בינוני הוא עובד ה'- צדיק הוא עבד ה'. מדריגות בבינוני - עובד ה'' ואשר לא עבדו.
Catalog entry: TANYA ENGLISH ט"ו no. 32 Pocket Guide p. 76 English 51 min
Listen
About this shiur
The Mashgiach explains that the beinoni's avodah is measured by his toil rather than his feelings, and that by striving to act like a tzaddik he can draw down the soul of a tzaddik to help him.
Continuing the Tanya's discussion of the beinoni, the Mashgiach distinguishes avodas avodah, serving Hashem with toil and without desire, from avodas matanah, the gift of enjoying one's service given to tzaddikim. He shows from Avraham Avinu at the Akeidah, who acted without any feeling, that toil is the essence of avodah, and describes Shabbos as a time when many taste the gift, telling stories of tzaddikim who sought the Shabbos within the food. He then answers the Tanya's opening question about the oath to be a tzaddik: some are born tzaddikim, depending on the root of their souls in Adam Harishon, and the oath obligates everyone at least to strive. The beinoni should meditate on how fleeting worldly pleasure is and on Hashem's greatness, training himself until it becomes second nature. Such effort sets corresponding forces above vibrating, and the soul of a tzaddik may come as an ibbur to help him.
Topics: Tzaddik, Beinoni and Rasha (Tanya ch. 9-17) · Gilgulim and Tikkun HaNeshamos
Order of the shiur
-
0:00 Avodas avodah and the Akeidah listed in the guide
The Mashgiach reviews that the beinoni cannot control the inclinations of his heart and that tzaddikim have levels. He distinguishes avodas avodah, toil without desire, from avodas matanah, the gift of enjoying the service, and shows from Avraham Avinu at the Akeidah that avodah is measured by effort, not feeling.
-
8:21 Shabbos, a taste of the gift listed in the guide
The Mashgiach explains that at special times, above all Shabbos, and after overcoming a test, Hashem lets a person taste the pleasure of Olam Haba. He tells of a poor young tzaddik who asked for Shabbos in his challah and fish, and of a chassid who said a poritz's lavish sugar spectacle could not compare to his pleasure saying Nishmas on Shabbos, while noting that not everyone merits it.
-
14:33 Born tzaddikim and the roots of souls listed in the guide
The Mashgiach returns to the Tanya's opening question about the oath to be a tzaddik and explains that Hashem created tzaddikim: some are born tzaddikim, as in the mashal of children born on a mountaintop. He explains that this depends on where a soul is rooted in Adam Harishon, in the head for Torah or the heart for tefillah.
-
21:34 The beinoni must still strive listed in the guide
The Mashgiach explains the Tanya's answer: the oath tells everyone to strive to be a tzaddik and at least not to be a rasha. The beinoni should set times to think about how fleeting worldly pleasures are and about Hashem's greatness in caring for him, bringing himself to joy in Hashem even if it is only imitation, and try even if he may never reach it.
-
31:05 Second nature and the tuning fork listed in the guide
The Mashgiach explains that through practice the beinoni's joy becomes second nature, like someone who trains himself to walk on his hands, and that the Tanya calls it truth according to his level rather than absolute truth. With the mashal of a piano tuner's tuning fork he explains that an act below sets the corresponding forces above vibrating, bringing a response from above.
-
36:36 Gilgulim and the decrees of persecution
The Mashgiach digresses on gilgul, explaining that it answers why tzaddikim suffer. He tells that those killed in the Chmielnicki decrees were explained as the souls of those who worshipped idols in Nevuchadnetzar's time, for whom the decree of Haman was nullified, alluded to by the large ches and tav in the Megillah.
-
40:00 The ibbur of a tzaddik's soul listed in the guide
The Mashgiach explains ibbur, when a tzaddik's soul temporarily dwells in another Jew, and tells of a talmid who merited the soul of Rabbi Pinchas ben Yair through pidyon shvuyim. He explains that a beinoni who strives hard sets the heavenly chords vibrating and may become a seat for a tzaddik's soul, serving with true joy, and mentions that Moshe Rabbeinu comes down once in fifty years in a tzaddik's soul.
-
46:06 The lasting mark of an ibbur
After a brief personal note, the Mashgiach adds that a born tzaddik earned it through a previous gilgul, and that an ibbur may last a moment or a lifetime but always leaves a mark of kedushah and an incentive to reach that level again. He answers a question briefly and closes with wishes for the summer.
