Emunah - A Hereditary Instinct from the Avos
Catalog entry: EMUNAH #1 (English) no. 3 Pocket Guide p. 71 English 27 min
Listen
About this shiur
The Mashgiach explains that a Jew's emunah is an inherited instinct, a piece of Avraham Avinu in every Yid that Hashem guards and that can never be lost, and that it comes through the mother as feeling rather than logic.
The Mashgiach compares Avraham Avinu to a seed from which a whole tree grows: every Yid was once in Avraham, and Avraham is now in every Yid. Following the Chiddushei HaRim, the bracha Magen Avraham means that Hashem guards this point of emunah, which can be covered up but never extinguished; a kofer only covers it. Since every Yid has a beginning in Avraham, he also has an end, and he will return. He tells the story of the Ramban's student Avner, who found his name in the middle letters of a verse in Ha'azinu, and explains that only the middle, the temporary part of a Jew, can be lost. He then speaks of the Seder night, when emunah is implanted in children through words and through matzah, wine and the cups, and explains that emunah, being emotion and instinct, comes from the mother. He ends that inherited emunah is not yet the mitzvah of emunah.
Topics: Foundations of Emunah · Avraham Avinu · The Pintele Yid: The Inner Point of Every Jew · The Seder Night
Order of the shiur
-
0:00 A piece of Avraham Avinu in every Yid listed in the guide
The Mashgiach compares Avraham Avinu to a seed that holds the whole tree, and explains with the Chiddushei HaRim that Magen Avraham means Hashem guards this point of emunah in every Yid. A kofer only covers it up; since every Yid has a beginning in Avraham he has an end, and when Moshiach comes the hidden spark will flare up.
-
5:46 The Ramban and his student Avner Story
The Mashgiach tells the story brought in the Kav HaYashar of the Ramban's student Avner, who left Yiddishkeit and challenged the Ramban to show him where he is alluded to in Ha'azinu. The Ramban found his name in the third letters of a verse that speaks of erasing their memory, and Avner did teshuvah and set out to sea in a boat without oars.
-
10:00 Why the middle letters: a Yid is never lost listed in the guide
The Mashgiach asks why the hint was in the middle letters, when one normally reads first or last letters, which contain the whole word. He explains that every Yid has a beginning in Avraham and therefore an end that returns to it, like the Torah reading that starts again from Bereishis; only the middle, the temporary part, can be lost, so even Avner will come back.
-
13:40 The Avos as a new beginning and the Seder night listed in the guide
The Mashgiach recalls that the Avos and Imahos could not have children because they were a new species cut off from the previous generations. He then explains that the Seder night was formed as the night to instill emunah in children, since Yetzias Mitzrayim, in which the Ten Utterances of creation were replayed backwards in the Ten Plagues, is the foundation of emunah.
-
18:02 Matzah and wine: logic and feeling listed in the guide
The Mashgiach explains that eating matzah, the food of emunah, internalizes emunah, and that the three matzos correspond to the Avos and the four cups to the Imahos, like the shin of three and four heads on the tefillin. Wheat brings knowledge while wine brings feeling; men lean to logic and women to emotion, and emunah is feeling and instinct.
-
21:29 Emunah comes from the mother listed in the guide
Through a rule of dikduk, dropping the final nun of a root to form a noun, the Mashgiach shows that from 'amen', to believe, comes 'em', mother. Everything else is determined by the father, but Jewishness follows the mother, because emunah is instinct like the spider's web or the beaver's dam. He ends that this inherited emunah, which Magen Avraham guards, is not yet the mitzvah of emunah, to be discussed next time.
The shiur, written up
A piece of Avraham Avinu in every Yid
The Mashgiach says emunah is in a Yid's blood, because every Yid carries a piece of Avraham Avinu. Every apple and leaf of a tree was once in its seed; so every Yid was once in Avraham, and Avraham is now in every Yid. This, he says, should give a person elation when learning about the Avos.
Following the Chiddushei HaRim, he explains the bracha Magen Avraham: Hashem shields that point of emunah so it can never be extinguished. A kofer only covers it, as kofer is the pitch that covered Noach's ark. Since a Yid's beginning is in Avraham, he has an end: when Moshiach comes, the spark under the sand will flare up. a,b,c
The Ramban and his student Avner
The Mashgiach tells a story brought in the Kav HaYashar. The Ramban's student Avner left Yiddishkeit and became a general. On Yom Kippur he summoned the Ramban and challenged him to show where he is alluded to in Ha'azinu. After a short tefillah the Ramban showed him a verse about erasing their memory from mankind, whose third letters spell Avner. Avner did teshuvah and let himself out to sea in a boat without oars. d,e
Why the middle letters
The Mashgiach asks why the hint was in the middle letters. First letters hold the whole word, as Rosh Hashanah holds the year, and so do last letters. He answers that a Yid rooted in Avraham has a beginning and therefore an end that returns to it, like the Torah reading that starts Bereishis again. Only the middle is temporary; there a Yid can get lost, but he will come back.
