אהבה ויראה שכליות מביאה את האדם לתשובה. רשע ורע לו אין לו אפשרות להיות עובד ה' אלא ע"י תשובה תתאה.
Catalog entry: TANYA ENGLISH י"ז no. 35 Pocket Guide p. 76 English 56 min
Listen
About this shiur
The Mashgiach explains how a beinoni whose heart cannot be stirred to feel love of Hashem can still serve Him through love and fear that he understands with his mind, and how Hashem joins that intellectual love to his mitzvos so they rise above.
The Mashgiach reads the opening of Tanya chapter 16: the great rule for a beinoni is that the mind rules the heart, so that contemplating Hashem's greatness arouses love and fear. Most people, however, understand but cannot feel; the Tanya's note traces this to a soul still in the stage of 'ibur', not yet 'born'. Such a person still understands that his soul should long to leave the body and cleave to Hashem, like a 'living widow' kept from her husband, and that the only contact is Torah and mitzvos. The Mashgiach brings stories of souls nearly leaving the body in dveikus, and the principle of 'ratzo vashov'. Acting on this intellectual love gives the mitzvos the two wings of love and fear. Since thought is too high to clothe a physical deed, Hashem 'combines' it with the deed beyond nature, as Chazal say of a good thought, lifting such mitzvos to the world of Beriah.
Topics: Tzaddik, Beinoni and Rasha (Tanya ch. 9-17) · Ahavas Hashem and Dveikus
Order of the shiur
-
0:00 The mind should rule the heart
The Mashgiach reads the opening of the chapter, the great rule for the beinoni that the mind directs the heart. He contrasts a 'seichel nivdal', an intellect untouched by emotion, with the common case where laziness bends the mind to justify putting off davening.
-
6:17 Those who understand but cannot feel
The Mashgiach describes the desired path, where the mind's contemplation stimulates love of Hashem in the heart, and says most people cannot reach it. He explains that souls pass through stages like conception, pregnancy and birth, and a soul sent down before its 'birth' cannot produce felt love, so it serves Hashem from understanding alone.
-
13:42 Love hidden in the mind: the soul of ibur
Reading the Tanya, the Mashgiach explains that such a person's love stays hidden and never flames in the heart. The Tanya's note gives the reason: his soul is from the stage of 'ibur', not yet revealed. Still he understands that his soul should long to leave the body and cleave to Hashem.
-
19:25 Ratzo vashov: souls that nearly flew out Story
The Mashgiach explains that Hashem made the world run on 'ratzo vashov', running and returning, so no one may let his soul rush out in love. He tells of a tzaddik who played with his pocket watch in Shemoneh Esrei to keep his soul in his body, and brings a sefer that Avraham's words 'we will return' kept his soul in him at the Akeidah, while Sarah's soul left her when she heard of it.
-
25:41 The soul as a 'living widow'
The Mashgiach explains that the soul, which comes from the Kisei HaKavod, is held in the body against its will like a 'living widow' whose husband is alive but barriers keep her from him. He adds that in galus the tzaddikim long for Hashem more than in the time of the Beis HaMikdash, like a thirsty man in the desert without water.
-
30:00 Torah and mitzvos: the only contact
The Mashgiach explains that the soul in the body can grasp Hashem only through Torah and mitzvos, citing the earlier chapters' parable of one who embraces the king through his garments. One who understands this with his mind, and makes his mouth and limbs act on it, gives his mitzvos wings even without felt love.
-
35:13 The two wings and the Ba'al Shem Tov's shul
The Mashgiach brings the Zohar that love and fear are the two wings that lift mitzvos, and tells of the Ba'al Shem Tov who could not enter a shul packed with mitzvos done without love and fear. He explains that intellectual love counts as these wings, which is why Chassidus dwells so much on the greatness of Hashem, and that without it a person would follow his body's pleasures.
