ביאור על תשובה תתאה. עצה למי שאפילו אהבה שכליות אינו יכול לפועל בעצמו. כי קרוב אליך בדרך קצרה - יותר קלה לחלושי כח ע"י האהבה המתוסרת בלבו.
Catalog entry: TANYA ENGLISH י"ז וי"ח no. 36 Pocket Guide p. 76 English 54 min
Listen
About this shiur
The Mashgiach explains Tanya chapter 17: why 'the thing is very near to you' is true for every Jew through the mind's rule over the heart, why it does not speak to a true rasha, and how even he returns through the lower teshuvah that raises the fallen Hei.
The Mashgiach reviews the previous chapter: one who cannot turn intellectual love and fear into emotion may serve with the mind alone, since some souls are still 'in the womb'. Chapter 17 now applies these ideas to the verse the Tanya's title page names as its purpose, 'ki karov eilecha'. Our senses seem to deny it, since a complete turning of the heart is rare: love cannot be divided, and one who still craves worldly pleasure does not truly love Hashem. He tells stories of tzaddikim who no longer tasted food. The Gemara's 'yirah is a small thing' applies to Moshe Rabbeinu, and what is asked of everyone is action driven by the mind. Logical love, like a mother's love she does not feel, is within every person's power, because the mind rules the heart by nature, except in the true rasha, whose lost control is a punishment. Such a rasha needs teshuvah first: a broken heart, often aroused from above, the lower teshuvah that raises the fallen Hei, connected to Chanukah.
Topics: Tzaddik, Beinoni and Rasha (Tanya ch. 9-17) · Teshuvah · Ahavas Hashem and Dveikus
Order of the shiur
-
0:00 Review: serving with the mind alone
The Mashgiach reviews the previous chapter: Chochmah and Binah meditating on Hashem's greatness should stir love and fear in the heart, but one who cannot may serve with the mind's understanding alone. Such a soul is still 'in the womb' of Knesses Yisroel and not yet 'born', so revealed love is not required of it.
-
6:09 Chapter 17 and the verse 'ki karov' listed in the guide
The Mashgiach explains that chapter 17 begins a new phase, applying the earlier axioms in practice, and that the title page names the verse 'ki karov eilecha' as the Tanya's purpose. He raises the difficulty that our senses seem to deny it, and rejects the idea that it applied only to Moshe Rabbeinu's generation: the Torah speaks to every generation and every person.
-
10:00 Love cannot be divided
The Mashgiach explains why turning the heart from worldly desire to true love of Hashem is so hard: love is indivisible and can be directed to only one object. With the example of enjoying an ice cream, he says that one who still desires worldly pleasure and thinks he also loves Hashem is imagining it, though thinking of Hashem while eating is better than nothing.
-
14:51 Tzaddikim beyond the taste of food Story
The Mashgiach says the Ba'al HaTanya and his chassidim experienced this level, and tells of tzaddikim in recent times: one who said he had not known the taste of food for twenty years, two Rebbes recalling the wartime transports, and the Yismach Moshe, who ate dishwater thinking it was soup. He ends that one who still enjoys the ice cream should not fool himself that his love of Hashem is complete.
-
20:20 'Yirah is a small thing' for Moshe
The Mashgiach brings the Gemara that calls yirah a small thing for Moshe Rabbeinu, and explains that a complete transformation of the heart belongs to tzaddikim like Dovid HaMelech, not to beinonim. What Hashem asks of everyone, as the previous chapters explained, is enough yirah in the mind to drive the doing.
-
23:54 Doing the mitzvah from the mind's duty
The Mashgiach stresses that the Tanya does not say to refrain from the ice cream; it says that when a mitzvah comes, the mind should recognize the duty and act. His example is tefillin: one may not feel the glow, but feels the obligation because Hashem requires it, and this suffices for a soul from ibbur rather than leidah.
