לבינוני אין לו הבחירה להיות צדיק ממש שמואס ברע באמת' אלא שונא רע מצד שכליות. עצות לכך.
Catalog entry: TANYA ENGLISH י"ד no. 31 Pocket Guide p. 76 English 47 min
Listen
About this shiur
The Mashgiach explains Tanya chapter 14: the beinoni cannot make himself abhor evil like a tzaddik, but he can always control his deeds, speech and thoughts, and he can overcome his yetzer hara by awakening the hidden love of Hashem that would make him give his life rather than serve avodah zarah.
The Mashgiach reviews the tzaddik, who has done away with his yetzer hara, and the rasha, and then turns to the beinoni of Tanya chapter 14, whose lifelong struggle is the calling of most people. The beinoni cannot choose what his heart desires, and a stronger urge may even come from being raised to a higher level, but he can always control what he does, says and thinks. Every aveira is like avodah zarah, and every Jew has a hidden love of Hashem that would make him give his life rather than worship an idol, as a story of a Jewish thief shows. Answering a question, the Mashgiach explains that resisting daily is a real mesiras nefesh. The advice is to tell oneself: I do not want to be a rasha even for a moment. He connects the hidden love to the fortieth level of a person, Yom Kippur and the Rambam on forced consent, discusses lost bechirah, levels of judgment and teshuvah, and closes with chasing away a bad thought at once.
Topics: Tzaddik, Beinoni and Rasha (Tanya ch. 9-17) · The Yetzer Hara and Nisyonos · Mesiras Nefesh
Order of the shiur
-
0:00 The beinoni's lifelong struggle listed in the guide
The Mashgiach reviews the tzaddik and the rasha and opens chapter 14: the beinoni is born to struggle with his yetzer hara all his life, as most people are, and always wins the battle without killing the yetzer hara. He brings the Gemara that the yetzer hara is like a fly that keeps coming back.
-
4:25 The heart is not in his hands, deed, speech and thought are listed in the guide
The Mashgiach explains that every person can be a beinoni, and that having an urge to sin does not mean Hashem frowns on him; a stronger struggle may even come because he was raised to a higher level. The beinoni cannot control what his heart wants, but he can control his deeds, his speech and his thoughts, and say to himself that he does not want to be a rasha even for a moment.
-
10:23 Every aveira is avodah zarah; the hidden love listed in the guide
The Mashgiach recalls the earlier chapters: one who sins becomes a vessel for the sitra achra, worse than the lowliest creature because he has free choice, and the Ba'al Shem Tov said any deviation from Hashem's will is like avodah zarah. He explains why sin is called foolishness: every Jew, even the worst, has a hidden love that makes him ready to give his life rather than deny Anochi Hashem, which was heard directly from Hashem.
-
13:48 The thief who would not kiss the cross Story
The Mashgiach tells, from the sefer of Rabbi Yaakov Yosef, of a woman, by tradition Adel the daughter of the Ba'al Shem Tov, who said that Hashem did not make a bad choice in Klal Yisrael: a Jewish thief who had done every aveira was caught stealing from a church and let himself be burned rather than kiss the cross. He applies it to the Tanya: a person who sins would never sin if he knew that the aveira is also avodah zarah.
-
17:49 Daily struggle as mesiras nefesh listed in the guide
Answering a listener who argues that dying once is easier than a lifetime of struggle, the Mashgiach explains that nefesh means will, as Rashi explains, so resisting every day is mesiras nefesh, and Hashem counts its sum total, like a stone ground to sand that falls on a person grain by grain. He adds that only for the three cardinal sins must one give his life, because of v'chai bahem.
-
24:27 The advice: I do not want to be a rasha listed in the guide
The Mashgiach explains the Tanya's advice: to tell one's heart that a rasha is a seat for the sitra achra, separated from Hashem. The tzaddik hates evil because he loves Hashem, as in 'ohavei Hashem sin'u ra'; the beinoni loves evil only on the surface, while in the chamber of his hidden love he hates it. Even the lowliest Jew can give his life for Kiddush Hashem, and he fails in the smaller test only because a spirit of folly makes him forget his hidden love.
-
31:34 The fortieth level and Yom Kippur listed in the guide
The Mashgiach explains that a person is made of forty levels, like the forty days of the forming of a child; a sinner gets thirty-nine lashes, not forty, because in the fortieth level he never sinned, and that is the hidden love. On Yom Kippur, the fortieth day, it surfaces and every Jew is forgiven, and this is how the Rambam explains why a forced 'I want' is true. He adds the strategy of delaying the urge and says a person always has the strength to overcome.
-
36:46 When bechirah is lost; Hashem looks inside listed in the guide
Asked whether bechirah can be taken away, the Mashgiach agrees it sometimes happens, as with Yehuda and Tamar and in the Gemara about a woman whose consent came after force, but only in isolated cases that Hashem knows; a person should always assume he still has bechirah. He says Hashem knows the inner self of every Jew, and Yom Kippur looks at that inner self, and teshuvah means returning to one's root, where one is good.
