נשמות שהם בבחינת עיבור די להם לעורר אהבה ויראה שכליות. ביאור גודל אהבת ותשוקת הצדיקים לה'. אהבה ויראה שכליות עליהם נאמר "מחשבה טובה הקב"ה מצרף למעשה." וזהו חוץ מדרך הטבע.

Catalog entry: TANYA ENGLISH ט"ז no. ⁨34⁩ Pocket Guide p. 76 English 50 min

Listen

  1. Download · Length 50 min

Open in the listening app

Notes Notes prepared by AI from the recording; not reviewed, and not the Mashgiach's words. The recording is the source.

About this shiur

Opening Tanya chapter 16, the Mashgiach explains that a Jew's service is to rule over nature, shown by Avraham's inherited emunah above understanding and by the mitzvah of milah, and made possible by the neshamah that stands above nature.

The Mashgiach reviews the end of Tanya chapter 15: true service of Hashem is the effort to go beyond routine, aroused either by contemplating Hashem's greatness or by stirring the hidden love inherited from Avraham Avinu. Opening chapter 16, which calls for ruling over the nature in the left chamber of the heart, he ties this to milah. A Jew's emunah is hereditary, like an animal's instinct, while a non-Jew is held responsible because an honest look at the world and at Sinai shows the truth. Avraham was a new species, given a new power of birth through the added hei. His mitzvos were emunah and milah: emunah begins where understanding ends, so milah comes at eight days, while Yishmael's empty milah waits for thirteen. After a long digression on Yishmael, Eretz Yisrael and the end of the exile, he returns: milah defies nature, and the neshamah, above nature, lets the mind rule the heart.

Topics: Tzaddik, Beinoni and Rasha (Tanya ch. 9-17) · Simple Emunah, Above Reason · Bris Milah · Avraham Avinu · Seven and Eight: Nature and Above

Order of the shiur

  1. 0:00 Review: what makes one an oved Hashem

    The Mashgiach reviews that real service of Hashem is the extra effort beyond routine, and the two ways the Tanya gives to arouse it: contemplating Hashem's greatness, or stirring the hidden love inherited from Avraham Avinu.

  2. 6:29 Chapter 16: ruling nature; inherited emunah

    The Mashgiach opens chapter 16, that the main thing is to rule over nature, and links it to milah and to the emunah inherited from Avraham. He compares hereditary emunah to animal instinct and explains why a non-Jew is still responsible to believe.

  3. 12:06 Avraham, a new species of believer

    The Mashgiach explains that a non-Jew's denial is rationalization to escape obligation, while Jews believe by inheritance. Avraham and Sarah were barren because Avraham was a new species, given a new power of birth with the added hei, and with him creation was completed.

  4. 16:38 Emunah and milah: above understanding

    After a question about Yishmael, the Mashgiach explains that Avraham's mitzvos are emunah and milah. Emunah starts where understanding ends, which is why milah is done at eight days without daas, while Yishmael's milah at thirteen is an empty milah that needs daas.

  5. 24:18 The eighth day and Yishmael's empty milah

    The Mashgiach explains that milah is on the eighth day because the senses and intellect reach only the nature of the seven days of creation, while Jewish emunah is above nature. Yishmael's milah lacks the spiritual power of a Jew's, and the Zohar says he received Eretz Yisrael through it while it lies empty.

  6. 27:59 Digression: Yishmael and the end of exile

    In a long digression the Mashgiach speaks of Eretz Yisrael flourishing as a sign of Moshiach, of Yishmael as the adversary of Yitzchak and the last stage of the exile, and of Torah codes he heard from Rav Michoel Ber Weissmandl, pointing to a hint of Moshiach in this week's parsha.