The shiur, written up
Avodas avodah and the Akeidah
The Mashgiach reviews the Tanya's point that the beinoni is born a beinoni: he has no choice over the inclinations of his heart and remains tempted, since hating evil is given over to the heart. Even tzaddikim have levels, and a lesser tzaddik may not yet have reached the level of rendering his yetzer useless. a
He then distinguishes two kinds of service. Avodas avodah is toil: a person has no desire to learn, daven or give tzedakah, but does it anyway. Avodas matanah, the gift of enjoying the service, is a taste of Olam Haba given to tzaddikim. Yet the essence of a person's avodah is the toil.
He shows this from Avraham Avinu at the Akeidah, the greatest mitzvah ever done. Reading the verse in Bereishis that he saw from a distance, the Mashgiach explains that Hashem felt distant: his levels were taken from him, and he forced himself to go without feeling. Avodah is measured by effort, not feeling. e
Shabbos, a taste of the gift
At special times Hashem lets a person taste the pleasure of Olam Haba, above all on Shabbos, which Chazal call a semblance of Olam Haba. A very warm tefillah, even a day or a year later, may be the reward for overcoming a hard test. The Mashgiach says one should strive for real oneg Shabbos, coming from the Shabbos itself, not from the challah or the fish. f
He tells of a poor young tzaddik who asked Hashem to give him Shabbos for his challah and fish, and of a chassid who said a poritz's sugar-covered meadow could not compare with his pleasure saying Nishmas on Shabbos. Yet not everyone merits it: some wait at the window for three stars.
Born tzaddikim and the roots of souls
The Mashgiach returns to the question the Tanya asked at its beginning: how can the oath tell a person to be a tzaddik, when that is not in his hands, and how could it be said that Hashem created tzaddikim? He explains that some people are born tzaddikim, some could become tzaddikim, and some must work their way up. b,c,d
When someone asked a young prodigy, son of Rav Avraham HaMalach, how he reached his level without struggle, he answered with a mashal of children found playing atop a mountain: they were born there. This depends on the soul's root in Adam Harishon, alluded to in the verse in Iyov. A soul from the head is drawn to Torah; one from the heart, to tefillah, the service of the heart. g,h
The beinoni must still strive
The Tanya now answers: the oath tells everyone to strive to be a tzaddik, whether or not he succeeds, and at least not to be a rasha. Even a beinoni who can never be a real tzaddik is not freed from trying. He should set times to think that every worldly pleasure is fleeting: after the best meal he has nothing, and he is only feeding the worms. b,c
Second nature and the tuning fork
Through practice the beinoni's joy becomes second nature, like one who trains himself to walk on his hands: it works, but it is not natural walking. The Tanya therefore calls it truth according to his level, not absolute truth. i
Every act below has a corresponding force above. As a piano tuner's tuning fork sets matching strings vibrating, the beinoni who trains himself to act like a tzaddik brings a response from above.
Gilgulim and the decrees
The ibbur of a tzaddik's soul
In an ibbur a tzaddik's soul comes temporarily into another Jew, who becomes refined in avodas Hashem. A tzaddik once stood up for a talmid, explaining that it was for the soul that had come to him: the talmid had done pidyon shvuyim, and Rabbi Pinchas ben Yair's soul came to help him.
The lasting mark of an ibbur
A born tzaddik earned it in a previous gilgul. An ibbur may stay a lifetime or a single Shabbos, but even when it leaves it leaves a residue of kedushah, and recalling the experience spurs a person to reach it again. The Mashgiach closes with wishes for a good summer, to learn and daven well.
Sources
Torah
Kesuvim
Talmud Bavli
Acharonim and Chassidus
Key points
- 4:40 Avodas avodah, serving Hashem through toil without desire, is the essence of a person's avodah; avodas matanah, enjoying the service, is a gift given to tzaddikim.
- 7:05 Avraham Avinu performed the Akeidah, the greatest mitzvah ever done, with his spiritual levels taken from him and without feeling, showing that avodah is measured by effort, not by feeling.
- 15:40 Some are born tzaddikim, depending on where their soul is rooted in Adam Harishon, while others must struggle not to be a rasha.
- 22:31 The oath to be a tzaddik obligates even a beinoni who cannot reach that level to strive for it, by setting times to meditate on Hashem's greatness and the emptiness of worldly pleasure.
- 31:05 Through practice the beinoni's joy in Hashem becomes second nature, though it is not the tzaddik's true nature.
- 40:12 A person who strives to act like a tzaddik can become a dwelling for the soul of a tzaddik that comes as an ibbur, and through it serve Hashem with true joy.
Questions and answers
-
Question: 6:40 How did Avraham Avinu feel at the Akeidah: did he feel exultation?
Answer: 6:46 No; his levels were taken from him, Hashem seemed distant, and he had to struggle against the yetzer and force himself to go.
