קליפת נוגה בארבע יסודות. חילוק בין תיקון חטא דקליפת נוגה וחטא דשלש קליפות הטמאות.
Catalog entry: TANYA ENGLISH ז no. 17 Pocket Guide p. 74 English 52 min
Listen
About this shiur
Learning Tanya chapter 7, the Mashgiach explains how the permitted pleasures of kelipas nogah can be raised back to kedushah, why forbidden things stay bound until the final redemption, and how teshuvah from love turns even sins into merits.
The Mashgiach continues Tanya chapter 7. After the example of a light word said to lift the mood for learning, he turns to one who eats meat and drinks wine for pleasure alone. Pleasure comes from the element of water; such eating draws the food down into kelipas nogah. Because kosher food is 'heter', untied, it rises again when its energy is used for avodas Hashem, while forbidden food is 'asur', tied to the three impure kelipos. He explains that a person's possessions are sparks of his own soul, placed with him by hashgacha pratis, and why later generations added chumros. Even raised, permitted indulgence leaves a mark that the beating of the grave removes, while forbidden food needs Gehinnom or the end of death itself. He discusses samples of that future purification, and closes with teshuvah from love, which raises the baal teshuvah above the tzaddik and turns sins into merits.
Topics: Kedushah and Kelipah · The Two Souls (Tanya ch. 1-8) · Teshuvah · Serving Hashem in Physical Life
Order of the shiur
-
0:00 Review, and a light word for a good purpose listed in the guide
The Mashgiach reviews that deeds in thought, speech and action can tilt to kedushah or to the impure kelipos, then explains the Tanya's example of saying something humorous to lighten the mood so that one can learn and daven better.
-
3:45 The four elements and the pleasure of water listed in the guide
The Mashgiach turns to those who eat meat and drink wine only to satisfy desire. He explains the four elements, that every pleasure comes from the element of water, and why wine is especially dangerous, bringing a remark on the words of Kiddush.
-
10:05 Heter is untied, issur is bound listed in the guide
The Mashgiach explains that kosher meat and wine eaten for desire fall into kelipas nogah but rise back when he uses their energy for avodas Hashem, because a permitted thing is 'untied'; forbidden food stays bound and its energy cannot raise Torah.
-
14:41 Sparks of the soul in one's possessions
The Mashgiach explains that by exact hashgacha pratis every possession, his yarmulke, his bread, his home, carries sparks related to his soul, which he redeems by using them for Heaven's sake. He illustrates with a lost yarmulke, a broken glass and a loaf of bread, and brings the Ba'al Shem Tov and the Rambam on health.
-
23:17 Why later generations added chumros listed in the guide
The Mashgiach asks why the Rema forbids things the Gemara permits. He explains that borderline items could once be refined by great souls through their avodah and brachos, but later poskim saw that such things are now bound by thin strings that this generation cannot cut.
-
27:01 The mark that remains in the body listed in the guide
Reading the Tanya that a mark of the indulgence remains in the body, the Mashgiach compares it to a stain left on a shirt, connects it to Rashi on a tzaddik leaving a mark, explains why fervent young people can grow coarse with age, and brings that the beating of the grave removes this mark.
-
30:47 Dust and stains: the grave, Gehinnom and the end of death listed in the guide
With the mashal of a dusty mattress beaten clean versus a cloth that needs hot water, the Mashgiach explains that permitted indulgence is removed by the beating of the grave and forbidden pleasure by Gehinnom, while what is fully bound rises only when death is swallowed up forever.
-
35:14 Samples of the future purification listed in the guide
The Mashgiach brings the question how Moshe Rabbeinu could use Egyptian animals that had been worshipped as korbanos, and the Satmar Rav's answer that Yetzias Mitzrayim was a local sample of the future end of tumah. He adds the Rema on adorning the Seder table with pledged vessels and explains bitul b'shishim as a case Hashem arranges, which a person may not do himself.
-
41:59 Teshuvah from love: a private redemption listed in the guide
The Mashgiach explains the Tanya that teshuvah from great love, with a thirst like parched land, releases even forbidden things, a private sample of the future redemption. He brings that baalei teshuvah stand where complete tzaddikim cannot, and the Zohar's mashal of a bird escaping from a hand.