    1. 27:59 Eretz Yisrael flourishing; each tzaddik's adversary : The Mashgiach recalls Eretz Yisrael as barren sand and brings the Gemara that its flourishing is the clearest sign of the end. He brings the Baal HaTurim that when Yishmael falls Moshiach comes, since every tzaddik has an adversary.
    2. 30:33 Edom and Yishmael, the last exile : The Mashgiach explains that the last of Daniel's four kingdoms is a collection of Christian nations, and that since Hitler the trouble comes from Yishmael, the partner of Edom in the same exile.
    3. 34:02 Torah codes and Moshiach in the parsha : The Mashgiach tells what he heard from Rav Weissmandl about equally spaced letters in the Torah, says computers now show such patterns beyond chance, and that the closest spacing of the word Moshiach is in the passuk of this week's parsha about Yitzchak's birth.
    4. 38:26 Yitzchak against Yishmael today : Stressing he is not a prophet, the Mashgiach reads the passuk as hinting that Moshiach comes when Yitzchak rises against Yishmael, and names Iran as the nation of Yishmael that arms the others against Eretz Yisrael. He then notes he went off on a tangent.
  7. 42:08 Milah: the model of breaking nature

    Returning to the Tanya, the Mashgiach explains that nature dictates every creature's behavior and a Jew must rule above it. Milah removes the orlah that nature produces, and that power accompanies a Jew all his life: to get up when nature says sleep, and to check and sanctify himself even in what is permitted.

  8. 46:37 How a creature of nature rules nature listed in the guide

    The Mashgiach asks how a person, himself a product of nature, can defy it, and answers from the Tanya that the neshamah, a part of G-d above, shines into the nefesh, so the mind rules the heart. Contemplating Hashem's greatness in chochmah and binah gives birth to the middos and to withdrawing from evil.

The shiur, written up

Review: what makes one an oved Hashem

0:13

The Mashgiach recalls the Gemara in Chagigah that one who reviews his learning a hundred times cannot be compared to one who reviews it a hundred and one times, since the custom was a hundred. The extra time takes effort because it is no longer routine, and only that effort is called service of Hashem; one who does everything by routine, even without sin, is not yet an oved. a

2:52

Continuing in Tanya chapter 15, he explains the two ways a beinoni can muster that effort: with the mind, contemplating the greatness of the Ribono shel Olam, or with the heart, stirring the hidden love inherited from Avraham, whom the passuk calls 'Avraham ohavi'. Either way, the Mashgiach says, he compels himself not to seek rest and routine but to do more. b,d

Chapter 16: ruling nature; inherited emunah

6:29

Opening Tanya chapter 16, the Mashgiach reads that the main thing is to rule over the nature in the left chamber of the heart. He links this to milah, a Jew's first bond with Hashem, which belongs to Avraham, from whom we inherit emunah, as in 'vehe'emin baHashem'. e,f

8:08

Such emunah is hereditary knowledge, like a beaver separated from its mother at birth that still builds a dam like an engineer. A non-Jew, by contrast, is held responsible to believe, because an honest look at the world, his own body, and the mass experience at Sinai shows the truth.

Avraham, a new species of believer

12:20

The Mashgiach explains that a non-Jew denies because belief would bind him, even to the seven Noachide mitzvos, so he rationalizes. Jews instead have emunah by inheritance from Avraham, the first believer.

13:49

Avraham and Sarah were barren because he was a new species, cut off from Terach's line, so Hashem gave him a new power of birth: the hei, which the Mashgiach connects to 'hei lachem zera' in Vayigash, added to his name. He brings 'asher bacharta b'Avram' in Nechemiah: with Avraham creation was completed, and his trait is a faithful heart, which is why Jews are believers, children of believers. g,h

Emunah and milah: above understanding

16:38

Asked how Avraham was barren if he had Yishmael, the Mashgiach answers that Yishmael came from a residue of the old power of birth and is not truly considered his child. He then notes two things found by Avraham, emunah and milah, and that every neshamah is bound to a particular mitzvah. Citing the Ramban that emunah is not counted among the 613 but is their prerequisite, he calls emunah Avraham's mitzvah.

19:14

Emunah, he explains, is believing what the mind cannot grasp. The higher a tzaddik's understanding, the more he sees that Hashem is greater still, and where his mind stops, emunah begins, unlike Greek philosophy, which believes only what it understands.