The Avos and the Seder night
The Mashgiach recalls that the Avos and Imahos could not have children because they were a new species, cut off from earlier generations, and needed a new power to give birth.
Hashem formed the Seder night as the night to instill emunah in children. The Rambam counts emunah among the 613 mitzvos, and Yetzias Mitzrayim is its foundation, since the Ten Utterances of creation were replayed backwards in the Ten Plagues: the first utterance is Bereishis, the last plague struck the firstborn.
Matzah and wine
Eating matzah, which the Zohar calls food of emunah, internalizes emunah. The three matzos are the emunah of the Avos and the four cups that of the Imahos, like the shins of three and four heads on the tefillin. Wheat, as the Gemara says, brings a child to recognize his parents; wine brings feeling. Men lean to cold logic, women to emotion, and emunah is feeling and instinct. f,g
Emunah comes from the mother
The Mashgiach brings a rule of dikduk: dropping the final nun of a root makes a noun. Shanan, to sharpen, as in 'veshinantam', gives shen, a tooth; ganan, to protect, gives gan, a fenced garden. h,i
Sources
Torah
Nevi'im
Talmud Bavli
Zohar and Kabbalah
Acharonim and Chassidus
Tefillah and Piyut
Other
Key points
- 0:43 Like every apple and leaf of a tree that was once in its seed, every Yid was once in Avraham Avinu, and a piece of Avraham is now in every Yid.
- 3:31 The bracha Magen Avraham means that Hashem shields the point of Avraham's emunah in every Yid, so that it can never be extinguished, only covered up.
- 4:44 Whatever has a beginning has an end; since every Yid begins in Avraham, he will ultimately return to his roots and do teshuvah.
- 15:03 On the Seder night emunah is implanted in children, both through telling of Yetzias Mitzrayim and through eating matzah, which the Zohar calls the food of emunah.
- 23:32 Emunah is instinct and feeling rather than logic, and therefore, unlike other traits, it is determined by the mother.
- 26:30 Inherited, instinctive emunah is one way of having emunah, but it is not yet the fulfillment of the mitzvah of emunah.
Questions and answers
-
Question: 7:30 How can every Yid, millions of them, be alluded to in the parsha of Ha'azinu?
Answer: 8:34 The Ramban showed Avner his own name hidden in the third letters of a verse in Ha'azinu.
-
Question: 10:07 Why was Avner's name hidden in the middle letters, when we normally interpret first or last letters?
Answer: 12:40 Because his beginning and end, rooted in Avraham, cannot be touched; only the temporary middle can be lost, so he will come back.
-
Question: 24:08 Why is Jewishness determined by the mother when all other traits follow the father?
Answer: 25:02 Because emunah is emotion and instinct, and 'em', mother, comes from 'amen', to believe.
Stories
-
5:51 The Ramban's student Avner and the verse in Ha'azinu
A student of the Ramban named Avner left Yiddishkeit and became an army officer and then a general. On Yom Kippur he summoned the Ramban and argued against him in a matter of halacha, and when the Ramban gave him a sharp look he said he had gone off because he could not believe the Ramban's teaching that every Yid is alluded to in Ha'azinu, and challenged him to show where he was. After a short tefillah the Ramban showed him the verse speaking of erasing their memory from mankind, whose third letters spell Avner, meaning he would be lost. Struck, Avner did teshuvah, and the next day he set out to sea in a boat without oars, and nobody knows what became of him.
In the story: the Ramban, Avner
Insights
- 2:14 The seed and the tree can be seen both ways: every Yid was once in Avraham, and Avraham is now in every Yid, a 'gene' of emunah that nurtures him.
- 4:08 A kofer is one who covers up, as the word kofer means pitch that coats the ark; the emunah is underneath, flickering like a spark under sand.
- 10:22 First and last letters hold the whole word, as Rosh Hashanah holds the year and its last day holds it for teshuvah; Avner's name in the middle letters showed that only the temporary middle of a Yid can be lost, never his beginning or end.
- 18:21 The three matzos stand for the emunah of the three Avos and the four cups for the four Imahos, matching the three-headed and four-headed shin of the tefillin.
- 24:36 Dropping the final nun of 'amen' leaves 'em', mother: emunah, being feeling and instinct, is passed through the mother, which is why Jewishness alone among all traits follows her.
What the Mashgiach says to take from it
- 2:32 The Mashgiach says that learning about Avraham, Yitzchak and Yaakov in these sedras should give a person elation, knowing that he was once part of Avraham Avinu.
- 17:19 The Mashgiach says that on the Seder night parents implant emunah in their children, both with words and by having them internalize it through the matzah.
Mentioned in this shiur
People Avner, Avraham Avinu, Dovid HaMelech, the Chiddushei HaRim, the Rambam, the Ramban, Yaakov Avinu, Yitzchak Avinu
Terms אמונה, יציאת מצרים, ירושה, כפירה, מגן אברהם, נקודה, עשר מכות, עשרה מאמרות, ראשי תיבות, רבונו של עולם, שופר של משיח, שורש, תשובה