-
48:18 Sins become merits listed in the guide
The Mashgiach explains that the sin itself caused the baal teshuvah's higher level, so it is rectified at its root and becomes a merit, as Chazal say. He ends with a question on Rashi about a tzaddik son of a rasha and a tzaddik son of a tzaddik.
The shiur, written up
Review, and a light word for a good purpose
The Mashgiach reviews that what a person does in thought, speech and action can tilt either to kedushah or to the three impure kelipos. Moving from eating to speech, he explains the Tanya's example of someone who says something humorous to lighten the atmosphere, so that he or his students can learn Torah and daven better. Used for this purpose, the light word tilts to kedushah. a
The four elements and the pleasure of water
Now the Tanya turns to those who eat meat and drink wine to excess, not from hunger but to satisfy desire. The Mashgiach explains that everything in the physical world is made of four elements, fire, air, water and earth, which he likens to energy, gas, liquid and solid. All pleasure, he says, derives from the element of water; there is no pleasure without liquid. a
Heter is untied, issur is bound
If a person ate kosher meat and wine for desire and then returns to learning, using the strength he gained for avodas Hashem, the food is released from the kelipah and rises back to kedushah. The Tanya explains why: it was permitted, and the Mashgiach reads 'heter' and 'mutar' literally as untied, while 'asur' means tied down to the sitra achra. Forbidden meat stays bound; its energy brings no aliyah and even pulls the Torah down, unless he does teshuvah. a
Sparks of the soul in one's possessions
The Mashgiach explains that Hashem's hashgacha pratis over every detail is beyond imagining. Everything a person owns, his yarmulke, his bread, his clothing and home, contains sparks of kedushah that are extensions of his own soul. These sparks were mixed with evil through the sin of the Eitz HaDaas, and using them for Heaven's sake redeems them.
When the redeeming is complete the object is lost or broken; this, he suggests, is why Jews say 'mazel tov' when a glass breaks, like one released from prison. Someone else may find it and redeem the remaining sparks. Likewise, a particular loaf is grown and baked for a particular family, and each person receives his exact slice.
He adds that eating to be healthy is a good thought, citing the Rambam that one must care for one's health, and the Ba'al Shem Tov that a person eats, wears and lives in himself. Someone who moves into a house intending to learn Torah and serve Hashem there makes his dwelling there for Heaven's sake.
Why later generations added chumros
The Mashgiach notes that Yoreh De'ah has more chumros than any other part of Shulchan Aruch, where the Rema records customs to forbid what is basically permitted. He explains that some items lie on the borderline between kelipas nogah and the impure kelipos. Great souls of earlier centuries could separate the good from the evil through their avodah and brachos; later poskim saw that such items are now bound by thin strings this generation cannot cut. d
The mark that remains in the body
The grave, Gehinnom and the end of death
The Mashgiach compares the mark to dust in an old mattress, which beating removes, while something absorbed into cloth needs hot water. So the beating of the grave suffices for permitted pleasures, and Gehinnom, which is in essence a laundry, for forbidden ones, since the body will rise again and must be purified.
Samples of the future purification
Yet some cases can be rectified now. The Mashgiach brings a question: how could Moshe Rabbeinu use Egyptian animals that had been worshipped as korbanos, when such an object stays forbidden forever? The Satmar Rav answers that Yetzias Mitzrayim was a local sample of the future end of evil; as the Midrash says, Egypt's idols melted and burned, and the passuk speaks of judgment on Egypt's gods, so the tumah left the animals. i,j
Similarly the Rema allows adorning the Pesach table with vessels pledged by non-Jews, because on Pesach night everything becomes subordinate to Klal Yisroel. Bitul b'shishim, too, is such a case, which Hashem brings about when a soul deserves the spark; mixing in a forbidden drop on purpose achieves nothing, just as the geulah cannot be taken by force.
Teshuvah from love: a private redemption
Sources
Torah
Nevi'im
Kesuvim
Talmud Bavli
Midrash
- i Midrash (place not identified) In the write-up: 35:33
Zohar and Kabbalah
Rishonim
Acharonim and Chassidus
Key points
- 7:03 Pleasure derives from the element of water, and eating meat or drinking wine only for pleasure draws them down into kelipas nogah.
- 12:19 Kosher food eaten for pleasure can rise back to kedushah when its energy is later used for avodas Hashem, because 'heter' means untied; forbidden food is 'asur', tied to the impure kelipos.