-
27:58 Logical love is in every person's power listed in the guide
The Mashgiach explains that the level near to everyone is a logical love, even if it is not revealed in the heart like flames of fire, because the mind is in a person's power: he cannot love as he wishes but can think as he wishes. He compares it to a mother's love that she does not always feel, and says the felt joy of the mitzvah is its reward, granted to tzaddikim but not required of everyone in this world.
-
33:20 The mind rules the heart, except in a rasha
The Mashgiach explains that by nature the mind controls the heart, the mouth and the limbs, except in a true rasha, who has lost that control; he brings Chazal that the wicked are in the power of their heart and the heart of tzaddikim is in their power, and the question of Pharaoh's hardened heart. He explains the loss of control as a punishment that began with free choice, comparing it to a case in the Gemara that starts with negligence and ends with compulsion, and concludes that 'ki karov' does not speak to such reshaim, who are called dead in their lifetime.
-
41:30 How a rasha begins: a broken heart listed in the guide
The Mashgiach asks how one who lost his free choice can do teshuvah, and answers that every Jew has a point that evil cannot touch, which Hashem sometimes arouses through circumstances. A rasha can do a mitzvah here and there, but to begin real service he must first break the iron wall of the kelipos with a broken heart; this is the lower teshuvah, as opposed to the higher teshuvah from love.
-
46:46 Raising the fallen Hei; Chanukah listed in the guide
The Mashgiach explains that sin separates the lower Hei, the Shechinah, from the Name, dragging it into exile with the person, and teshuvah, 'tashuv Hei', returns it. He connects this to Chanukah of the coming month Kislev: the wicks and oils that do not burn on Shabbos burn on Chanukah, since then Hashem comes down to lift the fallen; he ends with the Tanya's description of the rasha's soul in exile.
The shiur, written up
Review: serving with the mind alone
The Mashgiach reviews the previous chapter. Chochmah and Binah, dwelling on Hashem's greatness, are meant to stimulate the heart to real love and fear, the way organs of the body respond to stimuli. Some people cannot reach this, and for them it is enough that the mind understands that love and fear are fitting; Hashem joins that thought to the deed.
Such a soul, he explains, is not yet 'born': it is still in the womb of Knesses Yisroel, so it cannot produce revealed love and fear. Not the same is required of everyone; one who is capable must stir his heart, and one who is not passes with his mind's understanding.
Chapter 17 and the verse 'ki karov'
With chapter 17, the Mashgiach says, the Tanya moves from laying down axioms to using them. The title page declares that the sefer's purpose is to explain how 'the thing is very near to you, in your mouth and your heart to do it', the verse that follows 'it is not in heaven... not across the sea'. d,a,b,c
Yet our senses seem to deny it. Nor may one say the verse was for Moshe Rabbeinu's giant souls; the Torah is forever, and every verse applies to every generation, every person and every moment.
Love cannot be divided
Turning the heart from worldly desire to true love of Hashem is not simple, the Mashgiach explains, because love is indivisible: as the philosophers say, it goes to one object only. He mentions that the Yismach Moshe asks a contradiction on this, answering that loving every Jew for his G-dly soul is itself love of Hashem. e
One who pursues worldly pleasure and believes he also loves Hashem is imagining it. Thanking Hashem for a delicious ice cream is a good thought, better than not remembering Him, but if one enjoys it, the love is divided.
Tzaddikim beyond the taste of food
The Ba'al HaTanya and even the least of his disciples reached a level where nothing else had place in the heart, and the Mashgiach says he knew such people in his own generation. One Rebbe said that for twenty years he had not known the taste of food. Two Rebbes once recalled the wartime transports, packed like herring, near death from thirst, when one drank three glasses of water at a station fountain and spoke of the intent of each drink.
The Yismach Moshe's wife once left him supper; she returned to find the soup untouched, for he had eaten a pot of dishwater without noticing. Whoever enjoys his ice cream, the Mashgiach concludes, should not fool himself that his love is complete.
