The Enigma of the Survival of an Exiled Nation; Clarifying Anti-Semitism

Catalog entry: EMUNAH #1 (English) no. ⁨3⁩ Pocket Guide p. 72 English 38 min

Listen

  1. Download · Length 38 min

Open in the listening app

Notes Notes prepared by AI from the recording; not reviewed, and not the Mashgiach's words. The recording is the source.

About this shiur

The Mashgiach shows that the survival of a small, hated and exiled Jewish nation, its influence on the world and the endurance of its Torah were all foretold in the Torah and have no explanation other than Hashem's promise.

Continuing from the previous week, the Mashgiach recalls Hashem's promise that the Jews will be an eternal nation: the tochachah says He will not reject them in their enemies' lands, the Torah foretells they will remain few, and Yeshaya promises His love will never move away. He then asks why the nations hate the Jews, and answers that they know the Jews are the chosen people and superior in every field, and envy breeds hatred, as with Yosef's brothers. He reads testimony from Mark Twain, Tolstoy and John Adams on Jewish eternity and influence. Since then the Jews survived pogroms and Hitler, and Torah emerged stronger in quantity, as Moshe Rabbeinu foretold that Torah would never be forgotten. He tells of the Abarbanel, who refused to stay in Spain, and contrasts Spain's decline with Eretz Yisrael in the headlines. These wonders, like bread growing from the ground, go unnoticed only because people are used to them.

Topics: Netzach Yisroel · Yisroel and the Nations

Order of the shiur

  1. 0:00 The promise of an eternal nation listed in the guide

    Continuing from last week, the Mashgiach recalls Hashem's promise that the Jews will survive every exile, bringing the tochachah in Bechukosai, the prophecy that they will remain few, and Yeshaya's promise that Hashem's love will never move away.

  2. 4:10 Why do the nations hate the Jews? listed in the guide

    The Mashgiach asks why the nations hate the Jews when other peoples' claims to superiority are ignored. He answers that they know the Jews are truly the chosen people and excel in every field, and envy breeds hatred, as with Yosef and his brothers.

  3. 9:35 Mark Twain and Tolstoy on the Jew listed in the guide

    The Mashgiach reads Mark Twain's description of the Jews as one percent of mankind whose influence is out of all proportion and who outlived every great empire, and then Tolstoy's words calling the Jew the emblem of eternity whom no persecution could destroy.

  4. 15:50 John Adams' testimony and the root of hatred listed in the guide

    The Mashgiach tells how John Adams rejected a proposal to deny the Jews equal rights and wrote that the Hebrews did more to civilize mankind than any nation, teaching the world that there is a G-d. With such testimony from gentiles, he concludes, it is no wonder they envy and hate the Jews.

  5. 19:24 Surviving Hitler: Torah keeps the Jews listed in the guide

    The Mashgiach notes that since those writers the Jews survived Russian persecution, wars and Hitler, who targeted Torah learners first. Citing Rav Saadia Gaon that the Jews are a nation through their Torah, he shows that Torah emerged greater in quantity, though its quality declines with each generation's distance from Sinai.

  6. 23:42 A Torah never forgotten; a light to the nations listed in the guide

    The Mashgiach stresses that no scholar could have predicted three and a half thousand years ago that the Torah would last forever, yet Moshe Rabbeinu did, and Jews learn until old age. He adds that, as Yeshaya foretold, the nations walk by the Jews' light and kings were guided by Jewish ministers.

  7. 27:26 The Abarbanel and the expulsion from Spain Story

    The Mashgiach tells of the Spanish expulsion, when thousands chose to leave with nothing rather than convert, and of Don Yitzchak Abarbanel, the king's finance minister, who refused the king's request to stay. Since the Jews left, Spain declined into insignificance, while Eretz Yisrael is on the front page every day.

  8. 32:31 Wonders we take for granted listed in the guide

    The Mashgiach brings the blessing to Avraham that all families of the earth will be blessed through him, and calls the Jews' survival and influence one of the wonders that prove the truth of the Torah. He explains that people overlook such wonders because they are used to them, like the generation that ate the mann and was amazed that bread grows from the ground.

The shiur, written up

The promise of an eternal nation

0:02

Continuing from last week, the Mashgiach recalls that Hashem promised the Jews they would be an eternal nation, a promise no one else could give. In the tochachah of Bechukosai, Hashem says He will not reject them even in the land of their enemies, and the Torah foretells that they will remain few among the nations. Yeshaya adds that even if the mountains move, Hashem's love for Klal Yisrael will never move away. a,b,c

Why do the nations hate the Jews?