-
41:51 Levels of judgment, teshuvah and bad thoughts listed in the guide
With the Yerushalmi on asking wisdom, Torah and Hashem what the sinner's punishment is, the Mashgiach explains these are higher and higher levels, and Hashem judges by the inner will of a Jew; on this he reads the Rambam that the geulah comes through teshuvah. He closes with the Tanya's point that a bad thought is not a sin but an opportunity: one must chase it away at once and not explore it, so that the heart is in one's hands.
The shiur, written up
The beinoni's lifelong struggle
After reviewing the tzaddik, who has done away with his yetzer hara, and the rasha, the Mashgiach opens Tanya chapter 14: the beinoni is born to struggle with his yetzer hara to his last breath. This is his shlichus, and that of most people. He always wins the battle but never kills the yetzer hara, which, as the Gemara says, is like a housefly that returns however often it is chased away. a,b
The heart is not in his hands; deed, speech and thought are
Every person can be a beinoni. The Mashgiach warns against a common mistake: feeling an urge to sin does not mean Hashem frowns on a person; Hashem watches who will win and has great nachas when he wins. The urges also vary, and a stronger struggle may mean he was raised to a higher level and must pass a test to prove himself worthy of it. a
Every aveira is avodah zarah
As the earlier chapters explained, one who sins becomes a vessel for the sitra achra, worse than the lowliest creature because he has bechirah, and the Ba'al Shem Tov said any deviation from Hashem's will is like avodah zarah. Every Jew, even the worst, has a hidden love that makes him ready to give his life for Anochi Hashem, which was heard directly from Hashem. d
The thief who would not kiss the cross
The Mashgiach tells, from the sefer of Rabbi Yaakov Yosef, of a woman, by tradition Adel the daughter of the Ba'al Shem Tov, who said Hashem made no bad bargain in choosing Klal Yisrael. A Jewish thief who had done every aveira was caught stealing from a church; offered his life for conversion, he refused to kiss the cross and was burned. The Tanya's point follows: a sinner would never sin if he knew the aveira is also avodah zarah. e
Daily struggle as mesiras nefesh
A listener argues that dying once seems easier than a lifetime of struggle. The Mashgiach disagrees: nefesh means will, as Rashi explains, so mesiras nefesh means setting aside one's will. A whole life of avodas Hashem does add up to more than dying once, but a test is not felt as a sum; people who suffer for years would not choose to be killed. f
Hashem, however, counts the sum total, so one who restrains himself each day gets credit for it all. The Mashgiach illustrates with a king's son sentenced to a large stone dropped on him; the king had the stone ground to sand, and no grain hurt him. Asked why one must give his life only for three mitzvos, he answers that the One who commanded those also said v'chai bahem for the others. h
The advice: I do not want to be a rasha
The Tanya's advice is that a person tell his heart he does not want to be a rasha, a seat for the sitra achra separated from Hashem; if he cannot say it strongly enough inwardly, the Mashgiach suggests saying it aloud. The tzaddik hates evil because he loves Hashem, as 'ohavei Hashem sin'u ra', just as one who loves a child hates whoever would harm it. i
The beinoni's love of evil is only on the surface. Deep inside he has a hidden love of Hashem, and in that chamber he hates evil and is a tzaddik. Even the lowliest Jew would give his life for Kiddush Hashem, so why not overcome a much smaller urge? Because a spirit of folly makes him forget that hidden love; knowing it helps him overcome.
The fortieth level and Yom Kippur
The Mashgiach explains that a person develops through forty stages, like the forty days of forming a child. A sinner receives thirty-nine lashes, not forty, because in his fortieth level he never sinned; that is the hidden love. On Yom Kippur, the fortieth day of teshuvah, it surfaces and every Jew is forgiven.
When bechirah is lost
Asked whether bechirah can be taken away, the Mashgiach agrees it sometimes happens, as with Yehuda and Tamar and in the Gemara's case of consent after force, but only in isolated cases Hashem knows. A person should always hold that he still has bechirah. Hashem knows the inner self of every Jew, Yom Kippur looks at it, and teshuvah means returning to one's root, where he is good. n,m
Levels of judgment and bad thoughts
Citing the Yerushalmi on asking wisdom, Torah and Hashem about the sinner's punishment, the Mashgiach explains these are not contradictions but rising levels; at the highest, Hashem sees that a Jew truly wants His will. So the Rambam ties the geulah to teshuvah: knowing the heart of a Jew is itself teshuvah. o,p
Sources
Torah
Kesuvim
Talmud Bavli
Talmud Yerushalmi
Rishonim
Acharonim and Chassidus
Key points
- 2:12 The beinoni is born to struggle with his yetzer hara until his last breath; this is his shlichus and that of most people.
- 6:25 A beinoni cannot control his heart's desires, but he can always control his action, speech and thought, doing and saying the opposite of what his heart wants and chasing away a bad thought.
- 10:23 Every aveira is like avodah zarah, and every Jew has a hidden love of Hashem that would make him give his life rather than serve an idol.