'Yirah is a small thing' for Moshe
This is why the verse 'what does Hashem ask of you, only to fear' seems puzzling, and the Gemara asks whether yirah is a small thing, answering that for Moshe Rabbeinu it was. A complete change of heart, as with Dovid HaMelech, belongs to tzaddikim, not beinonim. What Hashem asks of everyone is enough yirah in the mind to bring about the deed. g,f
Doing the mitzvah from the mind's duty
The Mashgiach stresses that the Tanya does not say to give up the ice cream. It says that when a mitzvah comes, the mind should grasp the duty: Hashem is great, so one serves Him with whatever one has, at least by doing.
His example is tefillin. Their great meaning could overwhelm a person, but one who does not feel that glow still feels the obligation because Hashem requires it. For a soul from ibbur, not leidah, this suffices.
Logical love is in every person's power
The level near to everyone, the Mashgiach explains, is a logical love: understanding that loving Hashem is fitting, even when it does not blaze in the heart like flames of fire. It is within reach because the mind is in a person's power: he cannot love as he wishes, but he can think as he wishes. d
He compares it to a mother whose child is bothering her: she feels no glow then, yet she knows she loves the child. The felt joy of a mitzvah, which tzaddikim taste even here, is its reward; what is required of everyone in this world is the deed.
The mind rules the heart, except in a rasha
As the beginning of the Tanya explained, the mind rules the heart, mouth and limbs by nature. Of the tzaddik, beinoni and rasha, only the true rasha has lost this control; one who sins occasionally has not. Chazal say the wicked are in their heart's power and the tzaddikim's heart is in theirs. h,i
Losing control is itself a punishment. To the question of what complaint there was against Pharaoh once Hashem hardened his heart, the Mashgiach answers that at first he had control and would not submit, so it was taken away. j
Why punish after control is gone? The Mashgiach says it is not our business, but suggests the Gemara's case of one who sleeps beside another's vessels and breaks them in his sleep: it begins with negligence and ends with compulsion, and he is liable. 'Ki karov' does not speak to such reshaim, called dead in their lifetime, only to people who still have control. k,l,b
How a rasha begins: a broken heart
If the rasha lost his free choice, how can he do teshuvah? Every Jew, the Mashgiach answers, has a point from Avraham Avinu that evil cannot touch, a flame covered with sand that is never extinguished. Hashem sometimes arouses it through circumstances, and if he grasps it he can return.
He may do a mitzvah here and there, but to begin real service he must break the kelipos, a wall of iron, through bitter remorse; Hashem does not despise a broken and humbled heart. Often the shock that stirs him comes from Hashem. This is the lower teshuvah, beside the higher teshuvah from love. m
Raising the fallen Hei; Chanukah
The two Heis of Hashem's Name, the Mashgiach explains, are the higher and lower teshuvah. A sin separates the lower Hei, the Shechinah, from the Name and drags it into exile with the person; teshuvah, 'tashuv Hei', returns it. As the Shechinah went with Israel when they were exiled to Edom, so one who falls to the deeds of Esav pulls it down with him. n
With Kislev being blessed, he connects this to Chanukah. The soul is 'Hashem's candle', with wick, vessel and oil as parts of the person; the wicks and oils that may not be lit on Shabbos may be lit on Chanukah, because then Hashem comes down to lift the fallen, an arousal from above even for a rasha. o,p
Sources
Torah
Kesuvim
Talmud Bavli
Midrash
Acharonim and Chassidus
Key points
- 5:20 One whose soul cannot produce emotional love and fear may serve Hashem with the understanding of the mind alone; not everyone is required to reach the same level.
- 10:42 Love cannot be divided: one who still pursues worldly pleasure and believes he also loves Hashem fully is deceiving himself.
- 22:41 What 'ki karov' promises every Jew is not a transformed heart but mitzvos done because the mind understands the duty.
- 29:48 A person can think as much as he wants even when he cannot love as much as he wants, so logical love is within everyone's reach.
- 34:08 By nature the mind rules the heart and the limbs, except in a true rasha, who as a punishment for his sins has lost that control.