-
41:02 Why 'combines' it with the deed
The Mashgiach brings Chazal that Hashem combines a good thought with the deed, and asks why they did not simply say He credits it as if it were done. He explains that felt love and fear give the mitzvah life because the heart is a physical organ that also holds spiritual emotion, so it can be the shliach of the limbs, as the Gemara shows from the kohanim as shluchim of Hashem.
-
46:05 Why the mind cannot be the shliach
Reading the Tanya, the Mashgiach explains that the heart, physical like the other limbs yet inward, can carry love and fear into the deed. Love that stays in the mind is far higher than the deed and cannot clothe it, so by nature it could not lift the mitzvah; it does so only because Hashem combines it.
-
50:01 Hashem joins thought to deed
The Mashgiach answers the question: Hashem, Who can do anything, goes beyond nature and joins the intellectual love to the deed, as the Rema explains that He joins the spiritual soul to the physical body. Mitzvos done this way reach the world of Beriah, while mitzvos done by rote, with the mind on business, go up only to a lower world.
The shiur, written up
The mind should rule the heart
The Mashgiach reads the opening of Tanya chapter 16, the great rule in the service of the beinoni: a person's actions should not come from the heart, the seat of the emotions, but from the mind, which directs the heart and controls the emotions. a
He notes that it can work the other way. A few tzaddikim had a 'seichel nivdal', an intellect untouched by any wish, as the Avnei Nezer said of certain great men. Usually the emotions bend the mind: a lazy person at the time for davening finds his mind devising reasons to put it off. The Tanya asks instead that the mind's contemplation arouse love of Hashem. b
Those who understand but cannot feel
The desired way, the Mashgiach explains, is that the mind, steeped in Hashem's greatness, sends a message down and the heart gives out love of Hashem. Tzaddikim have this love naturally; a beinoni must stimulate it. But most people cannot. They understand with cold logic and can learn Chassidus all day, yet their emotions are not 'plugged in', and davening stays cold.
The reason lies in the soul. Souls are creations, and like life they pass through stages: conception, pregnancy, birth, nursing and growing up. A soul sent down before its 'birth' has not yet come into the world and cannot give out love. Such people should at least act on what the mind concludes, that Hashem is great, and learn, do mitzvos and daven from that logic; for them this is acceptable.
Love hidden in the mind
Continuing in the Tanya, the Mashgiach explains that for such a person the love never surfaces in the heart like flames of fire; it stays hidden in the mind. The Tanya's note gives the reason: his soul is from the stage of 'ibur', like a fetus within the mother, not yet born and revealed outside. c
Even so, he understands that everything is as nothing before Hashem, and that it is fitting for his soul to long to leave the body that envelops it and fly to cleave to Hashem. He knows it is proper, even though he cannot produce it.
Ratzo vashov: souls that nearly flew out
Hashem does not let a person rush his life out to Him, the Mashgiach says, because He made the world on 'ratzo vashov', running and returning: day and night, summer and winter, and the pulse that pushes blood up and lets it fall back. Great tzaddikim faced this danger. One, whose name he does not recall, played with his pocket watch in Shemoneh Esrei; tzaddikim understood that without touching something physical his soul would have flown out.
He cites a sefer that Avraham at the Akeidah reached such dveikus that his soul should have left him, but because he had said 'we will return' it did not. When Sarah heard that her son had been ready to give his life, she was so charged with love that her soul left her.
The soul as a 'living widow'
The beinoni understands that his soul, which comes from the Kisei HaKavod, is held in the body against its will like an 'almanus chayus', a woman whose husband is alive but barriers keep her from him. She knows she will be reunited, and the distance only deepens her longing.
Torah and mitzvos: the only contact
Thought in the body cannot grasp Hashem, the Mashgiach explains, except when it is clothed in Torah and mitzvos, as the earlier chapters taught: Torah is Hashem's wisdom, and doing a mitzvah is like embracing the king through his sleeves, still a real embrace. So the longing is satisfied only through Torah and mitzvos. e
One who cannot feel this love but understands it with all his mind, and makes his mouth and limbs act on that understanding, gives his Torah and mitzvos wings to fly up, as if he did them with felt love and fear.
