The 50th Gate of קדושה is Opposed to the 50th Gate of טומאה
Catalog entry: EMUNAH #1 (English) no. 23 Pocket Guide p. 72 English 46 min
Listen
About this shiur
The Mashgiach explains that the fiftieth gate of tumah, apikorsus, stands opposite the fiftieth gate of kedushah, emunah, and that the doubts it sends before Moshiach must be ignored rather than argued with.
After a short warning about insects in food during the summer, the Mashgiach turns to Shavuos, the fiftieth day. Hashem took the Jews out of Egypt from the forty-nine gates of tumah just before they fell into the fiftieth, and since everything in creation is balanced, the fifty gates of tumah stand opposite the fifty gates of kedushah. The first forty-nine are midos, each with a nation as its vessel, as he shows with chesed and gevurah and the dream of the Ohr HaChaim; the fiftieth is daas: in kedushah emunah, in tumah apikorsus, whose force is Amalek, numerically equal to safek. Citing the Ohr HaChaim that before Moshiach the Jews fall into this gate, he describes the doubts that torment even believing Jews and explains that they are not logical, so one must ignore them and drive them away, a fulfillment of lo sasuru. He closes with the story of Reb Mendel of Vitebsk and the mazikim.
Order of the shiur
-
0:00 Insects in summer; the fiftieth gate listed in the guide
The Mashgiach warns about insects in food in the hot weather. He then turns to Shavuos: Hashem took the Jews out of the forty-nine gates of tumah before they fell into the fiftieth, and each day of Sefirah brings them into a gate of kedushah, with the fiftieth being emunah; since everything is balanced, fifty gates of tumah stand opposite fifty gates of kedushah.
-
4:07 The fiftieth gate is apikorsus listed in the guide
The Mashgiach explains that the forty-nine gates are midos while the fiftieth is daas: emunah in kedushah, apikorsus in tumah. He brings the Ohr HaChaim that before Moshiach the Jews will fall into the fiftieth gate; unlike in Egypt they now have the Torah to hold on to, and he says the world today is in that gate.
-
7:20 The seven nations and the midos listed in the guide
The Mashgiach explains that each bad midah has a nation as its vessel. Chesed is giving and gevurah is recoiling; in kedushah the right and the giver lead, as seen in dressing right first and in kiddushin, while in tumah the left dominates, as he shows from Esav and from the Ohr HaChaim's dream of two dogs. That is why the chesed of tumah is called Canaani, and he touches on Chiti for gevurah.
-
14:29 Amalek and the doubts of today listed in the guide
The Mashgiach identifies Amalek as the force of the fiftieth gate of tumah, whose purpose is to inject doubts in emunah. He describes how many believing Jews, even bnei Torah, suffer from such doubts and fight them, and how young men come to him crying, unable to sleep.
-
17:44 Doubts are not logical listed in the guide
The Mashgiach brings the Ruzhiner that before Moshiach simple emunah will be like climbing a slippery wall, and the Zohar on that period. He says even great tzaddikim had such doubts; they are not logical but like a bug, as in people who keep checking a locked door. One of the Erev Rav welcomes such thoughts, while a Jew from Har Sinai fights them; the Mashgiach says not to argue with them, for it is like a fly in a spider web.
-
24:02 Ignore them: lo sasuru listed in the guide
The Mashgiach tells of a man who could not daven because of an image in his mind, and Rabbi Nachman of Breslov told him to ignore it. Driving such thoughts away is the mitzvah of lo sasuru, and the Mashgiach gives a remez for it. The doubts are a temporary punishment with a limit, and one who fights them comes out with purer emunah.
-
28:14 Summary: emunah beyond understanding listed in the guide
The Mashgiach repeats and summarizes: the fiftieth gate of kedushah, reached on Shavuos, is emunah, which even Moshe Rabbeinu could not grasp, and its opposite is apikorsus, which is also beyond logic. He brings the Chovos HaLevavos's image of ink splashing into a poem, and explains that today, unlike pagan times, people believe in nothing, because this is the time of Amalek, numerically equal to safek.
-
34:44 A Jew from Sinai resists the doubts listed in the guide
The Mashgiach says every Jew who stood at Sinai would give his life for emunah, as whole communities did in the Crusades. The atmosphere is full of apikorsus, so such thoughts penetrate even believers, and he brings the Zohar praising one who holds on to emunah before Moshiach. A Jew from Sinai resents these thoughts while one of the Erev Rav welcomes them; again he says not to argue but to ignore them.
-
39:00 Reb Mendel of Vitebsk and the mazikim Story
The Mashgiach tells the story the Tzemach Tzedek related: a chassid of Reb Mendel of Vitebsk was taken by mazikim to a bris, warned by a captive woman not to eat, and told by his Rebbe to say they are nothing. The mazikim shrank away as he said it, and Ashmedai told him he had no power over him because his Rebbe's Torah was entirely for Heaven's sake.
