ביאור קליפת נוגה - “קדושים תהיו” - כנגד פריעה. (ישמעאל ומצוות מילה)

Catalog entry: TANYA ENGLISH ז no. ⁨16⁩ Pocket Guide p. 74 English 52 min

Listen

  1. Download · Length 52 min

Open in the listening app

Notes Notes prepared by AI from the recording; not reviewed, and not the Mashgiach's words. The recording is the source.

About this shiur

The Mashgiach explains klipas nogah, the middle layer that a Jew can elevate by using permitted things l'shem shamayim, and shows the same pattern in milah and priyah, which he connects to Yishmael's claim on Eretz Yisrael.

The Mashgiach contrasts the three wholly impure klipos, which can never be elevated, with klipas nogah, a scale that tips toward kedushah or tumah depending on intent. Kosher food is nogah: eaten l'shem shamayim it rises like a korban, eaten in excess it sinks. Citing the Ramban on 'kedoshim tihyu' and a psychologist's view that enjoyment is a real human need, he sets two conditions: no excess, and l'shem shamayim. Reading Tanya chapter seven, he explains that nogah is all good above but mixed below, and that meat and wine taken for an expanded mind for Torah, or for oneg Shabbos, are elevated. He finds the same rule in milah, where three layers are cut off and the fourth, priyah, is pulled up. This leads to Yishmael's 'empty' milah, Chevron as the place of milah, Shechem as the place of priyah, and the Shaagas Aryeh's chiddush that Bnei Yishmael are not obligated in priyah.

Topics: Kedushah and Kelipah · Serving Hashem in Physical Life · Bris Milah · The Two Souls (Tanya ch. 1-8)

Order of the shiur

  1. 0:00 Two extremes and the middle of klipas nogah listed in the guide

    The Mashgiach reviews the previous chapters: through mitzvos a person becomes a seat for kedushah, through aveiros a seat for the three wholly impure klipos. He introduces klipas nogah as a middle layer, like a scale that can tip either way, unlike forbidden food, which can never be elevated.

  2. 4:34 Kosher food tips up or down; the Ramban on kedoshim tihyu listed in the guide

    Kosher food, bound up with the body, is klipas nogah: eaten l'shem shamayim it rises like a korban, eaten without need it is drawn into tumah until teshuvah lifts it again, while the harm of forbidden food stays even after teshuvah. He brings the Ramban on 'kedoshim tihyu' that even permitted pleasures must be sanctified, or a person becomes a degenerate with the Torah's license.

  3. 8:08 Why a person needs enjoyment, and its limits listed in the guide

    The Mashgiach relates a psychologist's point that a person fed without tasting would break down, so enjoyment is a real need; but it must not be in excess and must be l'shem shamayim. A cookie to perk up one's learning is fine, a cookie because of a pleasant aroma is excess, and he cites his rebbe Rav Mendlowitz on a Midrash about the Leviasan's belly being in America.

  4. 14:10 Tanya ch. 7: the vital soul and permitted things listed in the guide

    The Mashgiach reads the opening of chapter seven: the vital soul of a Jew, the life of kosher animals, birds and fish, permitted produce, and permitted deeds and words draw from klipas nogah, not from the three impure klipos. He illustrates with someone talking about a ball game, which is no aveirah, and explains that nogah in its source above, the brightness around Hashem in Yechezkel, is entirely good.

  5. 19:16 Elevating nogah: meat, wine and oneg Shabbos listed in the guide

    In this world nogah is a mixture of good and bad on the borderline between the impure klipos and kedushah; used for good, the good separates and rises. He brings the example of fat meat and fragrant wine taken to gain an expanded mind for Torah, citing Rava, and distinguishes this preparation for a mitzvah from oneg Shabbos and Yom Tov, which is a mitzvah in itself.

  6. 24:27 Milah and priyah; Yishmael's empty milah listed in the guide

    The Mashgiach shows the same rule in milah: the three layers cut off correspond to the three impure klipos, while the thin fourth layer of priyah is pulled up and elevated, like klipas nogah, and similarly the fourth year of a newly planted tree. He turns to Bnei Yishmael, circumcised at thirteen, and the Zohar that Eretz Yisrael was given to them for their empty milah and stays barren in their hands; the Gemara calls its renewed fruitfulness the clearest sign of the geulah.

  7. 30:00 Every place in Eretz Yisrael is a halachah

    The Mashgiach brings the Gemara in Temurah about the halachos forgotten after Moshe Rabbeinu's passing, which Osniel ben Kenaz restored through his pilpul, and an explanation that every place in Eretz Yisrael corresponds to a part of the Torah. Kiryas Sefer held those halachos, so mastering them let Osniel conquer the place; the plain meaning and the drash are both true.