The two wings and the Ba'al Shem Tov's shul
The Zohar says love and fear are the two wings that lift mitzvos to Hashem. The Mashgiach tells that the Ba'al Shem Tov once stood at a shul's door and could not enter: it was packed with Torah and mitzvos done by habit, without love and fear, so they stayed below. For the beinoni, intellectual love and fear also produce these wings. f
Such a person does mitzvos because his understanding, gained by contemplating Hashem's greatness, demands it. This, the Mashgiach explains, is why Chabad Chassidim learn so much Chassidus on that greatness. Without this understanding he would follow his body, which finds more pleasure in this world than in Torah.
Why 'combines' it with the deed
The Mashgiach brings Chazal that Hashem combines a good thought with the deed, and asks why the Gemara does not simply say He credits it as if done. Felt love and fear rise from the heart and clothe themselves in the mitzvah, giving it life. Mitzvos are done in this physical world, and the heart is a physical organ that also holds spiritual emotion, so it can serve as the shliach. g
Why the mind cannot be the shliach
The Tanya says the heart is physical like the other limbs, yet inward, giving them life; so it can clothe itself in them and lift the deed. Love and fear hidden in the mind are different. The mind, where the Shechinah dwells in a person, is far higher than physical deeds, and by nature cannot clothe a physical mitzvah or serve as its wings. i
Hashem joins thought to deed
This answers the question. Intellectual love has no natural link to the deed, but Hashem, Who can do anything, goes beyond nature and combines it. The Mashgiach compares the Rema on 'u'mafli la'asos': Hashem wondrously keeps the spiritual soul within the physical body, and so He joins mind and mitzvah. j
Mitzvos done with no love or fear stop in a lower world; those done with intellectual love reach Beriah, as the Tanya will explain later. A person who rushes to shul thinking about business has no love, not even in the mind. One who understands that Hashem is not served with lip service, and davens with kavanah, reaches where felt love reaches. k
Sources
Kesuvim
Talmud Bavli
Zohar and Kabbalah
Acharonim and Chassidus
- a apparently Tanya ch. 16 index In the write-up: 0:04
- b Avnei Nezer (place not identified) index In the write-up: 2:00
- c apparently Tanya ch. 16, note index In the write-up: 14:15
- e apparently Tanya ch. 4 index In the write-up: 30:00
- i apparently Tanya ch. 16 index In the write-up: 46:05
- j apparently Orach Chaim 6:1, Rema index In the write-up: 50:08
- k Tanya (place not identified) index In the write-up: 53:18
Key points
- 1:14 The Mashgiach explains the rule for the beinoni: action should flow from the mind, which contemplates Hashem's greatness and sends its message down to arouse love and fear in the heart.
- 7:50 Most people cannot turn understanding into felt love, because their soul is from the stage of 'ibur', still hidden like a fetus and not yet revealed.
- 26:02 Such a person still understands that his soul, sent down from the Kisei HaKavod, is like a 'living widow' longing for her husband, and that its only contact with Hashem is through Torah and mitzvos.
- 35:38 When he does mitzvos because of this intellectual love and fear, they act as the two wings that lift the mitzvos above, as if he felt real love.
- 46:07 By nature, love that is only in the mind cannot be the shliach of a physical deed, since only the heart is both physical and spiritual; Hashem combines it with the deed beyond nature.
- 53:18 Mitzvos done by habit, with no love or fear even in the mind, stop in a lower world, while those done with intellectual love and fear reach the world of Beriah.
Questions and answers
-
Question: 15:07 Why can't many people produce felt love of Hashem no matter how much they contemplate His greatness?
Answer: 15:26 Their soul is from the stage of 'ibur', still hidden within like a fetus and not yet 'born' and revealed outside, so the love stays hidden.
-
Question: 20:45 Why did the tzaddik play with his watch in the middle of Shemoneh Esrei?
Answer: 21:05 His dveikus was so great that without touching something physical his soul would have left him.