- 15:49 Everything a person owns holds sparks of his own soul, brought to him by hashgacha pratis, and using it for Heaven's sake redeems them.
- 27:52 Even after permitted indulgence is raised, a mark remains in the body; it is cleansed by the beating of the grave, while what is absorbed from forbidden food needs Gehinnom or the end of death in the future.
- 42:17 Teshuvah from great love reaches the level of the future redemption and can release even forbidden things; a baal teshuvah's sins become merits because they fueled his return.
Questions and answers
-
Question: 23:34 Why did later poskim, such as the Rema, forbid things the Gemara permits?
Answer: 24:02 Borderline items were once refined by great souls through their avodah and brachos; later poskim saw that today such things are bound by thin strings this generation cannot cut.
-
Question: 28:33 Why do people who learned and davened with fervor when young become burnt out as they get older?
Answer: 29:08 They kept engaging in physical pleasures, even permitted ones, and the marks accumulated and made them coarser, like repeated stains on a shirt.
-
Question: 35:33 How could Moshe Rabbeinu take Egyptian animals that had been worshipped and use them for korbanos, when an object of avodah zarah is forbidden forever?
Answer: 36:13 At Yetzias Mitzrayim, when Egypt's idols were destroyed, there was a local sample of the future end of tumah, so the impurity left those animals.
-
Question: 38:39 How does the Rema allow adorning the Pesach table with gold vessels held as a pledge from non-Jews, when one may not use a pledge for oneself?
Answer: 39:10 Pesach is a taste of the future redemption, when everything becomes subordinate to Klal Yisroel on the night of Pesach.
-
Question: 45:47 Why is a baal teshuvah on a higher level than a complete tzaddik?
Answer: 45:56 His teshuvah comes with force; like a bird escaping from a hand, he breaks free of the sitra achra with a surge that carries him higher.
-
Question: 50:55 According to this, how is Rashi to be understood, that the tefillah of a tzaddik son of a rasha is not like that of a tzaddik son of a tzaddik?
Answer: 52:05 The tzaddik son of a rasha may be a great baal teshuvah, but the tzaddik son of a tzaddik has his parents' merits added to his own.
Insights
- 13:26 The Mashgiach reads the halachic terms literally: 'heter' and 'mutar' mean untied and 'asur' means tied, so a permitted thing that fell into kelipah can free itself while a forbidden thing is bound to the sitra achra.
- 18:21 A person's possessions are extensions of his own soul; when the work of redeeming their sparks is finished, the object is lost or broken, which the Mashgiach connects to saying 'mazel tov' when a glass breaks, and someone else finds it to redeem the remaining sparks.
- 24:19 The Mashgiach explains the growing chumros of later generations: borderline items are bound to the sitra achra by thin strings that earlier great souls could cut through their avodah and brachos, but this generation cannot.
- 31:07 Gehinnom is in essence a laundry: a dusty mattress is cleaned by beating, like the beating of the grave for permitted indulgence, while what has been absorbed needs hot water, like Gehinnom.
- 40:00 Bitul b'shishim is a small instance of the future purification that Hashem brings about when a soul deserves it; a person who mixes a forbidden drop in on purpose achieves nothing, just as the geulah cannot be taken by force.
- 43:05 Teshuvah from love is a private geulah: an individual can experience now, for himself, what the collective redemption will bring.
- 46:16 Like a bird that breaks free from a grip and flies higher than one that rises normally, the baal teshuvah escapes the sitra achra with greater force; since the sin produced that surge, it is rectified at its root and becomes a merit.
What the Mashgiach says to take from it
- 21:53 The Mashgiach says that when one moves into a house he should have in mind that he wants to learn Torah and serve Hashem there, so that his living there is for Heaven's sake.
- 20:48 The Mashgiach says it is a mitzvah to be healthy and to care for one's health, and eating with the intention of being healthy is a good thought.
Mentioned in this shiur
People Esav, Moshe Rabbeinu, Rashi, the Baal Shem Tov, the Rambam, the Rema, the Satmar Rav (Rabbi Yoel Teitelbaum), Yishmael
Terms ארבע יסודות, בטל בששים, השגחה פרטית, חיבוט הקבר, לעתיד לבוא, ניצוצות, סטרא אחרא, קליפת נוגה, רשימו, שלש קליפות הטמאות, תשובה מאהבה