4:26

The Mashgiach then asks why the goyim hate the Jews. Tribes in Africa call themselves the best and nobody cares, while the Jews proudly say, every Yom Tov, that Hashem chose them from all the nations. They are hated, he answers, because the nations know it is true: Jews are always on top, ministers and financiers of kings, far out of proportion to their numbers. d,e

8:01

Envy breeds hatred, as with Yosef, whose brothers first envied him and then hated him. The honest ones among the nations admit that Jews lead in medicine, finance and science, with Einstein towering above all. f

Mark Twain and Tolstoy on the Jew

10:00

Recalling the book reports of his school days, the Mashgiach reads from Mark Twain: the Jews are barely one percent of mankind, yet their contributions to science, medicine and finance are out of all proportion. The Egyptian, Babylonian, Persian, Greek and Roman empires rose and vanished; the Jew saw them all, beat them all, and remains, holding a secret of immortality. g

13:39

He then reads Tolstoy, whom he calls the greatest writer the world had: the Jew, abused, burned and butchered by all nations, is still alive, never forsook his faith, and is the emblem of eternity whom no fire, sword or inquisition could destroy. h

John Adams' testimony

16:05

Next comes John Adams, who rejected a proposal to deny Jews equal rights and wrote that the Hebrews did more to civilize man than any nation, teaching the world there is a supreme G-d. The Mashgiach calls these witnesses certified goyim testifying that Jews are superior; no wonder they envy and hate them. i

Surviving Hitler: Torah keeps the Jews

19:39

Since then, the Mashgiach continues, Jews survived seventy years of Russian persecution, wars and Hitler, who first targeted those who learn Talmud, knowing that they keep the Jews alive. As Rav Saadia Gaon said, the Jews are a nation through their Torah. Today one large yeshiva has as many talmidim as all prewar yeshivos together. Quality, however, declines in every generation, as the Gemara says, because each is further from Sinai, the fountain, until the new fountain of Moshiach. k

A Torah never forgotten

23:44

No professor could have predicted, thirty-five hundred years ago, that the Torah would last forever, yet Moshe Rabbeinu said it would never be forgotten from the Jews. No other people learn until old age. Haskalah and reform ruined many, but a small remnant still learns. As Yeshaya foretold, the nations walk by the Jews' light, and kings were guided by Jewish ministers. l,m

The Abarbanel and the expulsion from Spain

27:26

The classic example is the Abarbanel. Ferdinand and Isabella decreed that Jews convert or leave Spain with only their clothes. Thousands chose to leave with mesiras nefesh; many were killed by bandits or drowned, and the rest settled in the eastern lands, becoming the Sefardim.

29:33

The king begged one Jew to stay: Don Yitzchak Abarbanel, a descendant of Dovid HaMelech and his finance minister. He refused and left with his brothers. Spain then declined into a small, insignificant country, while Eretz Yisrael is on the front page of the newspaper every day.

Wonders we take for granted

32:31

Hashem told Avraham Avinu that all the families of the earth would be blessed through him, and indeed the nations need the Jews and the honest ones admit it. The Mashgiach calls this one of the seven wonders proving the truth of the Torah: they have no explanation except that there is a G-d, who predicted it all. o

34:25

People overlook these wonders because they are used to them. The generation raised on the mann was amazed, after crossing the Yarden, that bread grows from the ground. So too, a nation of one percent surviving two thousand years without a country is a wonder like bread from heaven.

Sources

Torah

  1. a apparently Vayikra 26:44 index In the write-up: 0:02
  2. b apparently Devarim 4:27 index In the write-up: 0:02
  3. d apparently Devarim 7:6 index In the write-up: 4:26
  4. f Bereishis 37:11 text index In the write-up: 8:01
  5. j apparently Devarim 19:15 19:00 index
  6. l apparently Devarim 31:21 index In the write-up: 23:44
  7. o Bereishis 12:3 text index In the write-up: 32:31

Nevi'im

  1. c Yeshayahu 54:10 text index In the write-up: 0:02
  2. m apparently Yeshayahu 60:3 index In the write-up: 23:44

Talmud Bavli

  1. k Gemara (place not identified) index In the write-up: 19:39

Tefillah and Piyut

  1. e Yom Tov Amidah (Atah Bechartanu) (place not identified) index In the write-up: 4:26