-
Question: 14:53 How could the oath tell a person to be a tzaddik, if being a tzaddik is not in his choice?
Answer: 22:15 The oath tells everyone to strive to be a tzaddik, whether or not he succeeds, and at least not to be a rasha; even a beinoni must try.
-
Question: 16:34 How did the young prodigy reach his level without the struggle others needed?
Answer: 17:17 Like the children found at the top of the mountain, he was born there.
Stories
-
10:14 Shabbos for the challah
A great tzaddik was poor in his youth and scraped together a few pennies to buy challah and fish for Shabbos. When he sat down Friday night to eat his challah, he asked Hashem: You gave me challah for Shabbos, please give me Shabbos for the challah, and he said the same over the fish. The Mashgiach adds that he himself watched a wondrous tzaddik eat fish on Friday night with obvious enjoyment, yet it was the Shabbos in the fish he enjoyed, not the fish.
-
12:57 The poritz's sugar and Nishmas on Shabbos
A chassid worked for a wealthy poritz at a time when sugar was very expensive in Russia. He came running excitedly to his Rebbe and told how the poritz had his workers carry thousands of sacks of sugar to cover a meadow and went sled riding on it in the middle of August. Then the chassid said: how does this compare with the pleasure I have on Shabbos when I say Nishmas kol chai, which the poritz can never have.
In the story: the Beis Aharon (Rabbi Aharon II of Karlin-Stolin), Reb Eliyahu Shalom (the Mashgiach's father), Rabbi Moshe Leib of Sassov
-
16:06 Children born on the mountaintop
Someone who worked very hard to reach the level of a young prodigy from a distinguished family, whose father was Rav Avraham HaMalach, asked him how he reached it without struggle. The young man answered with a mashal: a man spent days climbing a very difficult mountain, and at the top he found small children playing. When he asked how they got there, they answered that they were born there.
In the story: Rabbi Avraham HaMalach
-
41:05 Standing up for the soul of Rabbi Pinchas ben Yair
A tzaddik stood up for a talmid and told him he was not standing for him but for the soul that had just come to him temporarily, and asked what he had done to merit it. It emerged that the talmid had done the mitzvah of pidyon shvuyim, redeeming captives. Since that was the mitzvah in which Rabbi Pinchas ben Yair excelled, his soul came as an ibbur to help him in that mitzvah.
In the story: Rabbi Chaim Vital, the Arizal, Rabbi Pinchas ben Yair, Benayahu ben Yehoyada, the Midrash Shmuel (Rabbi Shmuel di Uzeda), the Ben Ish Chai
Insights
- 7:05 The greatest mitzvah ever done, the Akeidah, was performed by Avraham Avinu with his levels taken from him and without feeling; this is why it is the merit invoked whenever Jews need a zechus.
- 9:09 A special warm tefillah or elation during a mitzvah may be the reward for an earlier hard-won victory over the yetzer, even a day or a year before.
- 19:40 Whether a soul is drawn to Torah or to tefillah depends on whether it was rooted in the head or the heart of Adam Harishon; one who misuses that root may become a scientist or a philosopher, or a poet or songwriter.
- 34:09 Like a tuning fork that sets matching piano strings vibrating, the beinoni's effort to act like a tzaddik sets the corresponding heavenly chords vibrating and draws down a tzaddik's soul.
- 32:18 The Tanya deliberately calls the beinoni's trained joy truth according to his level rather than absolute truth, since each person has his own level of truth.
- 48:51 Even when an ibbur departs, it leaves a residue of kedushah in the soul and a memory that spurs the person to try to reach that level again.
What the Mashgiach says to take from it
- 9:57 The Mashgiach says a person should strive to have real oneg Shabbos, coming from the Shabbos itself and not from the challah or the fish.
- 24:30 The Mashgiach says even a beinoni should set times to sit and think that worldly pleasures are fleeting, so that at least his mind tells him evil is no good.
- 28:12 The Mashgiach says the beinoni should meditate, according to his ability, on Hashem's greatness in caring for him and bring himself to joy, even if it is only imitation.
- 30:13 The Mashgiach says a person should try even if he may never reach the level, leaving the outcome to Hashem.
Mentioned in this shiur
People Adam HaRishon, Avraham Avinu, Chmielnicki, Haman, Iyov, Moshe Rabbeinu, Nevuchadnetzar, Rabbi Avraham HaMalach, Rabbi Pinchas ben Yair, the Baal HaTanya (Rabbi Shneur Zalman of Liadi)
Terms אתכפיא, בינוני, גלגול, טבע שני, מעין עולם הבא, מרכבה, עבודת מתנה, עיבור, פדיון שבויים, רבונו של עולם, שבועה