20:56

This answers why milah is at eight days, before the child has understanding: milah is the sign of emunah above daas, where even an adult surrenders his daas. Yishmael's milah, at thirteen, is not a bris; it is like any mitzvah needing daas, an empty milah. i

The eighth day and Yishmael's empty milah

24:19

The Mashgiach explains why milah is specifically on the eighth day: the senses and intellect reach only nature, the world of the seven days, while Jewish emunah is above nature. Yishmael's milah lacks the spiritual faculties a Jew receives through his. Therefore, the Mashgiach brings from the Zohar, since the land was given in the passage of milah, Yishmael received Eretz Yisrael while it is empty. j,k

Digression: Yishmael and the end of exile

27:59

The Mashgiach recalls that on his first visit Eretz Yisrael was dust and sand, and each year he finds it more developed. He brings the Gemara in Sanhedrin that there is no clearer sign of the end than the land flourishing, and the Baal HaTurim that when Yishmael falls, the son of David comes, for every tzaddik has his adversary: Avraham had Nimrod, Yitzchak Yishmael, Yaakov Esav. l,m

31:05

The last of the kingdoms Daniel saw is a collection of Christian nations, which the Midrash links to the four kings Avraham fought. Since Hitler, the Mashgiach says, the trouble comes from Yishmael, Edom's partner in the same exile, and its end will be Yishmael's fall before Yitzchak. n,o

33:43

He tells that Rav Michoel Ber Weissmandl, whom he heard himself, found words in equally spaced Torah letters before computers, which now show such patterns defy chance. The closest spacing of the word Moshiach is in this week's passuk 'lamo'ed ashuv eilecha... ul'Sarah ven'. p

38:26

Stressing that he is no prophet, the Mashgiach reads it as a hint that Moshiach comes when Yitzchak rises as Yishmael falls, and names Iran as the nation of Yishmael arming the others against Eretz Yisrael. p

Milah: the model of breaking nature

42:35

Returning, the Mashgiach explains that nature dictates every creature's behavior and pushes a person to indulge, while a Jew must rule above it. Milah removes the orlah, which strengthens desire; fasting on Yom Kippur also defies nature, but nothing as strikingly, since right at birth one cuts away what nature made.

45:12

That power of milah accompanies a Jew all his life: when nature says sleep, he gets up to serve Hashem; when it says enjoy, he checks whether it is permitted, and even then, 'kadesh atzmecha bamutar lach'. q

How a creature of nature rules nature

46:37

The Mashgiach asks how a person, himself a product of nature, can defy it. He answers that the neshamah, a part of G-d above, comes from beyond nature and shines into the nefesh, so the mind, its seat, rules the heart. Contemplating Hashem's greatness, chochmah stimulates binah to give birth to the middos, and he withdraws from evil. e,r

Sources

Torah

  1. f Bereishis 15:6 text index In the write-up: 6:29
  2. g apparently Bereishis 47:23 index In the write-up: 13:49
  3. i apparently Bereishis 17:25 index In the write-up: 20:56
  4. k apparently Bereishis 17:8 index In the write-up: 24:19
  5. p Bereishis 18:14 text index In the write-up: 33:43, 38:26

Nevi'im

  1. c apparently Malachi 3:18 5:49 index
  2. d apparently Yeshayahu 41:8 index In the write-up: 2:52

Kesuvim

  1. h Nechemiah 9:7-8 text index In the write-up: 13:49
  2. n Daniel (place not identified) index In the write-up: 31:05

Talmud Bavli

  1. a Chagigah 9b text index In the write-up: 0:13
  2. l Sanhedrin 98a text index In the write-up: 27:59
  3. q Yevamos 20a text index In the write-up: 45:12

Midrash

  1. o Midrash (place not identified) In the write-up: 31:05

Zohar and Kabbalah

  1. j Zohar (place not identified) index In the write-up: 24:19

Rishonim

  1. m apparently Baal HaTurim on Bereishis 25:18 index In the write-up: 27:59

Acharonim and Chassidus

  1. b apparently Tanya ch. 15 index In the write-up: 2:52
  2. e apparently Tanya ch. 16 index In the write-up: 6:29, 46:37
  3. r apparently Tanya ch. 2 index In the write-up: 46:37

Key points

  1. 1:11 True service of Hashem is the effort that breaks routine and comfort, aroused either by contemplating Hashem's greatness or by stirring the hidden love in the heart.
  2. 8:02 A Jew's emunah is an inheritance from Avraham Avinu, hereditary like an animal's instinct, while a non-Jew is held responsible because honest observation of the world and of Sinai leads to the truth.
  3. 19:56 Emunah begins where understanding ends, and milah at eight days is the sign of this emunah above understanding.
  4. 42:29 Milah is the clearest illustration of a Jew's task to defy nature: right at birth one removes what nature produced.
  5. 47:28 A person can rule over nature because his neshamah, a part of G-d above, is above nature and shines into his nefesh, so the mind rules over the heart.