The shiur, written up
Insects in summer; the fiftieth gate
The Mashgiach first warns that in hot weather insects are common in vegetables, grains and other foods, and one must be careful.
Turning to Shavuos, he explains that Hashem took the Jews out of the forty-nine gates of tumah just before they fell into the fiftieth. Since Hashem made one opposite the other, as in Koheles, fifty gates of tumah stand opposite fifty of kedushah, and the fiftieth of kedushah, reached on Shavuos, is emunah. b
The fiftieth gate is apikorsus
The forty-nine gates are midos, such as good and bad chesed; the fiftieth is daas: emunah in kedushah, apikorsus in tumah. The Ohr HaChaim writes that before Moshiach the Jews will fall into it. Before the Torah was given that would have been the end, but now the Torah lets them hold on, and the Mashgiach says the world today is in that gate. c
The seven nations and the midos
Each bad midah has a nation as its vessel. Chesed is to give and reach out to others; gevurah is to recoil into oneself and hold back. In kedushah chesed, the right side and the giver, leads: the Shulchan Aruch has the right side dressed first, and at kiddushin the man gives while the woman only accepts. d
In tumah it is reversed: with Esav the Chumash puts the women before the men. The Ohr HaChaim in Parshas Vayechi tells of a dream in which tumah fought him as two dogs; he defeated the male at once but the female only partly, because in tumah the female is stronger. That is why the chesed of tumah is Canaani, a subdued chesed. e,f
Amalek and the doubts of today
The nation of the fiftieth gate of tumah is Amalek, whose purpose is to inject doubts in emunah. Many believing Jews, even bnei Torah, now fight such doubts; young men come to the Mashgiach crying that they want to learn and daven yet cannot sleep because of them.
Doubts are not logical
The Ruzhiner said that before Moshiach simple emunah would be like climbing a slippery wall, and the Zohar speaks of that time. Even great tzaddikim had such doubts, because they are not logical: like a person who keeps checking a door he knows is locked, or washing clean hands. g
One of the Erev Rav welcomes such thoughts as permission to do as he likes; a Jew whose soul stood at Sinai fights them. Arguing is like a fly in a spider web: the more it struggles, the more it is entangled.
Ignore them: lo sasuru
A man told Rabbi Nachman of Breslov that he could not daven because he imagined a man carrying a cross, and Rabbi Nachman told him to ignore it. Having such a thought is no sin; giving it lodging transgresses lo sasuru, while driving it away fulfills that mitzvah. i
The doubts are a punishment with a limit, lasting days or years, and one who fights them comes out with purer emunah.
Summary: emunah beyond understanding
Summarizing, the Mashgiach explains that the fiftieth gate of kedushah cannot be grasped; the Gemara says even Moshe Rabbeinu was not given it, which is why the fiftieth day is not counted. That gate is emunah, believing without understanding, and on that day the first of the Ten Commandments, Anochi Hashem, was given. j,k
Opposite it, apikorsus is also beyond reason: it defies logic to say the ordered universe made itself, just as, the Chovos HaLevavos says, no one would think spilled ink wrote a poem. Earlier ages believed in idols; today people believe in nothing, because this is the time of Amalek, numerically equal to safek. l
A Jew from Sinai resists the doubts
Reb Mendel of Vitebsk and the mazikim
The Mashgiach tells a story the Tzemach Tzedek told. Mazikim invited a chassid of Reb Mendel of Vitebsk to a bris, and a captive Jewish woman warned him not to eat there or he could never leave. Reb Mendel told him to tell them they are nothing.
When they became fierce animals and charged, he kept saying it and they dwindled away, until Ashmedai said he had no power over him: his book holds the teachings of many leaders, but Reb Mendel's Torah had no personal interest and was not in it. The Tzemach Tzedek concluded that one should light candles when speaking of such a tzaddik.
Sources
Torah
Kesuvim
Talmud Bavli
Zohar and Kabbalah
Rishonim
Acharonim and Chassidus
Key points
- 3:37 The fifty gates of tumah stand opposite the fifty gates of kedushah, because Hashem made everything in balance.
- 5:13 The first forty-nine gates are midos; the fiftieth is daas: emunah in kedushah and apikorsus in tumah.
- 5:34 Before Moshiach the Jews fall into the fiftieth gate of tumah, and the Torah is what lets them hold on to emunah inside it.
- 14:36 Amalek is the force of the fiftieth gate of tumah; its purpose is to inject doubt in emunah, and Amalek is numerically equal to safek.
- 19:02 Thoughts of doubt are not logical and cannot be answered with logic; one must ignore them and not argue with them.
- 25:30 Driving such a thought away is itself the mitzvah of lo sasuru; the sin is only in giving it lodging in the mind.
