofer covers over the truth listed in the guide

    The Mashgiach sums up that the believing Jew is a new kind of being, which is why the Avos had to be barren. He then explains that 'kofer' means one who covers over a truth he knows, like the kofer (tar) smeared on Noach's ark and the kapores covering the aron, and concludes that every Jew believes deep down, as believers the children of believers.

The shiur, written up

Emunah as an inherited instinct

0:00

The Mashgiach recalls that the children of Avraham, Yitzchak and Yaakov have emunah by inheritance, like knowledge a creature is born with. A newborn knows how to form a vacuum to nurse; a bird returns each spring to the same tree with no instruments and little memory. Every ba'al teshuvah shows this sense: his heart navigates him back to Hashem.

Why do Jews deny? Rationalization

4:18

He asks why, then, so many Jews declare that they do not believe. They are not telling the truth, he answers: not believing is comfortable, so they suppress their emunah. This is the psychological law of rationalization.

5:54

Psychology is a young science, the Mashgiach notes, but all of it is in the Torah, which the Midrash calls the blueprint of creation; the Chazon Ish, as told in Pe'er HaDor, told a rabbi to learn it from Chumash and Rashi. He illustrates rationalization with the wolf who could not climb the vineyard fence and declared the grapes sour. b,a

Examples of rationalization: Chiel of Beis El

9:13

A weak bochur blames the lighting; a man building a sukkah who hits his thumb blames the hammer. Yehoshua cursed whoever would rebuild Yericho, and when Chiel of Beis El did so his sons died one after another. Driven by ambition, he blamed each death on a virus, a cold or a kidney disorder rather than admit the curse. d,e

Taivah, ga'avah and teshuvah in old age

13:25

Like the bird that hides its head in the sand, people are too weak to admit their faults. The Mashgiach describes old people in a nursing home who never kept Shabbos and now start davening: when young they found the Torah a brake on their pleasures, but once the doctor forbids indulgence there is nothing left to rationalize, and they do teshuvah.

15:53

Others never return. The difference, he explains, is the dominant drive: taivah, desire, or ga'avah, ego. A proud person's ga'avah only grows in old age and will not let him admit that his life was folly. Likewise a man who will not fight his yetzer says the fault lies in religion.

Avraham Avinu, a new species of believer

18:28

So the Mashgiach says a professed atheist is a liar: deep down he believes, as an heir of Avraham Avinu, of whom the Torah first says that he believed in Hashem. Avraham was a new species that naturally believes in Hashem, as is said each morning in Vayevarech David. f,g

20:39

This is why Avraham was barren: had he had children naturally, Yitzchak would simply be Terach's grandchild. Hashem severed him from the earlier generations and gave him a new power to reproduce through the hey added to his name. Chazal say that Sarah too had no children until a hey was added to hers.

A kofer covers over the truth

26:01

A kofer, the Mashgiach explains, denies a truth he knows inside. The word first appears with the kofer, tar, smeared on Noach's ark, and Rashi calls the aron's cover the kapores. Apikorsus is only a veneer; every Jew believes deep down, as believers the children of believers. i,j,k

Sources

Torah

  1. f Bereishis 15:6 text index In the write-up: 18:28
  2. i Bereishis 6:14 text index In the write-up: 26:01

Nevi'im

  1. d Yehoshua 6:26 text index In the write-up: 9:13
  2. e Melachim I 16:34 text index In the write-up: 9:13

Kesuvim

  1. g apparently Divrei HaYamim I 29:10 (Vayevarech David) index In the write-up: 18:28

Talmud Bavli

  1. h Gemara Bava Metzia (place not identified) 25:53 index
  2. k apparently Shabbos 97a index In the write-up: 26:01

Midrash

  1. b Midrash (place not identified) In the write-up: 5:54

Rishonim

  1. j apparently Rashi, Shemos 25:17 index In the write-up: 26:01

Other

  1. a Pe'er HaDor (place not identified) index In the write-up: 5:54
  2. c Ben Sira (place not identified) 7:10 index

Key points

  1. 0:00 Every Jew has emunah by inheritance from the Avos, like the knowledge animals and infants are born with rather than learn.
  2. 4:40 A Jew who declares that he does not believe is not telling the truth: he believes, but finds it comfortable not to, and suppresses his emunah.
  3. 8:19 Rationalization means that a person's ego will not let him admit his own fault, so he blames something else.
  4. 16:00 Whether a person does teshuvah in old age depends on whether his dominant drive is taivah or ga'avah.
  5. 19:11 Avraham Avinu was a new species, a human being who naturally believes in Hashem, and the hey added to his name gave him the power to continue that species.
  6. 26:35 A kofer is one who covers over a truth he knows inside; his heresy is only a veneer.