  8. 33:50 Chevron, the place of milah listed in the guide

    The Mashgiach explains that Chevron is the territory of the mitzvah of milah, Avraham Avinu's own mitzvah, which is why he bought the Me'aras HaMachpelah with money. The Arabs, who claim Eretz Yisrael through their milah, fight hardest over Chevron, but he says Hashem will shake them out of the land like a sheet, since their milah is only an imitation.

  9. 37:19 The imitation and the genuine son of Avraham listed in the guide

    Responding to a listener, the Mashgiach brings the Ba'al HaTurim on the passage of Yishmael's end followed by the offspring of Yitzchak ben Avraham: Yishmael claims to be the son of Avraham, while Yitzchak is the genuine one. He says each generation has a rasha who embodies Yishmael's accusation, in his time Arafat, whose name he shows equals 'Yishmael ben Avraham' in gematria.

  10. 41:47 Shaagas Aryeh: milah without priyah listed in the guide

    The Mashgiach brings the Shaagas Aryeh's chiddush that Bnei Yishmael are obligated only in milah, not priyah, and confirms it from Kabbalah: their body stems from the three impure klipos, so they cannot repair nogah. He adds a gematria on 'tachlis', a Midrash he heard from Rav Mendlowitz, and the halachah that a gentile may bring only an olah, not a shelamim, since only a Jew can make eating into avodah.

  11. 47:58 Shechem, the place of priyah, and the closing listed in the guide

    The Mashgiach explains that priyah was given in Yehoshua's time, and Yehoshua comes from Yosef, whose purchased portion is Shechem, so Shechem is the place of priyah as Chevron is the place of milah. He closes that the work of klipas nogah is harnessing bodily pleasure to Hashem's will, like fourth-year fruit, and ends with a story of a seminary professor who spent his whole hour on the root of one word.

The shiur, written up

Two extremes and the middle of klipas nogah

0:32

The Mashgiach reviews that through mitzvos a person becomes a seat for kedushah, and through aveiros he is enveloped in the Sitra Achra. Between these extremes stands klipas nogah, which he compares to the thin fourth skin of a nut that is eaten with it, and to a scale that can tip either way. Forbidden food, by contrast, comes from the three wholly impure klipos; it can never be elevated and drags a person down.

Kosher food tips up or down

4:34

Kosher food, bound up with the body, is nogah. Eaten l'shem shamayim because he needs it, it rises like a korban; eaten without need, it sinks into tumah until teshuvah lifts it, while the harm of forbidden food remains even after teshuvah.

6:48

The Ramban on 'kedoshim tihyu' teaches that permitted pleasures too must be harnessed to kedushah; otherwise a person can be a degenerate with the Torah's license. b

Why a person needs enjoyment, and its limits

8:18

Every person needs enjoyment, the Mashgiach says. A psychologist told him that someone fed all his nutrients through a zipper in his stomach would eventually break down, because a person needs gratification as he needs air. So enjoying needed food is not a fall, on two conditions: no excess, and l'shem shamayim, knowing he eats to be healthy and serve Hashem.

12:24

A cookie with coffee to revive oneself for learning is fine; asking for one only because of the aroma of baking is excess. He cites his rebbe Rav Mendlowitz on the Midrash that the Leviasan's belly is in America, and warns that excess becomes part of the klipah. c

Tanya ch. 7: the vital soul and permitted things

14:10

The Mashgiach then reads the opening of Tanya chapter seven: the vital soul of a Jew, like the life of kosher animals, birds and fish and of permitted produce, draws from klipas nogah. Permitted deeds and words are no aveirah either; talking about a ball game, he notes, has no root in the forbidden. In its source nogah is all good, like the brightness around Hashem described in Yechezkel. a,d

Elevating nogah: meat, wine and oneg Shabbos

19:22

Down in this world nogah is a mixture, mostly bad with some good, standing on the borderline between the impure klipos and kedushah. When it is used for good, the good separates from the bad and rises.

21:52

So one who eats fat meat and fragrant wine to broaden his mind for Torah, as Rava said that wine and fragrance made him wise, elevates them like a korban. The Mashgiach distinguishes this preparation for a mitzvah from oneg Shabbos and Yom Tov, which is a mitzvah itself. e

Milah and priyah; Yishmael's empty milah

24:58

The same rule appears in milah: three layers are cut off, corresponding to the three impure klipos, while the fourth, thin as the nut's inner skin, is torn and pulled upward in priyah, as nogah is elevated.