- 27:05 The trial is temporary and has a limit; one who fights and stays with emunah comes out with emunah clearer and purer than before.
Questions and answers
-
Question: 4:16 What is the fiftieth gate of tumah?
Answer: 4:19 The forty-nine gates are midos, but the fiftieth is daas; in kedushah it is emunah and in tumah it is apikorsus.
-
Question: 8:17 Why is the chesed of tumah associated with Canaan?
Answer: 13:19 In tumah the left dominates the right, so the chesed there is subdued, nichna, the opposite of kedushah where chesed prevails.
-
Question: 17:09 Why do doubts come into the heads of Jews who believe and want to be good?
Answer: 18:27 Because this is the time before Moshiach when the fiftieth gate of tumah, the force of Amalek, fills the atmosphere; the doubts are not logical but a temporary trial and punishment.
-
Question: 44:24 Why did Ashmedai have no power over the chassid?
Answer: 44:49 Ashmedai's book holds the teachings of many leaders, giving him power over them, but Reb Mendel's Torah was said without the slightest personal interest, so it was not in the book.
Stories
-
12:24 The Ohr HaChaim's dream of two dogs
The Ohr HaChaim relates a dream in which the forces of tumah came to fight him in the form of two dogs, a male and a female. He overpowered the male at once, but with the female he had a hard battle and prevailed only partly. The Mashgiach explains that in tumah the female is stronger than the male.
In the story: the Ohr HaChaim HaKadosh, Yaakov Avinu
-
24:05 Rabbi Nachman and the man who could not daven
A man came to Rabbi Nachman of Breslov and said he could not daven, because whenever he began he saw in his imagination a man carrying a cross. Rabbi Nachman answered: what do you care, let him carry it; ignore it. The Mashgiach says this is how to treat thoughts of doubt.
In the story: Rebbe Nachman of Breslov
-
39:10 The chassid of Reb Mendel of Vitebsk and the mazikim
The Tzemach Tzedek told his chassidim that a mazik invited a chassid of Reb Mendel of Vitebsk to perform a bris; there a captive Jewish woman warned him not to eat or he could never leave, so he pleaded a bellyache. Reb Mendel told him these were mazikim and that next time he should tell them they are nothing. When they turned into fierce animals and charged, he kept saying they were nothing and they shrank and disappeared, until Ashmedai remained and said he had no power over him, because his Rebbe's Torah had no personal interest and so was not in his book. The Tzemach Tzedek concluded that one must light candles when speaking of such a tzaddik.
In the story: the Tzemach Tzedek, Rabbi Menachem Mendel of Vitebsk, Ashmedai
Insights
- 5:13 The fiftieth gate differs from the other forty-nine in kind: they are midos, while it is daas, so in tumah it is not a bad trait but apikorsus itself.
- 10:10 In kedushah the right side and the giver lead, while in tumah the left and the receiver dominate; this is why the chesed of tumah is Canaani, a chesed that is subdued.
- 30:44 Just as emunah in kedushah is beyond reason, apikorsus in the fiftieth gate of tumah is also beyond reason: it defies logic, as in the claim that the ordered universe made itself.
- 21:34 Being tormented by doubts is itself a sign that one's soul stood at Sinai; one of the Erev Rav is not troubled by them but welcomes them.
- 23:05 Arguing with doubts only entangles a person further, like a fly struggling in a spider web, because the doubts are letzanus and do not respond to logic.
- 34:03 Unlike earlier ages, when people believed in idols, the present age is one of believing in nothing at all, which shows that the fiftieth gate of tumah now rules the world.
What the Mashgiach says to take from it
- 0:04 The Mashgiach says to be careful about insects in food in the summer and to become familiar with the laws of insects in food.
- 22:37 The Mashgiach says that when thoughts of doubt in emunah come, one should not argue with them or try to answer them, but simply ignore them.
- 25:57 The Mashgiach says to drive such thoughts away, even to laugh them off, and to know that doing so fulfills the mitzvah of lo sasuru.
- 19:29 The Mashgiach says not to be afraid of such periods, to keep declaring one's belief in Hashem, and to trust that the trial will pass.
Mentioned in this shiur
People Ashmedai, Avraham Avinu, Esav, Moshe Rabbeinu, Rabbi Menachem Mendel of Vitebsk, Rabbi Yisrael of Ruzhin (the Ruzhiner), Rebbe Nachman of Breslov, Shlomo HaMelech, the Baal Shem Tov, the Ohr HaChaim HaKadosh, the Tzemach Tzedek
Terms אפיקורס, גבורה, ולא תתורו, זה לעומת זה, חסד, יובל, ליצנות, מזיקים, נ' שערי טומאה, ספק, עמלק, ערב רב, רבונו של עולם