-
Question: 28:16 Why do tzaddikim in galus long for Hashem more than in the time of the Beis HaMikdash?
Answer: 28:30 Like a thirsty man in the desert without water, the distance makes the longing much stronger.
-
Question: 41:27 Why does the Gemara say Hashem 'combines' a good thought with the deed, rather than that He credits it as if it were done?
Answer: 50:12 Intellectual love from the mind has no natural connection to the physical deed and is not a fitting shliach for it, so Hashem must actively join it to the deed beyond nature.
-
Question: 48:05 How can love and fear that are only in the mind serve as wings for a physical mitzvah?
Answer: 49:28 By nature they cannot, since the mind is far above the physical deed; Hashem, Who can do anything, joins them anyway.
Stories
-
20:39 The tzaddik and his pocket watch
A great tzaddik, whose name the Mashgiach does not recall, took out his pocket watch in the middle of Shemoneh Esrei and played with it. Some onlookers frowned, but tzaddikim who saw it understood. He had reached such dveikus that without some contact with the physical his soul would have flown out of him, so he had to do something physical to keep it down.
-
24:20 Avraham, Sarah and the Akeidah
According to a sefer the Mashgiach cites, Avraham at the Akeidah reached such dveikus that his soul should have left him, but because he had said 'we will return' he was not 'zocheh' to have it surge out to Hashem. When Sarah heard that her son had been ready to give his life for Hashem, she was so charged with love of Hashem that her soul left her.
In the story: Avraham Avinu, Sarah Imeinu
-
35:59 The Ba'al Shem Tov at the shul door
The Ba'al Shem Tov once came to a shul, stood by the door and said he could not go in. Asked why, he explained that the shul was packed with Torah and mitzvos done without love and fear, out of mere habit; such mitzvos do not fly up but stay below, filling the shul.
In the story: the Baal Shem Tov
Insights
- 10:17 The Mashgiach compares a soul's development to conception, pregnancy, birth and nursing: a soul sent down before its 'birth' has not yet come into the world, so it cannot give out felt love however much it contemplates.
- 21:39 He shows 'ratzo vashov' as the pattern of all creation: day and night, summer and winter, and the pulse that pushes blood up and lets it fall back until the next beat.
- 24:20 Citing a sefer, he explains that Avraham's words 'we will return' at the Akeidah kept his soul from leaving him in his great dveikus, while Sarah, hearing that her son had been ready to give his life, was so charged with love that her soul left her.
- 28:22 He explains that in galus the tzaddikim long for Hashem more than in the days of the Beis HaMikdash, as a man in the desert without water thirsts more than one who has water at hand.
- 44:41 The Mashgiach applies the Gemara's rule that a shliach can only do what the sender can do: the heart can be the limbs' shliach because it is physical like them, while the mind, being higher, is not a fitting shliach.
- 38:50 He explains that since the Ba'al HaTanya holds that all Torah and mitzvos must come from contemplation of Hashem's greatness, Chabad Chassidim learn so much Chassidus that speaks of that greatness.
- 52:09 He links 'Hashem combines it with the deed' to the Rema on 'u'mafli la'asos': just as Hashem wondrously joins the spiritual soul to the physical body, He joins the mind's love to the physical mitzvah.
What the Mashgiach says to take from it
- 12:02 The Mashgiach says that one who cannot arouse felt love should at least act on what his mind understands: since Hashem is great, he learns Torah, does mitzvos and davens because of that logic.
- 55:02 The Mashgiach says Hashem is not to be served with lip service: davening should be with kavanah from the mind, not by rote while thinking about business.
Mentioned in this shiur
People Avraham Avinu, Sarah Imeinu, the Avnei Nezer of Sochatchov, the Baal HaTanya (Rabbi Shneur Zalman of Liadi), the Baal Shem Tov, the Rema
Terms אהבה מסותרת, בינוני, דביקות, התבוננות, כסא הכבוד, מוח שליט על הלב, עולם הבריאה, עולם היצירה, רבונו של עולם, רצוא ושוב, שכל נבדל, שליחות