27:24

Bnei Yishmael circumcise at thirteen like Yishmael, and the Zohar says Eretz Yisrael was given to them for this, but since their milah is empty the land stays barren under them. The Gemara in Sanhedrin calls the land's fruitfulness the clearest sign of the geulah, and the Mashgiach sees it blooming where Jews have settled, without calling it the beginning of the geulah. f,g

Every place in Eretz Yisrael is a halachah

30:57

The Mashgiach brings an explanation of the Gemara in Temurah: after Moshe Rabbeinu's passing many halachos were forgotten, and Osniel ben Kenaz restored them through pilpul. Every place in Eretz Yisrael corresponds to a part of the Torah, and Kiryas Sefer held those halachos, so mastering them let him conquer it. The plain meaning and the drash are both true. i

Chevron, the place of milah

34:00

Chevron, the Mashgiach says, is the territory of milah, Avraham Avinu's own mitzvah, so he acquired the Me'aras HaMachpelah with money as his own property. The Arabs, who claim the land through their milah, cling most to Chevron, as if holding its deed, but Hashem will shake them out like a sheet, since their milah is only an imitation.

The imitation and the genuine son of Avraham

38:45

Answering a listener, the Mashgiach brings the Ba'al HaTurim: the passage of Yishmael's end is followed by the offspring of Yitzchak ben Avraham, teaching that Yishmael is an imitation son of Avraham, claiming Chevron through milah, and Yitzchak the genuine one. In every generation a rasha embodies Yishmael's accusation; in his, the Mashgiach says, Arafat, whose name equals 'Yishmael ben Avraham' in gematria, as does the pasuk in Tehillim about the nations perishing from His land. m,n

Shaagas Aryeh: milah without priyah

42:22

Every halachah, the Mashgiach says, must hold true in Kabbalah too. The Shaagas Aryeh rules that Bnei Yishmael are obligated in milah but not priyah, since Avraham was given only milah and priyah came in Yehoshua's time. The Mashgiach confirms it: their body stems from the three impure klipos, so they can repair through milah but not nogah. o

46:12

He brings the halachah in Menachos that a gentile may bring only an olah, not a shelamim. Eating a korban as avodah, as the Gemara in Pesachim says the kohanim eat and the owners gain atonement, belongs only to a Jew, who can elevate nogah. q,r

Shechem, the place of priyah, and the closing

48:02

Priyah was given through Yehoshua, a descendant of Yosef, whose portion is Shechem, bought by Yaakov and given to Yosef. Just as Avraham's purchase, Chevron, is the place of milah, Shechem is the place of priyah, and there the Yishmaelim make the most trouble.

50:00

The Mashgiach closes that klipas nogah means harnessing the body's pleasures to Hashem's will, so that eating l'shem shamayim becomes 'kodesh hillulim', like fourth-year fruit. He ends with a story of a seminary professor who spent a whole Talmud lecture on the roots of one word. s

Sources

Torah

  1. s apparently Vayikra 19:24 index In the write-up: 50:00

Nevi'im

  1. d apparently Yechezkel ch. 1 index In the write-up: 14:10
  2. j apparently Yehoshua 15:15-17; Shoftim 1:11-13 31:00 index

Kesuvim

  1. k apparently Iyov 38:13 36:07 index
  2. n apparently Tehillim 10:16 index In the write-up: 38:45

Talmud Bavli

  1. e apparently Yoma 76b index In the write-up: 21:52
  2. g apparently Sanhedrin 98a index In the write-up: 27:24
  3. h apparently Megillah 17b 28:56 index
  4. i apparently Temurah 16a index In the write-up: 30:57
  5. l apparently Megillah 3a 36:35 index
  6. q apparently Menachos 73b index In the write-up: 46:12
  7. r apparently Pesachim 59b index In the write-up: 46:12

Midrash

  1. c Midrash (place not identified) In the write-up: 12:24
  2. p Midrash (place not identified) 45:37

Zohar and Kabbalah

  1. f Zohar (place not identified) index In the write-up: 27:24

Rishonim

  1. b apparently Ramban, Vayikra 19:2 index In the write-up: 6:48
  2. m apparently Baal HaTurim, Bereishis 25:18-19 index In the write-up: 38:45

Acharonim and Chassidus

  1. a Tanya ch. 7 text index In the write-up: 14:10

Other

  1. o Shaagas Aryeh (place not identified) index In the write-up: 42:22

Key points

  1. 3:17 The three impure klipos can never be elevated, while klipas nogah is like a scale that tips toward kedushah or tumah depending on how it is used.
  2. 4:34 Kosher food eaten l'shem shamayim rises like a korban; eaten without need it is drawn into tumah until teshuvah lifts it.
  3. 9:22 Enjoyment is a real human need, but it must not be in excess and must be for the sake of serving Hashem.
  4. 18:48 Nogah is entirely good above but mixed with bad in this world; using it for good separates the good and raises it.
  5. 24:58 In milah the three layers cut off correspond to the three impure klipos, and priyah, the fourth layer pulled upward, corresponds to klipas nogah.
  6. 43:02 Bnei Yishmael, whose body stems from the three impure klipos, can repair only through milah and have no share in priyah, which corresponds to nogah.