Questions and answers

  1. Question: 9:08 Why is a non-Jew held responsible for believing in Hashem?

    Answer: 9:30 Because if he is honest he can see the Creator in the world and in his own body, and the giving of the Torah at Sinai was experienced by millions; his denial is rationalization to escape obligations.

  2. Question: 16:38 If Avraham had Yishmael, how could he have been barren?

    Answer: 17:13 Originally he too was barren; Yishmael came from a residue of the old power of birth and is not truly considered his child, and with him that power ended.

  3. Question: 20:56 Why is milah done at eight days instead of waiting until the child can do it with understanding?

    Answer: 21:21 Because milah is the sign of emunah above daas; even an adult surrenders his daas in matters of emunah, so it does not need understanding.

  4. Question: 23:33 Why is Yishmael's milah only at thirteen?

    Answer: 23:43 His milah is not a bris and gives no sign of emunah above daas; it is like any mitzvah that must be done with daas, so it waits until he is a bar daas.

  5. Question: 46:37 How can a person, himself a product of nature, defy nature?

    Answer: 47:26 Because one component of him, the neshamah, comes from a higher sphere above nature and shines into the nefesh, giving him a power from above.

Stories

  1. 27:59 Eretz Yisrael then and now

    The Mashgiach recalls that when he first came to Eretz Yisrael everything was dust and sand. Since Jews began coming, the land has been cultivated, and every year he goes he sees it more developed than the year before.

  2. 33:43 What he heard from Rav Weissmandl

    The Mashgiach says the study of equally spaced letters in the Torah was begun by Rav Michoel Ber Weissmandl before the computer was invented, and that he heard it from him directly. Rav Weissmandl showed how letters at fixed intervals from the start of a sefer spell out words, and said many marvelous things without any computer.

    In the story: Rav Michoel Ber Weissmandl

Insights

  1. 8:08 A Jew's emunah is a hereditary knowledge, like the beaver that builds a dam with an engineer's skill though separated from its mother at birth.
  2. 13:49 Avraham and Sarah were barren because Avraham was a new species cut off from the earlier generations; the hei added to his name was a new power of birth, and with him creation was completed.
  3. 19:21 The greater a tzaddik's understanding, the more he sees that Hashem is greater still; emunah begins exactly where his understanding stops.
  4. 20:56 Milah is done at eight days, before the child has understanding, because it is the sign of emunah above daas; Yishmael's milah waits for thirteen because it is like any mitzvah that needs daas, an empty milah.
  5. 30:11 Every tzaddik has his adversary: Avraham had Nimrod, Yitzchak had Yishmael and Yaakov had Esav; the end of the exile comes through the fall of Yishmael before Yitzchak.
  6. 44:12 Milah is the most striking defiance of nature: as soon as a child is born one cuts off what nature produced, declaring that this is not how a Jew is made.

What the Mashgiach says to take from it

  1. 2:00 The Mashgiach says a person should arouse himself to serve Hashem by thinking about Hashem's greatness or by stirring the hidden love in his heart.
  2. 6:04 The Mashgiach says one should not seek rest and routine but do more than the routine.
  3. 45:19 The Mashgiach says that when nature says sleep, a Jew gets up to serve Hashem; when it says enjoy, he checks whether it is permitted, and even then sanctifies himself in what is permitted.

Mentioned in this shiur

People Avraham Avinu, Daniel, Esav, Hagar, Nimrod, Rav Michoel Ber Weissmandl, Sarah Imeinu, the Baal HaTurim, the Ramban, Yaakov Avinu, Yishmael, Yitzchak Avinu

Terms אהבה מסותרת, אמונה, בינוני, חלל השמאלי, חלק אלוק ממעל, טבע, למעלה מן הדעת, מאמינים בני מאמינים, מוח שליט על הלב, מילה, עבודת השם, ערלה, רבונו של עולם, שבע מצוות בני נח

Report an error on this page