- 43:03 A true rasha cannot begin serving Hashem without first breaking the barrier of the kelipos through a broken heart; this is the lower teshuvah, which returns the lower Hei of Hashem's Name.
Questions and answers
-
Question: 8:03 How can the Torah say love and fear are 'very near', when our senses show that almost nobody can turn his heart completely to Hashem?
Answer: 22:41 A complete transformation belongs to tzaddikim; what is near to everyone is acting on the mind's understanding, with a logical love.
-
Question: 8:43 Does the verse perhaps apply only to the great souls of Moshe Rabbeinu's generation?
Answer: 9:02 No; the Torah is eternal and every verse applies to every generation and every person.
-
Question: 37:13 Since Hashem hardened Pharaoh's heart, what complaint is there against him?
Answer: 37:46 At first he had control and did not submit to Hashem, so his punishment was to be deprived of that control.
-
Question: 41:28 If the rasha has lost his free choice, how can he do teshuvah?
Answer: 41:45 Every Jew has a point that evil cannot touch; Hashem sometimes arouses it through circumstances, and if he grasps it he can break through with a broken heart.
Stories
-
15:19 A Rebbe who no longer knew the taste of food
To show that tzaddikim reached a level where nothing else had place in their heart, the Mashgiach says he knew such people in his own generation. One Rebbe once said that for twenty years he had not known the taste of food; he was in a different world.
-
15:58 Two Rebbes recall the wartime transports
Two Rebbes sat together, with chassidim standing around, recalling what they went through in the camps during the war. One told how they were transported in a wagon packed like herring in great heat, many near death from thirst, and at a certain station they were allowed down to drink at a fountain. He drank three glasses of water and spoke about the intention of each drink.
-
18:23 The Yismach Moshe and the dishwater
Once the wife of the Yismach Moshe had to go to a simcha and asked him to take supper himself; she left a pot of meat and a pot of soup on the stove. When she returned, the soup was untouched though he said he had taken it. She found that on the same stove stood a pot of dirty dishwater with suds, and he had eaten that, not knowing the difference.
In the story: the Yismach Moshe, the Satmar Rav (Rabbi Yoel Teitelbaum)
Insights
- 8:43 The Mashgiach reads 'ki karov' as speaking to every generation and every moment, rejecting the idea that it was meant only for the great souls of Moshe Rabbeinu's generation.
- 13:10 The Mashgiach rejects 'sublimating' worldly enjoyment as a way to claim complete love of Hashem: thinking of the Creator while enjoying the ice cream is good, but if one enjoys it, the love is divided.
- 24:15 The Mashgiach explains that the Tanya does not demand abstaining from pleasure; it demands that when a mitzvah comes, the mind's recognition of duty carries the action.
- 32:34 The felt joy of a mitzvah is its reward, which tzaddikim taste even in this world; it is not what is asked of everyone here.
- 38:52 The Mashgiach suggests that the rasha's punishment after losing control follows the Gemara's principle that what starts with negligence and ends with compulsion is still culpable.
- 51:24 The Mashgiach links the lower teshuvah to Chanukah: the wicks and oils that cannot burn on Shabbos burn on Chanukah, since then Hashem comes down to lift even the fallen.
What the Mashgiach says to take from it
- 27:04 The Mashgiach says that one who cannot feel the glow of a mitzvah such as tefillin should do it out of the mind's sense of duty, because Hashem requires it.
- 19:51 The Mashgiach says one who enjoys worldly pleasures may think of Hashem who made them so good, but should not fool himself that his love of Hashem is complete.
Mentioned in this shiur
People Avraham Avinu, Dovid HaMelech, Moshe Rabbeinu, Pharaoh, the Baal HaTanya (Rabbi Shneur Zalman of Liadi), the Yismach Moshe
Terms בינוני, גלות השכינה, כי קרוב אליך הדבר מאד, לב נשבר ונדכה, מוח שליט על הלב, עיבור, קליפה, רבונו של עולם