Questions and answers

  1. Question: 4:14 If emunah is in every Jew's blood, why do so many Jews declare that they do not believe?

    Answer: 4:40 They do believe; it is comfortable for them not to, so they suppress their emunah into the subconscious.

  2. Question: 15:49 Why do some irreligious people do teshuvah in old age while others do not?

    Answer: 16:00 It depends on the dominant drive: those ruled by taivah return once they can no longer indulge, but those ruled by ga'avah cannot admit their life was folly.

  3. Question: 20:39 Why was Avraham Avinu barren?

    Answer: 21:36 As a new species cut off from the previous generations he could not continue Terach's line, and needed a new power of reproduction, given by the hey added to his name.

  4. Question: 25:59 What does the word 'kofer' mean?

    Answer: 26:27 One who denies a truth he knows inside; the word means a covering, like the tar smeared on Noach's ark.

Stories

  1. 6:04 The Chazon Ish and the psychology books

    A rabbi who was already a good rabbi wanted to improve, and asked the Chazon Ish whether he should study psychology books to become a better rabbi. The Chazon Ish answered that he could get it from Chumash and Rashi: one who learns Chumash and Rashi should know psychology.

    In the story: the Chazon Ish

    told in 2 other shiurim →

  2. 7:34 The wolf and the sour grapes

    A wolf came to a vineyard and saw beautiful grapes, but a high fence surrounded it. For three days and three nights he tried to climb over and could not. He turned around and said the grapes were sour anyway.

    In the story: Ben Sira, Aesop

    told in 2 other shiurim →

  3. 10:12 Chiel of Beis El rebuilds Yericho

    Yehoshua cursed whoever would rebuild Yericho: his oldest son would die when he began and his youngest when he set up the gates. Chiel of Beis El, who had ten sons, rebuilt it, and his sons died one after another. The Mashgiach suggests that he wanted to be remembered in history, and for each death he found a natural cause rather than admit the curse.

    In the story: Yehoshua bin Nun, Chiel of Beis El

    told in 1 other shiur →

Insights

  1. 3:05 The Mashgiach compares the ba'al teshuvah to the migrating bird: with no memory or instruments it returns to the very tree where it was born, and so the Jew's heart navigates him back to Hashem by an inherited sense.
  2. 11:52 Chiel of Beis El found a natural explanation for each son's death, a virus, a cold, a kidney disorder, because his ambition would not let him admit Yehoshua's curse; the Mashgiach presents this as the model of rationalization.
  3. 15:36 Old people who return to observance once their desires are gone no longer need to rationalize, while those whose driving force is ga'avah grow even prouder in old age and cannot admit their life was folly.
  4. 20:39 Avraham Avinu had to be barren because he was a new species; had he been able to have children in the natural way, Yitzchak would simply have been a grandchild of Terach.
  5. 22:40 The Mashgiach connects the hey added to Avraham's and Sarah's names with the power to have children, and brings that Bilhah's name has two heys, one for Rachel and one for herself.
  6. 26:27 From the kofer (tar) on Noach's ark and the kapores that covers the aron, the Mashgiach explains that apikorsus is only a cover smeared over the emunah that remains inside.

What the Mashgiach says to take from it

  1. 18:22 The Mashgiach says that when one meets someone who professes to be an atheist, one should tell him he is a liar: deep down he does believe.

Mentioned in this shiur

People Avraham Avinu, Ben Sira, Bilhah, Chiel of Beis El, Rachel Imeinu, Sarah Imeinu, Sigmund Freud, Terach, the Chazon Ish, Yaakov Avinu, Yehoshua bin Nun, Yirmiyahu HaNavi, Yishmael, Yitzchak Avinu

Terms אמונה, אפיקורס, בעלי תשובה, גאוה, יצר הרע, ירושה, כפירה, מאמינים בני מאמינים, מעשה בראשית, עקרה, קללות, רבונו של עולם, תאוה

Report an error on this page