Questions and answers

  1. Question: 9:35 If a person enjoys his food, does that enjoyment go into klipas nogah's bad side?

    Answer: 9:45 Not when he needs it for his health, provided it is not in excess and is l'shem shamayim.

  2. Question: 36:53 Why do the Arabs fight over Chevron more than any other place?

    Answer: 36:57 Because Chevron is the place of milah, which they feel gives them the deed to Eretz Yisrael.

  3. Question: 43:02 Why are Bnei Yishmael obligated in milah but not in priyah?

    Answer: 43:10 Halachically, Avraham was commanded only milah and priyah came in Yehoshua's time; in Kabbalah, their body stems from the three impure klipos, so they can repair only that and not nogah.

  4. Question: 46:12 Why may a gentile bring only an olah and not a shelamim?

    Answer: 47:01 A shelamim is eaten, and eating as avodah means elevating nogah, which a gentile cannot do.

  5. Question: 49:08 How is Shechem specifically the place of priyah?

    Answer: 48:02 Priyah came through Yehoshua, a descendant of Yosef, and Yosef's purchased portion is Shechem, just as Avraham's is Chevron, the place of milah.

Stories

  1. 8:34 The psychologist and the zipper

    The Mashgiach relates that he once spoke to a psychologist. The psychologist told him that if a person had a slit made in his stomach with a zipper, and every day food was put in that way, giving him all the nutrients he needs, after a while he would have a nervous breakdown. The Mashgiach explains that just as a person needs food and air, he needs a certain gratification for his health.

    told in 1 other shiur →

  2. 50:55 The professor and the word 'kordiakos'

    The Mashgiach tells of a professor at a seminary who came to give an hour-long lecture in Talmud. They were learning a Gemara with the word for a certain malady of the heart, and he spent the whole hour explaining the word's Latin and Greek roots. When the hour was up he looked at his watch and said they had already learned for an hour.

Insights

  1. 9:14 Enjoyment itself is a human need, like air or food, so enjoying needed food is not a fall into klipah; only excess and the absence of l'shem shamayim tip it down.
  2. 25:19 Priyah is not removed but torn and pulled upward, which is exactly how klipas nogah is treated: not discarded, but elevated into kedushah.
  3. 42:28 The Shaagas Aryeh's halachic chiddush that Bnei Yishmael are not obligated in priyah is confirmed by Kabbalah: a body rooted in the three impure klipos cannot repair nogah.
  4. 32:11 Each place in Eretz Yisrael corresponds to a part of the Torah, so Osniel ben Kenaz, by recovering the halachos of Kiryas Sefer, became master of the place itself.
  5. 35:10 Chevron, bought by Avraham, is the place of milah, and Shechem, bought by Yaakov and given to Yosef, is the place of priyah; this is why the Yishmaelim make the most trouble in those two places.
  6. 46:20 A gentile may bring only an olah and not a shelamim because eating as avodah means elevating nogah, which only a Jew can do.

What the Mashgiach says to take from it

  1. 10:11 The Mashgiach says a person should eat what he needs to be healthy, even enjoy it, but should know that he eats in order to be able to serve Hashem.
  2. 11:07 The Mashgiach says one should eat only as much as one needs and stop, unlike eating merely because something smells good.
  3. 11:36 The Mashgiach says there is nothing wrong with taking a cookie or ice cream to lift one's mood so as to learn and daven with more vigor.

Mentioned in this shiur

People Avraham Avinu, Kalev ben Yefuneh, Moshe Rabbeinu, Osniel ben Kenaz, Rav Shraga Feivel Mendlowitz, Rava, the Baal HaTurim, the Ramban, the Shaagas Aryeh, Yaakov Avinu, Yasser Arafat, Yehoshua bin Nun, Yishmael, Yitzchak Avinu, Yosef HaTzaddik

Terms לשם שמים, מילה, מערת המכפלה, נפש הבהמית, עונג שבת, פריעה, קליפת נוגה, שלש קליפות הטמאות

Report an error on this page