- 24:41 The beinoni overcomes temptation by telling himself that he does not want to be a rasha even for one moment, because in the chamber of his hidden love he truly hates evil.
- 20:01 Overcoming the yetzer hara every day is a true mesiras nefesh, since nefesh means one's will, and Hashem counts the sum total of these daily sacrifices.
- 44:47 A bad thought that comes into the mind is not an aveira; the aveira is letting it linger and exploring it, and the mitzvah is to chase it away at once.
Questions and answers
-
Question: 12:07 Why is sin called foolishness?
Answer: 12:25 Because every Jew, even a rasha, has a hidden love that would make him give his life rather than serve avodah zarah, and every aveira is avodah zarah; he sins only because he does not realize it.
-
Question: 29:42 If even the lowliest Jew would give his life for Kiddush Hashem, why does he not overcome a far smaller temptation?
Answer: 30:13 A spirit of folly makes him forget the hidden love in his heart, where he hates evil.
-
Question: 23:24 If daily resistance is mesiras nefesh, why is a person commanded to give his life only for three mitzvos?
Answer: 23:35 The One who commanded these three said that for other mitzvos one should live; in these three Hashem knows it is better to give one's life, and without v'chai bahem one would have to give his life for every mitzvah.
-
Question: 33:57 How can a forced 'I want' count as real consent?
Answer: 34:08 As the Rambam explains, every Jew in his heart wants to do Hashem's will and only his yetzer hara overcomes him; the blows remove the yetzer hara, so his 'I want' is the truth.
-
Question: 36:46 Can a person's bechirah be taken away?
Answer: 36:50 Sometimes, as the Gemara shows, but only in isolated cases for reasons Hashem knows; a person should always hold that he still has his bechirah.
Stories
-
14:24 The Jewish thief who refused to kiss the cross
The Mashgiach brings, from the sefer of Rabbi Yaakov Yosef, a woman's saying that Klal Yisrael did not err in choosing Hashem, and Hashem knew what He was doing in choosing them; by tradition the woman was Adel, the daughter of the Ba'al Shem Tov. A Jewish thief stole from a church and was caught, and they told him they would burn him unless he converted. He had done every aveira one can think of, but he would not kiss the cross, and they burned him.
In the story: Adel, daughter of the Baal Shem Tov, the Baal Shem Tov, Rabbi Yaakov Yosef of Polnoye (the Toldos), the Maggid of Mezritch
-
21:59 The king's son and the ground-up stone
The Mashgiach tells, unsure of who said it, of a king's son who transgressed a law for which the punishment was to have a large stone dropped on him from a roof. The king, unable to change the law, had the stone ground into sand and thrown on him, so each grain did him no harm. The Mashgiach uses it to show that what comes little by little can be borne, but Hashem counts the sum total.
Insights
- 7:06 A stronger urge to sin need not mean a fall: it may come because the beinoni was raised to a higher level and must pass a test to show he is worthy of it.
- 20:01 Nefesh in mesiras nefesh means one's will, so giving up a small desire each day is itself mesiras nefesh, and Hashem counts the sum total, while people judge only the single blow, like grains of a ground-up stone.
- 27:39 The beinoni is a tzaddik in one chamber of his heart: there, where his hidden love of Hashem lives, he truly hates evil.
- 31:58 A person is built of forty levels, and the sinner receives thirty-nine lashes rather than forty because his fortieth level never sinned; on Yom Kippur, the fortieth day of teshuvah, that level surfaces and every Jew is forgiven.
- 41:51 Wisdom, Torah and Hashem give different answers about the sinner not as contradictions but as rising levels, and at the highest Hashem judges by the inner will of a Jew, who truly wants to do His will.
- 44:49 A bad thought that enters the mind is not a sin but a privilege, an opportunity; the sin is only in letting it linger and exploring it.
What the Mashgiach says to take from it
- 24:41 The Mashgiach says one facing temptation should tell his heart that he does not want to be a rasha even for a moment, and if he cannot say it strongly enough in his heart, perhaps say it aloud.
- 36:00 The Mashgiach says a person should use strategies against the yetzer hara, such as delaying the urge by minutes, hours or days rather than jumping at the opportunity.
- 36:57 The Mashgiach says a person should always strengthen himself in the knowledge that he still has his bechirah.
- 8:42 The Mashgiach says that when a bad thought comes, one should chase it away at once and not let it linger or explore it.
Mentioned in this shiur
People Adel, daughter of the Baal Shem Tov, Moshe Rabbeinu, Rabbi Yaakov Yosef of Polnoye (the Toldos), Rashi, Tamar, the Baal HaTanya (Rabbi Shneur Zalman of Liadi), the Baal Shem Tov, the Maggid of Mezritch, the Rambam, the Ramban, Yehudah (son of Yaakov)
Terms אהבה מסותרת, בחירה, בינוני, יצר הרע, מחשבה דיבור ומעשה, מסירות נפש, נסיון, סטרא אחרא, עבודה זרה, פנימיות, צדיק, קידוש השם, קל שבקלים, רבונו של עולם, רוח שטות, רשע, שלש קליפות הטמאות, תשובה