Other

  1. g Mark Twain, Concerning the Jews (place not identified) index In the write-up: 10:00
  2. h Tolstoy, What Is a Jew? (place not identified) index In the write-up: 13:39
  3. i John Adams, letter on the Jews (place not identified) index In the write-up: 16:05
  4. n Abarbanel on Tanach (place not identified) 29:48 index

Key points

  1. 0:02 Hashem promised that the Jews would remain a small nation in exile yet never be destroyed, a promise only He could make.
  2. 6:35 The nations hate the Jews because they know the Jews are the chosen people and excel in every field, and envy leads to hatred.
  3. 8:31 Honest gentile writers and leaders, such as Mark Twain, Tolstoy and John Adams, testified to the eternity and unique influence of the Jews.
  4. 20:04 The Torah keeps the Jews alive; after Hitler tried to destroy it, Torah learning emerged greater in quantity, though its quality declines with each generation's distance from Sinai.
  5. 23:44 Moshe Rabbeinu foretold that the Torah would never be forgotten from the Jews, something no human being could have predicted.
  6. 33:38 These facts are among the wonders that prove the truth of the Torah and the existence of G-d; people overlook them only because they are used to them.

Questions and answers

  1. Question: 4:26 Why do the nations hate the Jews, when other peoples who call themselves the best are simply ignored?

    Answer: 6:35 Because they know the Jewish claim is true and that Jews excel everywhere, and they envy them; envy brings hatred.

  2. Question: 21:46 If the Torah emerged stronger after Hitler, why is the quality of Torah lower today?

    Answer: 22:01 That is not Hitler's doing: each generation is further from Sinai, the fountain, so Torah naturally diminishes until the new fountain of the days of Moshiach.

  3. Question: 34:09 If the survival of the Jews is such a wonder, why does nobody pay attention to it?

    Answer: 34:17 Because people are used to it, just as they take for granted that bread grows from the ground.

Stories

  1. 27:44 The Abarbanel refuses to stay in Spain

    King Ferdinand and Queen Isabella decreed that the Jews must either accept Christianity or leave Spain, taking nothing but the clothes they wore. Thousands chose to leave; many were killed by bandits or drowned, and the survivors settled in the eastern lands, which is why they are called Sefardim. The king asked one Jew to stay: Don Yitzchak Abarbanel, his finance minister, who ran the finances of the country. The Abarbanel refused and went with his brothers.

    In the story: the Abarbanel, King Ferdinand of Spain, Queen Isabella of Spain

    told in 1 other shiur →

  2. 34:32 The generation of the mann discovers bread from the ground

    For forty years in the desert bread came down from heaven, and the children born there knew nothing else. When they crossed the Yarden and the mann stopped, they saw bread rising from the ground and were amazed at the wonder, and made the bracha on it for the first time in their lives.

Insights

  1. 4:36 The nations' hatred is itself a sign of their recognition: they ignore other peoples' boasts but hate the Jews because, deep down, they know the Jewish claim to chosenness is true.
  2. 8:12 Envy and hatred go together, as the Torah describes Yosef's brothers first envying him and then hating him.
  3. 20:04 Hitler's attack on Talmud learners shows that even the enemy understood that Torah is what keeps the Jews alive, and the greater quantity of Torah after the war shows that he failed.
  4. 22:01 The decline in the quality of Torah is not Hitler's doing but the natural result of each generation's greater distance from Sinai, the fountain, until the new fountain of the days of Moshiach.
  5. 30:46 Spain's fall into insignificance after the Jews left, compared with Eretz Yisrael appearing daily on the front page, illustrates how the Jews drive the importance of the nations they live among.
  6. 34:25 Just as the generation raised on the mann saw bread growing from the ground as a great wonder, the survival of the Jews is a wonder that goes unnoticed only because it is familiar.

Mentioned in this shiur

People Albert Einstein, Avraham Avinu, Hitler, John Adams, King Ferdinand of Spain, Leo Tolstoy, Mark Twain, Moshe Rabbeinu, Queen Isabella of Spain, Rav Saadia Gaon, the Abarbanel, Yeshayahu HaNavi, Yishmael, Yitzchak Avinu, Yosef HaTzaddik

Terms גלות, ימות המשיח, מן, מסירות נפש, עם הנבחר, עם הנצח, קנאה, רבונו של עולם, תוכחה

Report an error on this page